Gas Chromatography with Glass Capillary Columns (Jennings, Walter

Feb 1, 1982 - Gas Chromatography with Glass Capillary Columns (Jennings, Walter). R. J. Laub. J. Chem. Educ. , 1982, 59 (2), p A70...
1 downloads 0 Views 2MB Size
proximately one third of the book. The authors have wisely restricted their discussion to the more relevant or commonly encountered asoeets of each tooie. The clear ogy make this book a useful reference source for the researcher and graduate classroom instructor alike. This hook would, however, be a great deal more valuable had the authors taken more care in updating certain sections in the book. For examole. in reviewine techtechniques that were popular ten years ago and exclude from discussion more recent ones. To site a specific example, temperature and pressure studies of enzyme reactions were included in the chanter coverine enzvme Similar types of omissions are made in some of the theoretical treatments. For example, great detail is given to equations which describe the pH behavior of enzyme reactions most of whieh was taken from papers published a decade aeo. The more current theopapers dealing with supporting experimental studies. The chapter whieh appears mast severely effected by being out-of- date is that dealing with enzyme mechanisms. Perhaps equally disturbing is the authors' frequent failure to provide references that are either current or general in nature. Thus, while "Enzymes" provides the reader with a well-organized, concise review of the vast area of enzymology, its value is somewhat compromised by the fact that it is already at least five years out-of-date. Debra Dunaway-Mariano

earhonmd hydrogen provide the molecular weights of the hydrocarbon fuels. The gross and net enthalpies of combustion fur liquid and vapor fuels a t 25' C a r e reported for 16 paraffins, 15 olefins, and 7 alkylhenzenes. The chapter a n data sources gives a detailed description of the statistical mechanical partition functions used to compute the ideal gas thermodynamic functions. The volum6 provides data far one-dimensional, isentropic, compressible flow. Tables of Rayleigh lines, Fanna lines, and the normal shock function are given a t selected values of the polytropic exponent. Some asditional tables for two-dimensional flow functions are also given for the polytropic exponent 1.4. The numerical values in this second edition are significantly different from the first edition values a t low and hightemperatures. The central portion of the tables are nearly the same. This is the reason for presenting the second edition. Those who must make thermodynamic or gas dynamics calculations for air, its constituents, and hydrocarbon fuel combustion product systems will find these data very helpful. These data can he used in a classroom and a design office. Those who do computations routinely will probably have access t o computer codes for doing their calculations. This book can serve to check the results produced by the computer codes. The book is attractively printed and easy to read. Unfortunately, all tables are presented in Enelish units. Conversion factors have provided a source of thermodynamic data whieh many will find useful for many years to come. Truman Storvick Blacr and ei.rcr>Professor of Engineer ny ilnd Profcssar 01 Cnem,cn Eng neorlng ,n WF I) of Mm0.r -COJmn ;1

.

Columbia, MO 65211

University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742

G a s Tables. Thermodynamic Properties of Air, Products Of Combustion a n d Component G a s e s , Compressible Flow Functions Joseph H. Keenan, Jing Chao, and Joseph Kaye, John Wlley & Sons, NY 1980. xiv 217 pp. 22 X 26.5 cm. $22.50.

+

This hook is a revision of the 1948 edition ofthe"GasTab1es" written by J. H. Keenan and Joseph Kaye. It follows the same format and is designed for use in thermodynamic calculations where air and its constituents and the products of combustion of hydrocarbons with air are considered. A tahle for combustion with 100% excess air has heen added with the remainder of the book essentially unchanged. The volume remains unique as a source of these thermodynamic data. The authors of the second edition have used the latest physical, molecular, and spectroscopic constants t o compute the reA70

Journal of Chemical Education

G a s Chromatography with G l a s s Capillary Columns Walter Jennmgs, Academ c Press, hew York. 1980 Secono Edition Figs. nnd taoles. 23 X 16 cm. xiv T 320 pp. $25.00. There probably does not remain a single practitioner of packed-column gas chromatography who has not a t one time or another stared incredulously a t a capillary chromatogram of several hundred haseline-resolved oeaks. Yet. there is tadav absolutelv no que&ion that separations are gaasihle with such systems whieh simply cannot he realized otherwise. Thus, considerable interest has arisen over the past few years regarding open-tubular columns for GC (delayed somewhat as aresult, perhaps, of the original patent covering the methodology), and activity in this field continues to grow a t a remarkable pace. The second edition of this text seeks to introduce the title subject to those already versed in gas chromatography as well as t o provide a number of practical guidelines for those now engaged in related areas of re-

the chromatographic process which, however, contains a few errors: Gaussian peak widths a t the inflection point wi are 20 whereas those a t half the height of the peak wliz are 2 o m = 2.3550. Thus, the two are not identical. Measurement .of peak widths is facilitated simply by running the chart speed faster rather than the indicated procedure of using a magnifying glass (why this obvious fact seems to continue to elude chromatographers is a mystery). The symbol t~ is used fort* (tM = jtA) which should be measured from the peak maximum and not from the peak leading edge (the differences will, however, be slight). "Phase" is mispelled as "phrase" frequently. The symbol k is used for k' and will cause some confusion (k = llk' as originally defined by van Deemter, e t al.). The term uida infra is used far too frequently in the text and should wherever it appears he replaced by a section or page number. Chapter two introduces glass-capillary GC columns with a welcomed section on surface pre-treatments (those after drawing but prior to coating) while chapter three details various methods of deposition of stationary phases. Contrary to the opinion expressed on pp. 46-47, user-made columns (at least in the laboratory of the reviewer) exhibit higher efficiencies than those available commercially. Indeed, if i t is true as stated that commercial columns are cheaper and better what, then, is the point of writing a book about the subject? Chapter four provides a discussion of inlet systems while chapter five offers hints as to column installation. Chapter six, measuring column efficiency, correctly points out that currently-popular methods of assessment of the merits of this or that system are only variants of methods of measurement of resolution between two peaks. Most of chapters seven (treatment of retention data) and eight (temperature programming and carrier flow considerations) should he deleted; those aspects peculiar to open-tubular columns can then be expanded upon. Chapter nine, special analytical methods, is far too brief t o be of much use while chapter ten (column stability) could have been placed earlier in the book. Chapter eleven, column selection, offers virtually no help in choosing a stationary phase, nor are the problems associated with deposition of selective phases (e.g., eysnosilieones) onto glass treated with any authority. Chapters twelve (sample preparation), thirteen (analysis of non-volatile materials), and fourteen (weak discussion of instrument conversion) offer nothing for those who would presumably use this text and so should be deleted. Chapter fifteen (examples of applications) is undoubtedly the most informative in the text; numerous chromatograms are presented which illustrate the scope of separations possible with open-tubular columns of high efficiency. Chapter sixteen (fault diagnosis) is again far too brief to be of any use. The work is concluded with four appendices (nomenclature, a list of liquid phases, retention data with porous polymer adsorbents-why included is a mystery-and silylatian pracedures which have been covered in much greater detail elsewhere), none of which are of any use, and an index. Although intended to he pedagogic, this book fails to offer much other than a hrief taste of all that is involved in the construction and use of glass-capillary GC columns. The

-u! w d e q a pqql aq& '8018183 p183 aql pue c~uamaSmrm q3qs yooq 'sraqmu ~3 qnoq q l ! ~2 u q e 'raldeqn lxau aqi u! p a u y d x a are smalshs UO!lRXJ!SSEp h~arq!l s s a d u o 3 p h m r q ! ~p u ~[em!m(I haMaa aq& -am Lxerq!l u! uo!ynqsu! pue '8u!q3rsas paqra qndmos 'suo!+3a[lo3 p!aads '2u!hdo3oloqd ' s w q hmlqr[rqu! ' s a ~ a s a r'uo!pp3n3 'sa3p -1as wuarajaz sa sldamos q w s au!z!seqdma 'hr-eq!l a!mapaaw aql jo saqnras pue sa3lnos -el aql sannpoqu! raldeq3 au!uu!Saq aq&

s! 2 o p w -elem hr-eq![jo sadh& .pa+uasa~d prea aql qSnorq s[e!mlem 02 ssame pue 'pau!l$no s! hrelq!l aql u! s l q r a p m jo l u a u -aSue~maql 'pau!v[dxa a m Krerq!l [ej!dKl aql jo saq.uas pua saamosar aq& 'bmrq -!I qmapem uw!ramV aqq 0%uo!lwporlu! prauaa e sail12paluasard sqdal jo a2wl ap!M aq& 'a2enZwl pumas e se q s ! P u ~au!qmal u! saslnoa pamanpe pue ale!pamralu! JOJ ap!n2 anmosal B se parB!sap s! amnlon aqL xasn hmrq![ a q - p p o ~ s!ql roj a?u-ep!na amos ap!nord 0%paldual -le anuq haql p w 'luapnls leql JO 1q?i![d aq? q l ! ~reg!m8j a m r(lsno!nqo ap!n2 s!ql jo sroqlne aq& 'herq!l g m a p e x ueqzaruv aql JO r(l!xqduro2 Bu!m[aq~rano isom[-e aql q i ! ~p a q s! luapnls s!ql 'puno&peq qs!n2u!1 pun '18nqm '1e!306 $uaraJj!p u m a g 2u!mo3 'a2anawl ( p q l uana m ) puoaas e s! qs![2ua moqM oi quapnls aql jo tq2!1d

an!paJja lsom aql 2u!qQm u! hlln3!j~!p aneq u a l p sluapnls 2u!qeads-qs!Pug 'suu!zerq!l pal!un qmapeaa jo ama!radxa aql r q ol;'salq~ aql u! sa!q!sran!un p m sa2a[lo3 p sa!lerq!l 3!mapam aql a m qs![2u~ueql raqlo sazena u-e[ an!leu q l ! ~qaapnls dlaq 0% paredard uaaq seq yooq s!q&,, :sroqlne aql hq h l p u p -ms palals s! qooq s!ql jo asodmd aq&

O O S P $ ur3 YEZ x 9 1 'salqei pus !!!AX '086L 'AN ' W O h MaN

~ 6 ! dd d SEP

+

OLZCP HO 'snqwnlw

Al~s>an!un aLels o!qo aql

w e 1 .r .tl ZlL8L Xl 'U!LsnV u!lsnv le sexal lo i(l!slan!un arll Jauu!yS '3y

'luapnls s J s p q jo a2uer aql u!q$!~ I[aM s! w!zd aq$ puw 'paiou araM spajap raqlo 30 s x o m 1 s q d a r 2 o U l ou 'parallnpun pun aq3er$$e s! $nohsl aq& .aSetSml pumas e s! qs![8 - u moqM ~ roj szuapnls jo s d n o ~ 2ol sumiel -uasard 2u:qem ue!mq!l amamjar B 0%usla p3asn aq plnoa qooq aq& .1[aM dzan asodind

'ua!lspuam -mmar e l u e m m or aamlsqns %ua!xj~nsJO 'a3rreFq uo 'qou s! ?TOM s!ql jo uoypa puoaas aql ' r a n a ~ o q'spuels $! s-e :33 u! padaa aql se llaM sa rau!uu!Saq aql m j 4109 avgMglZOM aaord Kpqg p p o u~o y p a ua qans 'K[!sea peplap aq w3 (*I-I ~axpuaddaiuaqqs fuaal -moj p lsom !uaalr!ql !$@!a 30 lsom iuanas srald~qa)~ ! d qap!? a q 0%lmnalan! F!ra+em q q M hlqerap!suoa papuedxa pU6 pappdn aq p p q s (uaaqg iuaawnoj jo %lad!anlaw qanoqq au!u !@!a jo lied :x!s q2nozql auo) lsaralu! +ueu!mopard JO sraldsq3