GOVERNMENT & POLICY
MERCURY BATTLE States are demanding FASTER CUTS in mercury emissions than EPA requires CHERYL HOGUE, C&EN WASHINGTON
WHEN IT COMES to curbing air pollution, the Environmental Protection Agency historically has set the targets for cleaning up, and states have responded by imple menting EPA's national goals. But the case of reducing mercury pollution from power plants shows that the tide is turning. A number of states have decided that they can do more to protect public health than can EPA's rule. As a result, they are requiring deeper and faster cuts in mercury emissions than the federal agency has. This is a precedent-setting change in U.S. air pollution policy, says Felice Stadler, manager of the mercury program at the Na tional Wildlife Federation (NWF). In addition, some states may end up putting a crimp in EPA's emissions trad
ing strategy for reducing power plants' releases of the neurotoxic metal. Under this scheme, utilities can continue spew ing mercury if they purchase allowances to pollute from facilities that have cut their releases to below required levels. A number of states are opting out of the national trad ing plan, others are challenging the scheme in court, and some are doing both. In the U.S., coal-fired power plants are the largest source of mercury releases to the environment. Coal contains tiny amounts of mercury, generally less than ι part per million, or between about 5 and 36 lb of the metal per trillion Btu of energy. Each year, U.S. power plants release about 48 tons of mercury to the atmosphere when they burn coal, according to EPA.
ΩΜΕ
jr
Policymakers are concerned about air borne mercury primarily because some of it deposits in watersheds. Both bacte ria and abiotic chemical processes can convert deposited mercury into methylmercury, a form of the metal that can be taken up by fish. People, especially chil dren and pregnant women, are advised to limit or avoid consumption of mercurycontaminated fish because the metal is
mmi&$®® ^ ^ ^
„n ^er^ces to
Strat _,gic Partner in Dru g Discovery &
veiopment Service:
R&D facility • Spread over 295,000 sq. ft. • 1025 scientists
Kilo Lab cum Pilot Plant • • • •
2 Kilo-Lab cum Pilot plant facilities 22 reactors range (20 L to 630 L) Total Volume - 4100 Lts CGMP compliant facility
Commercial Plant Facilities • 6 Commercial Multipurpose plants at Gajraula (near Delhi) and 4 at Nanjangud (near Bangalore) • 135 reactors ranging from 1KL to 12 KL • Total Volume - 600 KL • CGMP and non CGMP compliant facilities
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
CO.
APRIL 2. 2007
Jubilant Organosys Ltd. 1 -A, Sector 16-A, Noida-201 301 U.P India Ph: +91 120 2516601-11 Fax: +91 120 2516627-30
CLAMP DOWN Several states are imposing tighter standards than EPA on mercury emissions from coalfired power plants.
linked to neurological problems. Bush Administration officials express pride that they crafted the first regulation anywhere in the world to curb emissions of mercury from the electricity-generating sector. They repeatedly tout this Clean Air Act rule, which was issued in 2005, as a major environmental accomplishment. EPA's rule is designed to cut current annual mercury emissions of 48 tons from power plants by 21% in 2010 and by 69% sometime after 2018, perhaps as late as 2025. Under the regulation, plant operators won't have to install equipment that specifically controls mercury until 2018. This is because the first round of cuts in mercury will come as a by-product of another EPA rule, one reducing utilities' emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides. States say EPA's rule sets the bar too low. Stadler says states are demonstrating that it's possible to control mercury emissions from power plants within the current decade and not have to wait until 2018 or beyond. NOT LONG AFTER the Bush Administration issued the rule, state and local air pollution regulators began pushing a plan for individual states to issue rules that would slash mercury emissions from power plants faster and deeper than does the EPA rule. The National Association of Clean Air Agencies (NACAA) developed the strategy to eliminate 80% of the mercury released from coal-fired power plants by 2008 and 90-95% by 2012. The group estimates its approach would add $1.00 to $2.00 to the monthly bill for residential electricity (C8cEN, Nov. 21,2005, page 8). The plan excludes the trading of mercury, says NACAA, which was recently formed from the merger of the State 8c Territorial Air Pollution Program Administrators and the Association of Local Air Pollution Control Officers. State and local air pollution agencies prefer a strong, effective federal rule on
mercury to provide the uniformity and certainty that electric utilities desire, says S. William Becker, executive director of NACAA. But state and local regulators "won't sit idly by when the federal government promulgates a deficient rule" like EPA's rule on mercury, he tells C8cEN. Some states are adopting even tougher measures than those in the NACAA plan.
For instance, Connecticut has enacted a statute mandating a 90% reduction in mercury emissions by July 2008. Other states, however, are unable to adopt more stringent limits than the one set by EPA because of laws prohibiting them from setting environmental standards that are tougher than national ones, Becker says. Meanwhile, 15 states are opting out
Expand the
^6unc^!|ièSof: |lcprpp§eri|fic
Plastics Polymers Nanomaterials Composites
disCOvit#ir:ît f c :
Ceramics
Connecting you t o a world of talented scientistsLeading R&D-driven companies are using InnoCentive to expand their research capacity, accelerate breakthroughs and bring products to market sooner. They're posting complex R&D challenges on innocentive.com - where our global online network of more than 120,000 accomplished researchers and scientists are ready to solve them. InnoCentive's open innovation platform is helping to deliver successful solutions at dramatic speeds, without the costs of added personnel or failed research. And we facilitate the process to maintain your confidentiality and protect intellectual property. Visit www.innocentive.com for more information or call +1-866-812-7339. ©2007 InnoCentive, Inc. All rights reserved.
*
\INNOCENTIVE
InnoCentive, the InnoCentive logo and InnoCentive Challenge are registered trademarks or trademarks of InnoCentive, Inc.
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
53
APRIL 2, 2007
GOVERNMENT & POLICY
of the national mercury-trading scheme established under the Bush regulation. Utilities in five of these states—Delaware, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New Mexico, and New York—likely would have pur chased emission allowances if these states had joined the national trading program, according to an analysis by NWF. Three of the 15 states opting out of the trading program don't have coal-fired power plants—Idaho, Vermont, and Rhode Island—but utilities have drafted plans to build two coal-burning generation plants in Idaho. Under the EPA rule, these new plants would have to purchase mercury emission allowances from facilities in other states before they could begin opera tion. Idaho is considering a rule that would restrict emissions of mercury from newly constructed coal-burning facilities. Even though the federal trading pro gram "isn't ideal" because of the states opt ing out of it, the scheme will still work as intended to lower the cost of cutting mer cury emissions, says Jeffrey R. Holmstead, a former EPA assistant administrator who was the architect of the Bush Administra-
POLLUTION CONTROL
Sales Of Mercury Removal Equipment Grow There's good business in cleaning up mercury. ADA-ES, a Littleton, Colo., firm that develops and installs mercury control technology for coal-fired power plants, reports that its business is grow ing. The firm sold its first control system for a coal fired boiler in 2005. By the end of 2006, the company had installed or had orders for 12 of these systems. Since the beginning of 2007, it has begun craft ing five more. Mark H. McKinnies, senior vice presi dent and chief financial officer for ADAES, says this growth began with calls for systems for new coal-fired power plants,
tion's 2005 mercury rule. "I'm quite confi dent of that," because most of the nation's coal-fired capacity is in states that buy and sell emission allowances, says Holmstead, a partner in the Washington, D.G., office of
In a capacity crunch?
which must install best-achievable con trol technology for a variety of air pol lutants, including mercury. Increasingly, though, operators are ordering systems for older plants that, due to a loophole in the Clean Air Act, have not had to install mercury controls. In some cases, utilities struck a deal with a state regulatory agency to equip their older coal-burning units with the mercury controls in return for the state's approving a permit for a new generating facility, McKinnies tells C&EN. But in recent months, the firm has seen "a quantum change" as utilt-
the law firm Bracewell & Giuliani, where he heads the environmental strategies group and consults with utility clients. Most of the states opting out of the EPA trading program for mercury don't have
Solutions from SK Custom Manufacturing Service
Increase your capacity by outsourcing organometallic compounds & reactions,
Continuous Production of pharmaceutical and fine chemical intermediates (From kg to 200MT) Continuous reaction capabilities include: * ^^Hydrogénation (300 atm)
â
Magnesium Bromide Etherate, MgB^EtzO
s
lilljpvy Temperature reactions
i l f l E a f a r f t u s Reactions (H2OJ
Scandium Triflate, Se(0Tf)3
„, i^^g^y -
u m
Distillation (up to 0.1 torr)
Sodium Cyclopentadienide, NaCp
ξχ BSC's custom-crafted reagents are backed by 35 years experience in the manufacture and use of air sensitive organometallics. Bulk, Kilo and R&D quantities available. Call today!
CD Ο
ir^ejÉflÇTSgri quality, reliable product supply... Phone: + 1 9 7 0 - 5 3 5 - 4 4 9 4 Fax: +1970-535-4584 Box 5 4 8 Mead, CO 8 0 5 4 2 www.bouldersci.com
^S^ \|3/ ΛΪΖ1
ο
I Call us for our Continuous reaction capabilities
Boulder Scientific7 Company
energy & c h e m i c a l , inc,
Innovative Specialty Chemical Solutions
22-TD Rpute 208 South, Fair Lawn, NJ, 07410, USA . Dr. JYYbon (201 ) 290^0370
[email protected] www.skcms.com
©-GRI6NARDS #-LIGANDS #-B0RATES #-METALLOCENES Specifications subject to change without notice. © 2006 Boulder Scientific Company. All rights reserved.
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
Ο Ζ
CA
APRIL 2, 2007
Ο
ranks fourth nationally in net electricity generation from coal, behind number one Texas, number two Ohio, and number three Indiana. Stadler of the NWF agrees that the states opting out of the trading program won't disable the national scheme. But Pennsylvania and another major coalproducing and -burning state, Illinois, are showing that cuts in mercury pollution are possible through state action without participation in the federal trading system, she says. Illinois ranks sixth in the nation in net generation of electricity from coal, ac cording to EIA. Holmstead says Pennsylvania's new requirement for an 80% cut in mercury by 2010 and 90% by 2015, as well as its choice not to be part of the federal trading system, will be costly to the commonwealth's elec tric utilities and their customers.
ties began ordering systems to comply with state laws or regulations that start taking effect in 2008 or 2009, he says. Moreover, the price of mercury con trol equipment has fallen dramatically from earlier estimates, he reports. Initial cost estimates were for $30,000 per lb of mercury captured, says McKinnies. The price today runs about $1,000 to $2,000 per lb for most types of coal burned to produce electricity, he says. Control costs for a few types of coal can run as high as $6,000 per lb of mercury captured, he notes, The cost of controlling mercury amounts to about 1% of the retail price of electricity, McKinnies adds.
significant coal-fired generating capacity, Holmstead tells C&EN. The exception is Pennsylvania, he says. According to the En ergy Information Administration's (EIA) preliminary figures for 2006, Pennsylvania
STADLER SAYS the actions that states are taking to reduce mercury won't affect a pending legal challenge to the Bush Admin istration's rule. Sixteen states and a coali tion of environmental groups are asking a
federal court to jettison the Bush Admin istration's mercury rule and force EPA to issue a tougher regulation in its place. They argue that EPA went afoul of the Glean Air Act in creating a cap-and-trade program for a pollutant that is neurotoxic. Instead, they claim, EPA should require coal-fired power plants to install mercury control technol ogy specified by the agency. Becker says EPA's mercury rule shows how important it is for states to have the ability to regulate air pollution more strin gently than does the federal government. He points out that some members of Con gress, as part of legislation to curb releases of greenhouse gases, want to curtail states' ability to impose limits on air emissions that are tougher than federal standards. Because of many states' actions to cut emissions of the metal faster and deeper, fewer people will be harmed by exposure to mercury than if all states merely adopted the weaker federal rule, Becker says. When EPA can't or won't make strong moves to protect the public from the risks of air pol lution, he says, states will "do what's right for public health and the environment." •
OPTIMA CHEMICAL GROUP LLC
2 -lutphth&lenAbocrosuc * c i d
Your Custom Manufacturing Partner
As a custom manufacturer and producer of over 150 substituted Boronic Acids, Optima Chemical is capable of supplying your requirements ranging from Grams, Kilograms or Tons. Our expertise and quality assurance will provide you the necessary consistency needed throughout your project life cycle.
20-diddCTcphetyIbOTanr «eu
Phenylboronic acid
3* F "\
s^.
y
\„
thioph ene-4-boronic acid
KEY AREAS OF EXPERTISE • Grignards [alkyl & aryl] • Organometallic [sodium, magnesium, potassium, lithium] • Low Temperature to-70°C • Βiomass Extraction
\: V
PRODUCTION CAPABILITIES • Kilo Lab; up to 22 liter • Pilot Plant; 50 gal. - 250 gal. • Main Plant; 1000 gal - 5000 gal [glass lined & stainless steel] • Dryers; Double Cone, Pan, Vacuum Tray, Solidaire® [glass lined & stainless steel] • Temperatures; -70°C to 300°C • Rosenmund Filters/Dryers 2 & 4 sq.m. and Centrifuges • Solvent Distillation/Recovery • cGMP
OPTIMA
Optima Chemical Group LLC 200 Willacoochee Highway / Douglas, GA 31535
912-384-5101 www.optimachem.com / email:
[email protected] WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
CC
APRIL 2, 2007
HEMICAL
