SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
IT’S ALL ABOUT ACCESS Collections of DIGITAL RESOURCES expand, enhancing current and ensuring future access to scientific data
ests without compensation, including the value added to the article by the publishers’ investments in the peer review process and other quality-assurance aspects of journal publication.” ACS is a member of AAP.
SOPHIE L. ROVNER, C&EN WASHINGTON
ONLINE BOOKS
Google has scanned many chemistryrelated books, which can be viewed and purchased online.
C HEM ICA L A BSTRACTS S ERVI C E
journal articles, books, and data are flowing into online archives and databases, potentially broadening access to the material for both scientists and the public. This trend raises issues such as who should have access to what material, what should be saved for the long haul, and how best to preserve the information. Without proper precautions, a disastrous loss of access to old data could occur. Just think how hard it is to find equipment to play an eight-track tape. Even accessing the data on a 5.25-inch floppy disk is problematic. Skip ahead a century or two, through multiple transformations in software and hardware, and you’ll get a sense of the nightmare bedeviling data preservationists. Other stakeholders are more concerned with providing current access. Google, for instance, is scanning the book collections of several major libraries so readers can view the books online and then buy or borrow them. The National Institutes of Health will soon require its grant recipients to deposit their journal articles in PubMed Central, its free digital archive of biomedical and life sciences literature. Some publishers welcome the enhanced exposure that these databases proffer. Others believe that Google and NIH are paying inadequate attention to intellectual property rights. Recent legislation has brought the disagreements with NIH to a head. In December 2007,
GOO GL E
MORE AND MORE scientific
OPEN ACCESS is also a hot issue in Europe. Last November, the Council of the European Union said it supported the concept of free online access to “scientific output resulting from publicly funded research … under economically viable circumstances, including delayed open access.” But it stopped short of mandating such access. Another European body, the European Research Council, went further. The EU established ERC a year ago to fund investigator-initiated cutting-edge basic research in science, technology, and other areas. Last December, ERC released guidelines pertaining to publications authored by its grantees. “In the age of the Internet, free and efficient access to information, including scientific publications OUT OF DATE President George W. Bush signed and original data, will be the key Obsolete a bill including a provision requirfor sustained progress,” according hardware ing NIH-funded investigators to to the guideline document. ERC and software deposit electronic copies of their added that “access to unprocessed threaten accepted, peer-reviewed manudata is needed not only for indefuture access to historic scripts in PubMed Central. The pendent verification of results but, manuscripts must be made public- scientific data. more importantly, for secure presly available in the archive within a ervation and fresh analysis and year of publication. NIH’s previous utilization of the data.” policy had called for voluntary submission ERC then declared that peer-reviewed of manuscripts. In January, NIH laid out publications based on research it funds the specifics of the new process, which af“must be deposited on publication into fects manuscripts accepted for publication an appropriate research repository where on or after April 7 (C&EN, Jan. 21, page 10). available, such as PubMed Central or an Allan Adler, vice president for legal and institutional repository, and subsequently governmental affairs made open access within six months of at the Association publication.” And it stated that primary of American Pubdata such as nucleotide/protein sequences lishers (AAP), says or macromolecular atomic coordinates the new policy is must be deposited in “relevant databases” “unprecedented and within six months of publication. inconsistent with Scientists have loads of data repositories important U.S. laws from which to choose, including the Proand policies regardtein Data Bank archive of macromolecular ing the conduct of structural data and the Cambridge Strucscientific research tural Database of crystal structures. and the protection of Some organizations are working to enintellectual property sure that data persist once they’re depositrights.” The policy ed in such an archive. The National Science “allows the agency to Foundation, the Andrew W. Mellon Fountake important pubdation, and other sponsors have formed an lisher property interinternational Blue Ribbon Task Force on
WWW.C E N- ONLI NE .ORG
26
FE BRUARY 4, 20 0 8
Sustainable Digital Preservation & Access, which held its first meeting in Washington, D.C., in January. The task force is charged with finding an economically viable plan for preserving and accessing digital data as the information migrates through computer upgrades and format and storage changes in the coming decades. NSF is encouraging digital preservation efforts through other means as well, including its new Sustainable Digital Preservation & Access Network Partners (DataNet) program. The agency says the program is designed to develop new types of technically and economically sustainable organizations that will “provide reliable digital preservation, access, integration, and analysis capabilities for science and/or engineering data over a decades-long timeline,” among other goals. NSF notes “data” can run the gamut from text and numeric data to software, models and simulations, video, and even websites. The agency is currently reviewing preliminary DataNet proposals submitted by academic institutions and by nonprofit, nonacademic organizations engaged in
scientific research and education. Full proposals will be due in March. NSF expects to invest up to $100 million in the project over a five-year period. SIMILAR EFFORTS are under way world-
wide. For instance, the Dutch government is funding research and development at the National Library of the Netherlands to ensure permanent access to the material in the library’s e-Depot digital archive. According to the library, the R&D is intended to preserve access to digital material, “which would otherwise be threatened by rapidly evolving software and hardware platforms as well as media decay.” The archive was established in 2003 and contains more than 10 million digital objects drawn from the arts, humanities, and social sciences; science, technology, and medicine; and digital culture. The library has made e-Depot storage services available to publishers worldwide who wish to participate in the project, including Elsevier and the International Union of Crystallography. Publishers determine access restrictions for the material they submit to the archive.
The National Library of the Netherlands is also coordinating the Alliance for Permanent Access, which was launched in November 2007. The group consists of European research institutes, research funders, national libraries, and international publishers, including the European Science Foundation, CERN, and the Max Planck Society. The library says the alliance plans to establish a “European infrastructure to secure permanent access to the digital records of science.” In addition, the National Library of the Netherlands is participating in the Digital Repository Infrastructure Vision for European Research (DRIVER). Funded by the European Commission, this project is integrating multiple repositories from many institutions to create a virtual network of open-access scientific information. But not all e-resource projects are so complex. For instance, several projects are under way to digitize books—including chemistry-related volumes—and make them more accessible for both scientists and the public. Examples include the Library Project
focused_expertise Focused on developing high potency APIs and maintaining an excellent regulatory track record, our expertise helps translate your discoveries into commercial realities. Our comprehensive and flexible development and manufacturing services includes:
R EQUEST MOR E AT ADI NFONOW.ORG
Getting drugs to market faster and more cost effectively requires Focus. Learn more at: www.ashstevensisfocused.com or call us at 734-282-3370.
focused_experience / focused_expertise / focused_results
WWW.C E N- ONLI NE .ORG
27
FE BRUARY 4, 20 0 8
R EQUEST MOR E AT ADI NFONOW.ORG
Process research and development Scale-up from grams to metric tons Analytical and regulatory support Stability services
WO RLD ACC ESS
Publishers Reach Out To Asia And Developing Nations cost online access to biomedical journals. The International Network for the Availability of Scientific Publications (INASP) manages a similar program for a broader range of journals—including those of the American Chemical Society—and also helps to strengthen local journals. AMERICAN PHYS ICA L SOC IETY
Greater access can be achieved in a variety of ways. One way is to make publications more welcoming for users outside the Western Hemisphere. For instance, the Health InterNetwork Access to Research Initiative (HINARI) provides nonprofit institutions in developing countries with free or low-
THE TWAIN MEET The American Physical Society is experimenting with the use of Asian characters for author names.
ing the search term in context. Additional information can include keywords, chapter titles, and a list of related books. A few sample pages, or even the entire book, can be viewed if the author or publisher has given permission or the book is no longer copyrighted. Links to stores and libraries allow the user to buy or borrow the book. The Association of American Publishers and others have sued Google for copyright infringement. Google maintains that it’s not infringing copyright because it allows publishers to opt out of the program.
run by Google, which is working with several major libraries to scan their collections into its online database. Users find books through Google Book Search, which can track down any type of book, including fiction and nonfiction, scholarly and reference, and out-of-print and rare books. Examples from the chemistry section of the site include “Carbon Nanotubes: Properties and Applications.” Clicking on a search result provides bibliographic information about the book and in many cases a few sentences show-
R EQUEST MOR E AT ADI NFONOW.ORG
High Precison Syringe Pumps • • • • •
Graphical User Interface Wide Flow Range Down To Pico-Liter/Hour Imbedded Syringe Library Run-time Status With Stall Detection Use Any Syringe Brand
Great For: • Microfluidics • Reactor Dosing • Electrospinning Chemyx Inc.
Additonal Features: • Computer Control • Automated Multi-step Dosing Optional Houston, TX USA
ing Pric m Fro
,650
5-1 $96
e-mail:
[email protected] WWW.C E N- ONLI NE .ORG
www.chemyx.com
28
FE BRUARY 4, 20 0 8
Publishers are striving to become more inclusive in other ways. For instance, the American Physical Society (APS) is experimenting with a program for Asian authors who publish in the society’s Physical Review journals. These authors can now include their names using Chinese, Japanese, or Korean characters in addition to the version in Latin characters. In a recent editorial about the program (Phys. Rev. Lett. 2007, 99, 230001), APS Editor-In-Chief Gene D. Sprouse lists eight Chinese names that all transliterate as Wei Wang. In this particular case, the addition of the author’s name in its original Chinese form would help clear up any ambiguities about which particular Wei Wang authored the paper. The program might be extended to additional languages in the future. ACS will introduce a similar capability in its journals later this year.
The U.K.’s Joint Information Systems Committee (JISC), which funds many archive projects, is digitizing numerous resources for free online access, including dissertations. JISC acknowledges that the dissertation project “knowingly infringes copyright” but notes that an author can have a dissertation removed from the collection and the service is not for profit. Other organizations have avoided such controversy altogether. They include the Open Content Alliance (OCA), which is scanning out-of-copyright books for free online access. It’s supported by Yahoo!, the Internet Archive, and several libraries. The online collection will also include multimedia works. OCA and some major libraries are also providing resources for Microsoft’s bookscanning project. The software company’s developmental Live Search Books service provides free online searching of and access to books that are out of copyright or have been provided by publishers. Of course, some books and data are more valuable than others. Given that archival resources are finite, those entrusted to safeguard the digital legacy of science will face difficult decisions about what digital materials to preserve, and for how long. ■
