1380
Anal. Chem. 1991, 63, 1380-1386
Membrane Technology and Dynamic Response of Ion-Selective Liquid-Membrane Electrodes Marin Huser, Peter M. Gehrig, Werner E. Morf, and Wilhelm Simon* Department of Organic Chemistry, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology ( E T H ) , Universitatsstrasse 16, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland Erno Lindner, Judit Jeney, Kllra Tbth, and Erno Pungor* Institute for General and Analytical Chemistry, Technical University of Budapest, Gellgrt tdr 4, H-1111 Budapest X I , Hungary
I n order to study the parameters affecting the dynamic response behavlor of neutral-carrier-based Iiquld-membrane electrodes, the potential response vs time curves of Na+-, Ca2+-, and w+-selecthre electrodes wtth different membrane compositions were recorded. The effects of the lipophlliclty of ionophores and plastldzers, of the presence of incorporated mobile anionic sites and of modifications of the membrane matrlx were Investigated. The experlmentai potential-tlme curves were compared to fitted functions on the basis of theoretical models.
INTRODUCTION The recent efforts in ion-selective electrode research made a tailored design of highly selective ionophores possible, which resulted in the realization of a large variety of corresponding membrane sensors ( I , 2). In spite of the primary importance of the ion-ionophore interactions exploited in these systems, however, selectivity is only one of the crucial parameters determining the whole performance of ionophore-based liquid-membrane electrodes. The ion-selective membranes applied in such macroelectrodes usually consist of about 1 wt 7'0 ionophore, 60-65 wt 7'0 plasticizer, 30-35 wt % PVC, and a strictly limited amount of lipophilic salt additives like sodium tetraphenylborate (NaTPB) or potassium tetrakisbchloropheny1)borate (KTpCLBP) ( 3 , 4 ) . Only the appropriate selection of each of these constituents finally guarantees for a highly selective and sensitive electrode that exhibits a stable and reproducible potential response. On the other hand, the specifications required for special applications such as in clinical chemistry can be fulfilled only by a thorough, very careful optimization of the membrane composition, which often involves compromises between competitive influences of components to be made. The most relevant fields of application of neutral-carrierbased ion-selective electrodes are clinical chemistry and bioelectrochemistry. In both fields the response time of the sensors is of utmost importance when the aim is to achieve a large sample throughput or to follow fast biological processes. On the other hand, there are very stringent requirements concerning the selectivity, sensitivity, potential stability, reproducibility, and lifetime of the sensors ( 5 , 6 ) . T o find the best compromise, one should know the exact influence of the different membrane components and of their properties on the response time of the sensor. In the present work we investigated in more detail the influence of the lipophilicity of the ligand, the lipophilicity of the plasticizer, the presence of lipophilic salt additives in the membrane, and modifications of the membrane matrix on the response time of selected cation-selective neutral-
* To whom correspondence should be addressed.
carrier-based PVC membrane electrodes. Similar studies on the response time of potassium sensors with different membrane matrices (PVC or silicone rubber) and with plasticizers of differing polarity were carried out earlier (7-10). To study the effects of lipophilicity of ligand and plasticizer on the dynamic response is, first of all, interesting from a practical point of view, since only sensors based on relatively lipophilic membrane components have practical relevance for clinical routine analysis (5). High lipophilicity is even more crucial when minielectrodes, fabricated with modern planar technologies, are concerned (11). However, it is difficult to investigate the dependence of response time on a single parameter. By varying the lipophilicity of the ligand and/or of the plasticizer, not only the extraction properties but also several other decisive parameters of the membrane (e.g. viscosity, ion permeabilities, etc.) are changed. In addition, it was shown earlier that ionophores having the same lipophilicities and only partly differing chemical constitutions may behave completely different in membrane electrodes with respect to slope and selectivity. The observed phenomena were interpreted as the result of kinetic limitations of the carrier-induced ion transfer between aqueous phase and membrane phase (12,13). The present studies seem to be important in theoretical respect as well. Therefore, the results on response times of ion sensors were analyzed in the light of theoretical models to get further information concerning the nature of the rate-determining processes.
THEORY There are a number of different possibilities to compare measured time response curves for ion sensors and to evaluate the relevant results. For practical purposes it is often convenient to characterize the observed potential transients by specifying the time needed to reach 90%, 95%, or 99% of the total potential change due to a given sample activity change. However, characterization of the complete response vs time curve by one single, arbitrarily selected point (e.g. t,,,) unavoidably leads to a loss of information or even to erroneous conclusions. For example, the time period after which the final, reliable potential reading can be taken might be underestimated, especially in cases where different sections of the curve are dominated by different rate-controlling processes (14-1 6).
Therefore, the potential transients recorded in the course of the present investigations have not simply been characterized by the respective tW% data, but they have also been further analyzed by using curve-fitting methods based on theoretical considerations. Equations 1 and 2 have been hE(t) = a E ( m ) + S log [I - (1 - ~ ? / a ~ ) e - ~ / ' (1) l] *(t) = A E ( ~+ ) s log [I - (1 - a ? / a i ) ( 1 / ( f i + I))] (2)
0003-270019110363-1380$02.50/0 0 1991 American Chemical Society
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 63,NO. 14, JULY 15. lQ9l
ETH 1534 (Na') log PTLC= 21.5
ETH 157 (Na') log PTLC= 4.5
3 -
-4
1381
CI KTpClPB
11 Figure 2. Constitutions and llpophilicity of plasticizers applied and constitution of potassium tetrakis@-ch1orophenyl)borate (KTpCIPB).
Figure 1. Constitutions and lipophiiicity of ionophores discussed.
with eq 2. By the latter relationship, originally, salt extraction and concomitant diffusion processes into the bulk membrane were taken into account (7).However, in the light of more recent studies on ionophore-based solvent polymeric membranes (21),such systems rather appear to behave as phases with fixed anionic sites, which makes an explanation of bulk diffusion processes within the membrane more problematic (20). Nevertheless, a square-root time dependence is often observed in dynamic response measurements on liquid-membrane electrodes as well as on solid-state sensors (20,22,23).
suggested in earlier contributions (7,8,14-19) (for a recent discussion, see ref 20) aa approximative descriptions of the dynamic response governed by diffusion/equilibration processes through the stagnant aqueous boundary layer and into the ion-selective membrane, respectively: where M(t)is the potential change found after the time t, M ( m ) is the total potential change reached a t final steady state, S is the experimentally determined slope of the electrode response function (emf vs log ai),a? is the initial activity of the primary ion in the bulk of the sample solution before applying an activity step a t t = 0, ai is the new activity value of the primary ion in the bulk of the sample solution after the step change, rl is a time constant (e.g. r1 = 62/2D)and ita interpretation is dependent on the model assumption used, r2 is the time constant for a diffusion process reaching into the membrane phase, t is the period of time after the activity step, 6 is the thickness of the aqueous boundary film (Nernstian diffusion layer), D is the mean diffusion coefficient of ions within this boundary layer. The short-time response behavior of the different sensors was generally compared on the basis of eq 1,while the long-time response data were mainly evaluated
Chemicals. For all experiments, deionized water doubly distilled in Pyrex glass and chemicals of puriss or pa grade were used. Membranes. The solvent polymeric membranes were prepared according to ref 24 by using 1wt % carrier, 64-66 wt % plasticizer, and 33 wt % poly(viny1 chloride). All ionophores (see Figure 1) were products of Fluka AG (Buchs, Switzerland) or were synthesized in our laboratories as described in the literature: ETH 2120 (ligand l),Fluka 71734; ETH 4120 (2) (25);ETH 1534 (3) (12);ETH 157 (4), Fluka 71733; ETH 4030 (5) (26);ETH 129 (61, Fluka 21193; ETH 5234 (7) (27). As plasticizers (see Figure 2), bis(2-ethylhexyl)sebacate (DOS,8),Fluka 84818, tetra-n-undecyl-3,3',4,4'-benzhydrol tetracarboxylate (ETH 2112, 9), Fluka 12103, o-nitrophenyl octyl ether (0-NPOE, lo), Fluka 73732, and chloroparaffii ( C P , 60% Cl), Scientific Polymer Products, hc., New York, were used. As polymeric membrane materials, poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC, high molecular weight, HMW),Fldsa 81392, carboxylated PVC (PVC-COOH, with 1.8 wt % COOH groups), Aldrich, 18,955-3, or a vinyl chloride/vinyl alcohol copolymer (PVC-OH, with 3.7 wt % OH groups) (28),were selected. The starting material for the preparation of PVC-OH was a copolymer of 82.9 wt % vinyl chloride and 17.1 wt % vinyl acetate prepared
ETH 5234 (Ca*') log PTLC= 23
7 -
EXPERIMENTAL SECTION
1382
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 03, NO. 14, JULY 15, 1991
Table I. Summary of Relevant Parameters of Membrane Systems Studied membrane svstem no.
ionophore*
matrix
1 2
1 1 1 1 1
HMW HMW HMW PVC-OH PVC-OH HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW HMW
3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
2 2 3 3
4 4 6
7 7 5
plasticb 8 8 9
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 10 10 10
chloroparaffin
amt of KTpClPB,' mol % 11
11 11 11
46 60
slope," mV/dec
H+
Na+
57.5 56.3 43.6 58.4 57.1 57.4 56.1 56.3 57.7 56.6 57.9 27.6 26.7 28.5 29.0
-0.8 -0.8 0.3 -0.7 -0.5 -0.6 -0.6 4.1 4.9 -1.1 -1.4 -2.0 4.7 -3.1 1.9
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -2.5 -3.2 -5.9 -3.7
log Ki,sot K+ Mg2+ -1.5 -1.5 4.7 -1.3 -1.1
-1.4 -1.3 -0.5 -0.5 -0.4 -0.4 -2.6 -3.5 -7.5 -3.5
-4.2 -3.8 -1.9 -3.0 -3.5 -3.8 -3.8 -3.6 -3.9 -3.8 -4.0 -3.1 -3.7 -4.4 0
Ca2+
R,MR
-3.1 -1.6 -0.1 -1.7 -0.8 -2.8 -1.7 -2.8 -2.4 -3.2 -2.6 0 0 0 0
38 3.1 3800 22 2.2 52 4.3 25 3.0 60 2.2 4.2 8.6 0.5 92 (49)
OThe slope values listed were determined in an activity range of 10-1-10-3.6. bThe numbers in the column refer to the numbers on Figures 1 and 2. 'The amount of KTpClPB is relative to the ionophores.
on a small scale (charge 916D) by IC1 (Switzerland) AG, Kunststoffwerk, CH-5643 Sins. The poly(viny1 chloride)-poly(viny1 acetate) copolymer (5 g) was dissolved in 100 mL of THF, and during a period of 10 min, the mixture was added dropwise to a solution of 1 wt % NaOH (puriss, Siegfried AG CH-4800 Zofingen) in 30 mL of methanol (MeOH; Fluka, puriss pa) at 50-60 OC. The solution was stirred during 1.5 h a t 63 OC, reduced to half of the volume, and then passed through filter paper into 1.5 L of water (25 "C) under stirring. After 10 min, the precipitate was filtered off, suspended in 300 mL of MeOH, and fitered again. The residue was suspended once more in 200 mL of MeOH and poured into 0.8 L of water (25 "C). After the product was filtered and dried (60 "C, vacuum), 1.2 g of product was obtained. The IR spectrum of a membrane cast with 50 mg of PVC-OH in 1.5 mL of THF showed a broad OH signal a t 3400 cm-', the sharp signal at 1732 cm-' due to the CO stretching vibration of the educt being absent. As lipophilic anionic-site additive, potassium tetrakis(p-chloropheny1)borate(KTpClF'B, ll), Fluka 60591, was used. The membrane compositions are given in Table 1. emf Measurements. The membranes of about 200-fim thickness were mounted in a Philips IS-560 liquid-membrane electrode body. The active membrane area was 0.126 cm2. emf values were measured with an Orion Research Model 701 pH meter coupled to an Orion Model 605 manual electrode switch. The external reference electrode was a Radelkis 8201 doublejunction Ag/AgCl electrode, with a 1 M potassium chloride or 1 M lithium acetate bridge electrolyte. Selectivity coefficients were determined by the separate solution method (SSM) (29) in lo-* M aqueous metal chloride solutions. The activity coefficients used were estimated as described in refs 30 and 31. The measured emf values were corrected for the liquid-junction potentials by using the Henderson formalism (30). Determination of the Internal Resistance of the Cells. The electrical membrane resistances were determined by the voltage divider method using known shunts (32). Further details were reported in ref 33. Determination of Lipophilicities. The lipophilicities of the plasticizers and of the ionophores, log P, were determined by The .uncertainties in the thin-layer chromatography (5b, 34,s) determined log P m values are in the range of *0.4 up to i 4 , depending on the absolute magnitude of data determined. Response Time Measurements. To determine the dynamic response (voltage vs time-function) of the different electrodes, a switched wall-jet arrangement was used (36). The rise time (10%-90% ) of the differential electrometer amplifier (Keithley Model 604) with a standard shunt resistance of 10 or 100 Mi2 was specified as 5 or 50 ms, respectively. To avoid undesirable and uncontrollable interference by the measuring electronics on the response time functions of membranes with high resistances, the effect of the cell resistance was checked experimentally by increasing this resistance with a standard resistor (of the same order
of magnitude) in series to the electrode studied. This procedure allowed the determination of the maximal cell resistance where the rise time of the measuring electronics did practically not affect the response time values. The flow rate was fixed at about 160 mL/min, applying a constant pressure of 0.3 bar on the solution containers. The standard deviation of the tW%data as a result of differences in flow rate setting and geometrical differences was found to be i 2 ms at a response time value of 40 ms. However, the membrane to membrane variation of the t,, data may be considerably larger (in the range 110-15 ms) as a result of hardly controllable parameters such as ionic impurities in any of the membrane components, changes of membrane properties in time, and differences in the surface geometry of the different electrodes and active surface area of membranes. All response time measurements were carried out in the presence of a background electrolyte of constant ionic strength in order to minimize effects by streaming potentials and liquidjunction potentials. The choice of this electrolyte was dependent on the selectivity properties of the membrane electrodes. Accordingly, 0.1 M MgClz and 0.1 M KCl were used as background electrolytes for measurements with Na+- and Ca2+-selective electrodes, respectively, and 0.1 M NaCl for M P - and K+-selective electrodes.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION In the course of this work, sodium-, calcium-, and magnesium-selective ionophores of different lipophilicities were incorporated into solvent polymeric membranes prepared with plasticizers of wide ranging lipophilicities. The chemical constitutions of these compounds together with the experimentally determined lipophilicity data (2.6 Ilog PTLc I23) are given in Figures 1 and 2, and the relevant parameters of membrane systems studied are summarized in Table I. On the basis of the results obtained with different ionophores it can be stated that the dynamic characteristics of corresponding membrane electrodes are virtually not influenced by the lipophilicity of the ligands as long as log P 2 5 (see Figure 3 and Table 11). The same trends were reported earlier for potassium-selective electrodes on the basis of bis( 15crown-5) and related ionophores (10, 37). The moderate slowing-down of the time-response observed for sensors with less lipophilic ionophores can be ascribed to a gradual loss of the relatively water-soluble components from the surface region of the membrane, which may results in a surface layer of low site density and high electrical resistance. No evidence for a relationship between the lipophilicity of the ion carriers and the response time of corresponding ion sensors is found for the calcium-selective systems (Table 111). Both Ca2+
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 63, NO. 14,JULY 15, 1991 _
_
_
_
_
~
1383
~
Table 11. Effect of the Lipophilicity of the Ligand on the tWaResponse Time Data and on the Time Constant of Eq 1 Fitted to the Experimentally Recorded Response Time Curves of the Sodium Sensors no.
membrane system ionophore
10 1 6 8
ETH 157 (4) ETH 2120 (1) ETH 4120 (2) ETH 1534 (3)
log PTU:
tms, ma 2
4.5 8.3 17.2 21.5
-
3b
ma 2
T ~ ,
365 177 202 168
-
params of eq 1" 3b RMSD, mV
38.2 12.4 15.2 16.9
tma, ma 3
2.3 2.1 2.6 2.0
-
2b
82 29 44 59
"The curve-fitting procedure was always the same; i.e. 79 data pointa were taken into consideration (every 20th) from the 1650 collected within 1-s time period. bThe numbers represent the negative logarithm of solution activities Q: and ai, while the arrows indicate the direction of the activity step. Table 111. Effect of Lipophilic Salt Additives on the twn Response Time Data and on the Time Constant of Eqs 1 and 2 Fitted to the Potential-Time Curves of Different Ca2+Electrodes membrane system ionophore KTpCIPBb
no.
ma 4
-
ETH 5234 (7) ETH 5234 (7) ETH 129 (6)
13 14 12
-
t90%9
2c
T
params of eq 1" RMSD, ~ ma , 4 2c mV
-
48 23 57
+-
162 109
T
params of eq 2" RMSD, ~ ma , 4 2c mV
-
0.21 0.25
10.7 6.3
tmk,
m ~ 2 - 4 ~
0.17 0.14
74 32 71
"The curve-fitting procedure was always the same; Le. 103 data pointa were taken into consideration (every 16th) from the 1650 collected within 25-s time period. Membranes denoted with a + sign were prepared with KTpClPB additive. The numbers represent the negative logarithm of solution activities Q? and Q;, while the arrows indicate the direction of the activity step. Table IV. Comparison of t ~ Response % Time Data as Well as of Time Constants of Eq 1 Fitted to the Experimentally Recorded Response Time Curves of Sodium Sensors Based on Ligands of Different Lipophilicity and Containing KTpClPB Additives no.
membrane system ionophore
11 2 7 9
ETH 157 (4) ETH 2120 (1) ETH 4120 (2) ETH 1534 (3)
log P ~ c
tma,
4.5 8.3 17.2 21.5
ma 2
-
3b
ma 2
T ~ ,
18 24 33 14
-
params of eq 1' 3b RMSD, mV
4.9 6.8 8.4 4.2
tmk ma 3
0.49 0.67 0.71 0.23
-
2b
14 31 30 9
"The curve-fitting procedure was always identical; i.e. 79 data pointa were taken into consideration (every 20th) from the 1650 collected within 1-s time interval. bThe numbers represent the negative logarithm of solution activities a? and ai, while the arrows indicate the direction of the activity step. EMF
I
EMF
DOS
-+&(-
PVC
IONOPHORE iONOPHORE IONOPHORE
4
2
1I
IONOPHORE
-
1.
---- --
,
Z O ~ V I'
I I
---.---
i
I 1
1 ,
0
I
40
80
120
160
200
ms TIME
Figure 3. Response time curves of solvent polymeric membrane electrodes with the sodium-selective ionophores 1-4 and DOS (8) as membrane solvent. condltkns: conc8nlratbn step;10-2-104M NaCI; supporting electrolyte; lo-' M MgCI,. The two vertical lines show the start and stop times of the jet switching motion.
ionophores studied dispose of an adequately high lipophilicity and yield membrane electrodes that exhibit a fast and almost identical response. The incorporation of additional anionic sites (KTpClPB in this work) into conventional neutral-carrier-based PVC membranes generally leads to fast responding electrodes (see Figure 4 and Tables I11 and IV), and the dynamic behavior is often found to become almost independent of the properties of the ionophore applied (Table IV). The electrodes with KTpClPB additive become so fast that the overall transients are primarily controlled by the time of switching and mixing.
0
/
II
1
LO
/
l
so
l
(
120
I
I
,
200 I
ms
160 TIME
Figure 4. Response time curves of solvent polymeric membrane electrodes with DOS (8) as plasticizer and the sodiumselective bncphore 3. Membranes without additional anionic sites are compared with membranes containing 1 1 mol % KTpCiPB relative to the ion@ phore. Conditions: concentration steps, 104-10-2 M NaCl and vice v m ; supportine electrolyte, lo-' M MgCi,. The two vertical lines show the start and stop times of the jet switching motion.
Such a favorable effect of lipophilic salt additives in respect to the response time could be confirmed both on the basis of t,, data and fitted time constants (compare Tables I1 and IV). Similar results have also been reported earlier (8,37). The experimental time response curves were analyzed in more detail by curve-fitting procedures based on the theoretical eqs 1 and 2. The comparison of the results was carried out on the basis of the fitted time constants, of the data obtained for the root mean square deviation (RMSD =
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 63,NO. 14, JULY 15, 1991
1384 EMF
I
I IONOPHORE ETH 2112 PVC
1
EMF EXPONENTIAL FUNCTION
rL -..
SOUARE- ROOT FUN
I
lC mV
0
21813
A3626
65439
,
872 52
109065
IONOPHORE KTpClPB CHLOROPARAFFIN PVC
ms
TIME
Flgure 5. Experimentally recorded potential-time functions of a sodium-selectlve membrane electrode containing the ionophore l and the highiy li ophilic plasticizer ETH 2112 (9).Conditions: concentration steps, 10-K10-2 M NaCl and vice versa; supporting electrolyte, lo-’ M
MgCI,. ~
I
[RSS/(n - ~ ) ] l /where ~ , RSS is the residual sum of squares, n is the number of experimental values taken into consideration, and p is the number of parameters) and of the numerical values found for the curve-fitting parameters (e.g. the slope S of the potential response function). The model assumptions used for the derivation of eq 1 are probably justified generally for ISE response time measurements under usual conditions. But they might not be valid if the switched wall-jet system is used at high sample flow rate. The switched wall-jet arrangement was developed with the aim to avoid the rate-controlling effect of the diffusion through the aqueous boundary layer in the overall response. Deviations from eq 1 can be attributed to differences between the model assumptions and experimental conditions. But they may indicate that processes other than the diffusion/equilibration through an adhering solution to the electrode surface are rate-determining. In the latter case no or little flow rate dependence is expected and the main goal was achieved. On the contrary a considerable flow rate dependence and a good fit of eq 1 imply that among the rate-determining processes the ion transport through the hydrodynamic boundary layer to the electrode surface is still basically rate determining. In these circumstances small changes in the response time may not be detectable, e.g. in the case of membranes containing KTpClPB. These studies showed that a dynamic behavior according to the square-root time relationship (eq 2) generally becomes more pronounced in the case of long-term measurements, of sensor systems with poorly lipophilic ligands and when a step from high to low sample activities is followed. In contrast, the response time curves recorded with ionophore-based PVC membranes containing KTpClPB additives are usually in better agreement with the exponential time dependence (eq l),independently of the lipophilicity of the carrier and of the direction of the activity change (compare RMSD data of Tables I1 and IV). Very often, however, the experimental curves could be rather well fitted with either of the two equations. Therefore, a clear-cut experimental distinction between the underlying rate-controlling processes (7,8,14-19) is not feasible and generally only a qualitative characterization of the curve type is given in this work. Washing-out of the plasticizer from the solvent polymeric membrane finally results in an increase of the membrane resistance and in a concomitant loss of ion sensitivity (38-40). For that reason, plastizicers of high lipophilicity have been suggested especially for biomedical applications (5a). The compound E T H 2112 was synthesized on the basis of such considerations (41). Unfortunately, membrane electrodes prepared with this extremely lipophilic plasticizer showed an unusually high response time (Figure 5) as well as reduced selectivity and sensitivity (Table I). The observed t,, values
IO mV
EXPONENTIAL FUNCTION
0
4000
8000
12000
16000
20000
24000 ms TIME
Flgure 6. Calculated and measured response time curves of a divalention-selectiveelectrcde containing the carrier 5 , 6 0 md % KTpClpS relative to the carrier and chloroparaffin as membrane solvent. The curves were fined on the basis of the exponential function (eq 1) and of the square-root function (eq 2). Conditions: concentration steps, 10-3-10-2M MgCI, and vice versa: supporting electrolyte, lo-’ M NaCI.
are typically in the range of several seconds for this case, i.e. by 1-2 orders of magnitude higher than the values listed in Table I1 for electrodes containing DOS as plasticizer. Exudation of the plasticizer and formation of a site-free or low site density surface layer of high resistance may be the reason for such a behavior. Unfortunately, the literature about impedance studies of PVC membranes is quite controversial in this respect. Some authors reported on the formation of high-resistance surface films (9, 42, 43) or on surfacecharge-transfer resistances related to slow ion-transfer kinetics (44,45), while the impedance studies of other authors showed no evidence for surface effects in normal membrane compositions (46, 47); see also ref 48. If the thickness and the resistance of such a layer are large enough, the diffusion of species to the active membrane surface becomes rate-limiting, which finally results in a square-root time dependence of the electrode response (20). On the basis of the divalent-ion-selective ionophore 5, membrane electrodes suited for water hardness determination, exhibiting a high discrimination of Na+ and K+ ions and nearly identical selectivities for Ca2+ and Mg2+ions, were realized earlier (49) by selecting chloroparaffin (log PTLc = 6.4-10.1) as plasticizer. In the present studies, the response time of this sensor turned out to be considerably longer than that for the Na+-, K+-, and Ca2+-selectivesensors. The experimentally found twoo/, data were 2120 and 600 ms for an activity step of 10-2-10-3 M and vice versa, respectively. Furthermore, eq 2 gave an almost perfect fit to the experimental data in both the relatively short-time and the long-time domains (see Figure 6). These results seem to corroborate the previous assumption of a surface layer predominantly formed by the plasticizer. When DOS as plasticizer was replaced with chloroparaffin in fast-responding ion-selective sensors (e.g. bis(crown ether)based potassium electrode), the rate of response became similarly slow. The incorporation of KTpClPB in such membranes results in some response time decrease as expected, but these values are still considerably larger as compared to those of membranes with DOS.
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 63,NO. 14, JULY 15, 1991
1385
Table V. Effect of the Membrane Matrix on the twon and tSraResponse Time Data and on the Time Constants of Eqs 1 and 2 Fitted to the Potential-Time Curves of HMW- and PVC-OH-Matrix-Based Sodium Sensors membrane system no. ionophore (additive) matrix
activity stepa
tWn, ms
t,,
ms
params of eq 1'~ ms RMSD, mV
71,
params of eq 2b ms RMSD, mV
72,
ETH 2120 (1) HMW 2-3 350 790 89.5 0.57 0.3 0.22 ETH 2120 (1) PVC-OH 2-3 898 2890 99 1.24 1.2 0.17 ETH 2120 (1) HMW 3-2 30 76 111 0.20 1.8 0.09 ETH 2120 (1) PVC-OH 3 4 2 137 660 169 0.56 18.6 0.16 ETH 2120 (1) HMW 2 4 3 21 6.1 0.41 0.035 1.29 + KTpClPB 35c 5 ETH 2120 (1) PVC-OH 2-3 46 9.4 1.15 0.23 1.48 + KTpClPB 26SC 35.1e 5.4c a The numbers represent the negative logarithm of solution activities a: and ai, while the arrows indicate the direction of the activity step. For the curve-fitting procedure, 80 data points at constant time intervals were taken into consideration from the 1650 collected. For the membrane systems without KTpClPB (nos. 1 and 4) and with KTpClPB (no. 2 and 5), time periods of 25 and 1 s, respectively, were evaluated. The experiments were carried out after conditioning the electrodes for 1 day and again after 8 days conditioning. The bold data correspond to the second set of experiments. 1 4 1 4 2
EM1
-\r -
SQUARE ROOT FUNCTiON EXPONENTIAL FUNCTION
1
IONOPHORE DOS PVC HMW
-
1
1
SQUARE- ROOT FUkCTION
L/ / EXPONENTIAL FUNCTION P
' +
1 1
SQUARE - ROOT FUNCTION
S,QUARE
-ROOT
FUNCTiON
I
I-+*-. I
0
I
5000
1
IONOPHORE DOS PVC - OH
;lomv
-
I
I
I
I
10000
15000
20000
25000
ms TIME
Flgure 7. Comparison of calculated and measured response time curves of electrodes with the sodlumselectlvecarrier 1 and DOS (E) as plasticizer, which were prepared either from conventional PVC or from hydroxylated PVC (PVCOH). The curves were fitted on the basis of the exponential function (eq 1) and of the square-root function (eq 2). Conditions: concentration steps, 103-10-2 M NaCl and vice versa: supporting electrolyte, lo-' M MgCI,.
Membranes with chemically modified PVC copolymer matrices (PVC-COOH, PVC-OH) were introduced in ionselective sensors primarily in the aim of improving their adhesion on surfaces of electronic semicondudor devices, which is an essential step in the manufacturing of ion-selective field effect transistors (50). Although it was shown that in these membranes the predominant part of the fixed ionic sites are in a nondissociated form (43,51), the corresponding sensors proved to be advantageous in comparison with conventional PVC-membrane-baseddevices. Thus, the use of the modified polymer matrices leads to a reduction of membrane bulk resistances by a factor of 1.5-5 and to a reduction of membrane surface resistances (43),as well as to a reduction of asymmetry potentials caused by protein adsorption onto the membrane after its exposure to blood serum or whole blood (28).
However, more detailed investigations revealed that ionselective electrodes prepared with carboxylated or hydroxylated PVC copolymer membranes generally tend to exhibit a slower response than the conventional PVC counterparts and that the observed time response curves appear to follow a membrane diffusion-controlled transient potential according to eq 2 (Table V and Figure 7). This equation gave a much better fit to the potential-time curves recorded with carboxy or hydroxy PVC based membranes than eq 1. The RMSD data are 2-7 times smaller if eq 2 was fitted to a given set of data points instead of eq 1. In contrast to the favorable effect of a high density of mobile site additives (e.g. KTpClPB) on the response time found for conventional PVC-based membrane sensors, the speed of response is significantly reduced in the case of these modified polymeric membranes with an increased fixed site density. Even in the presence of a well-defined amount of anionic sites (KTpClPB), electrodes prepared from PVC-OH behave fundamentally different from electrodes prepared from standard PVC (Table V). The response time of standard PVC-based membranes changed only slightly during the experimental time period of 8 days. The incorporation of KTpClPB into PVC-OH-based membranes initially leads to relatively fast responding electrodes, too,but the response time increases considerably with time, and the advantageous effect of KTpClPB becomes less pronounced. There are some hints that the rate of equilibration is here again limited by diffusion processes reaching into the membrane and may be influenced by the presence of a distinct surface film. Such surface films can generally be formed during membrane preparation (8, 91, by exudation of plasticizer (42), by dissolution of active membrane components from the outer membrane region, or by the development of a hydrated layer such as in the case of glass membranes (52). In connection with the last possibility, it is worth mentioning that both the carboxylated and the hydroxylated PVC membranes show a remarkably high water uptake during conditioning (53).
LITERATURE CITED (1) Rouiily, M. V.; Badeftscher, M.; Retsch, E.; Suter, G.; Simon, W. Anal. chem. 1988, 6 0 , 2013. (2) Pretsch, E.; Badertscher, M.; Welti, M.; Maruizumi, T.; Morf, W. E.; Simon. W. Pure ADD/. Chem. 1988. 6 0 . 567. (3) . . Meier.'P. C.: MoLrW. E.: LAubii. M.: Simon. W. Anal. Cbim. Acta 1884,. 156, 1. (4) Pretsch. E.; Wegmnn, D.; Ammann, D.; Bezegh, A.; Dinten, 0.; Uubil, M. W.; Mod. W. E.; Oesch, U.; Sugahara, K.; Weiss, H.; Simon, W. I n Ion Measurements in Physiologv and W l c i n e ; Kessler, M.. et ai., Eds.; Springer Verlag: Berlin, Heidelberg, 1085; p 11. (5) (a) Oesch. U.; Anker, P.; Ammann. D.; Simon, W. I n Ion-Selective E k h d S s ; Pungor, E., Ed.; Adadmial Kiad& Budapest, 1985; Part 4, p 81. (b) Dinten. 0.; Spichiger, U. E.; Chaniotakis, N.; Gehrig, P.; Rusterholz, B.; Mod. W. E.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1991, 63.598. (6) Buhrer, T.; Gehrig, P.; Simon, W. Anal. Scl. 1988, 4 , 547.
1388
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 63,NO. 14, JULY 15, 1991
(7) Morf, W. E.; Lindner, E.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1975, 47, 1596. (8) Lindner. E.; Tbth, K.; Pungor, E.; Mod, W. E.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1978, 50. 1627. (9) Lindner, E.; Niegreisz, 2s.;Tbth, K.; Pungor, E.;Berube, T. R.; Buck, R. P. J. Electroanal. Chem. Interfeclal Ektrochem. p89, 259, 67. (10) Tbth,..K.; Lindner, E.; HorvBth. M.; Jeney, J.; Bitter, I.; Agai, B.; Meisel. T.; Toke. L. Anal. Lett. 1089, 2 2 , 1185. (11) Oesch, U.; Simon, W. Transducers 87, The 4th International Conference on SolM-State Sensors and Actuators, Dlgest of Technical Pa pers; Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, 1-12-1, Yurakucho, Chiycda-ku, Tokyo, Japan, 1987; p 755. (12) Oesch. U.; Ammann, D.; Pretsch, E.; Simon, W. Helv. Chim. Acta 1979, 6 2 , 2073. (13) Gehrig, P.; Morf, W. E.; Weiti, M.; Pretsch, E.; Simon, W. Helv. Chim. Acta 1890. 7. 3,. -.. 203. .... (14) Lindner, E.; Tbth, K.; Pungor, E. Dynamic Cheracterlstics of Ion-Selectlve Electrodes; CRC Press Inc.: Boca Raton, FL. 1988. (15) Llndner, E.; Tbth, K.; Pungor, E. Anal. Chem. 1978, 48, 1071. (16) Shatkay, A. Anal. Chem. 1978, 48, 1039. Pungor, E. Anal. Chim. Acta 1971, 57, 131. (17) Tbth, K.; GavaiiC, I.; (18) Markovlc, P. L.; Osburn, J. AIChE J. 1073, 19, 504. (19) Morf, W. E. The Prlnclples of Ion-Selectlve Electrodes and of Membrane Transport; Akademiai Kiadb, Elsevier, MIR Publishers: Budapest, Amsterdam and New York, Moscow, 1981, 1981. 1985. (20) Berube, T. R.; Buck, R. P. And. Left. 1989, 2 2 , 1221. (21) Buck, R. P.; Tbth, K.; G r B f , E.;Horval, G.; Pungor, E. J. Electroanal. Chem Interfacie1 Electrochem. 1987, 223, 5 1. (22) Berube, T. R. Response of ion-selective electrodes to step in ion concentrations. Ph.D. Thesis, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hili, 1989. (23) Werner, 6.; Werner, G.; Lindner, E. Unpublished work. (24) craggs, A.; Moody, C. J.; Thomas, J. D. R. J. Chem. Educ. 1974, 57, 541. (25) Gehrig, P.; Rusterholz, 6.; Simon, W. Anal. Chim. Acta 1990, 233, 295. (26) Muller, M.; Rouiiiy, M.; Rusterholz, 6.; Maj-Zurawska, M.; Hu, 2 . ; Simon. W. Mlkrochlm . Acta 1988, 3 283. (27) Gehrig, P.; Rusterhoiz, 6.; Simon, W. Chlmla 1989, 43, 377. (28) Durseien, L. F. J.; Wegmann, D.; May, K.; Desch, U.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1988, 6 0 , 1455. (29) Guiibaut, G. G.; Durst, R. A.; Frant, M. S.; Freiser, H.; Hansen, E. H.; Light, T. S.; Pungor, E.; Rechnitz, G.; Rice, N. M.; Rohm, T. J.; Simon, W.; Thomas, J. D. R. Pure Appl. Chem. 1978, 48, 127. (30) Meler, P. C.; Ammann, D.; Morf, W. E.; Simon, W. I n Medical and Blologcal Applhxtlons of Elactrochemlcal Devlces; Koryta, J.. Ed.; Wiiey: Chichester, New York, Brisbane. Toronto, 1960; p 13. (31) Meler, P. C. Anal. Chlm. Acta 1982, 136, 363. (32) Ammann, D.: Pretsch, E.; Simon, W.; Lindner, E.; Bezegh, A,; Pungor,
.
~
E. Anal. Chim. Acta 1985, 171. 119. (33) Lindner, E.; T&, K.; Jeney, J.; Pungor, E.; Buck, R. P.; KemQny, P. I n Ion-selective Eleclrodes; Pungor, E., Ed.; Akademlal Kiadb: Budapest, 1989; Part 5, p 459. (34) Simon, W.; Pretsch, E.; Mod, W. E.; Ammann, D.; Oesch, U.; Dinten, 0. Analyst 1984, 109, 207. (35) Oesch, U.; Brzbzka, 2.; Xu, A.; Rusterhoiz, 6.; Suter, G.; Pham, H. V.; WeRi, D. H.; Ammann. D.; Pretsch, E.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1988, 58, 2285. (36) Lindner, E.; Tbth, K.; Pungor. E.; Berube, T. R.; Buck, R. P. And. Che" 1087, 5 9 , 2213. (37) Tbth, K.; Lindner, E.; Jeney, J.; G r B f , E.; MnvBth, M.; Pungor, E.; Bitter, I.; Meisel, T.; Agai, 8.; Toke, L.; Buck, R. P.; Kellner, R. I n I o n - S e k tive Electrodes; Pungor, E.,Ed.; AkadOmiai Kiadb: Budapest. 1989; Part 5, p 181. (38) Oesch, U.; Simon, W. Helv. Chlm. Acta 1979, 6 2 , 754. (39) Oesch, U.; Simon, W. Anal. Chem. 1980, 52, 692. 140) Horvai. G.; G r B f . E.; Tbth. K.; Pungor. E.; Buck, R. P. Anal. Chem. 1988, 58, 2735. (41) Oesch,U.; Xu, A.; Brzbzka, 2.; Suter, G.; Simon, W. Chlmie 1988. 40, 35 1 (42) K.; GrBf, E.; Horvai, G.; Pungor, E.; Buck, R. P. Anal. Chem. 1086. 58. 2741. (43) Lindner, E.; GrBf, E.; Niegreisz, 2s.;Tbth, K.; Pungor. E.; Buck, R. P. Anal. Chem. 19889 6 0 , 295. (44) Xie, s.-L.; Cammann, K. J. Electroanel. Chem. 1987, 229, 249. (45) Xie, S.-L.; Cammann, K. J. Electroanal. Chem. 1988, 245, 117. (46) Armstrong, R. D. Electrochlm. Acta 1987, 32, 1549. (47) Armstrong. R. D.; Nikitas, P. Electrochim. Acta 1985, 30, 1627. (48) Horvai, G.; HorvBth, V.; Farkas, E.; Pungor, E. I n Ion-Selectlve Electrodes;Pungor. E., Ed.; AkadOmiai Kiadb: Budapest, 1989; Part 5, p 397. (49) . , Mai-Zurawska. M.: Rouiiiv. M.: Morf. W. E.: Simon, W. Anal. Chim. A C b 1989, 218, 47. . (50) Satchwiil, T.; Harrison, D. J. J. Electroanal. Chem. 1986, 202, 75. (51) Ma, S. C.:Chaniotakis. N. A.; Meyerhoff, M. E. Anal. Chem. 1988, 60.---2293 (52) Kariberg. B. J. Electroanal. Chem. 1973, 42, 115. (53) Tbth, K.; Lindner. E.; Jeney. J.; Pokoi, Gy.;Pungor, E. Unpublished work.
Ti#,
--.
RECEIVED for review May 15, 1990. Revised manuscript received March 29, 1991. Accepted April 5,1991. This work was partly supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation.
