Natural Attenuation of Nonvolatile Contaminants in the Capillary

Aug 12, 2016 - Institute of Scientific Research and High Technology Services, Calle ... University of West Florida, Pensacola, Florida 32514-5751, Uni...
0 downloads 0 Views 2MB Size
Subscriber access provided by Northern Illinois University

Article

Natural attenuation of non-volatile contaminants in the capillary fringe Zohre Kurt, Elizabeth Erin Mack, and Jim C Spain Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b02525 • Publication Date (Web): 12 Aug 2016 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on August 16, 2016

Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.

Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.

Page 1 of 29

1  

Environmental Science & Technology

Natural attenuation of non-volatile contaminants in the capillary fringe

2   3  

ZOHRE KURT1,2*, E. ERIN MACK3 AND JIM C. SPAIN1,4

4   5  

1

6  

Atlanta Georgia 30332-0512

7  

2

8  

Panama

9  

3

School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology,

Institute of Scientific Research and High Technology Services, Calle Pullpn, Panamá,

DuPont, Corporate Remediation Group, P.O. Box 6101, Glasgow 300, Newark, DE

10  

19714-6101

11  

4

12  

Pensacola Florida 32514-5751

13   14   15   16   17  

*

18  

Abstract

19  

Center for Environmental Diagnostics and Bioremediation, University of West Florida,

Corresponding Author Phone: +(507) 317-1745 Fax: +(507) 507-0020 E-mail: [email protected]

When anoxic polluted groundwater encounters the overlying vadose zone an

20  

oxic/anoxic interface is created- often near the capillary fringe. Biodegradation of volatile

21  

contaminants in the capillary fringe can prevent vapor migration. In contrast, the

22  

biodegradation of non-volatile contaminants in the vadose zone has received

23  

comparatively little attention. Non-volatile compounds do not cause vapor intrusion, but

24  

they still move with the groundwater and are major contaminants. Aniline (AN) and

25  

diphenylamine (DPA) are examples of toxic non-volatile contaminants found often at dye

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

1  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 2 of 29

26  

and munitions manufacturing sites. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that bacteria

27  

can aerobically biodegrade AN and DPA in the capillary fringe and decrease the

28  

contaminant concentrations in the anoxic plume beneath the vadose zone. Laboratory

29  

multiport columns that represented the unsaturated zone were used to evaluate

30  

degradation of AN or DPA in contaminated water. The biodegradation fluxes of the

31  

contaminants were estimated to be 113 ± 26 mg AN • m-2 • hr-1 and 76 ± 18 mg DPA • m-

32  

2

33  

contaminant profiles along with enumeration of bacterial populations indicated that most

34  

of the biodegradation took place within the lower part of the capillary fringe. The results

35  

indicate that bacteria capable of contaminant biodegradation in the capillary fringe can

36  

create a sink for non-volatile contaminants.

• hr-1 in the presence of bacteria known to degrade AN and DPA. Oxygen and

37   38  

Introduction

39  

A considerable portion of microbial biodegradation at subsurface contaminated

40  

sites occurs at plume fringes where electron donors and electron acceptors intersect 1-4.

41  

For example, oxic/ anoxic interfaces are often found at the leading edges of plumes. The

42  

vadose zone often includes an oxic/anoxic interface in or near the capillary fringe when

43  

anoxic contaminated plumes interact with the overlying air 5. In principle, capillary

44  

fringes are similar to sediment/water interfaces6 and plume fringes7, 8 because microbial

45  

activity creates steep redox gradients, resulting in high rates of contaminant

46  

biodegradation.

47  

The fate of volatile contaminants in the vadose zone has been of great interest

48  

because they pose a risk of vapor intrusion9. As a result, biodegradation of petroleum

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

2  

Page 3 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

49  

hydrocarbons in the vadose zone has been studied extensively. Field measurements 10, 11

50  

and laboratory studies revealed rapid biodegradation of hydrocarbons in the presence of

51  

oxygen and the processes have been described by several models 5, 12-14. Such models

52  

along with the field data related to dissolved hydrocarbons clearly reveals that

53  

biodegradation in the lower part of the unsaturated zone near the capillary fringe is

54  

sufficient to prevent vapor migration and intrusion 11. Furthermore, studies performed

55  

with laboratory columns15, 16 and field measurements 17, 18 recently established the

56  

potential for aerobic biodegradation of chlorinated compounds in the vadose zone.

57  

Although considerable effort has been devoted to understanding the

58  

biodegradation of volatile compounds in the vadose zone, biodegradation of non-volatile

59  

compounds has received little attention. Some non-volatile compounds are known to

60  

biodegrade in unsaturated soil 19. Pesticide biodegradation in the vadose zone was

61  

demonstrated by microcosm studies 20, 21, field measurements 20, 22 and by isotope

62  

fractionation 20. Non-volatile and semi-volatile petroleum hydrocarbons 23 and some

63  

explosives 24, 25 have also been studied in laboratory systems designed to simulate the

64  

vadose zone. These contaminants were typically introduced from the surface. In contrast,

65  

biodegradation of dissolved phase non-volatile contaminants in the vadose zone is poorly

66  

understood.

67  

Example of non-volatile toxic contaminants found in soil and groundwater are

68  

aniline (AN) and diphenylamine (DPA) 26, 27, which are precursors of industrial chemicals

69  

such as dyes, pharmaceuticals and explosives 28-30. . The dimensionless Henry’s Law

70  

constants for AN and DPA at 20 0C are 5.82x10-5 and 1.83x10-4, but both are ionized in

71  

water at circumneutral pH. Both AN and DPA are readily biodegradable and used as

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

3  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 4 of 29

72  

carbon sources under aerobic conditions. Furthermore, aniline is biodegradable under

73  

anoxic conditions29, 31-34. The aerobic biodegradation pathway of DPA was reported to

74  

involve AN as an intermediate 29, but its biodegradation in soil was not established. The

75  

goal of this study was to determine the extent to which non-volatile compounds in AN or

76  

DPA contaminated groundwater are transported to and aerobically biodegraded in the

77  

capillary fringe of laboratory columns. The columns were inoculated with Burkholderia

78  

sp. JS667 and Ralstonia sp. JS668 29 to catalyze aerobic degradation of either AN or DPA

79  

in the capillary fringe. The results revealed rapid biodegradation in the lower portion of

80  

the capillary fringe and enhanced diffusive transport of the contaminants to the active

81  

zone.

82   83  

Materials and Methods

84  

Chemicals. AN (> 99.5 %) and DPA (> 99 %) were from Sigma-Aldrich. All other

85  

chemicals were reagent grade.

86  

Analytical methods. AN and DPA were analyzed in aqueous samples by high

87  

performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) by the method of Shin and Spain 29.

88  

Absorbance was monitored at 265 nm and detection limits were below 0.5 mg/L. The AN

89  

and DPA concentrations in the unsaturated region above the capillary fringe were

90  

analyzed with 45 µm Supelco solid phase microextraction (SPME) C18 fiber probes in 22

91  

Ga needles (catalog number 57281-U). The probes were inserted through the ports into

92  

the sand and held for 10 minutes. Desorption was performed for 20 minutes in a 50:50

93  

mixture of acetonitrile-water. Probes were calibrated with known amounts of AN and

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

4  

Page 5 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

94  

DPA in duplicate samples of sand with 5% w/w moisture content. AN or DPA used for

95  

calibration was prepared by adding to dry sand appropriate concentrations (0.2- 50 mg/L.

96  

Variability among duplicate samples in standards was less than 1%. Gas phase samples

97  

(100 µL) were analyzed for oxygen with an Agilent Technologies 6850 Network GC

98  

equipped with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD) as described previously 35. All the

99  

gas samples were analyzed in duplicate except the first port above the saturated layer of

100  

the multiport columns where there was only enough volume for single samples.

101  

Growth conditions. Burkholderia sp. strain JS667 and Ralstonia sp. strain JS668 that

102  

degrade both AN and DPA were grown as described by Shin and Spain 29 with either AN

103  

or DPA as the sole carbon source. When the cells were in the exponential growth phase

104  

they were centrifuged, washed and suspended in minimal salt medium (MSB) 36 to an

105  

OD600 of 0.2. Equal volumes of the suspensions were combined to obtain the mixture

106  

used to inoculate the columns and microcosms. One-quarter strength trypticase soy agar

107  

(1/4-TSA) was used to check the purity of the cultures based on colony morphology.

108  

Microcosms. Microcosms designed to determine whether bacteria could degrade DPA in

109  

unsaturated soil were constructed in 35 mL serum bottles sealed with Teflon lined

110  

stoppers. Soil used for the study was from the subsurface of a field site heavily

111  

contaminated for decades mainly with DPA. The bottles contained 5 g of homogenized

112  

DPA contaminated soil or contaminated soil that was mixed with potting soil. All the soil

113  

mixtures were dried for 24 hours at room temperature, inoculated with 1 mL of the

114  

Burkholderia sp. strain JS667 and Ralstonia sp. strain JS668 mixture described above to

115  

a final moisture content of 20% w/w and sieved (0.42 mm). Control microcosms included

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

5  

Environmental Science & Technology

116  

20 mg of sodium azide/g of soil. The microcosms were incubated at room temperature

117  

with no stirring. At appropriate intervals microcosms were sacrificed and the contents

118  

extracted with acetonitrile-water (50:50). The initial biodegradation rates were estimated

119  

from the slopes of the concentrations between the first and second data points in Figs.

120  

1A, B and C.

121  

Page 6 of 29

The microcosms prepared to evaluate the effect of moisture content on

122  

biodegradation rates and microbial growth were prepared using 15 mL scintillation vials

123  

sealed with Teflon lined caps. Each vial contained 10 g of sand (0.6 to 0.42 mm sieve

124  

size) and 0.2 mg of DPA. Moisture was adjusted with ¼ strength MSB. Inoculated vials

125  

contained 0.5 mL of the inoculum described above. Vials were vortexed for 30 sec and

126  

then centrifuged at 500 rpm for 10 min to pack the sand uniformly. Individual vials were

127  

sacrificed to measure DPA and protein concentrations at appropriate intervals. DPA was

128  

extracted with 3 mL of acetonitrile after addition of sufficient ¼ MSB to bring the

129  

moisture content to saturation (30 % w/w). Suspensions were mixed by vortexing for 30

130  

sec and incubated for 10 hours to allow proper desorption at 40 C prior to HPLC analysis

131  

of the liquid phase for DPA. Biodegradation rates were calculated from the initial slopes

132  

of the DPA depletion curves. Bacterial biomass was estimated by adding ¼ strength MSB

133  

to a final volume of 5 mL of liquid per vial, mixing for 1 min and using 1 mL of

134  

supernatant for protein measurements. Protein was quantified with a BCA assay reagent

135  

kit (Rockford, IL, USA) after suspending the cells in 0.1 N sodium hydroxide and

136  

incubation at 95 0C for 10 min. Controls included vials with no inoculum or with no

137  

DPA.

138  

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

6  

Page 7 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

139  

Multiport columns. Multiport columns (30 cm × 2.2 cm) 15 described previously were

140  

packed with sand that was baked overnight at 550 0C (0.6 to 0.42 mm sieve size) (Fig.

141  

S1). Deionized water containing either AN or DPA prepared under nitrogen was pumped

142  

in the bottom of the column and exited 1 cm above the feed port to simulate a water table.

143  

The aqueous feed and air flows in the column were maintained at 1 mL • h-1 to ensure

144  

that oxygen concentrations were sufficient. Autoclaved sand was used for packing all

145  

columns but no attempt was made to maintain sterility after columns were set up.

146  

Uninoculated control (abiotic) columns were first operated until steady state for AN and

147  

DPA concentrations were established (8 days of constant concentration profile of DPA

148  

and AN) and then inoculated with 25 mL of Burkholderia sp. JS667 and Ralstonia sp.

149  

JS668 mixture. Effluent ports were closed and the column was filled with the bacterial

150  

suspension from the bottom port of the columns to create the active columns. The liquid

151  

used for inoculation was drained immediately from the lowest ports of the column by

152  

gravity. The capillary fringe in the columns was estimated to be 12 to 17 cm thick based

153  

on the mesh size of the sand 12 and 13 cm as estimated visually. At the end of the study

154  

the moisture content in each section of the column was measured by scooping the sand

155  

out of the column and then weighing samples before and after drying at 105 0C for 12

156  

hours.

157   158  

Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR). A PowerSoil DNA Isolation Kit (MO

159  

BIO Laboratories, Carlsbad, CA) was used to extract DNA from 2 cm segments of the

160  

column packing. An ABI 7500 Fast Real-Time PCR System equipped with SDS v. 2.0.3

161  

software with default SYBR Green cycling parameters was used for qPCR with a

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

7  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 8 of 29

162  

previously established protocol 37. Total bacterial 16S rRNA, aniline dioxygenase (tdnA1)

163  

and diphenylamine dioxygenese (dpaAa) genes were amplified using BacF/BacR 38,

164  

ANDO-F/ANDO-R 29 and DPADO-F/DPADO-R 29 primers respectively. Calibrations

165  

were performed in triplicate with serial 10-fold dilutions (from approximately 3 × 108

166  

copies down to approximately 3 copies per reaction 39) of the 16S rRNA, aniline

167  

dioxygenase and diphenylamine dioxygenase genes of Burkholderia sp. JS667 cloned in

168  

the pGEM-T Easy Vector System. Standard curves had a linear slope of 3.1–3.4 and an

169  

R2 value higher than 0.90 where 33 copies per reaction was the minimum detection limit.

170  

It was assumed that there was a single AN and DPA oxygenase gene in each organism

171  

and that there were 3 and 6 copies of 16S rRNA gene per cell of Ralstonia and

172  

Burkholderia respectively 40.

173   174  

Results and Discussion

175  

Microcosms with contaminated soil

176  

Even though field samples were mainly contaminated with DPA there were also

177  

minor amounts of other uncharacterized contaminants present in the samples. There was

178  

no detectable biodegradation of DPA in the microcosms prepared with undiluted field

179  

samples (10,000 mg DPA/kg) during the course of the experiment as indicated by the

180  

similarity between concentrations in active microcosms and sterile controls (Fig. 1A).

181  

The results suggested that the field samples contained toxic concentrations of DPA or

182  

other contaminants. In contrast, DPA was biodegraded rapidly in inoculated microcosms

183  

containing diluted soil at DPA concentrations up to 2000 mg /kg dry soil (Fig. 1B-C).

184  

The biodegradation rates were 7.2 ± 1.4 µg • h -1 and 0.8 ± 0.2 µg • h -1 per g of soil for

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

8  

Page 9 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

185  

10x and 100x diluted soil, respectively. The results indicate that bacteria in the

186  

unsaturated soil could biodegrade DPA at loading rates far above the water solubility (50

187  

mg/L). It is also clear that the DPA degrading bacteria can degrade DPA under the

188  

unsaturated conditions expected to be encountered in the capillary fringe of the vadose

189  

zone.

190  

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

9  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 10 of 29

191   192  

Figure 1. Degradation of DPA in microcosms containing inoculated soil (blue) and

193  

uninoculated soil with sodium azide as a control (red). Field sample (A), field sample

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

10  

Page 11 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

194  

diluted 1:10 with potting soil (B) and field sample diluted 1:100 with potting soil (C)

195  

(Data represent means of duplicate microcosms).

196  

Biodegradation in the vadose zone columns

197  

Sand columns designed to represent the capillary fringe in the vadose zone above

198  

contaminated subsurface plumes were used to evaluate the biodegradation of AN or

199  

DPA. The uninoculated columns reached steady state within 66 hours (Fig. 2A and Fig.

200  

3A). The aqueous feed of the columns contained 59 ± 6 mg of AN/L or 37 ± 4 mg of

201  

DPA/L, and the effluent of the columns was 56 ± 7 mg of AN/L or 36 ± 5 mg of DPA/L

202  

which indicated negligible flux to the atmosphere or losses due to abiotic transformation.

203  

Contaminants were not detected above the capillary fringe (16 cm above the saturated

204  

layer) which is consistent with their low vapor pressure. The inoculated columns reached

205  

steady state after 58 hours (AN) and 62 hours (DPA) and were operated subsequently for

206  

201 hours (Fig. 2B and Fig. 3B) with a feed of 60 ± 5 mg of AN/L or 38 ± 4 mg of

207  

DPA/L. Effluent concentrations of 17 ± 3 mg of AN/L or 7 ± 2 mg of DPA/L indicated

208  

substantial flux due to biodegradation. DPA and AN were not detected 6 cm above the

209  

saturated layer. When air pumped into the top of the columns was switched to nitrogen

210  

biodegradation stopped within 36 hours, and the system remained stable for a total of 92

211  

hours (Fig. 2C and Fig. 3C). The activity in both columns recovered within 46 (AN) and

212  

52 (DPA) hours after air was reintroduced.

213  

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

11  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 12 of 29

214  

 

215  

 

216  

Figure 2. AN concentration profiles in the multiport column. Uninoculated control

217  

column after 100 hours (A), active column 201 hours after inoculation with bacteria (B),

218  

and anoxic column 92 hours after the air feed was replaced with nitrogen (C).

219   220  

221   222  

 

223  

Figure 3. DPA concentration profiles in the multiport column. Uninoculated control

224  

column after 100 hours (A), active column 201 hours after inoculation with bacteria (B),

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

12  

Page 13 of 29

225  

Environmental Science & Technology

and anoxic column 92 hours after air feed was replaced with nitrogen (C).

226   227  

Columns were designed so that the difference between the influent and effluent

228  

contaminant concentrations could be used to determine the mass balance and

229  

biodegradation flux in the capillary fringe. The non-volatile contaminants move

230  

throughout the columns only via diffusion in the water; therefore, there was no net flux of

231  

the contaminants to the unsaturated zones of the abiotic columns from the saturated zones

232  

after steady state was established. In the inoculated columns the difference between

233  

influent and effluent concentrations indicated the extent to which biodegradation of AN

234  

and DPA causes mass removal from the contaminated water. The fluxes were calculated

235  

as described in Kurt et al. 15, where the horizontal plane is the intersection between the

236  

top of the saturated zone and the base of the capillary fringe. The measured

237  

biodegradation fluxes were 113 ± 26 mg AN • m-2 • hr-1 and 76 ± 18 mg DPA • m-2 • hr-1.

238  

The conditions in the laboratory columns were favorable for biodegradation and the

239  

short distance from the capillary fringe to the oxygen source would be unusual in the

240  

field. In subsurface situations where there are no permeability issues oxygen will not be

241  

limiting because its diffusion in air would be faster than diffusion of non-volatile

242  

chemicals through the saturated zone. To estimate whether the biodegradation fluxes in

243  

the capillary fringe would remove appreciable amounts of contaminant mass from the

244  

underlying plumes, the maximum diffusion fluxes of the contaminants were determined

245  

based on the solubility of the contaminants in water at room temperature (36,000 mg/L

246  

for AN and 40 mg/L for DPA). Fick’s law of diffusion in Eq. (1) was applied assuming

247  

that biodegradation created a sink for the contaminants (3 cm above the saturated zone)

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

13  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 14 of 29

248  

where the effective diffusion coefficient was calculated based on Millington and Quirk 41

249  

by assuming that the sand is saturated with water.

250   251  

𝐽 = −𝐷

!×!! !

(1)

!  

252   253  

Where J is the flux, D is the diffusion coefficient of the compounds in the water (8.3 x 10-

254  

6

255  

the distance above the saturated layer (3 cm) and n is the water-filled porosity measured

256  

for the sand (0.42). The calculated diffusion fluxes were 19 ± 2 mg AN • m-2 • hr-1 and 16

257  

± 4 µg DPA • m-2 • hr-1. Comparing these diffusion fluxes to the biodegradation fluxes

258  

above clearly indicated that biodegradation in the columns was faster than the diffusion

259  

of AN and DPA therefore the process is diffusion limited. Biodegradation in the columns

260  

increases the diffusion flux of contaminants by creating a sink in the capillary fringe.

261  

Because the columns were filled with sand, they are likely to have more void volume

262  

than the field materials, and therefore the fluxes would likely be lower in the field. The

263  

high biodegradation rates at the oxic/ anoxic interface are consistent with numerous

264  

previous reports related to biodegradation of volatile compounds in the vadose zone 5, 14-

265  

16, 18

266  

Microbial distribution in the columns

cm2/s for AN and 6.3 x 10-6 cm2/s for DPA42), C is the contaminant concentration, Y is

.

267  

Microbial biomass in the vadose zone increases with increasing biodegradation

268  

fluxes 43, 44, and it has been established with similar columns that biomass is concentrated

269  

within the capillary fringe when volatile contaminants are the electron donors and oxygen

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

14  

Page 15 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

270  

is the electron acceptor 15, 16. Recent reports 45-47 indicated that bacterial growth and

271  

attachment to sand in the capillary fringe is concentrated in the transition zone when

272  

lysogeny broth was the carbon source for Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas putida

273  

strains. To determine the location of the bacteria that degrade AN and DPA, the microbial

274  

biomass was measured by qPCR throughout the column at the end of the experiments.

275  

Total bacterial numbers based on 16S rRNA genes were similar to the numbers

276  

based on the dioxygenase genes, indicating that most of the bacteria in the column were

277  

derived from the inocula (Fig. 4). The bacteria grew throughout the capillary fringe but

278  

were most concentrated near the saturated zone at the oxic/ anoxic interface (Fig. 4, 5).

279  

The results were similar to previously established microbial profiles in the unsaturated

280  

zone of columns designed to study biodegradation of volatile contaminants 15, 16. The

281  

initial inoculum that adhered to the sand (dashed line in Fig. 4) is highly overestimated as

282  

indicated by the brief contact time and the turbidity of the suspension (data not shown)

283  

that drained from the column after inoculation.

284  

 

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

15  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 16 of 29

285   286   287  

 

 

288  

Figure 4. Estimated microbial biomass in the AN (A) and DPA (B) multiport columns at

289  

the end of the experiments. Dashed lines represent the average initial bacterial inoculum

290  

calculated based on an assumption of 100% adherence of the bacteria to the sand during

291  

the brief exposure to the inoculum.

292  

293  

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

16  

Page 17 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

294  

Figure 5. Measured moisture content in the AN (A) and DPA (B) multiport columns at

295  

the end of the experiments described above.

296  

The correlation between moisture content and bacterial activity is well established

297  

48-51

298  

80% saturation 47 as would be found in the lower part of the capillary fringe where gas

299  

transport is greater than in the saturated zone. The results are consistent with previous

300  

observations that the microbial biomass accumulates at the transition zone in the capillary

301  

fringe 45-47. Similarly, a recent review concludes that maximum microbial activity in soil

302  

occurs where the water content and oxygen availability intersect 48. To investigate the

303  

effect of moisture content on biodegradation of contaminants, DPA was used as the

304  

electron donor for the microcosms prepared with different water saturation levels. The

305  

results revealed maximum biodegradation rates at 60-80 % saturation (Fig. 6), which

306  

corresponds to the lower level of the capillary fringe in the columns where most of the

307  

biomass was located.

308  

and recent studies demonstrated that microbial activity is maximum between 50 and

Oxygen diffusion is the key parameter that causes the microbial biomass to

309  

accumulate in the transition zone above the saturated layer. Oxygen diffusion in the

310  

capillary fringe is correlated with the volumetric air content because the diffusion of

311  

oxygen in air is faster than in the water. Therefore, there is a sigmoidal decrease of

312  

oxygen in the capillary fringe above anoxic plumes in the absence of bacteria 52. When

313  

bacteria are present, biodegradation creates an oxygen sink in the capillary fringe and the

314  

rate of oxygen transfer to the saturated layers below is further diminished. Another

315  

parameter that affects oxygen diffusion to the water in the unsaturated layer is the air-

316  

water interfacial area which decreases as the water content increases 53. Because aerobic

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

17  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 18 of 29

317  

microbes require water and oxygen to function there is a narrow region where oxygen

318  

and moisture content are optimal for microbial activity 54. In addition the microbial

319  

growth is limited by the rate of diffusive transport of the carbon and energy source from

320  

below. Thus, a transition zone in the capillary fringe supports microbial activity better

321  

than the saturated zone or the zone of maximum air-water interfacial area.

322   323  

324   325   326  

Figure 6. Growth (solid circle) and biodegradation rates (empty circle) of DPA degraders

327  

at different water saturation levels. Data represent the means of duplicate analyses.

328   329  

The rapid oxygen-dependent AN and DPA biodegradation in the capillary fringe

330  

along with moisture and microbial profiles throughout the columns indicated that the

331  

biodegradation takes place in a narrow zone where the moisture content is high, but not

332  

saturated, and where electron donors and acceptors intersect. The results are consistent

333  

with previous findings for volatile compounds 5, 13-16, 18 and with the predicted enrichment

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

18  

Page 19 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

334  

of microbial biomass at the interface between sources of electron donors and acceptors in

335  

plume fringes 7. Field data for many plumes of volatile dissolved hydrocarbons are

336  

consistent with the above conclusions in that such plumes do not cause vapor intrusion

337  

because of the high biodegradation rates immediately above the saturated zone 11. Even

338  

though the design of the columns we used is a good representation of the lower part of

339  

the vadose zone in an idealized system it has limitations that reduce the ability to

340  

extrapolate to field situations. Diffusion rates of both contaminants and oxygen would

341  

typically be lower in the field. Temperature, pH, nutrient concentrations, porosity or other

342  

factors would also affect transport and microbial activity in the field. Therefore, the

343  

findings should be confirmed at appropriate field sites before they are integrated into

344  

conceptual site models or risk assessments.

345  

The average concentration of DPA at a contaminated site was reported to be

346  

between 1400 to 2900 mg/kg of soil 28 and near solubility concentrations (around 35

347  

mg/L) in contaminated water 28. Similarly, previous treatability studies have considered

348  

that industrial wastewaters could contain AN concentrations approaching 1000 mg/L 55,

349  

56

350  

the capillary fringe could be sufficient to remove considerable amounts of contaminant

351  

mass from the plumes.

352  

The column study established that biodegradation removed DPA and AN in the capillary

353  

fringe. The microcosm studies established that natural attenuation of DPA could be

354  

achieved in the unsaturated zone as long as DPA degraders are present. Although the

355  

column was not designed to reflect field conditions at the contaminated site, the overall

356  

results clearly indicated that natural attenuation in the capillary fringe can remove

. Calculations based on the columns used here indicate that the biodegradation flux in

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

19  

Environmental Science & Technology

357  

substantial mass of AN and DPA from an underlying groundwater plume and it seems

358  

likely the findings can be extrapolated to other aerobically biodegradable non-volatile

359  

contaminants.

Page 20 of 29

360  

Models developed for biodegradation of hydrocarbons in the vadose zone

361  

describe microbial activity either by instantaneous degradation or by first-order or Monod

362  

kinetics considering oxygen availability as a limiting factor for biodegradation 5, 12-14, 57.

363  

Biodegradation of chlorinated compounds (chlorobenzene) in the capillary fringe was

364  

also modeled by including biomass concentration in addition to Monod kinetics 58. The

365  

model revealed that increase in contaminant flux increases oxygen flux and

366  

biodegradation rate resulting in instantaneous degradation in the capillary fringe when

367  

there are no physical limitations. Because the diffusivity of volatile contaminants is faster

368  

in air than in the water, modeling volatile contaminants relies only on the air

369  

concentrations, therefore application of the volatile compound models is not appropriate

370  

for non-volatile compounds. Development of a model including biomass and describing

371  

biodegradation of non-volatile compounds in the capillary fringe will be required to

372  

predict natural attenuation and its impact on plume concentrations in the field.

373   374  

 

375  

Acknowledgment

376  

Funding was provided by the DuPont Corporate Remediation Group.

377   378  

Supporting Information Available

379  

Figure S1 is in supplementary figure section.

380  

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

20  

Page 21 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

381  

References

382   383  

  1.

384  

resolved quantification of anaerobic toluene degraders and aquifer microbial community

385  

patterns in distinct redox zones of a tar oil contaminant plume. Appl. Environ. Microbiol.

386  

2008, 74, (3), 792-801.

387  

2.

388  

Mixing-controlled biodegradation in a toluene plume - Results from two-dimensional

389  

laboratory experiments. J. Contam. Hydrol. 2008, 96, (1-4), 150-168.

390  

3.

391  

biodegradation through depth resolved microbial community functional and structural

392  

profiling of a crude oil contaminant plume. Microb. Ecol. 2014, 68, (3), 453-462.

393  

4.

394  

profiling over an aerobic/anaerobic redox gradient in a toluene-contaminated aquifer.

395  

Environ. Microbiol. Rep. 2013, 5, (2), 225-234.

396  

5.

397  

limited biodegradation of petroleum hydrocarbon vapors in the subsurface. Ground

398  

Water Monit. Remediat. 2009, 29, (1), 126-137.

399  

6.

400  

nitrobenzene at interfaces between sediment and water. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2012, 46,

401  

(21), 11829-11835.

402  

7.

403  

plume fringe subject to transverse mixing in porous media: When can the rates of

Winderl, C.; Anneser, B.; Griebler, C.; Meckenstock, R. U.; Lueders, T., Depth-

Bauer, R. D.; Maloszewski, P.; Zhang, Y.; Meckenstock, R. U.; Griebler, C.,

Fahrenfeld, N.; Cozzarelli, I. M.; Bailey, Z.; Pruden, A., Insights into

Larentis, M.; Hoermann, K.; Lueders, T., Fine-scale degrader community

Davis, G. B.; Patterson, B. M.; Trefry, M. G., Evidence for instantaneous oxygen

Kurt, Z.; Shin, K.; Spain, J. C., Biodegradation of chlorobenzene and

Chu, M.; Kitanidis, P. K.; McCarty, P. L., Modeling microbial reactions at the

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

21  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 22 of 29

404  

microbial reaction be assumed to be instantaneous? Water Resour. Res. 2005, 41, (6), 1-

405  

15.

406  

8.

407  

Richnow, H. H., Monitoring in situ biodegradation of benzene and toluene by stable

408  

carbon isotope fractionation. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2005, 24, (1), 51-60.

409  

9.

410  

DeVaull, G. E.; Mayer, K. U., Evaluation of seasonal factors on petroleum hydrocarbon

411  

vapor biodegradation and intrusion potential in a cold climate. Ground Water Monit.

412  

Remediat. 2014, 34, (4), 60-78.

413  

10.

414  

biodegradation of volatile fuel compounds in the unsaturated zone: A large scale

415  

lysimeter experiment. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2002, 36, (1), 30-39.

416  

11.

417  

screening at petroleum UST sites. Ground Water Monit R 2013, 33, (2), 53-67.

418  

12.

419  

biodegradation of benzene vapors in repacked and undisturbed soil cores. Vadose Zone J.

420  

2012, 11, (1), 1-9.

421  

13.

422  

on soil vapor intrusion into buildings: Influence of degradation rate, source concentration,

423  

and depth. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2006, 40, (7), 2304-2315.

424  

14.

425  

atmosphere to soil gas beneath a slab-on-grade foundation overlying petroleum-impacted

426  

soil. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2008, 42, (15), 5534-5540.

Vieth, A.; Kastner, M.; Schirmer, M.; Weiss, H.; Godeke, S.; Meckenstock, R. U.;

Hers, I.; Jourabchi, P.; Lahvis, M. A.; Dahlen, P.; Luo, E. H.; Johnson, P.;

Pasteris, G.; Werner, D.; Kaufmann, K.; Hohener, P., Vapor phase transport and

Lahvis, M. A.; Hers, I.; Davis, R. V.; Wright, J.; DeVaull, G. E., Vapor intrusion

Kristensen, A. H.; Hosoi, C.; Henriksen, K.; Loll, P.; Moldrup, P., Vadose zone

Abreu, L. D. V.; Johnson, P. C., Simulating the effect of aerobic biodegradation

Lundegard, P. D.; Johnson, P. C.; Dahlen, P., Oxygen transport from the

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

22  

Page 23 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

427  

15.

428  

chloride in the capillary fringe. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2014, 48, (22), 13350-13357.

429  

16.

430  

1,4-dichlorobenzene in the vadose zone. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2013, 47, (13), 6846-

431  

6854.

432  

17.

433  

in the vadose zone. In Natural attenuation considerations and case studies: remediation

434  

of chlorinated and recalcitrant compounds, Wickramanayake, G. B.; Gavaskar, A. R.;

435  

Kelley, M. E., Eds. Battelle Press: Columbus, 2000; pp 121-127.

436  

18.

437  

Bouchard, D., Multiple lines of evidence to demonstrate vinyl chloride aerobic

438  

biodegradation in the vadose zone, and factors controlling rates. J. Contam. Hydrol.

439  

2013, 153 (1), 69-77.

440  

19.

441  

2005, 4, (1), 1-21.

442  

20.

443  

populations and pesticide degradation potentials in the unsaturated zone of loamy and

444  

sandy soils. Biol. Fert. Soils 2001, 33, (6), 514-520.

445  

21.

446  

aerobic isoproturon biodegradation and sorption in the unsaturated and saturated zones of

447  

a chalk aquifer. J. Contam. Hydrol. 1998, 30, (3-4), 281-297.

Kurt, Z.; Mack, E. E.; Spain, J. C., Biodegradation of cis-dichloroethene and vinyl

Kurt, Z.; Spain, J. C., Biodegradation of chlorobenzene, 1,2-dichlorobenzene, and

Graves, D.; Pohlmann, D.; Ingram, S., Intrinsic biodegradation of vinyl chloride

Patterson, B. M.; Aravena, R.; Davis, G. B.; Furness, A. J.; Bastow, T. P.;

Holden, P. A.; Fierer, N., Microbial processes in the vadose zone. Vadose Zone J.

Vinther, F. P.; Elsgaard, L.; Jacobsen, O. S., Heterogeneity of bacterial

Johnson, A. C.; Hughes, C. D.; Williams, R. J.; Chilton, P. J., Potential for

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

23  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 24 of 29

448  

22.

449  

of microbial pesticide degradation in soil: scales, controlling factors, and implications.

450  

Front. Microbiol. 2014, 5, 667.

451  

23.

452  

Biodegradation of semi- and non-volatile petroleum hydrocarbons in aged, contaminated

453  

soils from a sub-Arctic site: Laboratory pilot-scale experiments at site temperatures.

454  

Chemosphere 2010, 80, (3), 319-326.

455  

24.

456  

factors controlling biodegradation of DNT in the vadose zone. Environ. Sci. & Techn.

457  

2003, 37, (15), 3382-3391.

458  

25.

459  

hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX) in a contaminated vadose zone.

460  

Chemosphere 2008, 73, (9), 1492-1498.

461  

26.

462  

identification, toxicity and fate in the environment. Environ. Chem. Lett. 2014, 12, (3),

463  

371-386.

464  

27.

465  

acetaminophen as aniline metabolite. Int. J. Legal Med. 2000, 113, (3), 171-174.

466  

28.

467  

Chemosphere 2003, 53, (8), 809-818.

468  

29.

469  

diphenylamine biodegradation by Burkholderia sp strain JS667. Appl. Environ.

470  

Microbiol. 2009, 75, (9), 2694-2704.

Dechesne, A.; Badawi, N.; Aamand, J.; Smets, B. F., Fine scale spatial variability

Chang, W.; Dyen, M.; Spagnuolo, L.; Simon, P.; Whyte, L.; Ghoshal, S.,

Fortner, J. D.; Zhang, C. L.; Spain, J. C.; Hughes, J. B., Soil column evaluation of

Ronen, Z.; Yanovich, Y.; Goldin, R.; Adar, E., Metabolism of the explosive

Dsikowitzky, L.; Schwarzbauer, J., Industrial organic contaminants:

Iwersen-Bergmann, S.; Schmoldt, A., Acute intoxication with aniline: detection of

Drzyzga, O., Diphenylamine and derivatives in the environment: a review.

Shin, K. A.; Spain, J. C., Pathway and evolutionary implications of

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

24  

Page 25 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

471  

30.

472  

significance of dye manufacturing plant effluents Anal. Chem. 1977, 49, (9), 1433-1440.

473  

31.

474  

microorganism capable of aerobic and anaerobic degradation of aniline. Fems Microbiol.

475  

Lett. 2000, 190, (2), 215-221.

476  

32.

477  

of 4-aminobenzoyl-CoA in Desulfobacterium anilini. Arch. Microbiol. 1991, 155, (2),

478  

183-190.

479  

33.

480  

Degradation of aniline and monochlorinated anilines by soil-born Pseudomonas

481  

acidovorans strains. Arch. Microbiol. 1990, 155, (1), 56-61.

482  

34.

483  

anoxic conditions. Curr. Microbiol. 1997, 35, (6), 343-347.

484  

35.

485  

ion mass spectrometry imaging of microbial populations utilizing 13C-labelled substrates

486  

in pure culture and in soil. Environ. Microbiol. 2009, 11, (1), 220-229.

487  

36.

488  

taxonomic study. J. Gen. Microbiol. 1966, 43, 159-271.

489  

37.

490  

oxygenase genes by multiplex and real-time PCR. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2003, 69,

491  

(6), 3350-3358.

Games, L. M.; Hites, R. A., Composition, treatment efficiency, and environmental

Kahng, H. Y.; Kukor, J. J.; Oh, K. H., Characterization of strain HY99, a novel

Schnell, S.; Schink, B., Anaerobic aniline degradation via reductive deamination

Loidl, M.; Hinteregger, C.; Ditzelmuller, G.; Ferschl, A.; Streichsbier, F.,

Drzyzga, O.; Blotevogel, K. H., Microbial degradation of diphenylamine under

Pumphrey, G. M.; Hanson, B. T.; Chandra, S.; Madsen, E. L., Dynamic secondary

Stanier, R. Y.; Palleroni, N. J.; Doudoroff, M., The aerobic pseudomonads: a

Baldwin, B. R.; Nakatsu, C. H.; Nies, L., Detection and enumeration of aromatic

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

25  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 26 of 29

492  

38.

493  

trichloroethene using a hydrogen-based membrane biofilm reactor. Environ. Sci. Technol.

494  

2008, 42, (2), 477-483.

495  

39.

496  

quantification of cDNA using real-time PCR. J. Immunol. Methods 2003, 278, (1-2), 261-

497  

269.

498  

40.

499  

of rRNA and tRNA genes in bacteria and archaea. Nucleic Acids Res. 2009, 37, D489-

500  

D493.

501  

41.

502  

1961, 57, 1200-1207.

503  

42.

504  

net.com/en/publications/gsi-­‐chemical-­‐database.html (July 18),

505  

43.

506  

toluene by indigenous microbial populations in vadose sediments. Microb. Ecol. 1995,

507  

29, (3), 311-325.

508  

44.

509  

transport, fate and groundwater impacts of fuel ethanol releases. Curr. Opin. Biotech.

510  

2012, 24, 1-10.

511  

45.

512  

protein labeled Escherichia coli in a dynamic capillary fringe by fluorescence intensity.

513  

Vadose Zone J. 2014, 14, (1), 1539-1663.

Chung, J.; Krajmalnik-Brown, R.; Rittmann, B. E., Bioreduction of

Whelan, J. A.; Russell, N. B.; Whelan, M. A., A method for the absolute

Lee, Z. M.-P.; Bussema, C., III; Schmidt, T. M., rrnDB: documenting the number

Millington, R. J.; Quirk, J. M., Permeability of porous solids. Trans. Faraday Soc.

Environmental, G. GSI Chemical properties database. http://www.gsi-­‐

Fuller, M. E.; Mu, D. Y.; Scow, K. M., Biodegradation of trichloroethylene and

Ma, J.; Rixey, W. G.; Alvarez, P. J. J., Microbial processes influencing the

Jost, D.; Winter, J.; Gallert, C., Noninvasive quantification of green fluorescent

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

26  

Page 27 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

514  

46.

515  

bacteria within the capillary fringe of silica sand. Water Res. 2010, 44, (4), 1279-1287.

516  

47.

517  

putida growing in silica sand capillary fringes. Vadose Zone J. 2011, 10, (2), 532-540.

518  

48.

519  

respiration to moisture availability: An exploration of processes and models. Soil Biol.

520  

Biochem. 2013, 59, 72-85.

521  

49.

522  

a function of soil water content. Soil. Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1990, 54, (6), 1619-1625.

523  

50.

524  

storage tanks. J. Hazard Mater. 1991, 28, (1-2), 75-80.

525  

51.

526  

dynamics and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon degradation during bioremediation of

527  

heavily creosote-contaminated soil. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2005, 71, (11), 7008-

528  

7018.

529  

52.

530  

resolution non-invasive approach to quantify oxygen transport across the capillary fringe

531  

and within the underlying groundwater. J. Contam. Hydrol. 2011, 122, (1-4), 26-39.

532  

53.

533  

processes in soils. Vadose Zone J. 2004, 3, (2), 368-383.

534  

54.

535  

constraints affecting bacterial habitats and activity in unsaturated porous media – a

536  

review. Water Res. 2007, 30, 1505–1527.

Jost, D.; Winter, J.; Gallert, C., Distribution of aerobic motile and non-motile

Jost, D.; Winter, J.; Gallert, C., Water and oxygen dependence of Pseudomonas

Moyano, F. E.; Manzoni, S.; Chenu, C., Responses of soil heterotrophic

Skopp, J.; Jawson, M. D.; Doran, J. W., Steady-state aerobic microbial activity as

Kampbell, D. H.; Wilson, J. T., Bioventing to treat fuel spills from underground

Vinas, M.; Sabate, J.; Espuny, M. J.; Solanas, A. M., Bacterial community

Haberer, C. M.; Rolle, M.; Liu, S.; Cirpka, O. A.; Grathwohl, P., A high-

Rockhold, M. L.; Yarwood, R. R.; Selker, J. S., Coupled microbial and transport

Or, D.; Smets, B. F.; Wraith, J. M.; Dechesne, A.; Friedman, S. P., Physical

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

27  

Environmental Science & Technology

Page 28 of 29

537  

55.

538  

coagulation processes using a flow reactor for wastewater treatment. Chemosphere 2002,

539  

47, (3), 241-248.

540  

56.

541  

Bacterial growth on aniline: Implications for the biotreatment of industrial wastewater.

542  

Water Res. 2000, 34, (18), 4397-4409.

543  

57.

544  

biodegradation. http://www.api.org (June 23),

545  

58.

546  

capillary fringe. Environ. Sci. & Techn. 2014, 49, (3), 1501-1510.

547   548   549   550  

         

Brillas, E.; Casado, J., Aniline degradation by electro-Fenton (R) and peroxi-

O'Neill, F. J.; Bromley-Challenor, K. C. A.; Greenwood, R. J.; Knapp, J. S.,

API BioVapor, A 1-D vapor intrusion model with oxygen-limited aerobic

Luo, J.; Kurt, Z.; Hou, D.; Spain, J. C., Modeling aerobic biodegradation in the

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

28  

Page 29 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

ACS Paragon Plus Environment