Battle of the Atomic Kilowatts - C&EN Global Enterprise (ACS

Nov 5, 2010 - DEVELOPMENT OF THE PEACEFUL ATOM is surrounded by an atmosphere that is anything but peaceful. Sharply conflicting points of view have d...
3 downloads 6 Views 388KB Size
skilled m e n to building plants of primitive design, w e would reduce our opportunities for finding t h e optimum, economically competitive nuclear plants of the future. • Congress Deliberates. T h e Joint Committee on Atomic Energy has just concluded hearings on an atomic power bill ( S . 2725) sponsored b y Sen. Albert Gore ( D . - T e n n . ) . Under provisions of the Gore bill, AEC would build and !§> operate six full-scale atomic power 2.5 M i l l i o n Kw. by 1 9 6 0 plants, so-called demonstration plants. Cost of the program is estimated to b e $500 million. 2.5 M i l l i o n K w . by 1965 Committee chairman Sen. Clinton P . Anderson (D.-N. M.) is concerned over the lagging development of industrial atomic power. With nuclear power in 0.7 M i l l i o n K w . by 1 9 6 0 the uneconomical development stage, Sen. Anderson questions the wisdom of A E C s policy of asking industry t o carry t h e b u r d e n of putting these prototypes into full-scale operation. H e asks, " C a n w e expect these uncoordinated groups to provide t h e direction a n d accomplishment necessary to maintain our world leadership?" AEC head attacks Congressional plans to have Testifying in behalf of t h e bill, Sen. Gore says that the Government should Government build demonstration reactors lead t h e w a y for private industry and supplement plants constructed with • Strauss Speaks. A E C chairman private capital. H e urges vigorous Lewis L. Strauss, addressing the gradu- cooperation between Government and ATOM is surrounded by an atmosphere t h a t is anything but peaceful. Sharply ating class of Carnegie Tecli last week, industry in obtaining practical expericonflicting points of view have devel- struck back at critics of the atomic ence i n operating nuclear power plants. oped over the best way to handle the power program. "One of t h e most Noting that Russia's announced plans atomic electric power program. Some short-sighted decisions we could make for atomic power "dwarf t h e very best leaders urge the Government to sponsor as a nation is to adopt an arbitrary goal anticipated under our present program," crash development programs for atomic as to the number of full-scale plants Sen. Gore warns that we must use t h e power, while others are equally insist- we would build by a set d a t e . We a r e full resources of both Government and e n t that industry can do the job ade- not engaged in a kilowatt r a c e , " Strauss indus try if we are to keep the pace. quately by following the normal pattern said. Another complicating factor is t h e of development. But all are agreed on Dismissing Russian announcements long-standing difference of opinion over one thing—the United States must main- of plans to build huge nuclear plants as public power versus private power. tain i t s atomic leadership. propaganda or reactors designed to pro- Voicing h i s opposition to t h e Gore bill. Many Congressmen fear that w e are duce plutonium for weapon use, Strauss Rep. Sterling Cole (R.-N. Y.) says, falling behind Russia in t h e interna- compared the power picture in t h e "We r e going t o have TVA u n d e r t h e tional race for atomic power, and United States with that in power- guise of nuclear energy." severely criticize the Atomic Energy hungry countries abroad- I n Great • W h a t ' s Ahead. So far t h e Joint Commission for "abdicating some of its Britain, for example, the necessity for Committee on Atomic Energy has m a d e responsibilities." They urge passage of importing all the petroleum and a grow- no report on an atomic power bill. legislation to accelerate the develop- ing percentage of the coal required Chances a r e that t h e committee will ment of atomic power by building a makes the cost of atomic power a recommend that AEC build demonstran u m b e r of government demonstration secondary consideration. Here in t h e U. S., with adequate domestic fuel tion p o w e r plants on a smaller scale plants. than t h a t called for in the Gore bill. I n On the other hand, AEC contends supplies, nuclear power t o be effective view of t h e fears expressed b y many that there is no need to engage in a must be competitive in cost with conCongressmen that t h e United States is "kilowatt race" by building demonstra- ventional fuels, in Strauss" opinion. in danger of losing the international tion atomic power plants of types that Our goal, Strauss said, i s more technia r e already obsolescent. U. S. leader- cal advancement through improving power race, Congress is almost certain snip can best b e maintained, AEC says, atomic technology. AECs policy of to pass legislation calling for more b y applying scarce scientific talent to partnership between industry a n d government help in atomic power developing reactor technology to t h e Government is based on the "proven development. Meanwhile, the Edison Electric Instipoint that atomic power is economic. principles that have made t h e United However, all is not harmonious within States the most technologically a d - tute, a n association of privately owned A E C as commissioner Thomas E. vanced nation in t h e world." To em- utility companies, has just announced M u r r a y has gone on record before bark on a crash program of building the formation of a special task force o n Congress as favoring a government plants might be an exceedingly risky atomic power reactors. This group, crash program of demonstration reac- venture, according to Strauss. By di- seen b y many as an answer to criticism tors (C&EN, March 5, page 1080). verting our limited supply of technically of t h e industrial atomic program, will

GOVERNMENT

WORLD ATOMIC POWER R* CE

Battle of the Atomic Kilowatts DEVELOPMENT OF THE PEACEFUL

2990

C&EN

JUNE

J 8,

19 5 6

New Du Pont MYLAR adds improved qualities to pressure-sensitive tape REG. U. S . PAT. OFF.

Pressure-sensitive tapes made with new D u P o n t "Mylar"* polyester film are giving superior performance in a wide variety of diversified industrial uses. T h a t ' s because tapes made with " M y l a r " offer long-lasting strength in conjunction with chemical resistance, dielectric strength, and thermal stability. W h e t h e r it's masking for electroplating or harnesswrapping coils, pressure-sensitive tapes made with new D u P o n t " M y l a r " increase efficiency, improve performance and, in t h e case of electrical applications, help decrease weight and size of the finished product. D u Pont manufactures only t h e base material, " M y l a r . " T h e various firms t h a t make pressuresensitive tapes using " M y l a r " offer a variety of gauges, widths, and types of adhesives. Send i n coupon below for names of manufacturers a n d the new booklet listing properties and applications of pressure-sensitive tapes made with "Mylar."

fy:

fFÏ*-**

Amazing dielectric Strength, thermal stability, for countless electric uses. '·, '

Thin, yet strong . . . gives a snug wrap over irregular, bulky surfaces.

Dimensionally stable, can be used over a wide range of temperatures.

Can be metalized,

Resists effects of corrosion and moisture over wide range of temperature and h u m i d i t y .

•Registered Du Pont trademark for its brand of polyester

R

BETTER

Ee.U.S. Ρ

T H I N G S F O R BETTER LIVING . . .THROUGH CHEMISTRY

D U P O N T -T

MYLAR POLYESTER FILM:

printed, used for coding pipes and wires . . . decorative effects.

Resists edge fraying, has great tear strength... is ideal f o r tough j o b s .

film

Π Please send me further information on the basic properties o f " M y l a r . "

E . I . du Pont d e Nemours & Co. ( Inc. ) Film Dept., Room C-6, Nemours Bldg., Wilmington 98, Del. Name_

• Please send me your new booklet on pressuresensitive tapes made with " M y l a r " a n d names of manufacturers.

Firm Street

Address_

City

„State_ Λ

JUNE

18. 1 9 5 6 C & E N

2991

Γο Pick up , Every Drop

Use

FLORIDIN ADSORBENTS F o r laboratory and industrial processes inquiring selective a d ­ sorption t o t h e nth. degree, Florex offers an extremely porous, gran­ ular adsorbent unequalled^ b y other low cost natural materials. Almost a half century's expe­ rience assures intelligent, confi­ dential, and immecliate attention t o inquiries o n a n y problem of adsorption, dehydbcation, cataly­ sis o r decolorization.

FLORID!Ν COMPANY ADSORBENTS Dept. B, P. O. Box 9 8 ° , Tallahassee, Fia.

ûbto &3ΕΒΣΓΠΙΣΠ

ARMSTRONG CORK CUSHIONED 5-61Λ-13 gallon

CARBOY BOXES

Treen manufactured 5—6'/2-arad 13 gallon carboy boxes are quality built in accordance with I C C regulations, with features that give all-point protection, reducing hazards and breakage, ease I n handling and compact loading. Available with either " A " Mood or Export H o o d .

TREENBOXco MEMPHIS AND I I O G À S t S Ρ ΗI LA PELΡ Η 1A 3 4 , PA : 2992

C&EN

JUNE

18. 1956

GOVERNMENT^ appraise reactor designs and recom­ mend types most suitable for develop­ ment. Spokesmen for the task force emphasized that no eflFort would b e made to develop a crash program, but that work of the group would lead to an expansion in reactor building.

Executive Reserve Build-Up WHITE SULPHUR SPRINGS, W . VA. —Steps are being taken t o increase chemical industry participation i n the Government's executive reserve pro­ gram, Charles F. Honeywell told the Manufacturing Chemists' Association meeting here last week. Honeywell is administrator of the Commerce D e ­ partment's Business and Defense Serv­ ices Administration. The executive reserve program, brought into being early this year (C&EN, F e b . 27, p a g e 9 3 2 ) , is de­ signed to provide a pool of industrial executives who have h a d first-hand ex­ perience in government operations. These m e n will be available for service in expanded government operations un­ der mobilization conditions. Keystone of success in building up the reserve, Honeywell says, is the WOC (without compensation employ­ ees) program. For the Commerce D e ­ partment as a whole, active recruiting of former WOC's has been very suc­ cessful. So far, according to Honey­ well, more than 4 0 0 former WOC's have said that they are ready, willing, and able to come back to Washington and g o t o work should an emergency arise. But things are not so rosy in the chemical division of BDSA. T o date, only 3 4 former WOC's from the chemi­ cal industry have agreed t o serve in the reserve. Honeywell estimates that at least 6 0 men will b e required t o form the nucleus of a strong organization in the chemical division. To bring the chemical reserve up to the required strength, Honeywell pro­ poses to add four WOC's to BDSA's Chemical and Rubber Division. Each of these m e n will act as consultant to the chief of a branch in t h e division, thus they will not stand in the w a y of government career men. E a c h WOC will serve a term of six months in the department. According to Honeywell's figures, the expanded W O C program plus the present program will add 1 0 chemical executives to the reserve each year, so that at t h e end of 10 years there will be 100 additional men in t h e chemical reserve. If the WOC's selected are in the preferred age group, 35 to 4 5 years,

these men should be available for emer­ gency service f o r a period of 2 0 years. Urging the chemical industry to get behind the WOC program, Honeywell points out that i n such a diverse indus­ try there is a critical need for better understanding between the industry and Government. The broad aspects of the chemical industry are not too well understood in Government, Honeywell says. "Yet i n every emer­ gency in the past, chemicals have be­ come all important to maintenance o f our defense." WOC's returning t o in­ dustry will have knowledge of govern­ ment operations and government-busi­ ness relations that can b e gained in no other way.

Potomac

Postscripts

• National Civil Defense W e e k , Sept. 9 to 15, marks t h e first time a special period has been set aside to focus attention on this problem. For planners of community and industrial programs the Federal Civil Defense Administration has prepared a Help­ ful idea booklet, "Leadership Guide," copies of w h i c h may b e ob­ tained from F*CDA's national head­ quarters, Battle Creek, Mich. • Gas-cooled power reactor e x ­ periment will h e undertaken b y A E C at the Idaho test station. The proto­ type, eighth type chosen by A E C for research, is expected t o cost $ 4 mil­ lion, and will IDC used t o develop data and experience for designing mili­ tary package power reactors and small civilian central station power plants. • Selenium joins the list of critical materials to receive financial help from the Defense Minerals Explora­ tion Administration. T o encourage domestic production of this scarce material, DMEA will p a y up to 7 5 % of the costs o f authorized exploration projects. • Nickel alloys will become a con­ trolled material in t h e near future, Office of Defense Mobilization an­ nounces. Under provisions of the Defense Materials System, deliveries of the alloys t o contractors of the D e ­ fense Department a n d Atomic En­ ergy Commission will b e controlled, beginning with shipments in the last quarter of this year. Civilian pur­ chase, shipment, and use of nickel and nickel alloys will not be affected in any way, according t o ODM direc­ tor Arthur S. Flemming.