Phytovolatilization of Organic Contaminants - ACS Publications

Jun 1, 2016 - Missouri University of Science and Technology, Department of Civil, Architectural and Environmental Engineering, Rolla, Missouri ...... ...
0 downloads 14 Views 1MB Size
Subscriber access provided by BOSTON UNIV

Critical Review

Phytovolatilization of Organic Contaminants Matt Alan Limmer, and Joel Gerard Burken Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.5b04113 • Publication Date (Web): 01 Jun 2016 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on June 2, 2016

Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.

Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.

Page 1 of 40

1

Environmental Science & Technology

PHYTOVOLATILIZATION OF ORGANIC CONTAMINANTS

2 3

Matt Limmer1* & Joel Burken2

4

1

University of Delaware, Department of Plant & Soil Sciences, Newark, DE

5

2

Missouri University of Science and Technology, Department of Civil, Architectural and Environmental

6

Engineering, Rolla, MO

7 8

* Corresponding Author:

9

[email protected] 419.276.5358

10

152 Townsend Hall, Newark, DE 19716

11

1

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Environmental Science & Technology

12

ABSTRACT

13

Plants can interact with a variety of organic compounds, and thereby affect the fate and transport of

14

many environmental contaminants. Volatile organic compounds may be volatilized from stems or leaves

15

(direct phytovolatilization) or from soil because of plant root activities (indirect phytovolatilization).

16

Fluxes of contaminants volatilizing from plants are important across scales ranging from local

17

contaminant spills to global fluxes of methane emanating from ecosystems biochemically reducing

18

organic carbon. In this article past studies are reviewed to clearly differentiate between direct- and

19

indirect-phytovolatilization and discuss the plant physiology driving phytovolatilization in different

20

ecosystems. Current measurement techniques are also described, including common difficulties in

21

experimental design. We also discuss reports of phytovolatilization in the literature, finding that

22

compounds with low octanol-air partitioning coefficients are more likely to be phytovolatilized (log KOA
50 Pa) of subsurface tissues.32-35

132

These convective flows are thought to be driven by differences in humidity between the humid plant

133

interior and the relatively dry atmosphere. With flows exceeding 1 mL/min during these convective

134

events, advective flux of VOCs in these plants may significantly contribute to direct phytovolatilization

135

flux.

7

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Environmental Science & Technology

136

In herbaceous plants, during transport of VOCs to aboveground tissues these compounds can

137

escape from primary tissues such as stems and leaves. The plant epidermis is covered by a cuticle, which

138

consists of hydrophobic waxes and cutin to limit water loss. The cuticle is occasionally interrupted by

139

stomata, which open and close to regulate gas exchange. Thus, transport of VOCs through the epidermis

140

occurs through two parallel pathways: diffusion through open stomata and diffusion across the cuticle.

141

Permeability of the cuticle is enhanced for molecules that strongly partition into the cuticle and have

142

small molar volumes.36, 37 Permeability of the cuticle is also strongly plant and temperature

143

dependent,36, 37 and various regression models have been developed to predict permeability of plant

144

cuticles.37-39

145

In woody species, direct phytovolatilization from tree trunks and branches involves the diffusion

146

of VOCs through secondary xylem, secondary phloem and periderm, eventually reaching the

147

atmosphere where activity of the VOC is assumed lower than in the tree. The outermost layer of the

148

periderm, the phellem, consists of dead cells filled with suberin and waxes to regulate water loss from

149

the trunk. However, the phellem must allow some exchange of gasses to support the respiration of living

150

cells in the trunk. To allow gas exchange, the phellem is interrupted by lenticels, which are more

151

permeable to oxygen and water vapor than the surrounding tissue,40 although the permeance of

152

lenticels to H2O and O2 has been measured at ~1 order of magnitude lower than stomata.40 Interestingly,

153

lenticels appear to open and close seasonally, reducing the trunk’s permeability during the winter.41 A

154

study with evergreen species found no seasonal change in lenticel morphology, while deciduous species

155

exhibited seasonal changes in lenticel morphology.42 Further complicating gas transport in trees, some

156

trees growing in waterlogged conditions develop aerenchymatous phellem (secondary aerenchyma) to

157

aid in oxygen transport to the roots.43-45 The prevalence of aerenchymatous phellem and its effect on

158

VOC transport in wood remains uncertain; however, increasing the transport of O2 will certainly increase 8

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 8 of 40

Page 9 of 40

Environmental Science & Technology

159

transport of other volatile molecules. Plants growing in flooded conditions can also develop

160

hypertrophied lenticels,46 which are enlarged lenticels that form on flooded roots up to immediately

161

above the water table. These inflated lenticels aid in gas exchange and desiccate after flooding ceases.

162

Collectively, the transport of VOCs in wood is not well quantified due to uncertainty in the phellem

163

physiology. In studies involving CO2, the phellem’s resistance to diffusion, and therefore the flux, is

164

variable, even for clones.47, 48

165

MEASURING PHYTOVOLATILIZATION

166

Direct phytovolatilization has been measured both in laboratory and field studies. In laboratory

167

studies, plants are often dosed with contaminants, generally radiolabeled, in soil mesocosms or grown

168

hydroponically. After a prescribed amount of time, plant parts are typically analyzed to perform a mass

169

balance on the contaminant. The amount phytovolatilized may be directly measured by analysis of air

170

passed through a sorbent trap in a closed system (preferable) or calculated from the amount of

171

contaminant mass that remains unaccounted for in an open system. Note that the latter may be an

172

overestimate due to incorporation of other loss mechanisms, such as phytodegradation. Additionally, if

173

contaminant mass is captured on a sorbent trap, the phytovolatilization rate can be compared to

174

elapsed time or to transpiration rate.

175

At field sites, measurement of direct phytovolatilization from entire trees and other large plants

176

is technically challenging and costly, so typically only individual leaves49 or, more commonly, branches

177

are assessed. The leaves/branches are usually enclosed in a plastic bag, such as polyethylene,50 Tedlar51

178

or Teflon-lined plastic52, or in a sealed solid plastic53 or glass chamber.54 The enclosure must not be

179

permeable to the analyte of interest. To reduce humidity and to prevent the enclosed tissue from

180

overheating, clean air is generally passed through the bag or chamber. The exiting gas is passed through 9

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Environmental Science & Technology

181

a sorbent tube to capture the volatile analytes. Alternatively, a static system can be used that employs a

182

cold trap or condenser to reduce humidity and can be sampled using a Summa canister.51 To measure

183

the flux of VOCs emanating from tree trunks, a flux chamber is often used.55, 56 These chambers are

184

sealed to the tree trunk and operate similarly to the bags that capture VOCs from leaves and branches.

185

Clean air is passed into the chamber and contaminants are captured from the exit stream via a sorbent

186

tube. An alternative technology for monitoring direct phytovolatilization is open path Fourier transform

187

infrared spectroscopy (op-FTIR), a method that can detect VOCs in the air adjacent to the tree canopy.

188

While FTIR has been attempted to monitor TCE volatilizing from a phytoremediation plot, the method

189

was not sensitive enough to detect any TCE phytovolatilizing,49 although the method has been

190

successfully used in laboratory experiments.57

191

Phytovolatilization experiments with organic contaminants are not trivial to perform due to the

192

volatility of the analytes of interest. Numerous problems with experimental setups have been

193

encountered and discussed in the literature, both in laboratory and field setups.58, 59 See refs 35 and 60 for

194

a discussion of challenges in monitoring biogenic VOC phytovolatilization. Perhaps most problematic is

195

the need to seal the plant in a chamber while ensuring the plant undergoes natural photosynthesis and

196

respiration. Artificial and natural light will heat the enclosed space while transpired water vapor will

197

increase the humidity surrounding the leaves. The former can damage the leaf tissues while the latter

198

can slow transpiration. To offset these effects, clean air is usually passed through the chamber at high

199

flow rates to ensure humidity and temperature remain at acceptable levels. All the gas exiting the

200

chamber must pass through a sorbent to collect volatile compounds. The sorbent must have high affinity

201

for the targeted VOCs and low affinity for water. For many VOCs, Tenax meets these requirements. If

202

VOCs are allowed to accumulate to high concentrations in the chamber, the concentration gradient

203

across the plant boundary will lessen, likely resulting in lower diffusive fluxes and an underestimation of 10

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 10 of 40

Page 11 of 40

Environmental Science & Technology

204

phytovolatilization. Additional difficulties often arise in sealing the experimental setup to prevent

205

unmonitored release of VOCs. A particularly difficult region to seal is around the plant tissue. Stems are

206

often sealed using closed cell foam, acrylic caulk or paraffin wax. In laboratory experiments, the

207

tightness of system should be checked using wooden dowel rod or dead stem controls. However, a well-

208

sealed experimental setup can also limit supply of necessary gases, such as oxygen to the roots, which

209

may result in stress and increased root permeability. Care should be taken in plant selection, particularly

210

when small tissue volumes are sampled. Stress or damage can cause stomatal closure and potentially

211

affect both evapotranspiration and volatilization rates. Additionally, the dermal tissue of first-year wood

212

(whips or branches) will not have the secondary dermal features present in older wood. Extrapolation of

213

phytovolatilization rates from young woody plants to older woody plants is not recommended.

214

Regardless of the system chosen, a suitable experimental setup must control temperature,

215

relative humidity, and VOC concentrations inside the chamber, ensuring these values remain near

216

ambient. If these values are not well controlled, substantial measurement error is likely. The specific

217

flows of gases and other system parameters will depend on the plant, contaminant, and experimental

218

system under study, so caution must be exercised when adapting systems from literature.

219

REPORTS OF PHYTOVOLATILIZATION

220

Laboratory Experiments

221

Research regarding direct phytovolatilization has largely focused on the common groundwater

222

contaminants, trichloroethylene (TCE) and tetrachloroethylene (PCE), using traditional

223

phytoremediation plants such as willow (Salix sp.) and hybrid poplar (Populus sp. x P. sp.). These volatile

224

contaminants are frequently reported to undergo phytovolatilization, although the degree of

225

phytovolatilization varies substantially. In a closed system with hybrid poplars, Gordon et al.61 detected 11

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Environmental Science & Technology

226

14

227

up by the plant was 70-90%. However, when a controlled field study was conducted, a minimal amount

228

of TCE was phytovolatilized, as much of the TCE was dechlorinated in the subsurface. In another closed

229

system experiment with poplar and willow cuttings dosed with 14C-PCE or 14C-TCE, 75% of the

230

contaminant mass taken up by the plant was phytovolatilized (range: 27-96%, n=6), although

231

experimental details are scarce.62 In flow-through reactors designed to provide a constant supply of

232

contaminants, nutrients and oxygen, 90% removal of

340

chloroform, although only ~1.5% of the removal resulted from phytovolatilization. The authors

341

suspected much of the chloroform was degraded prior to phytovolatilization, but fate was not

342

conclusively determined. Reid and Jaffé77 explored direct phytovolatilization of sulfur hexafluoride (SF6)

343

in Typha latifolia and Scirpus acutus, finding daily fluctuations in the phytovolatilization rate. These

344

fluctuations were correlated to temperature, photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) and vapor

345

pressure deficit (VPD), which affected air-water partitioning, diffusivity and transpiration of this volatile

346

compound. The correlation between VPD and phytovolatilization rate in Typha was thought to result

347

from pressurized internal gas flows.32 Similar findings have been reported for methane direct

348

phytovolatilization from Phragmites australis and Scirpus lacustris in constructed wetlands.78 Phragmites

349

exhibited diel fluctuations in direct phytovolatilization, characterized by advective transpirative

350

transport during the day and diffusive transport at night. Diel fluctuations in Scirpus were much less,

351

implicating diffusive transport dominated, while transpiration-based fluxes were minimal. Direct

352

phytovolatilization of methane from herbaceous plants in wetlands is relatively well studied (see

353

reviews79, 80), as methane phytovolatilization can exceed methane volatilization from unplanted

354

wetlands by an order of magnitude.79

355

Direct phytovolatilization of methane from tree trunks has been measured less frequently than

356

from herbaceous plants. Gauci et al.81 report methane fluxes of 6.1±1.2 µmol/m2/d in May, 97±88

357

µmol/m2/d in June and 151±33 µmol/m2/d in October from wetland alder (Alnus glutinosa) trees (tree

358

diameter 0.18-0.3 m; values are average ± standard deviation, n=3). The large fluxes of methane in May

359

and June coincide with the tree in full leaf. Conversely, Terazawa et al.82 report relatively constant

360

methane fluxes from Fraxinus mandshurica over five sampling events. Fluxes were measured at 263 17

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Environmental Science & Technology

361

µmol/m2/d at 15 cm above ground surface, decreasing to 145 µmol/m2/d at 70 cm above ground

362

surface, although this difference was not statistically significant (p=0.071). Pangala et al.83 measured

363

methane fluxes of 25 – 277 µmol/m2/d in 7 of 8 tropical trees species. A multiple regression model could

364

explain methane fluxes using stem diameter, wood specific density and porewater methane

365

concentrations (R2 = 0.808, p