Subscriber access provided by University of Florida | Smathers Libraries
Article
Carboxymethylcellulose Mediates the Transport of Carbon Nanotubes —Magnetite Nanohybrid Aggregates in Water-Saturated Porous Media Dengjun Wang, Chang Min Park, Arvid Masud, Nirupam Aich, and Chunming Su Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.7b04037 • Publication Date (Web): 17 Oct 2017 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on October 18, 2017
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Carboxymethylcellulose Mediates the Transport of Carbon Nanotubes—Magnetite Nanohybrid Aggregates in Water-Saturated Porous Media
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
Dengjun Wang,†,* Chang Min Park,†,∆ Arvid Masud,§ Nirupam Aich,§ and Chunming Su‡,* †
National Research Council; and ‡Groundwater, Watershed, and Ecosystem Restoration Division, National Risk Management Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 919 Kerr Research Drive, Ada, OK 74820, United States ∆
Department of Environmental Engineering, Kyungpook National University, Buk-gu, Daegu 41566, South Korea
§
Department of Civil, Structural and Environmental Engineering, University at Buffalo, The State University of New York, Buffalo, NY 14260, United States *
Corresponding Authors: Dengjun Wang E-mail:
[email protected] Phone: (580) 436-8828 Fax: (580) 436-8703 and Chunming Su E-mail:
[email protected] Phone: (580) 436-8638 Fax: (580) 436-8703
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
32 33
TOC ART
34 35
2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 44
Page 3 of 44
36
Environmental Science & Technology
ABSTRACT
37
Carbon—metal oxide nanohybrids (NHs) are increasingly recognized as the next-
38
generation, promising group of nanomaterials for solving emerging environmental issues and
39
challenges. This research, for the first time, systematically explored the transport and retention of
40
carbon nanotubes—magnetite (CNT-Fe3O4) NH aggregates in water-saturated porous media
41
under environmentally relevant conditions. A macromolecule modifier, carboxymethylcellulose
42
(CMC) was employed to stabilize the NHs. Our results show that transport of the magnetic CNT-
43
Fe3O4 NHs was lower than that of non-magnetic CNT due to larger hydrodynamic sizes of NHs
44
(induced by magnetic attraction) and size-dependent retention in porous media. Classical
45
Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory can explain the mobility of NHs under
46
varying experimental conditions. However, in contrast with colloid filtration theory, a novel
47
transport feature—an initial lower and a following sharp, higher peaks occurred frequently in the
48
NHs’ breakthrough curves and the magnitude and location of both transport peaks varied with
49
different experimental conditions, due to the interplay between variability of fluid viscosity and
50
size-selective retention of the NHs. Promisingly, the estimated maximum transport distance of
51
NHs ranged between ~0.38−46 m, supporting the feasibility of employing the magnetically
52
recyclable CNT-Fe3O4 NHs for in-situ nanoremediation of contaminated soil, aquifer, and
53
groundwater.
54
3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
55
Page 4 of 44
INTRODUCTION
56
Nanoscience and nanotechnology are advancing our broad societal goals in various fields
57
including, but not limited to: medicine (e.g., magnetic resonance imaging),1 agriculture (e.g.,
58
nutrient nanocapsules and nanosensors),2 energy (e.g., solar cells and supercapacitors),3 and
59
environmental remediation (e.g., photocatalysts)4, 5. They are unprecedentedly maximizing
60
human potentials towards many frontiers such as addressing water-energy-agriculture-
61
environment (WEAE) nexus.6 Recently, the focus of interest in nanomaterial (NM) research and
62
development has shifted from singular NMs to multi-component nanohybrids (NHs), which are
63
nano-/hierarchical assemblies of multiple NMs conjugated by non-covalent (hydrogen bond, van
64
der Waals (vdW), and electrostatic interactions) or covalent (molecular linkage) bonds.7-9 The
65
goal of developing NHs is to maximize the existing functionality (e.g., contaminant adsorption
66
and degradation efficiency), and achieve novel-functionality that cannot be obtained by
67
manipulating the singular NM system.7-9 Taking environmental remediation as an example, the
68
carbon nanotubes (CNT) individually show limited adsorption capacity towards metoprolol.
69
When hetero-hybridized with nanoscale zero-valent iron (nZVI), the conjugated CNT-nZVI NHs
70
exhibit significantly higher and faster adsorption and degradation efficiency for metoprolol
71
(compared to CNT) due to greater specific surface area (SSA) and Fenton-type catalytic
72
reactions in the CNT-nZVI nanostructures.10 Promisingly, compared to the single-component
73
NMs, the performance and functionality of NHs are optimized. This is particularly true for
74
carbon-family based metal oxide NHs. Specifically, the photoelectrocatalytic reactivity and
75
sensitivity of CNT/graphene oxide (GO)—FexOy/TiO2/ZnO/MnO2/SiO2/Ag for removing toxic
76
gases (NOx),11 organic pollutants (dyes and phenolic compounds),10,
77
(As(III)/As(V), Cd2+, Cr(VI), Pb2+, and Hg2+),12,
4
13
12
heavy metals
and radionuclides (U(VI)),14,
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
15
are
Page 5 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
78
demonstrated to be greater than those of singular NMs. This is attributed to the
79
combinative/synergistic effects within the hybridized nanostructure system.7-9
80
The superior performance and multi-functionality of carbon—metal oxide NHs make
81
them the next-generation, promising candidates for in-situ nanoremediation of contaminated air,
82
soil, aquifer, and groundwater. It is also anticipated that increasing production and use of NHs
83
will result in their release to the environment. However, to date, little is known about their fate
84
and transport in the subsurface, which will likely restrict their widespread applications in
85
resolving issues and meeting challenges within WEAE nexus. Over the past decade, the fate and
86
transport of individual NMs such as carbonaceous (CNT16-19 and graphene20-22) and iron-bearing
87
NMs (nZVI23-25 and magnetite (Fe3O4)26, 27) in the subsurface have been well-explored. It is
88
noted that colloid science principles, Derjaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek (DLVO) theory28, 29
89
and colloid filtration theory (CFT)30 can describe the colloidal stability and transport of
90
individual NMs in aquatic environments. Nonetheless, deviations between experimental
91
observations and theoretical predictions occur frequently under unfavorable attachment
92
conditions or with varying properties (e.g., irregular shapes and surface modifications) of NMs.
93
For example, under unfavorable conditions, non-exponential retention31 of NMs was frequently
94
encountered in porous media (e.g., hyper-exponential retention for tubular CNT)16. Surface
95
modifications32 due to surfactant and polyelectrolyte coatings impart non-DLVO interactions
96
(steric hindrance) and change the rheological properties (viscosity) of fluid in porous media,33
97
likely yielding unanticipated transport behaviors for NMs. CFT predicts that transport of colloids
98
in porous media is controlled by random Brownian motion; and that interception and
99
gravitational sedimentation start to dominate colloid deposition when particle diameter is ≥1
100
µm.30, 34 Once released to the environment, the transport of individual NMs is dependent on the
5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
101
interplay of various physicochemical conditions including: (1) NM-specific properties (e.g.,
102
size/shape/hydrophilicity/aggregation state/surface chemistry); (2) medium-specific properties
103
(e.g., grain size/shape/surface chemistry/moisture content); (3) solution chemistries (e.g.,
104
pH/ionic strength and composition (IS and IC)/presence of natural organic matter (NOM)); and
105
(4) hydrodynamic conditions (e.g., flow rate/temperature/oxygen content).35, 36 However, it is
106
unclear whether the colloid science principles used for describing the environmental behaviors of
107
individual NMs hold true for the assembled NHs, e.g., how and to what extent (e.g., qualitatively,
108
semi-quantitatively, or quantitatively) the DLVO theory and CFT explain NHs’ transport in the
109
subsurface. Particularly, NHs’ new features such as altered hydrophilicity, magnetism, and
110
DLVO-type (e.g., vdW attraction) interactions, and enhanced population heterogeneity (e.g., size
111
distribution, morphology, surface defect and roughness, and charge heterogeneity; compared to
112
individual NMs) likely impact their aggregation and transport propensities in the subsurface.9, 37
113
Assembling magnetic iron oxide (e.g., Fe3O4) NMs having high redox potential and
114
contaminant immobilization capacity38-40 with CNT having superlative mechanical-strength and
115
large SSA41 provides a powerful strategy (e.g., synergistic adsorption and redox degradation) for
116
in-situ capturing and decomposing/detoxificating both inorganic and organic pollutants. But
117
knowledge of how DLVO theory and CFT describe the transport of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the
118
subsurface is nonexistent. This study systematically investigated the transport of the
119
multifunctional CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in water-saturated porous media under environmentally
120
relevant conditions. An environmentally-friendly and ‘green’ (non-toxic and biodegradable)
121
macromolecule carboxymethylcellulose (CMC) was employed to stabilize the CNT-Fe3O4 NHs
122
as they were highly-hydrophobic and easily-aggregated. The CMC has long been used to
123
stabilize individual nZVI23, 42, 43 and Fe3O4 NMs44 by imparting electrosteric repulsions arising
6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 44
Page 7 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
124
from the hydrophilic, negatively charged carboxymethyl (-CH2-COOH) groups. Critical
125
parameters characterizing the NHs’ mobility in water-saturated porous media were evaluated to
126
shed light on the feasibility of using the recyclable CNT-Fe3O4 NHs for in-situ nanoremediation
127
of contaminated sites. DLVO theory and CFT were employed in combination with electrokinetic
128
property and hydrodynamic size of NHs to understand the mechanisms behind their transport and
129
retention within the porous media. Significant efforts were devoted to explore how DLVO theory
130
and CFT explain the variability in NHs’ transport under varying experimental conditions. Finally,
131
potential limitations and future research directions of DLVO theory/CFT in describing NHs’
132
transport in the subsurface were also discussed.
133 134
MATERIALS AND METHODS
135
Preparation of CNT-Fe3O4 NH Influents and Solution Chemistries
136
Carbon nanotubes (purity>99.9%, outer diameter=8−15 nm, inside diameter=3−5 nm,
137
length=10−50 µm, and carboxyl group content=1.85%) were purchased from the Cheap Tubes
138
Inc. (Grafton, VT). The CNT-Fe3O4 NHs were synthesized in-house, and their physicochemical
139
properties including those of purchased CNT were characterized using X-ray diffraction (XRD),
140
transmission electron microscopy (TEM), Raman spectroscopy, and thermogravimetric analysis
141
(TGA) (see Supporting Information (SI) S1). The synthesized CNT-Fe3O4 NHs were highly-
142
hydrophobic because most hydrophilic carboxyl groups on the CNT surfaces were used for
143
anchoring CNT and magnetite during synthesis.
144
The NHs were easily-aggregated due to strong vdW and magnetic attractions (magnetism
145
was confirmed using a magnet). Various surfactants (sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), Triton X-
146
100, and Tween 20), polyelectrolytes (polyacrylic acid (PAA), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), and
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
147
polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP)), and macromolecules (CMC; nominal molecular weight=90,000
148
g/mol; Sigma-Aldrich) were tested to investigate the NHs’ colloidal stability. By monitoring the
149
UV-Vis response of absorbance for the NHs under different surfactants, polyelectrolytes, and
150
macromolecules, we found that only the CMC at the concentration of 2% well-stabilized the
151
NHs (see SI S2). Consequently, 2% CMC was chosen as the ‘modifier’ to stabilize the CNT-
152
Fe3O4 NHs for column experiments (described below).
153
Environmentally-relevant solution chemistries were selected to evaluate the mobility of
154
CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in porous media including: monovalent (0, 1, 10, and 50 mM NaCl) and
155
divalent electrolytes (0, 0.33, 1.67, and 3.33 mM CaCl2; note IS of 0, 0.33, 1.67, and 3.33 mM
156
CaCl2 is 0, 1, 5, and 10 mM, respectively); the presence of NOMs (0, 1, and 10 mg C/L
157
Suwannee River humic acid (SRHA) and fulvic acid (SRFA)) (details on preparing SRHA/SRFA
158
stock suspensions were given in SI S3), pHs (4.0, 7.3, and 10), and particle concentrations (10,
159
25, and 50 mg/L) (Table 1).45 2% CMC-stabilized CNT-Fe3O4 NH influents (via adding a pre-
160
determined volume of 5% CMC stock suspension; S3) at the desired solution chemistries were
161
freshly prepared via ultrasonication at 100 W and 42 kHz for 1 h (Branson 3510R-DTH
162
sonicator). Changes in concentration and average hydrodynamic radius (rh) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs
163
in the influent suspensions were monitored over the time frame of influent injection experiments
164
(described below) to investigate their colloidal stability (aggregation propensity). The influent
165
concentration changes of NHs were determined spectrophotometrically at 218 nm (SI Figure S1).
166
Time-resolved dynamic light scattering (DLS) was used to monitor rh change of NHs in influents
167
using the Zetasizer Nano-ZS ZEN3600 analyzer (Malvern Instruments Inc.) at a scattering angle
168
of 173° and 25 °C (see SI S4).
169
8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 44
Page 9 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
Table 1. Physicochemical properties of column transport experiments and mass recoveries of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (in 2% CMC) under different experimental conditions. NaCl (mM) 0 1 10 50 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1
CaCl2 (mM) 0 0 0 0 0.33 1.67 3.33 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SRHA (mg C/L)
SRFA (mg C/L)
pH
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 10 0 0 0 0 0 0
7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3 4.0 10 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.3
Particle conc (mg/L)
Sand size (µm)
Mass recovery (%) Meff
Mret
Mtot
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 25 50 10 10
360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 360 280 230
88.3±0.02 79.9±2.4 37.8±0.67 20.3±0.88 57.4±2.0 22.7±4.4 16.2±0.84 86.9±1.5 97.6±3.8 83.1±2.6 92.2±1.2 35.0±0.58 89.5±0.67 98.5±1.2 104±0.49 28.6±1.8 97.4±0.36
12.8±0.25 25.0±0.49 62.2±1.1 84.2±0.18 44.2±2.2 73.1±0.9 86.9±1.4 14.2±0.28 8.0±0.28 14.9±0.72 9.7±0.77 66.1±1.8 16.1±0.49 8.0±0.36 4.0±0.30 64.9±0.89 6.1±0.42
101±0.23 105±2.9 100±0.41 104±1.1 102±0.29 95.8±3.5 103±2.3 101±1.2 106±4.1 98.0±1.9 102±0.41 101±2.4 106±1.2 107±1.5 108±0.19 93.5±2.7 104±0.79
170 171 172 173 174
SRHA and SRFA are Suwannee River humic acid and Suwannee River fulvic acid, respectively. Conc is concentration. Meff, Mret, and Mtot are mass percentages of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs recovered from effluent, retentate, and total column, respectively. Other column transport parameters such as porosity, pore-water velocity, and dispersivity are shown in SI Table S1.
175
Porous Media
176
Ottawa sands (U.S. Silica, Berkeley Springs, WV) were chosen as representative aquifer
177
materials for column experiments. The sands were pre-sifted through 40-, 50-, 60-, and 70-mesh
178
sieves (U.S. Standard Testing Sieves), and the fractions captured by 40−50, 50−60, and 60−70
179
mesh sieves (average grain sizes of 360-, 280-, and 230-µm, respectively) were used. Before use,
180
the sieved sands were cleaned using 1 M HCl and washed thoroughly with deionized (DI) water
181
(Nanopure Diamond D11911, Barnstead International, Dubuque, IA). The colloidal particles
9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 10 of 44
182
from pulverized, cleaned sands were used as surrogates of sand grains for electrophoretic
183
mobility (EPM) measurements in triplicate on the Zetasizer analyzer at 25 °C. Experimentally
184
determined EPM values were converted to apparent zeta (ζ)-potentials for the sand grains using
185
the Smoluchowski equation.46
186 187
Column Experiments
188
Column experiments were conducted using glass chromatography columns (1.7-cm i.d. ×
189
10-cm long).47 Each column was dry-packed using the cleaned 360-, 280-, or 230-µm sands. The
190
packed-column was then purged with CO2 gas to remove any air remained during column
191
packing processes, and to maximize the water accessibility of the column. After purging, the
192
column was immediately saturated with DI water slowly in an upward mode. Following the
193
saturation step, a nonreactive tracer experiment was performed to assess the hydrodynamic
194
properties of column (see SI S5 and Table S1).
195
After the completion of tracer experiment, the column was pre-equilibrated with desired
196
background solution (Table 1). 2% CMC was not co-injected during the pre-equilibration
197
procedure because CMC alters column hydromechanical (rheological) properties due to its high
198
viscosity33 (described below). A two-step transport experiment was then initiated by injecting 3
199
PVs of CNT-Fe3O4 NH influents (in 2% CMC) at the desired solution chemistries (designated as
200
phase 1), followed by elution with 7 PVs of NH-free background electrolyte solution (without
201
CMC; phase 2). Column experiments with different collector sizes (360-, 280-, and 230-µm,
202
respectively) were also performed to examine the role of straining48,
203
Previous studies suggest that, under unfavorable conditions, secondary minimum starts to
204
capture colloids when solution IS is ≥10 mM NaCl50 or ≥1 mM CaCl245. To identify whether
10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
49
on NHs’ retention.
Page 11 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
205
secondary minimum is also involved in NHs’ retention, two three-step transport experiments
206
were run at the highest NaCl (50 mM) and CaCl2 concentrations (3.33 mM) investigated in this
207
study, i.e., eluting the column with 8 PVs of DI water in phase 3 after completing the two-step
208
transport experiments. Darcy velocity was maintained at 0.44 cm/min for all experiments,
209
mimicking typical fluid velocities in coarse aquifers51 or in forced-gradient in-situ remediation52.
210
Column effluents were collected via a fraction collector. Following completion of each transport
211
experiment, the spatial distribution of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs retained in the column (dissection
212
experiments) was determined (SI S6). Column transport and dissection experiments were also
213
performed for CNT-alone (in 2% CMC) to compare the mobility between NHs and parent NMs.
214
The concentrations of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and CNT in the effluents and retentates (retained
215
colloids collected from dissection experiments) were determined spectrophotometrically at 218
216
nm (SI Figure S1). To eliminate the interferences of CMC in NHs (and CNT) measurements,
217
two-step column transport experiments were also performed for 2% CMC-alone under the
218
experimental conditions identical to those for the transport of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (Table 1). The
219
actual concentration of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (and CNT) in the effluents was obtained by subtracting
220
the spectrophotometric response (at 218 nm) of CMC from that of the NHs (and CNT) at the
221
identical PV. Furthermore, to minimize the potential interferences of particle aggregation and
222
sedimentation, spectrophotometric measurements for all NHs, CNT, and CMC in the effluents
223
were controlled to be completed within 1.5 h after collecting from the fraction collector.
224
Additionally, selected column effluents of NHs were digested in 2.6 M HNO3 for 3 d at 25 °C,
225
and then filtered through 0.2-µm cellulose acetate membranes. Total Fe concentrations in the
226
filtered digestion solutions were determined using inductively-coupled-plasma optical-emission-
227
spectroscopy (ICP-OES; PerkinElmer Optima 3300DV, Norwalk, CT) to verify the reliability of
11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 12 of 44
228
spectrophotometric measurements of the NHs. Selected column effluents of NHs were also
229
measured using ICP-OES (effluents after HNO3 digestion for total Fe measurements) to identify
230
whether Fe3O4 NMs detach from the NHs or dissolve under acidic conditions (pH 4.0). Our
231
measurements (Fe content < detection limit, meaning no Fe3O4 NMs detach or dissolve)
232
substantiate the integrity of the NHs during porous media transport.
233 234
Electrokinetic Properties and Hydrodynamic Radii of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the
235
Influents
236
Electrophoretic mobility (EPM) and ζ-potential of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (and CNT) in various
237
influents (Table 1) were measured using the Zetasizer analyzer at 25 °C. The ζ-potentials of
238
CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and sand grains were then used to calculate their interaction energy using
239
DLVO theory that includes vdW and electrostatic double layer (EDL) interactions. It is
240
impossible to determine Hamaker constant (A) of the hydrophobic CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (without
241
CMC modification) in aqueous solutions experimentally. Thus, three Hamaker constants, i.e.,
242
Hamaker constants of CNT (ACNT=6.00×10−20 J)53, 54 and Fe3O4 NMs (AFe3O4=33.0×10−20 J)55,
243
and an estimated Hamaker constant of the NHs (ACNT−Fe3O4=17.6×10−20 J) based on the Hamaker
244
constants of parent NMs and NHs’ elemental (C and Fe) contents, were employed to calculate
245
the interaction energy between NHs and sand grains.56,
246
energy calculation including inherent limitation of this approach were given in SI S7.
57
Details on the DLVO interaction
247
The average hydrodynamic radius (rh) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (and CNT) in various influents
248
and hydrodynamic particle size distribution of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the influents at different NaCl
249
and CaCl2 concentrations were determined using DLS (described above). Particle size
250
distribution of 2% CMC was also determined to investigate the role of CMC on the transport of
12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 13 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
251
CNT-Fe3O4 NHs. The CONTIN algorithm was used to convert intensity autocorrelation
252
functions to intensity-weighted rh using the Stokes-Einstein equation for spherical particles.58
253
Given that the NHs, CNT, and CMC are non-spherical, DLS provides the diameter of a sphere
254
that has the same average translational diffusion coefficient as the particle being measured. For
255
selected column experiments, the rh of NHs and CNT in the effluents and retentates (retained in
256
the column inlet 0−1 cm) was measured using DLS to understand size-dependent retention in
257
saturated sand.
258 259
Data Analyses
260
Parameters characterizing the mobility of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in water-saturated porous
261
media including single-collector contact efficiency (η), attachment efficiency (α), deposition rate
262
coefficient (kd), and maximum transport distance (Lmax) were calculated using the well-defined
263
Tufenkji-Elimelech (TE) equation (SI S8).34
264 265
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
266
Electrokinetic Properties and Hydrodynamic Radii of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the
267
Influents and Electrokinetic Properties of Sand Grains
268
Physicochemical properties of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and CNT were characterized using XRD,
269
TEM, Raman spectroscopy, and TGA (Figure 1). A strong peak occurred at 26.5° for both NHs
270
and CNT in the XRD spectra, which corresponds to the d-spacing of [002] plane of graphite
271
(CNT; Figure 1a).59 In contrast, the characteristic reflections of 30.0° [220], 35.6° [311], and
272
43.4° [400] of Fe3O4 (JCPDS No. 19-0629) occurred only for the NHs, confirming the successful
273
hybridization of CNT and Fe3O4 NMs. TEM images showed that the Fe3O4 NMs (20−30 nm size)
13
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 14 of 44
274
heterogeneously-deposited on CNT’s surface as dense aggregates (Figure 1b). This is due to the
275
large SSA and surface reactivity, and strong magnetic attraction of the Fe3O4 NMs that promote
276
partial aggregation on the CNT’s surface (see SI Figure S5). The Fe3O4 NMs were strongly
277
anchored on the CNT’s surface even after ultrasonication treatment (100 W and 42 kHz for 1 h)
278
since no Fe was released from the NHs (via ICP-OES measurements). This could be due to the
279
strong covalent interaction between CNT (e.g., carboxyl (1.85% in the pristine CNT) and
280
carbonyl groups) and Fe3O4 NMs.7 The Raman spectrum of CNT exhibited three absorption
281
bands at 1343, 1571, and 2688 cm−1 (Figure 1c), which is assigned to the D-, G’-, and G’-bands,
282
respectively.60 However, these three bands shifted to higher wavenumbers of 1357, 1582, and
283
2710 cm−1, respectively, for the NHs, yielding a larger D/G-band intensity ratio of ID/IG=0.326
284
(ID/IG=0.316 for CNT). This indicates a smaller average size of the sp2 domains of carbon for the
285
NHs,60 likely due to the enhanced aggregation of NHs (more compressed structure) induced by
286
magnetic attraction (see S1 for more discussion). The TGA profiles showed that Fe accounted
287
for 42.8% of the total elemental mass because CNT was decomposed completely when the
288
temperature was >930 °C (Figure 1d). The C and Fe elemental composition information was
289
used to calculate the Hamaker constant and density of the NHs for DLVO interaction energy and
290
transport parameter calculations (described below).
14
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 15 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
a)
CNT
c)
CNT-Fe3O4
CNT-Fe3O4 CNT
Intensity (a.u.)
Intensity (a.u.)
CNT
Fe3O4
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
ID/IG=0.326
ID/IG=0.316
400
800 1200 1600 2000 2400 2800 3200
Raman shift (cm-1)
o
2Theta ( )
CNT-Fe3O4
Retained weight (%)
b)
CNT
100 80 60
42.8% 40 20
d)
0 0
0 200
400
600
800
1000
o
T ( C)
50 nm
291 292 293 294 295
Figure 1. XRD patterns (a), TEM images (b), Raman spectra (c), and TGA profiles (d) of the synthesized carbon nanotubes-magnetite nanohybrids (CNT-Fe3O4 NHs) and parent CNT component.
296
The EPMs and ζ-potentials of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the influents (in 2% CMC) and sand
297
grains under different experimental conditions are shown in Table S2. Both NHs and sand grains
298
were negatively charged, suggesting unfavorable conditions for column experiments. As
299
mentioned above, the NHs without CMC modification were highly-hydrophobic, making EPM
300
(and DLS) measurements impossible in aqueous solutions. However, in 2% CMC, the ζ-
301
potentials of NHs in the influents were highly negative (−39.4 to −58.7 mV) due mainly to the
15
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
302
adsorption of hydrophilic, negatively charged carboxymethyl groups of CMC (e.g., ζ-potential of
303
2% CMC-alone = −49.3 mV at 1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3) onto NHs’ surface. The ζ-potential of
304
NHs in the influents (in 2% CMC) was more negative than that of 2% CMC-alone at a specified
305
solution chemistry, e.g., −53.4 > −49.3 mV at 1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3 (Table S2). This
306
discrepancy could be due to the deprotonation of carboxyl and carbonyl groups of the NHs,
307
although most carboxyl groups are expected to be used for anchoring CNT and magnetite NMs
308
(described above). Consistent with reported results for individual NMs and sand grains,61-63
309
decreasing IS, and increasing NOM concentration and pH increased (more negative) the ζ-
310
potential of both NHs and sand grains. The divalent Ca2+ decreased the ζ-potentials of NHs and
311
sand grains more than monovalent Na+ at equivalent ISs by greater charge screening (both Na+
312
and Ca2+) and neutralization (Ca2+ only) effects.46
313
Table S2 also shows the variability in rh of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the influents (2% CMC)
314
with varying experimental conditions. Greater aggregation (larger rh) of the NHs was associated
315
with the lower ζ-potentials due to less electrostatic repulsions according to the DLVO interaction
316
prediction (described below). Similar findings have been documented for individual NMs.61, 62
317
The measured hydrodynamic diameter (2rh) of NHs and CNT (Table S2) lied within the diameter
318
(8−15 nm) and length (10−50 µm) of the CNT, consistent with the results reported previously.19
319
This is likely because, for non-spherical NHs and CNT, DLS gives the diameter of a sphere that
320
has the same average translational diffusion coefficient as the particle (NHs and CNT) being
321
measured (described above).
322 323
Mobility Comparison between CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and Individual CNT
16
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 16 of 44
Page 17 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
324
Breakthrough curves (BTCs) and retention profiles (RPs) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and CNT
325
(both in 2% CMC) under the identical transport condition (1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3) are presented
326
in Figure 2. Total mass recoveries (Mtot) of NHs in the effluents (Meff) and retentates (Mret) under
327
different experimental conditions are given in Table 1, which confirms a high degree of
328
confidence in our experimental measurements because virtually all NHs were recovered from
329
column experiments (Mtot−NHs=93.5−108% and Mtot−CNT=99.4%). The ICP-OES results for
330
effluent Fe analyses matched (standard errors 1526 > 3.4
368
nm) (Table S2 and Figure S4). This is due primarily to the greater interception efficiency (ηI) and
369
overall single-collector contact efficiency (ηo) at larger rh, because ηI and ηo increase
18
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 19 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
370
monotonically with colloid size when the diameter is ≥1 µm.34 To better understand the two-peak
371
transport feature, rh of NHs and CNT in the influents, effluents, and retentates was determined
372
(Figure 2d and Table 2). The rh of NHs was in the order: effluent < influent < retentate (e.g.,
373
1432 < 1632 < 2001 nm in 1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3; Table 2), indicating size-selective retention
374
in porous media. The size-selective retention that larger particles preferentially retain in the
375
column (retentates) due likely to greater ηI and ηo; and smaller ones elute out (effluents) has been
376
reported in colloid transport studies.47 Furthermore, for the effluents, the rh of both NHs and
377
CNT increased progressively with PV (Figure 2d), again strongly substantiating the size-
378
selective retention. It is thus logical to anticipate that smaller NHs/CNT associated with lower
379
viscous CMCs breakthrough earlier (yielding ‘peak 1’); whereas, larger NHs/CNT coated with
380
higher viscous CMCs are eluted out more retarded (i.e., ‘peak 2’). The peak location of ‘peak 2’
381
was earlier for CNT than that of NHs (4.5 vs. 5 PV; Figure 2a) further supports that larger
382
cumbersome NHs (effluent rh: CNT < NHs; Figure 2d) have a lower transport velocity (i.e., more
383
retarded breakthrough). Greater retention of NHs observed in Figure 2b is due to greater rh
384
(greater ηI and ηo) in the influents and effluents (Figure 2d). To sum up, the above results
385
underscore the interplay of viscosity variability of fluid and size-selective retention in the
386
transport of NMs (in 2% CMC) in water-saturated porous media.
19
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Peak 2
1.0
Page 20 of 44
1.2
a)
c)
CNT-Fe3O4
0.8
2% CMC
1.0
CNT
0.8
C/Co [-]
C/Co [-]
0.6 Peak 1 0.4 0.2
0.6 0.4 0.2
0.0
0.0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
1
2
3
4
PV 0.5
5
6
7
8
9
10
PV
b)
1600
CNT-Fe3O4
d)
CNT-Fe3O4
CNT
0.4
CNT
rh (nm)
0.3
3
S/Co (cm /g)
1200
0.2
400
0.1 0.0
800
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
PV
Depth (cm)
387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401
Figure 2. Breakthrough curves (BTCs; a) and retention profiles (RPs; b) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and individual CNT, respectively, in water-saturated sand columns at 1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3 (in 2% CMC). Breakthrough curve describes the normalized effluent concentration of NMs, C/Co (where Co is the initial influent concentration of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs or CNT) as a function of pore volume (PV); and retention profile shows the normalized solid-phase retention concentration of NMs, S/Co (where S is retention amount of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs or CNT per gram dry sand) as a function of distance from the column inlet. For column transport experiments, 3 PVs (marked by dash line in a) of CNT-Fe3O4 NH or CNT influent were injected in the column followed by elution with 7 PVs of NM-free background electrolyte solution (without CMC). Other column transport parameters were the same including: CNT-Fe3O4 NH or CNT influent concentration = 10 mg/L, influent pH = 7.3; background electrolyte = 1 mM NaCl; average sand grain size = 360 µm; and Darcy velocity = 0.44 cm/min. For comparison, the breakthrough curve of 2% CMCalone under the experimental condition (1 mM NaCl and pH 7.3) identical to that of NHs/CNT is shown in (c). Figure d shows the average hydrodynamic radius (rh) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and CNT
20
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 21 of 44
402 403
Environmental Science & Technology
in the effluents (collected from a). The error bars represent the standard deviations from duplicate experiments. Note different y-axis scales in figure.
404 Table 2. Average hydrodynamic radius (rh) of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in the influents (in 2% CMC), effluents, and retentates at different NaCl and CaCl2 concentrations. NaCl (mM)
CaCl2 (mM)
Sand grain diameter (µm)
rh (nm) Influent
Effluent a
Retentate b
∆rh c
0 1 10 50 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0.33 1.67 3.33
360 360 360 360 360 360 360
994±226 1632±143 1687±167 2025±290 1988±237 2238±399 2728±349
836±48 1432±152 1455±182 1734±324 1691±182 1825±297 1958±350
1096±41 2001±182 2285±234 2789±188 2338±146 2875±221 3568±438
260 569 830 1055 647 1050 1610
405 406 407 408 409 410
a
411
Mobility of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs under Varying Physicochemical Conditions
rh/r50 d (−) 5.52×10−3 9.07×10−3 9.37×10−3 1.13×10−2 1.10×10−2 1.24×10−2 1.52×10−2
Effluents collected at 1.5, 2, 2.5, and 3 PVs (Figures 2−3) were used for rh measurements. Retentates retained at the column inlet (0−1 cm) were used for rh measurements. c rh difference of NHs in the effluents and retentates. d r50 is the average sand grain radius (180 µm). The rh/r50 values were calculated to test the effect of straining on the retention of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs in column experiments. b
412
Environmentally-relevant physicochemical conditions were chosen to investigate the
413
mobility of CNT-Fe3O4 NHs (in 2% CMC) including: NaCl (Figure 3a−b), CaCl2 (Figure 3c−d),
414
SRHA (Figure 3e−f), and SRFA concentrations (Figure 3g−h), pHs (Figure S6a−b), particle
415
concentrations (Figure S6c−d), and collector sizes (Figure S6e−f). The DLVO interaction
416
energies between CNT-Fe3O4 NHs and sand grains under different experimental conditions are
417
shown in SI Figure S7 and Table S3. Before interpreting the mobility of NHs under different
418
experimental conditions, it is important to understand the colloidal stability of NH influents. In 2%
419
CMC, the NH influents were stable (influent concentration and rh stayed unchanged; Figure S2)
420
over the time frame of influent injection experiments. Recalling that without CMC, partial
21
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 22 of 44
421
aggregation of NHs was pronounced due to magnetic attraction (Figure S5), our findings
422
emphasize the critical role of 2% CMC in stabilizing the NH aggregates (e.g., NHs exist as stable
423
aggregates because rh varies with solution chemistries). No further aggregation and gravitational
424
sedimentation of NHs occurred in the influents during influent injection experiments, again
425
confirming the strong stabilizing effect of 2% CMC. Nonetheless, both CFT and TE equation
426
predict that gravitational sedimentation is appreciable when colloid diameter is ≥1 µm.30, 34 This
427
is likely because high viscous and negatively charged CMCs (described above) counterbalance
428
the role of gravity in causing particle sedimentation.
429
Similarly, the two-peak transport feature occurred frequently in the NHs’ BTCs with
430
altered C/Co values and peak locations (Figures 3 and S6). Decreasing IS, and increasing NOM
431
concentration, pH, particle concentration, and collector size (with the exception of 230-µm sand;
432
Figure S6e−f) increased the mobility of NHs (see Meff and Mret in Table 1), consistent with
433
DLVO theory prediction (Figure S7 and Table S3). Lower mobility of NHs under different
434
experimental conditions was again associated with less negative ζ-potential and larger rh due to
435
greater ηI and ηo. The size-selective retention also occurred during NHs transport (rh order:
436
effluent < influent < retentate; Table 2); and this effect became more pronounced (increased ∆rh)
437
at higher NaCl/CaCl2 concentrations. To better unravel the size-selective retention of NHs in
438
porous media, hydrodynamic particle size distribution of NHs in the influents (in 2% CMC) was
439
determined (SI Figure S8). Our results indicate a greater degree of particle size heterogeneity
440
(wider particle size distribution) among NHs populations, likely accounting for the greater size-
441
selective retention of NHs at higher NaCl/CaCl2 concentrations. Other potential explanations for
442
the greater size-selective retention at higher NaCl/CaCl2 concentrations include deeper attractive
443
secondary minimum (Table S3) and more pronounced straining (Table 2) given that hyper-
22
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 23 of 44
Environmental Science & Technology
444
exponential RPs occurred at high NaCl/CaCl2 concentrations (Figure 3b, d). The fact that
445
retained NHs were released upon injecting DI water during the three-step transport experiments
446
(SI Figure S9a) substantiates the important role of secondary minimum in NHs’ retention.
447
However, the extent of NHs’ release was much less in Ca2+ than in Na+ due likely to more
448
pronounced straining due to larger rh of NHs in the influents, effluents, and retentates (Table 2
449
and Figure S9b), i.e., Ca2+ bridges the -CH2COOH and -COOH groups of CMC-coated CNT-
450
Fe3O4 NHs. Straining is demonstrated to play a critical role in colloid retention and cause hyper-
451
exponential RPs when the diameter ratio of colloid vs. collector is ≥0.008.49 Our calculations
452
show that when the size ratio of NHs vs. collector was ≥0.00937 (≥10 mM NaCl and ≥1.67 mM
453
CaCl2; Table 2), straining started to yield the hyper-exponential RPs (Figure 3b, d). The slight
454
difference (0.008