Controlled Release of Pheromones Through Multi ... - ACS Publications

24 Controlled Release of Pheromones Through Multi-Layered Polymeric Dispensers AGIS F. KYDONIEUS and INJA K. SMITH Hercon Division, Health-Chem Corp., 1107 Broadway, New York, N.Y.

10010

Downloaded by FUDAN UNIV on November 20, 2016 | http://pubs.acs.org Publication Date: June 1, 1976 | doi: 10.1021/bk-1976-0033.ch024

MORTON BEROZA M. Beroza & Assoc., 821 Malta Lane, Silver Spring, Md. 20901

The purpose of this article is to discuss and review the experiences with the new 3-layer HERCON polymeric dispenser for controlled release of such volatile organic chemicals as the insect sex pheromones and related potent behavior-controlling chemicals. The dispenser is manufactured by The Hercon Division of HealthChem Corporation, New York, N.Y., 10010, and its first use in dispensing pheromones was reported in December 1974. (1) During the 1974 and 1975 seasons, millions of these dispensers containing sex pheromones were sold. This paper will report and examine the results that have become available and comment on the future potential of the product. First, some background material is in order. In the mid-fifties we began to hear of insects becoming resistant to insecticides and of pesticide residues appearing in our food. Later we heard of wildlife being affected, beneficial insects being destroyed along with the injurious ones, and that our air, soil, and water were becoming polluted with pesticides. Spurred by these ominous reports scientists began to cast about seriously in search of alternatives to the use of insecticides for insect control. One of the alternatives involved the use of insect attractants. At first, it was more fruitful to test a great variety of chemicals to find an attractant than to try to isolate and identify an attractive chemical from an insect. About half dozen attractants were found this way by the USDA, and they were put to good use. For example, traps each baited with synthetic lures for 3 of the world's worst insect pests, the Mediterranean fruit fly, oriental fruit fly, and the melon fly, were deployed about ports of entry to the U.S. since the early 1960s to detect an accidental importation of any of these subtropical pests. Infestations of all of these species were found, and they were eradicated quickly with the traps showing where and when to apply the appropriate counter measures. USDA has stated that the traps ®

283 Paul and Harris; Controlled Release Polymeric Formulations ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1976.


284

CONTROLLED RELEASE

POLYMERIC FORMULATIONS

have saved them millions of dollars in potential eradication costs, but they saved the agricultural community and the public far greater in increased prices o£ food that would have resulted i£ we had to live with these insects. With the great value of insect attractants established, the possibility of similar use of the attractants that the insects themselves manufacture, e.g., their sex attractants or pheromones, became most appealing. We have already heard from Dr. Bierl and her co-workers (2) about pheromones and their biological function, particularly their role in aiding the insect reproductive process. They also noted potential uses; i.e., how pheromones are useful in monitoring the whereabouts of injurious insect species, in timing control measures such as insecticide sprays to achieve optimum effects, and how pheromones may be useful in direct control, i.e., by mass trapping or by sowing pheromone-emitting particles among insect populations to prevent the sexes from finding each other and mating. For a long time, the isolation, identification, and synthesis of these materials—mainly the sex attractants—were hampered by the minute amounts of these potent substances present in insects. Fortunately, by the late 1960s, this situation was largely reversed by the introduction of remarkable improvements in spectrometric, chromatographic, instrumental, and specialized techniques, which greatly facilitated the isolation and identification of minute amounts of the pheromones. Progress has been so rapid in the past five years that pheromones or chemicals believed to be pheromones are now known for hundreds of insect species, (3), and many of these species are of great economic importance. What is needed now is the Technology to use the pheromones effectively. As a partial answer to this need, the HERCO^ dispensing system was developed. In its simplest form, the Hereon dispenser is a three-layer plastic laminate with the pheromone reservoir in the inner layer. (See Figure 1). A pressure sensitive adhesive can also be incorporated for ease of application. When the dispenser is exposed (as in a trap), the pheromone gradually diffuses out through the outer layers and is thereby released much as an insect releases its pheromone to lure a mate. Great flexibility in regulating the emission rate of the pheromone from the dispenser is readily achieved by adjusting the area of the dispenser (readily cut to size with scissors), the thickness of the outer layers, and the amount of pheromone per dispenser. Since most pheromones are potent, very little pheromone

Paul and Harris; Controlled Release Polymeric Formulations ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 1976.

24.

KYDONiEus ET AL.


φ

Pheromones

285

PRESSURE SENSITIVE ADHESIVE (OPTIONAL)

Figure 1

is needed and a dispenser may contain enough pheromone to last an entire season. A major point is that the pheromone is released at a near-constant rate. As a further feature, the position of the pheromone in the plastic laminate protects it from degradation by light or air. The importance of this protection should not be under estimated. Some pheromones, e.g., aldehydes, are rather unstable and have to be protected. Also, the degradation products of some sex attractants are inhibitors which quickly nullify attraction. For example, the sex lure of the cabbage looper (Tricoplusia ni [Hubner]) and the oriental fruit moth (Grapholitha molesta [Busck]) are acetates, and their corresponding alcohols (formed by deacetylation) are highly inhibitory (4)(5); as little as a few percent conversion of these acetates to their alcohols (hydrolysis) severly diminishes trap captures. The USDA gypsy moth (Lymantria dispar [L]) survey program was the first to use the HERCOI^ dispenser in their traps (6). In 1974, and again in 1975, at least 100, 000 of the traps were strat egically placed in the Eastern half of the U.S. to monitor the where abouts of the gypsy moth. The rate of emission of disparlure, the gypsy moth sex attractant, from the dispensers has been shown to be ample and fairly constant (6), and the dispensers are effective for an entire season. Compare Figure 2 and Figure 3 which give the emission rates of the Hereon dispenser and the previously used cotton wick dispenser. Mass-trapping with a new, inexpensive, highly efficient trap baited with the new dispenser has shown potential for direct control of the gypsy moth in light infestations (7). Further improvements of this trap are being made by the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service of the USDA. Earlier demonstrations that mass-



0.00L

10

20

30 40

DAYS

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

Figure 2. Rate of emission of HERCON laminated plastic dispensers of disparlure (lower graph) and percentage lure found in these laminates (upper graph) after aging at room temperature. Points for laminates with sealed ends designated by circles; points for laminates with open ends designated by triangles.

ι



24.

KYDONiEus E T AL.

0 , 0 0

0

10

287

Pheromones

20

30

40 50 DAYS

60

70

80

0

Figure 3. Rate of emission of cotton wicks, each initially containing 300 pg disparlure and 2 mg trioctanoin (solid line, ordinate on left), and percentage lure remaining (dashed line, ordinate on right, lure initially — 100% ) after aging up to 84 days at room temperature

trapping can prevent a buildup o£ low-level populations have been reported. The HERCON dispenser has also been used successfully by the US DA (8) with grandlure, the boll weevil (Anthonomus grandis Boheman) sex pheromone, a 4-component mixture of chemicals (9), two of which are aldehydes. As one part of an integrated control program designed to determine the feasibility of eradicating the boll weevil (the worst pest of cotton), the dispenser is used to lure weevils into traps. Of 4 types of dispensers recently tested by scientists of the Boll Weevil Research Laboratory, the HERCON dispenser performed best (10). After 12 weeks in the field, it caught 177% as many weevils as the next best type of dispenser, which was the standard 3 mg lure on a filter in a vial that had to be changed weekly throughout the test. (See Table I). The HERCON grandlure dispenser has now been designated as the standard in the Belt-wide tests being conducted against the boll weevil. The release rate of grandlure is also constant with time as shown in Figure 4.


CONTROLLED RELEASE POLYMERIC

FORMULATIONS


TABLE I MEXICO GRANDLURE FORMULATION TEST (1975) BOLL WEEVIL CATCHES HERCO]Sf5> Week USDA STANDARD (changed weekly) 2 71 17 4 138 50 6 115 75 8 41 40 10 17 27 12 7 9 388 TOTAL 219 H HERCON 177% Catches o£ Standard PRODUCT A 29% Catches o£ Standard PRODUCT Β 25% Catches o£ Standard PRODUCT C 91% Catches of Standard Source: T.B. Davich, Boll Weevil Research Lab, USDA.

RELEASE RATE OF GRANDLURE

°0

4

8

12

16

20

24

28

32

36

40 44

DAYS Figure 4.

Release rate of grandlure



24.

KYDONiEus E T AL.

Pheromones

289

The HERCON dispenser has also been adopted for use in the USDA pinkbollworm (Pectinophora gossypiella [Saunders]) survey program. This insect is the second most injurious pest of cotton in this country. Dispensers, 1 sq cm in size and containing about 1.5mg of the lure, a 1:1 mixture of (Z, 5^- and U-hexadecadien-l-ol acetates, have been highly effective in capturing pink bollworms in the field tests in different parts of the country. A recent report by McLaughlin, Mitchell and Tumlinson (L2J stated that HERCON dispensers provide an "excellent means for baiting pheromone traps" for the peachtree borer (Synanthedon exitiosa [Say]), the lesser peachtree borer (Synanthedon pictipes [G.Y.R.]), the soybean looper, (Pseudophtsia includens [Walker]), and the cabbage looper. They state further that the HERCON system is excellent for baiting traps because the dispensers "can be stored and handled with relative ease, and the rate of release of active compound is readily adjusted." The smaller European elm bark beetle, Scolytus multistriatus (Marsham), has been responsible for the decline of the American elm tree (Ulmus americana L.) in this country. After the ingredients of the sex pheromone of this beetle were reported by Pearce et al. to be 4-methyl-3-heptanol, cubebene, and a chemical called multistriatin (I3j, formulations of HERCON dispensers containing these ingredients were tested by Dr. John Peacock and R. A. Cuthbert of the USDA Forest Service (14J, and some were found highly attractive to the beetle. A production run of the best dispensers was tested over a prolonged period by comparing captures of traps baited with it versus captures made by traps with the same dispenser but freshly baited every two weeks. For 11 weeks, captures with the aged and freshly baited dispensers were not too different, which indicates that the rate of release of lure from fresh and aged dispensers was not too different; if a 70% level of captures by aged versus fresh dispensers is considered acceptable, the HERCON dispenser gave a total of 13 weeks of acceptable performance (5/22 - 8/20/75) without rebaiting (See Table II)· These results indicate that only one rebaiting would be needed to retain trap effectiveness for the 150-180-day season of the beetle. HERCON dispensers have been prepared with virelure, the sex attractant of the tobacco budworm (Heliothis virescens (F.), which consists of a mixture of (Z)-ll-hexadecenal and (Z)-9-tetradecenal. Our latest information indicates that the HERCON dispensers with virelure are catching well compared to other commercial formulations It outcatches several live females in a trap and remains effective for at least a month (15 ). Favorable results have also been reported in tests of the 3-layer laminate against other insect species, e.g., fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugip^rda Q, E. Smith]), Douglas-fir


290

CONTROLLED RELEASE

POLYMERIC

FORMULATIONS

TABLE II


Catches of Elm Bark Beetle at traps baited with HERCON® dispensers May 22 - August 20, 1975 Mean beetle catches for 20 traps WEEKS I 3 5 7 9 11 13 HERCON 391 368 476 162 95 515 567 CHECK— 342 283 477 128 294 518 820 % of Check 114 130 100 127 33^ 100 69 IjFresh dispenser every two weeks ]y Probably anomalous due to high value for check Source: Drs. John Peacock and Roy Cuthbert N/E Forest Expt. Station, USDA, Delaware. tussock moth (Orgyia pseudotsugata [McDunnough]), eastern spruce budworm ( Choristoneura fumiferana [Clemans]); but again the data have not been released by the investigators doing the testing. The 3-layer laminates also have potential for dispensing chemicals other than pheromones. For example, in an experiment with trimedlure, a synthetic lure for the Mediterranean fruit fly, (Ceratitis capitata [Wiedemann]), HERCON laminates attracted more than 21/2 times as many flies as the bait dispenser in current use, and this throughout a 2-month period. Furthermore, the HERCON dispenser achieved these results with less than 1/4 of the amount of lure used in the current bait dispenser. Before we leave the subject of trapping, it is well to note that the design of an optimum trapping system, whether for detection or control, requires consideration of many parameters. In addition to emission rate of lure, lure stability and quantity, and duration of effectiveness — which are related to the lure dispenser, consideration must also be given to trap design and color, trap height, trap placement, trapping means (e.g., use of adhesive or insecticide), position of bait dispenser in trap, effect of host crop, effective distance of attraction, time of insect response, cost of trap, and ratio of ingredients if the lure is multi-component. More attention to the determination of these parameters for the many different species of insects is needed. A device now under investigation by the Herculite Protective Fabrics Corporation comprises a long-lasting combination of the HERCON pheromone dispenser with a similar laminate that releases



24.

KYDONiEus E T A L .

Pheromones

291

insecticide at a controlled rate. The objective o£ the device is to attract the target insect to an insecticide-containing plastic sheet that will dispatch the insect on contact. Permeation o£ the atmosphere with sex pheromone to dis orient insects trying to find mates has already been mentioned. This technique has proven successful in experiments with the gypsy moth (up to 98% suppression in mating) (7) (16 ), oriental fruit moth (1>), codling moth (Laspeyresia pomonella [L]) (18), pink bolloworm moth (19), and many other insect pests (12). In most of these applications, micorencapsulated solutions of the pheromone were dispensed from aircraft or ground equipment. In some cases, metal planchets were used to evaporate the chemical into the atmosphere. USDA workers Mitchell and Tumlinson have come up with a simple means of accomplishing this disruption of pheromonal communication between the sexes. Thus, in a preliminary exper iment, they demonstrated such disruption with the boll weevil in a cotton field by using HERCON dispensers as evaporators of the boll weevil pheromone (20). The 1-inch-square dispensers were arrayed in a checkerboard pattern in a test plot with a pheromone baited trap at its center. The general idea of the test is that the boll weevils in the cotton field would have difficulty finding the trap if the pheromone emitted by the dispensers disoriented the weevils, and, in fact, this is what happened. Over a 20-day period, trap cap tures of weevils in the plot with the dispensers were suppressed 83% compared to trap captures in a similar plot without the dispensers. Similar suppression in captures was also obtained with dispensers containing two of the four grandlure components. In another similar experiment, C.R. Gentry and coworkers disoriented the peachtree borer and the lesser peachtree borer (20). Laminated HERCON strips (1-inch-square) containing the pheromone of the peachtree borer, (Ζ, Z, )-3,13-octadecadien-l-ol acetate (21), were hung on trees in two 2-acre peach orchards; another orchard was left untreated as a check. Traps baited with the pheromone of each insect were placed in each orchard to monitor the ability of the borers to find the traps. In comparison with the check, captures of the lesser peachtree borer in the plots with the dispensers were suppressed 100% for 9 weeks; then results became erratic. Fresh HERCON strips restored almost complete suppression of captures for another 10 weeks. (See Table III). Similar results were recorded for the peachtree borer, but because the population of this insect was extremely low, the significance of these results are question able.


292

CONTROLLED RELEASE POLYMERIC

FORMULATIONS


TABLE ΠΙ Effect of air-permeation trials on captures of lesser peachtree borer males in pheromone traps — Treated Untreated Week Orchard Ù/ Orchard 2 Orchard 3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

1 0 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 0

(86) (100) (92) (93) (100) (90) (100) (100)

-

(100)

0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2

(100) (93) (100) (100) (100) (100) (92) (100)

-

(83)

7 27 24 15 2 10 12 4 0 12

f!/ Each orchard had 5 traps baited with .100 mg of pure EJ Z. — Value in parenthesis is percent reduction compared to the untreated orchard. A preliminary report on the foregoing was made by McLaughlin et al (12) who also noted that HERCON formulations of (Z)-7-dodecen-l-ol acetate were tested in soybean fields as disruptants of soybean looper communication. "Several formulations were quite effective with excellent longevity",, according to these workers. If ground application of the pheromone formulation for air permeation is contemplated, use of the HERCON 3-layer dispensers as evaporators of the pheromone, e.g., by fastening them to foliage or other objects throughout the crop area, appears to offer a means that is simpler, more controllable, more dependable, and less expensive than any other means now available. In another variation of the air-permeation technique, sheets of the 3-layer laminate containing pheromone were reduced to a confetti or granules, which were then distributed over the crops to be protected. Although data are lacking on the results of such tests, we have been told that such material tested against the pink boll worm was effective for about 3 weeks. For application from aircraft or ground equipment, the pheromone granules or confetti will probably have to be dispensed with a sticker so the particles will adhere to the foliage upon impact and then slowly emit their lure to the atmosphere over a prolonged period and not be washed off



24. KYDONiEus E T A L .

Pheromones

293

by rain or removed by wind. Use of the HERCON granules may have advantages over other slow-release methods in terms of efficacy or cost or both. Mitchell has recently proposed the development of integrated pest management systems that use the atmospheric permeation technique with several chemicals to disrupt the mating of same or all of the offending coexisting species in a given vicinity (22). In seeking appropriate systems for Heliothis species, he has successfully disrupted insect communication with HERCON 3-layer laminates that volatilized (Z)-U-hexadecenal and (2J-9-tetradecenal into the atmosphere at a controlled rate. These unsaturated aldehydes are sensitive compounds. However, in most cases, the addition of an anti-oxidant has not improved performance of HERCON pheromone dispensers. In his article (22), Mitchell outlines how the laminated plastic strips would be used in simultaneous release of several chemicals #

Summarizing Contents With pheromones of economically important insects species rapidly becoming available (see recent listing of pheromones) (3) (23), the HERCON dispensing system appears to have excellent potential for use in trapping, air permeating, and in lure-insecticide combinations. The flexibility of the system makes it easy to adjust the rate of emission of the behavior chemical to values approaching optimum and greatly facilitates their use as dispensers in traps or as evaporators of pheromone in the air-permeation technique. Ease of handling and storage, protection of a broad variety of chemicals from degradation by light and air, and excellent weathering qualities are other unique features of the HERCON multi-layered polymeric dispenser. Literature Cited (1) Beroza, M., Paszek, E.C., Mitchell, E.R., Bierl, B.A., McLaughlin, J.R., and Chambers, D.L. Environ. Entomol. (1974) 3, 926-8. (2) Bierl, B.A., DeVilbiss, E.D., and Plimmer. The Use of Pheromones in Insect Control: Slow Release Formulations. This Symposium. (3) Mayer, M.S., and McLaughlin, J.R., "An Annotated Compendium of Insect Sex Pheromones", Fla. Agric. Exptl. Station, No. 6, Univ. Fla., Gainesville, August 1975. (4) Tumlinson, J.H., Mitchell, E.R., Browner, S. M., Mayer, M.S., Green, N., Hines, R., and Lindquist, D.A. Environ. Entomol. (1972), 1, 354-8.



294

CONTROLLED

RELEASE POLYMERIC

FORMULATIONS

(5) Beroza, M., Gentry, C.R., Blythe, J.L., and Muschik, G.M., J. Econ. Entomol. (1973) 66, 1307 - 11. (6) Beroza, M., Paszek, E.C., DeVilbiss, D., Bierl, B.A., and Tordif, J.G.R., Environ. Entomol. (1975) 4, 712-4. (7) Beroza, M., Hood, G.S., Trefrey, D., Leonard, D.E., Knipling, F.F., and Klassen, W., Environ. Entomol. (1975) 4, 705-11. (8) Hardee, D.D., McKibben, G.H., and Huddleston, P.M., J. Econ. Entomol. (1975) 68, 477-9. (9) Tumlinson, J.H., Hardee, D.D., Gueldner, R.C., Thompson, A.C., Hedin, P.Α., and Minyard, J.P. Science (1969) 166, 1010-2. (10) Private Communication. (11) Hummel, H.E., Gaston, L.K., Shorey, H.H., Kaae, R.S., Byrne, K.S., Silverstein, R.M., Science (1973) 181, 873-5. (12) McLaughlin, J.R., Mitchell, E.R., and Tumlinson, J.H., Proc. 1975 International Controlled Release Pesticide Symposium, Sept. 8-10, 1975, Wright State Univ., Dayton, Ohio, P. 209-15. (13) Pearce, G.T., Gore, W.E., Silverstein, R.M., Peacock, J.W., Cuthbert, R.A., Lanier, G.N. and Simeone, J.B., J. Chem. Ecol. (1975)1,115-124. (14) Peacock, J.W., and Cuthbert, R.A., Proc. 1975 Intn'l Controlled Release Pesticide Symposium, Sept. 8-10, 1975, Wright State Univ., Dayton, Ohio, P. 216. (15) Private Communication, E.R. Mitchell, USDA. (16) Schwalbe, C.P., Cameron, E.A., Hall, D.J., Richerson, J. V., Beroza, M., and Stevens, L.J., Environ. Entomol. (1974) 3,. 589-92. (17) Gentry, C.R., Beroza, M. Blythe, J.L., and Bierl, B.A., Environ. Entomol. (1975) 4, 822-4. (18) Anonymous. Agric. Res. (Wash., D.C.) (1974), May 15. (19) McLaughlin, J.R., Shorey, H.H., Gaston, L.K., Kaae, R.S., and Stewart, F.D., Environ. Entomol. (1972), 1, 645-50. (20) Mitchell, E.R., and Tumlinson, J.H., USDA, Gainesville Fla., Private Communication. (21) Tumlinson, J.H., Yonce, C.E., Doolittle, R.E., Heath, R.R., Gentry, C.R., and Mitchell, E.R., Science (1974) 185, 614-6. (22) Mitchell, E.R., Bioscience (1975) 25, 493-9. (23) Inscoe, M.N., and Beroza, M. ACS Symposium Series. In Press.


Controlled Release of Pheromones Through Multi ... - ACS Publications

Recommend Documents