Subscriber access provided by UNIV OF CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO LIBRARIES
Critical Review
Life cycle payback estimates of nano-silver enabled textiles under different silver loading, release, and laundering scenarios informed by literature review Andrea L Hicks, Leanne M. Gilbertson, Jamila S. Yamani, Thomas L. Theis, and Julie B. Zimmerman Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.5b01176 • Publication Date (Web): 02 Jun 2015 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on June 9, 2015
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Title: Life cycle payback estimates of nano-silver enabled textiles under different silver loading,
2
release, and laundering scenarios informed by literature review
3
Andrea L. Hicks 1,+,*, Leanne M. Gilbertson 2,+, Jamila S. Yamani 2, Thomas L. Theis 1, Julie B.
4
Zimmerman2,3
5
+
6
1
7 8
University of Illinois at Chicago, Institute for Environmental Science and Policy, 2121 West Taylor (MC 673), Chicago, IL 60612
2
9 10
Co-first authors
Department of Chemical and Environmental Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, CT 065208286
3
School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, Yale University, New Haven, CT 06520
11 12 13
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail:
[email protected]; Tel.: +1-312-996-5236; Fax: +1-312-355-0760.
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Abstract: Silver was utilized throughout history to prevent the growth of bacteria in food and wounds. Recently, nano-scale silver has been applied to consumer textiles (nAg-textiles) to eliminate the prevalence of odor-causing bacteria. In turn, it is proposed that consumers will launder these items less frequently thus, reducing the life cycle impacts. While previous studies report that laundering processes are associated with the greatest environmental impacts of these textiles, there is no data available to support the proposed shift in consumer laundering behavior. Here, the results from a comprehensive literature review of nAg-textile life cycle studies are used to inform a cradle-to-grave life cycle impact assessment. Rather than assuming shifts in consumer behavior, the impact assessment is conducted in such a way that considers all laundering scenarios to elucidate the potential for reduced laundering to enable realization of a net life cycle benefit. In addition to identifying the most impactful stages of the life cycle across nine-midpoint categories, a payback period and uncertainty analysis quantifies the reduction in lifetime launderings required to recover the impacts associated with nano-enabling the textile. Reduction of nAg-textile life cycle impacts is not straightforward and depends on the impact category considered.
31 32 33 34
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 2 of 42
2 35
Introduction
36
Although recently popularized, the use of silver for its antimicrobial properties dates back to
37
antiquity, when Hippocrates used it to treat ulcers and prevent the infection of wounds1. Prior to the
38
widespread use of refrigeration in North America, silver coins were used to prevent the spoiling of
39
water, milk, wine, and vinegar2. While these are just a few examples, the versatility of silver in
40
antimicrobial applications is readily apparent. Alexander and Klasen present a comprehensive review
41
of the historical uses of silver.2-4
42
With the advent of nanotechnology, manufactured nano-silver (nAg) has become popular for
43
use in novel applications, primarily due to its enhanced antimicrobial properties.5 Innovation in nAg-
44
enabled products has increased significantly since 2000, demonstrated by the increased market value,
45
patent applications, and nAg products available to consumers in USA (Figure 1a) and worldwide. The
46
global market value for nAg coatings and products is expected to grow from $290 million in 2011 to
47
$1.2 billion by 2016.6 Annual United States nAg production is estimated between 2.8 – 20 tonnes per
48
year7. Figure 1a presents the results of a nAg patent application search of the United States Patent
49
Office database by application year. Patent application data are commonly used as an indicator of
50
innovation and technological change particularly with respect to nanotechnology.8-18
51 52
Figure 1 The Project on Emerging Nanomaterials (PEN) maintains an inventory of all nano-enabled
53
products currently on the market, 25% of which are enabled with nAg (462 total products).19 These are
54
subdivided into several product categories: appliances, automotive, cross cutting, electronics and
55
computers, food and beverage, goods for children, health and fitness, and home and garden as
56
presented in Figure 1b. The category with the greatest number of nAg products is health and fitness,
57
which includes nAg-enabled textiles (nAg-textiles). These textiles include, but are not limited to,
58
shirts, pants, socks, underwear, and linens. The primary function of the embedded silver is to prevent
59
odors in the products through its antimicrobial properties. In the case of medicinal textiles, the function
60
extends beyond the prevention of odors to that of wound infection. ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 3 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
3 61
Figure 2
62
It is expected, and further supported by the patent search and inventory data, that nAg-textiles
63
will continue to represent a significant demand of nAg in the consumer market. These products have
64
unique characteristics that differentiate them from their conventional counterparts. Yet these novel
65
products present tradeoffs in terms of environmental and human health impact costs across the life
66
cycle, including mining of silver ore, nAg manufacture, and release from the textiles during the use
67
phase (i.e., during wear and laundering).
68
This paper presents a current and comprehensive literature review of nano-enabled textiles life
69
cycle assessment (LCA) studies. Critical research gaps are identified and addressed by conducting an
70
impact assessment that takes into account laundering habits, silver loading (µg silver/g textile), silver
71
release, and product lifetimes over multiple environmental and human health midpoint impact
72
categories. Finally, suggestions for future research directions are provided and emphasize the need for
73
additional insight on proper linking technology to prevent nAg release during wear and laundering as
74
well as how the adoption and use of nAg-textiles may change consumer laundering behavior.
75
Review of Life cycle Assessment Literature
76
LCA is a systematic tool whereby the environmental impacts of a product or process are
77
analyzed across all life cycle stages, including raw materials acquisition, manufacture, use, end of life,
78
and transportation. The current research findings will be discussed within each phase of the nAg-
79
textile.
80
Raw Materials
81
The principal intermediate products considered include nano-scale silver and the textile itself,
82
which is typically composed of either cotton or polyester (for the most common commercially
83
available nAg textiles). There is the potential for the environmental impact of the raw materials to shift
84
among life cycle stages as a function of the amount of silver embedded in the textile, the synthesis
85
method, silver attachment method, and the type of textile material considered.
86 ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 4 of 42
4 87
Silver
88
Silver exists primarily in the environment as an ore with other metals such as lead, zinc,
89
copper, and gold.20 In 2013, 819 million ounces of silver was mined worldwide, with the United States
90
being the ninth largest producer.8,21 A typical silver-bearing ore contains 0.085% silver, 0.5% lead,
91
0.5% copper, and 0.3% antimony.22 Silver mining occurs in either an open pit or underground mine
92
and begins with crushing and grinding the source rock. In addition to extremely low initial silver
93
concentrations in the ore, losses associated with the various processing stages contribute to the
94
environmental impacts associated with silver mining. In general, losses from tailings comprise 20% of
95
the ore in mixed mining operations and 12% of the ore in primary silver mines.20 Additional silver
96
losses at each step include 10% from tank leaching, 63% from heap leaching, 0.12% from smelting,
97
and 0.02% to slag.23 Floatation separation is used to create a concentrate, which typically contains
98
1.7% silver, 10-15% lead, 10-15% copper, and 6% antimony.22
99
The variety of ore and mining activity from which silver is obtained leads to a significant
100
variation in the environmental impact of the raw materials acquisition phase for silver. As such, the
101
life cycle inventory information for silver found in the Ecoinvent database includes a mix of ores for
102
calculating the environmental impact of silver mining.24 Swart and Dewulf used multiple
103
environmental impact methods to compare the mining and refining impact of copper with respect to
104
other metals, such as silver.25 They found the mining and refining of silver to have a greater impact
105
than copper, on the order of approximately 7 to 850 times, expressed in copper mining equivalents.
106
Synthesis of Nano-Silver
107
Synthesis of silver nanoparticles has received significant attention over the past decade. Since
108
the primary mechanism of silver antimicrobial activity involves the formation and release of
109
monovalent silver ion, the increased surface areas achieved by producing silver at the nano-scale is an
110
advantage.26 A variety of physical and chemical methods are used to synthesize silver nanoparticles
111
ranging from vapor deposition to chemical reduction.27 More recently, the principles of green
112
chemistry have been applied to the synthesis of silver nanoparticles. These methods aim to reduce the ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 5 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
5 113
environmental and human health impacts associated with the synthesis methods by using benign
114
reagents (i.e., solvent, reducing agent, and stabilizing agent), which include plant extracts, enzymes,
115
biodegradable polymers, and agricultural waste.28-30 While these methods reduce the net life cycle
116
impacts associated with the use of toxic reagents, there are tradeoffs in terms of control over purity,
117
particle size, morphology, and performance.29,31 Still, a review of the current literature reveals that the
118
majority of silver nanoparticles are synthesized in water using nitrate as the precursor salt, sodium
119
borohydride (NaBH4) or sodium citrate as the reducing agent, and citrate as the stabilizing agent.27 As
120
such, these reagents serve as a representative synthesis method in the LCA section discussed below.
121
Fabric Production
122
Cotton and polyester are commonly used as the base materials in nAg textile products. While
123
these materials serve a similar functional role, they are manufactured using significantly different raw
124
materials and processes, which consequently lead to different environmental impacts.
125
The collective environmental impacts of cotton vary significantly depending on where it is
126
grown, irrigation and pesticide requirements, and fluctuations in yield.32 The United States grows
127
approximately 16% of the world’s cotton, which requires between 3.27 and 8.91 cubic meters (m3) of
128
water per kilogram (kg) of cotton produced.32 In addition to water consumption, there are significant
129
impacts associated with insecticide and pesticide use.33 Cotton is estimated to be grown on 3% of the
130
world’s farmland, yet requires 25% of global pesticide use.34 Post-harvest, cotton is typically
131
processed using a scouring method in which the waxy outer layer is dissolved using sodium hydroxide
132
to allow for better color penetration when dyed.34 Subsequent processing steps, including baling cotton
133
lint, preparation and blending, spinning, knitting, dyeing and finishing, and making up (transforming
134
the fabric into a garment), are completed to fully transform the cotton into a garment. The total energy
135
consumption is 66.6 megawatt hours per metric tonnes (MWh/MT) of cotton garment.33,35
136
Polyester is a petroleum-based product. Polyester textiles are typically manufactured from
137
polyethylene terephthalate (PET), a synthetic polymer, and comprise 40% of the world textile
138
market.36-37 PET consumption in the United States and Canada was estimated at 5.5 million metric ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 6 of 42
6 139
tonnes (MMT) annually.36 The PET (or polyester chips) are produced through polycondensation of
140
terephthalic acid (TPA) with ethylene glycol.36,38 TPA is a xylene derivative, which is produced from
141
petroleum naptha, while ethylene glycol is made from the oxidation of ethylene, which is a petroleum
142
feedstock. In general, the yarn is produced by melting the PET chips, which are then drawn through
143
spinneret holes to produced filaments to be collected into thread.33,36 The threads are made into yarn,
144
which is woven into fabric, and then made into garments. The estimated energy consumption for the
145
manufacture of 1 MT of polyester garment is 91.5 MWh.35
146
Manufacture of Silver-Enabled Textiles
147
Nano-silver incorporation into textile fabric
148
Multiple methods exist for the incorporation of nano-scale silver into textiles. In general, nAg
149
textiles may be categorized one of three ways: coated, woven, and embedded (this is also true of the
150
attachment of silver at greater than the nano-scale, which has the potential to release nAg through use).
151
When textiles are coated, the completed garment or fabric is dipped in the silver, whereas in the woven
152
category single fibers are dipped in silver. In the case of embedded textiles, the silver is incorporated
153
into the fibers themselves. Methods of attachment may include surface coating, covalent bonding (with
154
a linking agent), and interwoven silver fibers.39-43 Although the majority of manufactured silver-enabled
155
textiles are synthetic, these techniques have also been used to enable cotton and silk with nAg.40-41
156
Use
157
Current LCA studies
158
To date, two LCA studies have explored the impacts associated with the life cycle use stage of
159
nAg textiles. Walser et al. completed a prospective LCA comparing nAg t-shirts, conventional t-shirts,
160
and t-shirts treated with tricolsan (an alternate antibacterial agent).44 Two production technologies for
161
the synthesis of nanoparticles were also compared, commercialized flame spray pyrolysis with melt-
162
spun incorporation of silver nanoparticles, and plasma polymerization with silver co-sputtering on a
163
laboratory, pilot, and estimated commercial scale. Shirts were treated with either silver or tricolosan.
164
Two nAg loadings were applied, 31 mg of pure nAg or 47 mg of nAg-tricalcium phosphate aggregates ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 7 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
7 165
(TCP) (which is equivalent to 0.93 mg of nAg). Shirts treated with the alternative antibacterial
166
contained 22 mg of tricolsan.
167
In the second study, Meyer, et al. performed a screening-level LCA on nAg-enabled socks.45
168
For this study it was assumed that each pair of socks contained 60.8 g of cotton fiber and 10.2 mg of
169
nAg. The production of nAg was modeled to include silver extraction and refining ore into a silver
170
feedstock for nAg fabrication, but the fabrication process itself was not included. The authors noted
171
that there are multiple methods for nAg synthesis, including: grinding, flame pyrolysis, laser ablation,
172
vapor deposition, and liquid-phase reduction. As such, modules were created to model impacts
173
associated with some of the nAg fabrication processes: yet, since this was not the intended focus of
174
their study, they were not included in the overall results. A summary of silver loadings compiled from
175
literature can be found in Table 1.
176
Nano-silver release from textiles
177
A significant amount of research has been conducted to characterize the amount of silver in
178
these textiles and the extent to which it is released (Table 1). There is a wide range in silver content
179
(0.9-21,600 micrograms (µg) per gram (g) of textile) and silver release rates during laundering (0.5-
180
100% of the initial silver content over various laundering lifetimes) reported in the literature. The same
181
antimicrobial properties that warrant use of nAg in these textiles is also a cause for concern given the
182
potential environmental impact associated with its release during laundering. The United States
183
Environmental Protection Agency estimates that in 2009, 6.8 MT of silver was used in the United
184
States for nAg-textiles with a range of 0.1-0.2 mg silver/ g textile (100-200 µg silver/g textile).45 Based
185
on the compiled literature values (Table 1), this is likely a very conservative estimate.
186 187
Table 1 Consumer Laundering Behavior
188
Results from life cycle assessments of textiles suggest that the laundering phase is associated
189
with the greatest environmental impact.52-53 Thus, manufacturers of silver-enabled textiles claim that
190
due to the reduction of odor, their products will require less laundering than conventional alternatives, ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 8 of 42
8 191
which will lead to a reduction in use-phase environmental impacts.54 However, to date, there is no
192
published research confirming changes in consumer laundering behavior. Nonetheless, this is a key
193
assumption in current LCA studies. Differences also exist in the assumptions and laundering protocols
194
modeled in the literature. While Walser et al. simulated the environmental impact of three different
195
laundering scenarios (varying the amount of water and electricity used per cycle, frequency of shirt
196
laundering, and duration of shirt lifetime), it remains unclear which of these assumed behaviors is the
197
most accurate representation of consumer behavior. 44 Thus, it is impossible to evaluate the
198
environmental costs and benefits associated with adoption of silver- textiles. The assessment
199
completed by Meyer et al. includes use phase assumptions such as an equivalent number of lifetime
200
launderings and no difference in laundering habits between the conventional and nano-enabled
201
textile.45 Additionally, it was assumed that by the end of its lifetime, 100% of the silver was released
202
through laundering, yet they did not account for the associated environmental impacts.
203
Inhibition of Bacterial Growth
204
While nAg is incorporated into fabrics to prevent growth of odor causing bacteria, further
205
resolution is necessary to fully evaluate the efficacy of the technology. Laboratory scale studies have
206
shown significant inhibition of bacterial growth on textiles55-57 and other substrates (e.g., stainless steel
207
and glass58) that are treated with nanosilver. Additionally, laboratory studies have found it is possible
208
for the nano-scale silver to migrate from the textile when exposed to synthetic sweat.61-62 However, in
209
situ studies found that silver chloride treated fabric did not significantly decrease the amount of
210
bacterial colonies on the skin and found no significant odor reduction or antimicrobial activity on the
211
fabric.59-60
212
End of Life
213
In general, options for textile disposal include municipal solid waste (in the United States, this
214
typically occurs in a landfill or through incineration), or through down cycling (e.g., denim turned into
215
insulation).63-64 LCA studies on nAg textiles have largely neglected analysis of the textile itself, and
216
have instead focused on the impact of the silver. As shown in Table 1, silver will be released from the ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 9 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
9 217
textile in varying degrees during the wash cycle where it is assumed to enter the wastewater system,
218
and be treated at a wastewater treatment plant (WWTP). In the United States, only 20% of households
219
are connected to septic systems, with the remainder having their wastewater treated at a WWTP.65
220
Between 90-95% of the silver entering the WWTP is removed from the water during treatment66-67, but
221
remains in the biomass created in the activated sludge system.66-70 As such, consideration of
222
environmental and human health impacts of silver is shifted to the landfill or land application of
223
biosolids scenarios.
224
Nitrification is a process by which ammonia is oxidized through bioconversion to nitrite and
225
nitrate. nAg particles in wastewater have been found to inhibit nitrification66,71-72, with a threshold
226
level of 0.1 mg/L causing inhibition. The silver-containing biomass generated in the activated sludge
227
system may be anaerobically digested or composted in order to reduce volume, inactivate pathogens,
228
and produce biogas. No significant difference in biogas production as a function of silver levels has
229
been observed from digestion68 or composting73, however some reduction in landfill gas (methane)
230
generation was observed at high silver levels.69
231
Questions remain as to the chemical form of the nAg in the treatment system. The speciation of
232
nAg in the WWTP is relevant to a life cycle impact assessment, particularly in regards to toxicity in
233
the environment. Most studies have concluded that as the silver enters the treatment plant it will be
234
primarily in the form of Ag2S66,73-74 and that secondary forms, such as AgCl75, are possible. Ag2S has
235
not been found to be bioavailable in freshwater conditions, and therefore is not considered to be as
236
toxic as ionic silver76, however, to the extent that ionic silver is present, there is the potential to
237
negatively impact the environment.77-78
238
Unintended Consequences of Silver Usage
239
While the antimicrobial properties of nAg offer a potential benefit upon incorporation into
240
various textiles, there is also potential for significant unintended environmental and human health
241
consequences resulting from the widespread adoption and use of nAg products. In addition to being
242
inherently cytotoxic, Wakshlak et al. proposed a so-called “zombie effect” in which bacterial cells are ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 10 of 42
10 243
rendered nonviable due to silver exposure, and then become repositories of silver that subsequently kill
244
other viable bacteria79. Furthermore, the potential for microbes to develop a resistance to silver has
245
been demonstrated and suggests that eventually, silver may become ineffective as an antimicrobial
246
agent.80-85 Beyond bacteria, nAg has been shown to have a negative impact on aquatic organisms,
247
including Daphnia magna86 and Drosophila87. Potential adverse human health effects resulting from
248
exposure to soluble silver include eye, skin, respiratory, and intestinal irritation, changes in blood cells,
249
and liver and kidney damage88. Chronic exposure to silver88 can result in skin discoloration (gray or
250
blue-black), called Argyria, due to do dermal deposits of silver. This is a permanent condition,
251
however, it is not considered physically harmful from a health perspective89. Currently the United
252
States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) categorizes nAg and nAg enabled products as
253
pesticides, which are subject to approval and regulation.90
254
Overall LCA
255
To date, there are three nAg textile LCA studies each using a different combination of impact
256
categories to represent their results. Walser et al.44 report greenhouse gas emissions (in units of carbon
257
dioxide equivalents) and ecotoxicity (in units of 1,4-dichlorobenzene equivalents), while Meyer et al.45
258
include nine environmental and human health categories available through the TRACI impact
259
assessment method. Polygiene54 computed Comparative Environmental Impact Factors (CEIFs), based
260
on environmental impact categories of climate change, ecotoxicity, human toxicity, eutrophication,
261
ozone depletion, photochemical smog, waste, and acidification. Meyer et al. concluded that the
262
impacts from laundering (e.g., water and energy demand) are significantly greater than those of the
263
added silver.45 Polygiene presented similar conclusions adding that reductions in laundering frequency
264
would significantly decrease the life cycle impact of the textile.54 Furthermore, Walser et al. concluded
265
that the potential for reductions in launderings could compensate for the increased burden of adding
266
the silver, and that the toxicity impacts associated with the release of silver during laundering are
267
minor when compared to the rest of the life cycle.44 These results are consistent with studies on
268
conventional textiles, which also found the use phase to have the greatest environmental impact.52-53 ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 11 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
11 269
While these results are consistent for nAg-enabled textiles for clothing, the most impactful life cycle
270
stage can shift depending on the application. For example, Pourzahedi and Eckelman modeled the
271
environmental impacts of nAg-enabled single use bandages using the environmental and human health
272
impact categories available through the TRACI assessment method.91 In their study, the silver content
273
was found to be the most influential factor when considering nanoparticle synthesis and bandage
274
manufacturing.
275
Summary of Current Research Gaps
276
Several research gaps exist in the life cycle considerations for nAg-textiles and are discussed in
277
order of life cycle stage. First, there is limited information on the industrial scale manufacturing
278
impacts, as opposed to laboratory, scale for nAg synthesis. Multiple processes exist for the fabrication
279
of nanosilver particles, each with varying degrees of energy and resource intensity. The silver
280
manufacturing process used in the forthcoming analysis represents the most commonly used synthesis,
281
is not considered the most intensive process, and is modeled on the laboratory scale. Second, the
282
relationship between nAg concentration (or loading) in textiles and the functional efficacy is not yet
283
fully understood. As a result, there is significant variability in the initial silver concentrations of
284
commercially available nAg textiles, as presented in Table 1. Third, the use phase has received the
285
most significant attention, focusing on silver release during laundering conditions and the influence
286
that detergent, bleach, water temperature, water chemistry, and laundering methodology have on its
287
release. However, the greatest variability in silver release is most likely associated with the silver
288
attachment method. Furthermore, laundering behavior modifications (i.e., reduced laundering of nAg-
289
textiles) has not yet been studied and is vitally important to resolve the life cycle impacts of nAg-
290
textiles given the critical role of consumer behavior on the realization of the aforementioned life cycle
291
benefits. Finally, the ultimate form and fate of the released silver remains unresolved. Laundering
292
studies conducted in the absence of bleach suggest that Ag2S66,70,73-74 will be the dominant form of
293
silver entering the WWTP. However when bleach is present (as is often the case in a consumer
294
setting), AgCl75 has been found. These two forms of silver are highly insoluble, suggesting that neither ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 12 of 42
12 295
would have a significant impact on microbial activity in WWTP and landfill scenarios. However, if the
296
silver is in another form, such as ionic silver, there is significant potential for disruption of current
297
system balances to occur in not only in the landfill setting, but also in the WWTP and ultimately the
298
water body where the effluent is discharged.
299
Life Cycle Assessment to Address Research Gaps
300
Building upon the current silver textiles LCA literature, the following impact assessment is
301
intended to address some of the identified research gaps discussed above, particularly as it relates to
302
the uncertainties with consumer laundering behavior, initial nAg concentration, and the release rate of
303
the nAg during laundering. Nine environmental and human health midpoint impact categories are used
304
to identify those life cycle stages of a nAg-textile that contribute most significantly to the cumulative
305
impacts as well as compare the impacts to those of a conventional textile made from either cotton or
306
polyester. Finally, pay back periods, in terms of number of launderings, are evaluated for a subset of
307
representative midpoint impact categories to determine whether changes in consumer habits (i.e.,
308
reduced number of lifetime launderings) are sufficient to overcome the impacts imposed by enabling a
309
textile with nAg.
310
Methods
311
The life cycle environmental and human health impacts are modeled using SimaPro (version
312
8.0.1 software), Ecoinvent, USLCI, and ELCD inventories, and the TRACI (2.1) assessment
313
method.92-94 The midpoint categories considered include: ozone depletion (kg CFC-11 eq), global
314
warming potential (kg CO2 eq), smog (kg O3 eq), acidification (mol H+ eq), eutrophication (kg N eq),
315
carcinogenics (CTUh), non carcinogenics (CTUh), respiratory effects (kg PM10 eq), and ecotoxicity
316
(CTUe).
317
Goal and Scope
318
Since the use phase has been identified to have both the greatest life cycle impact and the
319
greatest uncertainty based on a review of current literature, it serves as the focus of the LCA presented
320
here. Impacts from the use phase are compared with those of silver acquisition, silver nanoparticle ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 13 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
13 321
synthesis, textile raw materials acquisition and manufacture, transportation of, and end of life disposal,
322
as presented in Figure 2.
323 324
Figure 2 Reference Flow and System Boundary
325
The functional unit for the midpoint impact assessment is considered as the impact per shirt
326
lifetime. The shirt lifetime is defined here as the number of launderings (assumed to be 100 unless
327
otherwise noted) rather than the number of wears. The number of launderings was chosen because this
328
is the unit around which use-phase environmental impacts manifest. Inputs and outputs associated with
329
all stages of the life cycle are considered in this assessment, including potential benefits and
330
implications associated with incorporating silver into textiles (e.g., decreased laundering, silver ion
331
release). The manufacturing and maintenance of the washers, dryers, and clotheslines is not considered
332
in this study. To compare key aspects of the life cycle, the stages are represented in this study as
333
follows: silver mining and refining (Silver M/R), nanoparticle fabrication (NP Fab), textile fabrication
334
(textile), transportation (transport), laundering, disposal, and release of silver ions (Ag+). It should also
335
be noted that washing machines do exist that release silver during the wash cycle as a method of
336
microbial control, however, these novel washing machines are not considered in this study.
337
Assumptions
338
Silver (Mining and Refining)
339
The silver mining and refining stage includes raw materials and processes associated with the
340
mining and refining of silver ore into silver nitrate.
341
Nanoparticle Fabrication
342
The nanoparticle fabrication stage encompasses the synthesis of silver nanoparticles from silver
343
nitrate using NaBH4, the most commonly used reducing agent27, using the methodology of Solomon et
344
al.95
345
Textile Fabrication
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 14 of 42
14 346
The textile fabrication stage includes raw material acquisition, refining, and production of the
347
cotton (CO) or polyester (PL) shirts. Both shirts are assumed to have a total mass of 130 g.44 The raw
348
materials and manufacturing impacts of the polyester shirt are created using the same protocol as
349
Walser et al.44
350
Silver Loading
351
Based on the compiled literature data in Table 1, the average silver loading of 10,800 µg silver/
352
g textile is modeled as the base case scenario while 0.9 and 21,600 µg silver/g textile represent the
353
lowest and highest silver loadings, respectively.
354
Transportation
355
The transportation stage accounts for the impacts associated with transportation the shirt after
356
fabrication and is scaled per shirt. This is modeled based on a shirt manufacturing location of Lebanon,
357
Kansas (geodetic center of the continental United States) and a use stage destination of Chicago,
358
Illinois.96 This results in an allocation of 939 kilometers (km) to rail and 160 km to trucking.
359
Transportation among all other stages of the life cycle is included with their respective inventory
360
inputs.
361
Use Phase (i.e., Laundering)
362
The use phase includes both high efficiency (HE) and regular efficiency (RE) washing machine
363
scenarios to account for the range of efficiencies currently on the market. The HE washer is assumed
364
to use the following resources per load: 0.228 kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity, 56.8 liters (L) of
365
water, 29.6 milliliters (mL) of detergent, and launder 32 shirts.97-99 The RE washer is assumed to use
366
the following resources per load: 1.173 kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity, 87.1 L of water, 29.6 mL of
367
detergent, and launder 27 shirts.99-101 Estimates of washer capacity and laundry soap consumption are
368
based on a field experiment utilizing size large men’s t-shirts completed by the authors.
369
Three drying scenarios are posited, a HE dryer, a RE dryer, and a clothesline (LN). The
370
electricity per load of laundry is 2.31 kWh and 3.87 kWh for the HE and RE dyers, respectively; while
371
no electricity is consumed under the LN scenario.102-103 Both dryers modeled are assumed to be ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 15 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
15 372
electric. Each washer-dryer combination is assumed to have the same load capacity: 32 shirts for the
373
HE appliances and 27 shirts for the RE appliances.
374
The lifetime of both the silver-enabled and conventional shirts is assumed to have a base
375
lifetime of 100 launderings, as presented in the LCA results. During the laundering phase, silver is
376
released from the shirts and enters the wash water.46 The silver released has the potential to contribute
377
to the environmental and human health impacts, and is thus considered in this study. Silver release is
378
modeled as first order decay with a release constant of 2%, in the LCA results. This results in a
379
release, over the assumed lifetime of 100 launderings of approximately 86% of the initial silver
380
content of the textile. The silver released is assumed to enter a WWTP, and undergoes standard
381
treatment conditions, where 95% will be removed into the biomass.65-66 The silver contained in the
382
biosolids is expected to be in the form of Ag2S and AgCl, two relatively stable forms of silver in the
383
environment.66,70,73-75 The 5% of silver discharged from the WWTP is modeled in the form of Ag+
384
silver ions released to freshwater.
385
Disposal
386
The shirt and remaining silver content are disposed of in a landfill setting, characterized as inert
387
material. Silver release in and from the landfill is not considered, as modern landfills are designed with
388
linings and leachate collection systems.
389
Payback period and uncertainty
390
The concept of environmental payback is well established and has been used to compare the
391
relative environmental impact of numerous conventional and emerging technologies, particularly in
392
energy applications such as fuels and photovoltaics.104-106 The environmental payback concept is
393
utilized here to determine the reduction in launderings required to recover the impacts associated with
394
nAg-enabling a shirt. The following relationship was used to model this relationship for each midpoint
395
category:
396 397 ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 16 of 42
16 398
Impact of conventional t-shirt, laundered 100 times
399
=
Impact of Ag-enabled t-shirt, laundered z times
(1)
400 401 402
Using this relationship, the breakeven point occurs when the life cycle environmental and human
403
health impacts associated with the nAg-enabled shirt equal that of the conventional shirt laundered 100
404
times. This is possible with a reduction in launderings (z < 100 launderings) of the Ag-enabled shirt.
405
The degree of reduction necessary depends on a number of factors, not limited to the amount of silver
406
embedded within the shirt, the release rate of silver ions during laundering, and the impact of each unit
407
process for the relevant midpoint category.
408
The impacts of the conventional and nAg shirt were extracted from the previously described
409
TRACI models. The impact of nAg shirt was then subdivided into impacts of the life cycle that will
410
remain the constant (e.g., textile, transport, and disposal), and those that will change as a function of
411
silver content (silver mining and refining and nanoparticle fabrication) and those that will change as a
412
function of the number of launderings (laundering frequency). − ℎ = + ∗ + ∗ + !"# + !$ + %$ 2,
413 414
where the MR (impact of mining and refining silver) and NP (impact of nanoparticle synthesis)
415
(impact /(µg silver /g textile)) are described as a function of the silver content (Co, µg silver /g textile)
416
of the shirt. The impact of laundering (Laund) is described as a function of the impact per laundering
417
(impact/z) and number of launderings of the shirt during its lifetime (z). The three impacts that remain
418
constant under both scenarios are Text (textile, including cotton or polyester raw materials and
419
manufacturing), Trans (transportation of the textile), and Disp (disposal of the textile at the end of its
420
life).
421 422
A linear relationship between initial silver content (Co) and the number of launderings during the lifetime (z) is assumed, where the x-intercept represents Co,max, the maximum amount of silver that
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 17 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
17 423
can be incorporated into the shirt that allows for potential realization of a net benefit by reducing the
424
number of lifetime launderings to zero.
425 426
Since silver release, as Ag+, contributes significantly to the ecotoxicity impact category, an additional term was added to the above equation. − ℎ = + ∗ + ∗ + !"# + !$ + %$ + − " ()* 0.05 3
427
This additional term reflects the ecotoxicity impact due to the release of silver during laundering. The
428
first order release (decay) constant, /, represents the percent of silver lost to the wash water during
429
laundering (1/laundering), and 0.05 represents the fraction of that silver that is released to the
430
environment in ionic form. I is the ecotoxicity impact of the released ionic silver (impact/µg Ag).
431
Due to the non-linear nature of this expression and variability of both and /, a Monte Carlo
432
simulation was performed using MatLab (version R2014b) to consider the number of launderings
433
across all possible scenarios of initial silver concentration (Co, 0.9-21,600 µg silver/g textile) and
434
release rate constant (k, 0.01-0.99). In this analysis, and / are varied across their relevant range
435
using a linearly spaced mesh grid, resulting in 4x104 ( , / points at which the expression was
436
evaluated. The impacts associated with the textile (raw materials and manufacturing), transport, and
437
disposal stages remain constant and are equivalent for the conventional and nAg shirt.
438
Results and Discussion
439
The LCA conducted here evaluates the environmental and human health impacts of cotton and
440
polyester shirts (both with and without silver) under four laundering scenarios (washing
441
machine/drying scenario: HE/LN, HE/HE, RE/LN, RE/RE). The impacts associated with the various
442
washing and drying scenarios are presented in Figure 3 on a per shirt per laundering basis in the units
443
of greenhouse gas equivalents (kg CO2e).
444
Figure 3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 18 of 42
18 445
Unsurprisingly, the life cycle greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) due to laundering vary based
446
on the washing and drying methods used. In all four laundering scenarios considered, electricity is the
447
most significant contributor to the overall GHGs. As expected, use of HE appliances significantly
448
reduces the environmental impact compared to RE appliances. The HE/LN and RE/RE include the
449
minimum and maximum impact values, respectively, and are thus, used henceforth in the analysis.
450
The disaggregated cumulative life cycle environmental and human health impacts of these
451
laundering scenarios for conventional and nAg-enabled (Ag) cotton (CO) and polyester shirts (PL) are
452
compiled in Figure 4. Since several of the impact categories exhibit similar trends in results, four
453
representative categories are presented and include a distribution of environmental and human health
454
impacts: ozone depletion, global warming potential, carcinogenicity, and ecotoxicity. The results for
455
the remaining five impact categories are available in Supplemental Information (Figure S1).
456
Figure 4
457
The results indicate that the life cycle phase (i.e., silver mining and refining, nanoparticle
458
synthesis, laundering, textile, disposal, silver release or transportation) associated with greatest
459
environmental impact is dependent on the midpoint impact category considered. For example, the
460
production and manufacture of the textile (cotton or polyester) contributes most significantly to ozone
461
depletion (Figure 4a) while laundering contributes most significantly to global warming potential.
462
Mining and refining the silver is a significant contributor to the carcinogenicity impact category, and
463
the release of silver as Ag+ contributes most significantly to ecotoxicity.
464
Further evaluation of the underlying resource inputs and processes was carried out for each
465
category. For ozone depletion and the textile stage (Figure 4a), the majority of the impacts are
466
associated with knitting and spinning the fibers of the polyester shirt. However, for the cotton shirt,
467
the greatest portion of the textile impact is due to the farming and processing of the cotton. When
468
considering global warming potential (Figure 4b), the laundering phase is associated with the greatest
469
environmental impact when a dryer is used due to the electricity consumption (previously described in
470
Figure 3). When a dryer is not used, the environmental impact of laundering is significantly reduced ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 19 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
19 471
and impacts associated with the textile fabrication become the most significant contributor to GHGs.
472
These results are representative of not only the global warming potential impact category, but similarly
473
for smog formation, acidification, and respiratory effects (Figure S1).
474
For the carcinogenicity impact category (Figure 4c), the textile fabrication is the most
475
significant contributor for the conventional shirt and the two nAg-cotton shirt scenarios. For the nAg-
476
enabled polyester shirts, the impacts from silver mining and refining are most significant, due to the
477
impact of the polyester shirt being less than that of the cotton shirt. These impacts will shift as a
478
function of the initial concentration, Co, of silver incorporated into the shirt. A similar trend is
479
observed for the eutrophication and non-carcinogenicity midpoint impact categories (Figure S1).
480
A novel trend is observed for the ecotoxicity impact category (Figure 4d). Here, the importance
481
of the silver discharged from the WWTP to surface water, as Ag+, is observed for the nAg shirts. This
482
is due to the potential of silver ions to disrupt healthy function of a variety of organisms and thus, to
483
impart negative impacts on the ecosystem.107-108 Based on the literature review (Table 1) the release of
484
silver ions during laundering remains unresolved and warrants further exploration to determine those
485
factors that contribute most significantly to the release of silver from the textile and ways to minimize
486
the associated environmental impacts.
487
It is important to note that regardless of the impact category considered, nanoparticle synthesis,
488
transportation, and end of life disposal are not significant contributors to the environmental and human
489
health impacts. The conventional washing and drying laundering scenario (RE/RE) utilizes
490
significantly more energy than the high efficiency washer and line drying (HE/LN) laundering
491
scenario. This suggests that shifts in consumer laundering behavior, including replacement of RE with
492
HE appliances and line drying or reduced laundering as a function of the nano-enabled properties of
493
the textile, has the potential to significantly reduce laundering impacts, and subsequently GHGs. While
494
the median concentration of silver (10,800 µg silver/g textile) (Table 1) was used for these impact
495
assessments, there is potential for the impacts to shift as technology improves (e.g., attachment
496
method, functional efficacy). These combined results suggest that the overall environmental and ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 20 of 42
20 497
human health impacts of next generation nAg-textiles is highly dependent on multiple life cycle stages
498
and that approaches to reduce such impacts are not straightforward.
499
Determining Environmental Payback
500
Considering the utilization of nAg-textiles may shift consumer-laundering behavior, it is
501
important to determine the potential reduction in environmental impacts associated with increased
502
wears per wash. This is pursued by determining the reduction of launderings required for the overall
503
life cycle impacts of a nAg-enabled shirt to be equivalent to those of a conventional shirt (equations 1
504
and 2), establishing the payback point for the different midpoint impact categories. The results are
505
presented as either a relationship between the initial silver concentration (Co) and the number of
506
launderings (z) (Figure 5), or as a heat map representing the number of launderings (0-100) across all
507
possible Co and k combinations (Figure 6). While the analysis was carried out for all nine-midpoint
508
impact categories, the same four representative categories are shown here and the remaining five can
509
be found in the Supplementary Information (Figure S2).
510
Figure 5
511
The compiled results in Figure 5 illustrate the potential opportunity to realize a net
512
environmental and human health benefit from enabling shirts with nAg in terms of the number of
513
lifetime launderings. The conventional shirt is assumed to have a lifetime of 100 launderings and thus
514
serves as the upper limit (y-intercept). As is indicated in Figures 5 a-d, the impacts of the nAg-shirt are
515
equivalent to that of the conventional shirt when the initial silver concentration (Co) is zero, and thus,
516
the number of lifetime launderings is 100. For all other values of Co, the solid line (green for HE/LN
517
and blue for RE/RE) bounds the shaded region, which represents the number of lifetime launderings
518
permitted to still achieve a net life cycle benefit. The x-intercept represents the maximum
519
concentration of silver (Co,max) that can be incorporated into the shirt and have the potential to recover
520
the life cycle impacts. In other words, the consumer would never launder the shirt (z = 0) during its
521
lifetime. The scales of the x-axes, Co, differ by orders of magnitude and the Co,max decreases
522
accordingly for different midpoint categories with the trend being global warming potential > ozone ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 21 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
21 523
depletion, ecotoxicity > carcinogenics. This follows the relative contribution of silver mining and
524
refining to the overall impact category, which contributes significantly to the carcinogenicity and only
525
marginally to the global warming potential. Since the ecotoxicity impact includes Ag+ release, the
526
inclusion of the release factor (e-kz) results in a non-linear relationship with the number of launderings.
527
Finally, because the HE/LN laundering scenario is associated with comparatively lower environmental
528
and human health impacts, there is a smaller gain in terms of allowable silver concentration for every
529
unit reduction in laundering (i.e., a steeper negative slope) compared to the RE/RE scenario. In the
530
calculations above, a single release constant was assumed (k = 0.02). Since there is significant
531
uncertainty in both the initial silver concentration, Co, and the release constant, k, and because both
532
variables significantly influence the resulting ecotoxicity impact, an additional sensitivity analysis was
533
carried out for the ecotoxicity payback period using Monte Carlo simulation. The evaluated range for
534
each variable is based on reported values found in the literature (Table 1). Thus, the number of
535
launderings was calculated across all possible scenarios within the ranges of Co (0.9-21,600 µg/g) and
536
k (0.01-0.99) using Equation 2. The results are compiled as a heat map (the color gradient
537
representative of the number of lifetime launderings) for the HE/LN and RE/RE scenarios (Figure 6).
538 539
Figure 6 Based on the lifetime laundering assumptions outlined previously, 100 launderings suggests
540
that no reduction in lifetime launderings is necessary to recover impacts associated with nAg-enabling
541
the shirt (this is the case for Co = 0 µg/g). On the other hand, zero launderings suggests that in order to
542
recover the impacts associated with incorporating nAg, the shirt can never be washed during its
543
lifetime. The maximum allowable silver content (Co,max) associated with each laundering scenario is
544
15,000 and 1200 µg Ag/g textile for RE/RE and HE/LN, respectively. It is interesting to note that k is
545
significant only under certain conditions, particularly when k is small, ~0.01- 0.05, and when Co is
546
below 6,000 and 600 µg Ag/g textile for RE/RE and HE/LN, respectively. Otherwise, the resulting
547
number of permitted lifetime launderings is driven by Co. Additionally, since the HE/LN laundering
548
scenario is associated with comparatively lower environmental and human health impacts, there is a ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 22 of 42
22 549
smaller gain in terms of allowable silver concentration for every unit reduction in laundering compared
550
to the RE/RE scenario. Finally, for most values of Co and k, a large reduction in washes (90-100%) is
551
required to realize a net ecotoxicity benefit indicating that a reduction in life cycle environmental
552
impact via reduction of life time launderings may not be attainable.
553
Shifting Consumer Behavior
554
As mentioned previously, shifting consumer laundering behavior in terms of frequency has the
555
potential to significantly reduce the lifetime environmental and human health impacts of nAg-enabled
556
shirts with respect to the impact categories of global warming potential, smog formation, acidification,
557
and respiratory effects. If the added silver reduces the lifetime number of launderings, there will be an
558
added environmental benefit with respect to the use phase. On the other hand, carcinogenic potential
559
(and other impact categories that follow the same trend) are largely independent of the number of
560
reduced launderings. Making the necessitated reduction in the number of launderings unrealistically
561
high. At the same time, it is unknown whether the adoption of a nAg shirt would actually cause the
562
consumer to launder the textile less frequently between wears.
563
Added Functionality
564
While these nAg textiles are primarily marketed to consumers for their odor reduction
565
capabilities, there are additional potential benefits resulting from silver’s antimicrobial properties. One
566
such benefit is reduced transmission of infection or transfer of contamination, which has a clear
567
applicability in hospitals or other environment where sterility is imperative. Hospital acquired
568
infections are the fourth highest cause of death in the United States (behind heart disease, cancer, and
569
stroke).109 Contaminated hospital objects, such as the floor, bed linens, gowns, over-bed tables, and
570
blood pressure cuffs serve as potential sources of contamination.110 The Center for Disease Control
571
(CDC) has reported that Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infections (better known as
572
MRSA) can spread through indirect contact, by touching contaminated objects (such as towels, sheets,
573
wound dressings, and clothes) that have come into direct contact with the infected wound.111 Hospital
574
linens have been evaluated for their role in microbial transfer; in one study, clean linen (before patient ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 23 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
23 575
contact), dirty linen, and staff uniforms were all found to be contaminated with microbes, with 57% of
576
the species found identified as pathogenic.112 Biocidal textiles (including nAg) have been proposed as
577
an effective method for reducing hospital acquired infections.113,114 A 2012 study estimated that
578
hospital acquired infections in adults cost approximately $10 billion in the United States annually.115
579
Thus, there are significant human health and economic benefits that can be realized through the
580
adoption of antimicrobial textiles (such as those enabled with nAg).
581
Conclusions
582
Upon comprehensive review of the nAg-textile LCA literature, an impact assessment under a variety
583
of scenarios (i.e., silver loading, silver release, laundering) was completed to address critical research
584
gaps. This enabled identification of the most important aspects of the nAg-enabled shirt life cycle,
585
based on the assumptions used in the model, across nine environmental and human health midpoint
586
impact categories. For those impact categories where the use-phase dominates, such as global warming
587
potential, shifts in laundering behavior have significant influence on the net impact. As such, there is
588
potential to realize an environmental benefit by incorporating nAg in textiles intended to reduce the
589
frequency of laundering. However, when considering other environmental impact categories where the
590
silver mining and refining contribute significantly, such as carcinogenics, there is reduced likelihood
591
of achieving impact payback through reduction in the number of launderings (i.e., when Co,max is order
592
of magnitude lower). The release of silver, as Ag+, in the wash water is an important influence on the
593
ecotoxicity impacts. One way to reduce the release of silver from textiles is to advance research aimed
594
at improving methods for incorporating silver into the textile fabric. This will not only prevent
595
unnecessary silver release during laundering (and reduce k), but also has the potential to extend the
596
functional performance lifetime of the silver-enabled t-shirt. In addition, reducing in the amount of
597
incorporated silver (Co) will subsequently reduce the cumulative life cycle impacts associated with this
598
next generation textile technology. Further research is required to optimize the minimum amount of
599
silver required to achieve the desired functional efficacy (i.e., prevention of odor causing bacterial
600
growth). ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 24 of 42
24 601
While the results presented herein address several existing gaps, additional research is required
602
to fully resolve the outstanding issues (e.g., consumer behavior, attachment technology, functional
603
efficacy, impacts and form of nAg released) to ensure sustainable implementation of nano-silver
604
textile applications. Still, much can be gleaned from a regulatory standpoint. First, it is important to
605
consider the final product and its entire life cycle when evaluating the safety and environmental impact
606
of a nAg enabled textile. Second, because the different environmental and human health impact
607
categories present strikingly different profiles, generalized conclusions cannot be drawn and thus, must
608
be treated case-by-case. Finally, shifts in consumer behavior cannot be assumed. Critical and
609
comprehensive evaluation, like that presented herein, will elucidate the contribution of consumer
610
behavior to the overall potential realization of a net life cycle benefit.
611
Acknowledgments
612
ALH, LMG, JBZ, and TLT acknowledge the generous support of the U.S. Environmental Protection
613
Agency Assistance Agreement No. RD83558001-0 that funded this research. JSY recognizes the
614
support from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency STAR Fellowship Assistance Agreement No.
615
FP-917515010. This work has not been formally reviewed by EPA. The views expressed in this
616
document are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Agency. EPA does
617
not endorse any products or commercial services mentioned in this publication.
618
References
619
1 Hill, W.R.; Pillsbury, D.M. Argyria-the pharmacology of silver; Williams & Wilkin: 1939.
620
2 Alexander, J.W. History of the medical use of silver. Surg. Infect. 2009, 10, 289-292.
621
3 Klasen, H.J. A historial review of the use of silver in the treatment of burns. I. Early uses. Burns.
622
2000, 26, 117-130.
623
4 Klasen, H.J. A historial review of the use of silver in the treatment of burns. II. Renewed interest for
624
silver. Burns. 2000, 26, 131-138.
625
5 Varner, K. State of the science literature review everything nanosilver and more. US Environmental
626
Protection Agency. 2010. ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 25 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
25 627
6 Pistilli, M. Nanosilver market growth: boon or bust for silver price.
628
http://silverinvestingnews.com/8575/nanosilver-market-growth-boon-or-bust-for-silver-prices.html
629
7 Hendren, C.; Mesnard, X.; Droge, J.; Wiesner, M. Estimating production data for five engineered
630
nanomaterials as a basis for exposure assessment. Environmental Science and Technology. 2011,
631
45(7), 2562-2569.
632
8 Barirani, A.; Agard, B.; Beaudry, C. Discovering and assessing fields of expertise in nanomedicine:
633
a patent co-citatio network perspective. Scientometrics, 2012. 94 (3), 1111-1136.
634
9 Daim, T.U.; Rueda, G.; Martin, H.; Gerdsri, P. Forecasting emerging technologies: Use of
635
bibliometrcis and patent analysis, Technological Forecasting & Social Change. 2006, 73, 981-1021.
636
10 Popp, D. Lessons from patents: Using patents to measure technological change in environmental
637
models, Ecological Economics. 2005, 54, 209-226.
638
11 Alencar, M.S.M.; Proter, A.L.; Antunes, A.M.S. Nanopatenting patterns in relation to product life
639
cycle, Technological Forecasting & Social Change. 2007, 74, 1661-1680.
640
12 Leitch, M.; Casman, E.; Lowry, G.V. Nanotechnology patenting trends through an environmental
641
lens: analysis of materials and applications. J Nanopart Res. 2012, 14, 1283.
642
13 Griliches, Z. Patent Statistics as Economic Indicators: A Survey ," in R&D and Productivity: The
643
Econometric Evidence; University of Chicago Press: Chicago, USA, 1998.
644
14 Basberg, B.L. Patents and the measurement of technological change: A survey of the literature.
645
Research Policy. 1987, 16, 131-141.
646
15 Johnstone, N.; Hascic, I.; Popp, D. Renewable energy policies and technological innovation:
647
Evidence based on patent counts. Environ Resource Econ. 2010, 45,133-155.
648
16 Pilkington, A.; Dyerson, R.; Tissier, O. The electric vehicle: Patent data as indicators of
649
technological development. World Patent Information. 2002, 24, 5-12.
650
17 Hall, B.H.; Ziedonis, R.H. The patent paradox revisited: An empirical study of patenting in the U.S.
651
semiconductor industry, 1979-1995. The RAND Journal of Economics, 2001, 32(1), 101-128.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 26 of 42
26 652
18 Dang, Y.l Zhang, Y.; Fan, L.; Chen, H.; Roco, M. C. Trends in worldwide nanotechnology and
653
patent applications: 1991 to 2008. J Nanopart Res, 2010, 12, 687-706.
654
19 Project on emerging nanomaterials: Consumer products inventory;
655
http://www.nanotechproject.org/cpi/
656
20 Johnson, J.; Jirikowic, J.; Bertram, M.; van Beers, D.; Gordon, R.B.; Hendersen, K,; Klee, R.J.;
657
Lanzano, T.; Lifset, R.; Oetjen, L.; Graedel, T.E. Contemporary anthropogenic silver cycle: a
658
multilevel analysis," Environmental science and technology. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2005, 39,4655-
659
4665.
660
21 Silver Institute: www.silverinstitute.org
661
22 Silver processing: http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/544891/silver-processing
662
23 Eckelman, M.; Graedel, T.E. Silver emissions and their environmental impacts: a multilevel
663
assessment. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2007, 41, 6283-6289.
664
24 Ecoinvent database: http://www.ecoinvent.org/database/
665
25 Swart, P.; Dewulf, J. Quantifying the impacts of primary metal resource use in life cycle
666
assessment based on recent mining data. Resources, Conservation and Recycling. 2013, 73,180-187.
667
26 Sotiriou, G.A.; Pratsinis, S.E. Antibacterial activity of nanosilver ions and particles. Environ. Sci.
668
Technol., 2010, 44, 5649-5654.
669
27 Tolaymat, T.M.; El Badawy, A.M.; Genaidy, A.; Scheckel, K.G.; Luxton, T.P.; Suidan, M. An
670
evidence-based environmental perspective of manufactured silver nanoparticle in synthese and
671
applications: A systematic review and critical appraisal of peer-reviewed scientific papers. Science of
672
the Total Environment, 2010, 408, 999-1006.
673
28 Varma, R.S. Greener approach to nanomaterials and their sustainable applications. Current
674
Opinions in Chemical Engineering, 2011, 1, 1-6.
675
29 Sharma, V.K.; Yngard, R.A.; Lin, Y. Silver nanoparticles: green synthesis and their antimicrobial
676
activities. Adv Coll Interf Sci, 2009, 145, 83-96.
677
30 Iravani, S., Green synthesis of metal nanoparticles using plants. Green Chem, 2011, 13, 2638-2650. ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 27 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
27 678
31 Sun, Y.; Xia, Y. Shape-Controlled synthesis of gold and silver nanoparticles. Science, 2002, 298,
679
2176-2179.
680
32 Pfister, S.; Koehler, A.; Hellwer, S. Assessing the environmental impacts of freshwater
681
consumption in LCA. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2009, 43, 4098-4104.
682
33 Seuring, S. Integrated chain management and supply chain management comparative analysis and
683
illustrative cases. Journal of Cleaner Production, 2004, 12, 1059-1071.
684
34 Chen, H.L.; Burns, L.D. Environmental analysis of textile products. Clothing and Textiles Research
685
Journal, 2006, 24, 248.
686
35 Woolridge, A.C.; Ward, G.D.; Phillips, P.S.; Collines, M.; Gandy, S. Life cycle assessment for
687
reuse/recycling of donated waste textiles compared to use of virgin material: An UK energy savings
688
perspective. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2006, 46, 94-103.
689
36 Kuczenski, B.; Geyer, R. Material flow analysis of polyethylene terephthalate in the US, 1996-
690
2007. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2010, 54, 1161-1169.
691
37 Aizenshtein, E.M. Polyester fibres continue to dominate on the world textile raw materials balance
692
sheet. Fibre Chem, 2009, 2009, 41, 1-8.
693
38 Scheirs, J.; Long, T.E. Modern polyesters: chemistry and technology of polyesters and
694
copolyesters; Wiley, 2003.
695
39 Eman, H.E.; Mowafi, S.; Mashaly, H.; Rehan, M. Production of antibacterial colored viscose fibers
696
using in situ prepared sphereical Ag nanoparticles. Carbohydrate Polymers, 2014, 110, 148-155.
697
40 El Rafie, M.H.l Ahmed, H.B.; Zahran, M.K. Characterization of nanosilver coated cotton fabrics
698
and evaluation of its antibacterial efficacy. Carbohydrate Polymers, 2014, 107, 174-181.
699
41 Zhang, G.; Liu, Y.; Gao, X.; Chen, Y. Synthesis of silver nanoparticles and antibacterial property of
700
silk fabrics treated by silver nanoparticles. Nanoscale Research Letters, 2014, 9, 216.
701
42 Nobel biomaterials: http://www.x-staticperformance.com/xt2/
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 28 of 42
28 702
43 HeiQ materials:
703
http://caat.jhsph.edu/programs/workshops/HeiQ%20Proposed%20Registration%20Decision%20Docu
704
ment%208-12-2010.pdf
705
44 Walser, T.; Demou, E.; Lang, D.J.; Hellwed, S. Prospective environmental life cycle assessment of
706
nanosilver T-shirts. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2011, 45, 4570-4578.
707
45 Meyer, D.E.; Curran, M.A.; Gonzalez, M.A. An examination of silver nanoparticles in socks using
708
screening-level life cycle assessment. J. Nanopart Res, 2011, 13, 147-156.
709
46 Benn, T.M.; Westerhoff, P. Nanoparticle silver released into water from commercially available
710
sock fabrics. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2008, 42, 4133-4139.
711
47 Troy Benn, Personal Communication, October 3, 2014.
712
48 Geranio, L.; Heuberger, M.; Nowack, B. The behavior of silver nanotextiles during washing.
713
Environ. Sci. Technol., 2009, 43, 8113-8118.
714
49 Lorenz, C.; Windler, L.; von Goetz, N.; Lehmann, R.P.; Schuppler, M.; Hungerbuhler, K.;
715
Heuberger, M.; Nowack, B. Characterization of silver release from commercially available functional
716
(nano)textiles. Chemosphere, 2012, 89, 817-824.
717
50 Lombi, E.; Donner, E.; Scheckel, K.G.; Sekine, R.; Lorenz, C.; Von Goetz, N.; Nowack, B. Silver
718
speciation and release in commercial antimicrobial textiles as influenced by washing. Chemosphere,
719
2014, 11, 352-358.
720
51 Mitrano, D.M.; Rimmele, E.; Wichser, A.; Erni, R.; Height, M.; Nowack, B. Presence of
721
nanoparticles in wash water from conventional silver and nano-silver textiles. ACS Nano, 2014, 11-17.
722
52 Cartwright, J. Assessing the environmental impacts of industrial laundering: Life cycle assessment
723
of polyester/cotton shirts. MS Thesis, University of California, Santa Barbara, 2011.
724
53 Smith, G.G.; Barker, R.H. Life cycle analysis of a polyester garment. Resources, Conservation and
725
Recycling, 1995, 14, 233-249.
726
54 Polygiene, Applying a comparative environmental impact factor (CEIF) for the comparison of
727
Polygiene-treated textiles to non-treated textiles, 2011. ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 29 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
29 728
55 Lee, H.J.; Yeo, S.Y.; Jeong, S.H. Antibacterial effect of nanosized colloidal solution on textile
729
fabrics. Journal of Materials Science, 2003, 38, 2199-2204.
730
56 Lee, H.J.; Jeong, S.H. Bacteriostasis and skin innoxiousness of nanosize silver colloids on textile
731
fabrics. Textile Research Journal, 2005, 75, 551.
732
57 El-Rafie, M.H.l Ahmed, H.B.; Zahran, M.K. Characterization of nanosilver coated cotton fabrics
733
and evaluation of its antibacterial efficacy. Carbohydrate Polymers, 2014, 107, 174-181.
734
58 Molling, J.W.; Seezink, J.W.; Teunissen, B.E.; Muihrers-Chen, I.; Borm, P.J.A. Comparative
735
performance of a panel of commercially available antimicrobial nano-coatings in Europe.
736
Nanotechnology, Science and Applications, 2014, 4(7) 97-104.
737
59 Walter, N.; McQueen, R.H.; Keelan, M. In vivo assessment of antimicrobial-treated textiles on skin
738
microflora. International Journal of Clothing Science and Technology, 2014, 26(4) 330-342.
739
60 Keelan, R.H.; McQueen, M.; Xu, Yin; Mah, Tannie. In vivo assessment of odour retention in an
740
antimicrobial silver chloride-treated polyester textile. The Journal of the Textile Institute, 2013, 104(1)
741
108-117.
742
61 von Goetz, N.; Lorenz, C.; Windler, L.; Nowack, B.; Heuberger, M.; Hungerbuhler, K. Migration
743
of Ag- and TiO2-(Nano)particles from textiles into artifical sweat under physical stress: experiments
744
and exposure modeling. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2013, 47, 9979-9987.
745
62 Hedberg, J.; Skoglund, S.; Karlsson, M.; Wold, S.; Wallinder, I.O.; Hedberg, Y. Sequential studies
746
of silver released from silver nanoparticles in aqueous media simulating sweat, laundry detergent
747
solutions and surface water. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2014, 48, 7314-7322.
748
63 Cotton: https://www.thefabricofourlives.com/our-programs/blue-jeans-go-
749
green?gclid=CKfEyLus6cECFReBaQodi5YAjQ
750
64 Council for Textile Recycling: http://www.weardonaterecycle.org/
751
65 US EPA-Office of Wastewater Management:
752
http://water.epa.gov/aboutow/owm/upload/2009_06_22_septics_septic_systems_factsheet.pdf
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 30 of 42
30 753
66 Kaegi, R.; Voegelin, A.; Sinnet, B.; Zuleeg, S.; Hagendorfer, H.; Burkhardt, M.; Siegrist, H.
754
Behavior of metallic silver nanoparticles in a pilot wastewater treatment plant. Environ. Sci. Technol.,
755
2011, 45, 3902-3908.
756
67 Hendren, C.O.; Badireddy, A.R.; Casman, E.; Wiesner, M.R. Modeling nanomaterial fate in
757
wastewater treatment: Monte Carlo simulation of silver nanoparticles (nano-Ag). Science of the Total
758
Environment, 2013, 449, 418-425.
759
68 Yang, Y.; Chen, Q.; Wall, J.D.; Hu, Z. Potential nanosilver impact on anaerobic digestion at
760
moderate silver concentrations. Water Research, 2012, 46, 1176-1184.
761
69 Yang, Y.; Xu, M.; Wall, J.D.; Hu, Z. Nanosilver impact on methanogenesis and biogas production
762
from municipal solid waste. Waste Management, 2012, 32, 816-825.
763
70 Ma, R.; Levard, C.; Judy, J.D.; Unrine, J.M.; Durenkamp, M.; Martin, B.; Jefferson, B.; Lowry,
764
G.V. Fate of zinc oxide and silver nanoparticles in a pilot wastewater treatment plant and in processed
765
biosolids. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2011, 48, 104-112.
766
71 Liang, Z.; Das, An; Hu, Z. Bacterial response to a shock load of nanosilver in an activated sludge
767
treatment system. Water Research, 2010, 44, 5432-5438.
768
72 Hu, Z. Impact of silver nanoparticles on wastewater treatment. WERF, 2010.
769
73 Gitipour, A.; El Badawy, A.; Arambewela, M.; Miller, B.; Scheckel, K.; Elk, M.; Ryu, H.; Gomez-
770
Alvarez, V.; Domingo, J.S.; Thiel, S.; Tolaymat, T. The impact of silver nanoparticles on the
771
composting of municipal solid waste. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2013, 47, 14385-14393.
772
74 Kim, B.; Park, C.S.; Murayama, M.; Hockella, M.F., Discovery and characterization of silver
773
sulfide nanoparticles in final sewage sludge products. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2010, 44, 7509-7514.
774
75 Impellitteri, C.A.; Tolaymat, T.M.; Shceckel, K.G., The speciation of silver nanoparticles in
775
antimicrobial fabric before and after exposure to a hypocholorite/detergent solution. J Environ Qual,
776
2009, 38, 1528-1530.
777
76 Hirsch, M. Toxicity of silver sulfide-spiked sediments to the freshwater amphipod (Hyalella Aztec).
778
Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry. 1997, 17(4):601-604. ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 31 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
31 779
77 Ratte, H.T., Bioaccumulation and toxicity of silver compounds: a review. Environmental
780
Toxicology and Chemistry, 1999, 18(1) 89-108.
781
78 Liu, J.; Hurt, R.H., Ion release kinetics and particle persistence in aqueous nano-silver colloids.
782
Environ. Sci. Technol., 2010, 44, 2169-2175.
783
79 Wakshlak, R.; Pedahzur, R.; Avnir, D., Antibacterial activity of silver-killed bacteria: the
784
“zombies” effect. Nature Scientific Reports, 2015, 5(9555), 1-5.
785
80 Silver, S.; Phung, L.; Silver, G. Silver as biocides in burn and would dressings and bacterial
786
resistance to silver compounds. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol. 2006, 33, 627-634.
787
81 Bridges, K.; Kidson, A.; Lowbury, E.; Wilkinson, M. Gentamicin- and silver-resistant
788
Pseudomonas. Br. Med J. 1979, 1, 446-449
789
82 Davis, I.; Richards, H.; Mullany, P. Isolation of silver- and antibiotic-resistance Enterobacter
790
cloacae from teeth. Oral Microbiol Immunol. 2005, 20,191-194.
791
83 Hendry, A.; Stewart, I. Silver-resistant Enterobacteriaceae from hospital patients. Can J Microbiol.
792
1979, 25, 915-921.
793
84 Li, X.; Nikaido, H.; Williams, K. Silver-resistant mutants of Escherichia coli display active efflux
794
of Ag+ and are deficient in porins. J Bacteriol. 1997, 179 6127-6132.
795
85 McHugh, S.; Moellering, R.; Hopkins, C.; Swartz, M. Salmonella typhirium resistant to silver
796
nitrate, chloramphenicol, and ampicillin. Lancet, 1975, 1 235-240.
797
86 Martins, J.; Teles, L.; Vasconcelos, V. Assays with Daphnia magna and Dani rerio as alert systems
798
in aquatic toxicology. Environ Int. 2007, 33(3), 414-425.
799
87 Webster, T.; Gorth, D.; Rand, D. Silver nanoparticle toxicity in Drosophila: size does matter. Int J
800
Nanomed. 2011, 6, 343.
801
88 Drake, P.; Hazelwood, K. Exposure-related health effects of silver and silver compounds: a review.
802
Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2005, 49(7) 575-585.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 32 of 42
32 803
89 Rupp, M.; Fitzgerald, T.; Marion, N.; Helget, V.; Puumala, S.; Anderson, J.; Fey, P. Effect of
804
silver-coated urinary catheters: efficacy, cost-effectiveness, and antimicrobial resistance. 12th Annual
805
Meeting of the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology 2004, 32(8), 445-450.
806
90 Bergeson, L. Washington Watch: Nanosilver: US EPA’s pesticide office considers how to best
807
proceed. Environmental Quality Management. 2010, 19(3), 79-85.
808
91 Pourzahedi, L.; Eckelman, M.J., Environmental life cycle assessment of nanosilver-enabled
809
bandages. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2015, 49, 361-368.
810
92 TRACI: http://www.epa.gov/nrmrl/std/traci/traci.html
811
93 SimaPro: http://www.pre-sustainability.com/simapro
812
94 SimPro Database Manual: http://www.pre-
813
sustainability.com/download/DatabaseManualMethods.pdf
814
95 Solomon, S.D.; Bahadory, M.; Jeyarajasingam, A.V.; Rutkowsky, S.A.; Boritz, C., Synthesis and
815
study of silver nanoparticles. Journal of Chemical Education, 2007, 84 (2) 322-326.
816
96 Richeson, D., The center of the United States and other applications of calculus to geography.
817
College Mathematics Journal, 2005, 36(5) 366-373.
818
97 Lowes-Energy Guide WF42H5200A:
819
http://www.samsung.com/us/system/consumer/product/wf/42/h5/wf42h5200afa2/Energy-
820
Guide_WF42H5500_5200_5100_5000A_1.jpg
821
98 Lowes-Product Specifications WF42H5200A:
822
http://www.samsung.com/us/system/consumer/product/wf/42/h5/wf42h5200afa2/WF42H5200AF_Lo
823
wes_F.pdf
824
99 Energy Star: http://www.energystar.gov/certified-products/detail/clothes_washers
825
100 Lowes-Specification Sheet MVWC200BW: http://www.lowes.com/pd_502407-46-
826
MVWC200BW_0__?productId=50059141
827
101 Lowes-Energy Rating MVWC200BW: http://pdf.lowes.com/energyguides/883049285788.pdf
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 33 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
33 828
102 Samsung DV42H5200EW 7.5 cu. ft. Electric Front Load Dryer:
829
http://www.dtmccalls.com/samsung-dv42h5200ew-7-5-cu-ft-electric-front-load-dryer-white.html
830
103 Energy Star Market & Industry Scoping Report Residential Clothes Dryers:
831
http://www.energystar.gov/ia/products/downloads/ENERGY_STAR_Scoping_Report_Residential_Cl
832
othes_Dryers.pdf
833
104 Gibbs, H.K.; Johnston, M.; Foley, J.A.; Holloway, T.; Monfreda, C.; Ramankutty, N.; Zaks, D.,
834
Carbon payback times for crop-based biofuel expansion in the tropics: the effects of changing yield
835
and technology. Environmental Research Letters, 2008, 3, 1-10.
836
105 Geurt, J. G.; Junginger, M.; Faaij, A., Carbon payback period and carbon offset parity point of
837
wood pellet production in the South-eastern United States. GCB Bioenergy, 2013, 6 (4), 371-389.
838
106 Rankine, R.K.; Chick, J.P.; Harrison, G.P., Energy and carbon audit of a rooftop wind turbine.
839
Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of Power and Energy, 2006,
840
220, 643.
841
107 Wang, Z.; Chen, J.; Li, X.; Shao, J.; Peijnenburg, W.J.G.M., Aquatic toxicity of nanosilver
842
colloids to different trophic organisms: contributions of particles and free silver ion. Environmental
843
Toxicology and Chemistry, 2012, 31(10) 2408-2413.
844
108 Hogstrand, C.; Wood, C.W., Toward a better understanding of the bioavailability, physiology, and
845
toxicity of silver in fish: implications for water quality criteria. Environmental Toxicology and
846
Chemistry, 1998, 17(4) 547-561.
847
109 Klevens, R.; Edwards, J.; Richards, C.; Horan, T.; Gaynes, R.; Pollock, D.; Cardon, D. Estimating
848
health-care associated infections and deaths in U.S. hospitals, 2002. Public Heath Rep. 2007,
849
122(2):160-166.
850
110 Beggs, C. The airborne transmission of infection in hospital buildings: fact or fiction? Indoor Built
851
Environ. 2003,12:9-18.
852
111 CDC. Fact Sheet. 2007, http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/hip/Aresist/mrsafaq.htm.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 34 of 42
34 853
112 Pinon, A.; Gacget, J.; Alexandre, V.; Decherf, S.; Vialetter, M. Microbiological contamination of
854
bed linen and staff uniforms in a hospital. Advances in Microbiology. 2013, 515-519.
855
113 Borkow, G.; Gabbay, J. Biocidal textiles can help fight nosocomial infections. Medical
856
Hypotheses. 2008, 70: 990-994.
857
114 Nicas, M.; Sun, G. An integrated model of infection risk in a health-care environment. Risk
858
Analysis.2006, 26(4):1085-1096.
859
115 Zimlichman, E.; Henderson, D.; Tamir, O.; Franz, C.; Song, P.; Yamin, C.; Keohane, C.; Denham,
860
C.; Bates, D. Health care-associated infections: A meta-analysis of costs and financial impact on the
861
US health care system. JAMA Intern. Med. 2013, 173 (22) 2039-2046.
862 863 864 865 866 867 868 869 870 871 872
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Shirt
3
5
6
7
8
9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Shirt
lo ba Life Cycle Impact ( ) Po l W t e ar nt m i a in l g O zo ne D ep le tio n Ca rc in og en ic s Ec ot ox ic ity Conventional + nAg-enabled
1
Reduction in Laundering Required per Unit nAg Loading to Achieve Parity ( )
G
Page 35 of 42 Environmental Science & Technology
Tables and Figures
2
TOC Art
4
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 36 of 42
1 a.
b. Embedded Medical
El
od om g pu o o & B ter ds ev s fo era r g H ea C h e lth i l d & re H om F n e itne & s G s ar de n
e iv
ut
Fo
G
C
C
ec
tro
ni
C
cs
nc ia pl
Au
Ap
Year
tin
es
13
10
0
20
07
20
04
20
01
20
98
20
95
19
19
92
0
50
ot
20
100
m
40
150
ss
60
200
ro
80
250
to
100
300
&
Number of Silver Products
Textile Suspended
120
19
Number of Annual Nano Silver Patent Applications
Nanosilver
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Product Category
Figure 1. a) United States nAg patent applications by year b) PEN nAg search by product category (Retrieved July, 25, 2014) nAg patent applications per year from 1990-2013. Overlap in the different product categories is possible since multiple product matrices were investigated in the patent application search. Specific search terms included textile, fabric, shirt, pants, and clothing. Suspended nAg products include personal care products and coatings Embedded products are those where the product encases the silver, such as in composites. The medical category includes applications such as silver bandages to promote wound healing. Textile applications refer to clothing items such as shirts and socks, and are the focus of this work. Overall, there has been a significant increase in nAg applications over the past decade.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 37 of 42
Environmental Science & Technology
Table 1. Compiled research to date on silver content and release from commercially available textiles arranged by product type Silver Released During Silver Content Product Type Laundering Conditions (µg silver/g textile) (% of total silver content) Sock 36 1111 Benn and Westerhoff used a laundering protocol where socks were placed 1 in 1 liter glass bottles with ultrapure water and agitated for either 1 or 24 Sock 58 117 hours. In their paper the authors acknowledge that although detergent was Sock 2.1 ND not used in the study, most consumers do use detergent when laundering textiles. Socks in this study had between 0.9 – 1,358.3 µg of silver/g of Sock 1,358