Chemical Education Today
Letters M&M Orange The article “A New Glow on the Chromatography of M&M Candies” (1) was of interest to us as we had run a similar experiment using Kool-Aid dyes for some time. Last year we included this experiment in our organic labs on chromatography with considerable success. But I was intrigued by the identity of the “unidentified orange” listed in the supplementary material as being found in orange and brown M&Ms. This summer I had a little time to devote to the problem. A considerable help was a copy of the Sigma–Aldrich Handbook of Stains, Dyes and Indicators (2) given to me by an associate. Looking through the UV–vis spectra in this work, I concluded that the unknown dye was an azo dye produced from an aniline and a 2-naphthol derivative. Our experience in lab making water-soluble azo dyes for dyeing multifiber cloth convinced me that the dye must have at least two sulfonic acid groups. NMR of the extract showed a lot of carbohydrate but no aromatic signals. Chromatography of the material separated the dye from the sugars, but did not yield enough material for a spectrum. TLC showed that the M&M dye was none of the following: Orange I, Orange B, Orange G, Crocein Orange G, Acid Orange 8, Orange GGW. At this point I decided to synthesize a number of orange dyes. Using ten substituted anilines and six 2-naphthols commonly used in making dyes, 60 orange dyes were produced. Of these nearly half were not water soluble enough for serious consideration. The rest were assayed by TLC leaving four contenders. Careful recording of the visible spectra showed that one was an exact fit. This was the dye formed
www.JCE.DivCHED.org
•
from sulfanilic acid and Schaeffer’s acid (6-hydroxy-2-naphthalene sulfonic acid). This was confirmed by running this dye and the M&M dye in about 10 different TLC systems. A trip back to the Color Index in the library brought a great surprise. The dye in question is C.I. 15985 (also known as sunset yellow or FD&C yellow 6), which is not included in the Sigma–Aldrich handbook. Literature Cited 1. Birdwhistell, K. R.; Spence, T. G, J. Chem. Educ. 2002, 79, 847. 2. Green, F. J. Sigma–Aldrich Handbook of Stains, Dyes and Indicators; Aldrich Chemical Company Library: Milwaukee, WI, 1990. John W. Elder Department of Chemistry Fairfield University Fairfield, CT 06824
[email protected] The authors reply: We cannot confirm or dispute Elder’s assignment of the identity of the dye. Without doing a few experiments we cannot comment further. Kurt R. Birdwhistell and Thomas G. Spence Department of Chemistry Loyola University New Orleans, LA 70118
[email protected] and
[email protected] Vol. 82 No. 2 February 2005
•
Journal of Chemical Education
209
