Subscriber access provided by - Access paid by the | UCSB Libraries
Characterization of Natural and Affected Environments
Recoupling industrial dairy feedlots and industrial farmlands mitigates the environmental impacts of milk production in China Xing Fan, Jie Chang, Yuan Ren, Xu Wu, Yuanyuan Du, Ronghua Xu, Dong Liu, Scott X Chang, Laura A. Meyerson, Changhui Peng, and Ying Ge Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.7b04829 • Publication Date (Web): 08 Mar 2018 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on March 12, 2018
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Recoupling industrial dairy feedlots and industrial farmlands mitigates the
2
environmental impacts of milk production in China
3 4
Xing Fan,† Jie Chang,† Yuan Ren,† Xu Wu,‡ Yuanyuan Du,† Ronghua Xu,† Dong Liu,§ Scott
5
X Chang,|| Laura A. Meyerson,┴ Changhui Peng,# Ying Ge†,*
6 7
†
College of Life Sciences, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, China
8
‡
Zhejiang Provincial Economic Information Center (Zhejiang Center for Climate Change
9
and Low-carbon Development Cooperation), Hangzhou, 310006, China
10
§
11
Nanjing 210042, PR China
12
||
13
Canada
14
Nanjing Institute of Environmental Sciences, Ministry of Environmental Protection,
Department of Renewable Resource, University of Alberta, Edmonton T6G 2E3, Alberta,
┴
Department of Natural Resources Science, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI
15
02881, USA
16
#
17
Quebec at Montreal, Montreal, QC H3C 3P8, Canada
Department of Biological Sciences, Institute of Environment Sciences, University of
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
18
ABSTRACT
19
Dairy production is becoming more industrialized globally, especially in developing
20
countries. The large amount of animal wastes from industrial feedlots cannot be fully used
21
on nearby farmlands, leading to severe environmental problems. Using China as a case
22
study, we found that most dairy feedlots employ a semi-coupled mode that only recycles
23
solid manure to farmlands, and only a few dairy feedlots employ a fully-coupled mode that
24
recycles both solid and liquid animal manure. To produce one ton of milk, the fully-coupled
25
mode could reduce greenhouse gas (including carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous oxide
26
in this paper) emissions by 24%, ammonia emissions by 14%, and N discharge into water
27
by 29%, compared with the semi-coupled systems. Coupling feedlots with constructed
28
wetlands can further result in greater mitigation of N leaching into groundwater. However,
29
the fully-coupled system has not been widely used due to the low benefit to farmers and the
30
institutional barrier that the feedlot owners have no right to use adjacent farmlands. Since a
31
fully-coupled system improves net ecosystem services that favor the public, a policy that
32
supports removing the economic and institutional barriers is necessary. Our approach
33
provides a template for mitigating environmental impacts from livestock production
34
without sacrificing milk production.
35
2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 36
Page 3 of 36
36
Environmental Science & Technology
INTRODUCTION
37
Global dairy production has doubled over the past five decades, and it will continue to
38
grow by approximately 50% from 2011 to 2050.1,2 The growth of global dairy production
39
will mainly occur in emerging economies,2,3 where dairy production is transitioning from
40
extensive to industrial systems.4,5 The industrialization of dairy production improves
41
production efficiency but also results in many environmental problems due to the
42
difficulties in handling and disposing of excessive animal waste, especially liquid waste.6,7
43
Manure management for industrial livestock production results in a substantial contribution
44
to climate change8 and plays an important role in eutrophication, groundwater
45
contamination,9 and outdoor particulate matter pollution.10,11 How to achieve sustainable
46
industrialization that produces more dairy products with less environmental and human
47
health impacts is a challenge.
48
In an industrial production system, the decoupling between animal and land
49
exacerbates environmental degradation.9 Decoupling hinders the recycling of manure to
50
farmlands, and as a result, both inadequately treated waste, especially liquid waste, from
51
specialized feedlots and excessive mineral fertilizer application on farmlands are severe
52
threats to the environment.9,12 Recoupling of crop and livestock production is proposed to
53
mitigate environmental pollution.9,13,14 Recoupling through reusing animal manure on
54
farmlands can reduce N pollution from industrial feedlots and croplands15,16 and improve
55
resource use efficiency in the crop-livestock system, turning the linear nutrient flow
56
(plant-animal) to a plant-animal-plant cycle.13,15 Recoupling through introducing grasslands
3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
57
or forage within arable cropping systems can also improve the environmental performance
58
of intensive farmlands, such as by increasing the soil organic matter level, reducing
59
agrochemical usage, and reducing soil erosion and N leaching.17-20 Nevertheless, specific
60
measures of recoupling affect the realization of these benefits. Even in developed countries,
61
there are still improper practices in recycling manure that cause substantial pollution, such
62
as long-term outdoor exposure before manure spreading, which releases terrible smells and
63
maximizes ammonia (NH3) emissions.21,22 Moreover, many industrial livestock feedlots in
64
developing countries only use solid animal manure in farmlands and discharge liquid waste
65
into the environment.5,23 Designing modern recoupled systems with improved technologies
66
is crucial to minimizing pollution while meeting the growing demand for animal products.14
67
For better implementation of recoupling, there is an urgent need to conduct
68
comprehensive assessments of the environmental performance of recoupling and relevant
69
socio-economic factors that constraint its promotion.24 Some efforts have been carried out
70
to assess recoupling that occurred on the same lands or between spatially separated
71
cropping and livestock systems.13,25 For large confined livestock operations, recoupling
72
between spatially separated systems is the more common form, but there is a lack of
73
evaluations of the environmental impacts on a regional scale.18,23,26 In addition, current
74
studies on recoupling pay little attention to the details of manure management, while
75
studies on manure management technology only focus on the stages after animal excretion.
76
For example, as an engineered ecosystem with the main purpose of wastewater
77
treatment,27,28 constructed wetlands (CWs) have been proven effective at treating liquid
4
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 36
Page 5 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
78
animal manure through mechanisms such as plant absorption (Table S1),29,30 but
79
assessments on the recoupled system of livestock feedlots and CWs are lacking. Moreover,
80
only a few environmental parameters are considered in previous assessments, which limit
81
the comprehensive understanding and spread of recoupling.
82
In this study, we conducted a life cycle assessment of the entire milk production chain
83
that includes four stages: feed crop production, feed processing, dairy cow rearing, and
84
milk processing (Figure S2). We used China as a case study because it has rapidly grown
85
into a new global player in milk production (the third largest in the world).1 We compared
86
the environmental performances of the semi-coupled (only solid dairy manure is recycled)
87
and the fully-coupled (both solid and liquid dairy manure are recycled) systems. Total
88
nitrogen (N) loss and the environmental impacts including nitrous oxide (N2O), methane
89
(CH4), carbon dioxide (CO2) and NH3 emissions and N discharge into water were included
90
in the comprehensive assessment. We then analyzed the costs and benefits of these coupling
91
modes and the land requirement, which is a significant factor to be considered in
92
developing countries with substantial land pressure. As an additive measure for ecological
93
and economic performances, ecosystem services under different coupling modes are
94
assessed and compared. Furthermore, we estimate the mitigation potential of implementing
95
fully-coupled systems for the whole dairy sector in China by 2020.
96 97 98
MATERIALS AND METHODS Data sources. There are three main data sources in this study: our field survey,
5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
99
Chinese official statistics, and the synthesis of literature. We investigated 122 dairy feedlots
100
in 24 provinces across China through interviews and web searches from 2014 to 2016
101
(Figure S1) to acquire information about the land area, herd structure and milk yield of
102
dairy cows, feedstuffs, manure management (collection, storage, treatment), and manure
103
recycling practices (Table S2, S3). The basic information related to China’s dairy sector,
104
such as milk production and number of dairy cows in each dairy system, fertilizer
105
application rates and yield of feed crops, and energy consumption in dairy feedlots, was
106
taken from Chinese statistical records (e.g., Figures S15a, S16a, and Table S6); coefficients
107
for calculating the N fluxes and the environmental impacts, such as N deposition rates, gas
108
emission factors, and farmland leaching/runoff rates, were obtained from the synthesis of
109
literature (e.g., Tables S5, S9, and S10). Details are described in Supplementary
110
Information (SI).
111
Industrial dairy production systems. Two coupling degrees are distinguished
112
according to manure management (Table S4): semi-coupled and fully-coupled. In a
113
semi-coupled system, only solid dairy manure was used on farmlands while the liquid
114
manure is discharged into water or dried in situ. In a fully-coupled system, both solid and
115
liquid dairy manure is treated and recycled to farmlands. In our survey, the complete
116
decoupled system, in which neither of the solid nor liquid dairy manure is used on
117
farmlands, does not exist in China; fully-coupled systems only account for 5% of the
118
industrial dairy feedlots; most of the industrial dairy feedlots employ the semi-coupled
119
mode. In a semi-coupled system, solid manure is composted for at least one month before it
6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 36
Page 7 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
120
is applied to land. In a fully-coupled system, popular practices include biogas digestion for
121
slurry, composting solid manure, and storage of liquid manure before application (Table
122
S2).
123
Based on the results of our field survey, we calculated the two modeled fully-coupled
124
systems: fully-coupled between industrial feedlots and industrial farmlands (FCIIC) and
125
fully-coupled between industrial feedlots and constructed wetlands (FCICW). In the FCIIC,
126
besides the abovementioned popular practices, a storage covering measure is also adopted
127
as it has been proved effective at reducing NH3 volatilization.31 In the FCIIC, after
128
anaerobic fermentation, the separated solid fraction is composted for an average period of
129
one week, and the separated liquids are stored in a covered tank for three weeks before
130
application (see SI for details). The application of solid manure is the same as that in a
131
semi-coupled system. The liquid manure is applied to industrial farmlands, which are
132
intensive farmlands with high levels of inputs and outputs per unit of land area and
133
mechanized equipment. The basic requirement of industrial farmlands is to be equipped
134
with a fertigation pipeline system through which the liquid manure is pumped out from the
135
storage tank and distributed to land. In fact, CWs can also be regarded as industrial
136
farmlands for feed planting as well as wastewater treatment (see SI for details, Table S1). In
137
addition to pipeline systems and valves to control the influent and effluent, CWs usually
138
have artificial structures with an impermeable bottom that can prevent nitrogen leaching
139
into groundwater. Thus, we proposed and assessed the FCICW based on a previous study of
140
our research group,28 even though we did not find the same case in our survey as the
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
141
FCICW proposed. In the FCICW, manure management is the same as that in the FCIIC,
142
and CWs replace farmlands as the liquid manure receiver. The land application methods in
143
this study are surface spreading for chemical fertilizers, incorporation for solid manure, and
144
band spreading for liquid manure.32
145
Calculation of nitrogen flux and environmental impacts. We calculated the
146
parameters using the STELLA graphic programming system (High Performance System
147
Inc., Version 9.1.2). For each coupling mode, the calculator includes four parts: Part 1 is
148
used to simulate N fluxes for the entire milk production chain, part 2 is used to calculate
149
NH3 emissions, part 3 is used to calculate GHGs emissions, and part 4 is used to calculate
150
N discharge into water (Figures S3-S6). The sources of GHGs (N2O, CH4, and CO2)
151
include the production of chemical fertilizers, the application of chemical fertilizers and
152
manure, enteric fermentation, manure management, energy use, and transportation. The
153
sources of NH3 considered include the following: fertilizer production, fertilizer application,
154
N fixation, animal manure management, and transportation. The effects of different manure
155
management practices on GHGs and NH3 emissions were considered in our calculations
156
(see SI for details). N discharge into water occurred mainly through leaching and runoff
157
from farmlands, processing losses from feed crop processing plants and milk processing
158
plants, and manure management (see the SI for details).
159
Calculation of ecosystem services. Based on the framework of the Millennium
160
Ecosystem Assessment33 and other studies,28,34 we evaluated ecosystem services (including
161
provisioning, regulating, and cultural services) and dis-services (Figure S7) associated with
8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 36
Page 9 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
162
milk production. The ecosystem services and dis-services of dairy feedlots and the entire
163
milk production system where nutrient recycling occurred were calculated. Specifically, we
164
quantified and monetized milk provision, water saving, water regulation, and four
165
regulating dis-services (GHG emissions, NH3 emissions, and surface water and
166
groundwater N pollution); cultural services such as education could not be monetized (see
167
the SI for details of calculation). Among the total 122 dairy feedlots in our investigation,
168
108 dairy feedlots across 24 provinces in China (Table S3) were used to calculate
169
ecosystem services and dis-services, due to data availability. We investigated the net
170
ecosystem services of each dairy feedlot as it transforms between different coupling modes,
171
regardless of its original coupling mode, to avoid the dairy feedlot (such as breeding
172
density and specific climatic conditions) having a greater influence on net ecosystem
173
services than the coupling mode.
174
Cost-benefit analysis. The private costs and benefits of dairy feedlot owners and feed
175
crop farmers were analyzed. The costs include material and service costs (such as feed, fuel,
176
depreciation of fixed assets, disease prevention, repair and maintenance, etc.), labor costs,
177
and land rent. The benefits include products and subsidies. The specific items related to the
178
costs and benefits are shown in Tables S16 and S17. We highlighted the changes in costs
179
and benefits transitioning between coupling modes, and the other unchanged items are
180
summed as “other” in Tables S16 and S17.
181
Projection of the environmental impacts of China’s milk production in 2020. We
182
used 2011 as the reference year because of data availability, and 2020 as the target year
9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
183
because of the ‘13th Five-Year Planning’ for China’s dairy and the target of zero fertilizer
184
growth by the end of 2020.35,36 To quantify the effects of the technical transformation of
185
manure management, three scenarios were analyzed: Scenario 1: business-as-usual (BAU),
186
in which the percentages of semi-coupled and fully-coupled systems across national
187
industrial dairy production systems are kept at the 2011 level; Scenario 2: all industrial
188
dairy feedlots are fully-coupled with industrial farmlands; and Scenario 3: all industrial
189
dairy feedlots are fully-coupled with CWs.
190
To calculate the environmental impact of national dairy production and the reduction
191
potential of technological improvements, we also account for non-industrial dairy
192
production systems: grassland-based systems, traditional systems, and collective systems
193
(see SI for details).
194 195
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
196
Nitrogen loss. The total N loss when producing one ton of milk in a semi-coupled
197
system in China was 36.3 kg N (Figure 1, Figure S8). The total N loss in the FCIIC (30.3
198
kg N) and FCICW (23.6 kg N) was 17% and 35% lower than a semi-coupled system,
199
respectively. Our results on the status quo systems in China (mainly semi-coupling) are
200
lower than that of a previous study (54.5 kg N loss when producing one ton of milk) in
201
which the dairy feedlots employed the decoupling mode.5 To produce equal amounts of
202
milk products, recoupling reduces the external N input to the system through manure
203
recycling, thus reducing N loss and increasing N use efficiency of the whole system. In a
10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 10 of 36
Page 11 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
204
semi-coupled system, 20% of the N from chemical fertilizers is replaced by manure. In
205
fully-coupled systems (FCIIC and FCICW), the managed manure from the dairy feedlots
206
can replace 44% of the chemical fertilizer N required by feed crop production. In addition,
207
in the FCICW, effluent from the CWs is controllable, and effluent N can be refed into the
208
CWs for plant growth, further reducing N loss.
209
Greenhouse gas emissions. The total N2O emissions from a semi-coupled system are
210
304.2 kg CO2e per ton of milk (Figure 2a). Shortening the exposure time of manure to the
211
air can reduce N2O emissions; for example, by shortening the composting period from three
212
to one month, approximately 60% of N2O from solid manure can be avoided (Figure 3a,
213
3d). However, the current composting period often lasts for several months or even half a
214
year. N2O emissions in the FCIIC are 33% lower than those in the semi-coupled system
215
(Figure 2a) owing to the shorter exposure time of both solid and liquid manure. Recoupling
216
with CWs can further reduce N2O emissions from feed crop production by optimizing the
217
hydraulic pattern or28 adding carbon or plant assemblages.37
218
The total CH4 emissions from a semi-coupled system are 408.6 kg CO2e per ton of
219
milk. The CH4 emissions in the FCIIC and FCICW are reduced by 10% and 12%,
220
respectively, compared with a semi-coupled system (Figure 2b). Shortening the exposure
221
time of manure reduces CH4 release (Figure 3b, 3e), but practices such as covering and
222
biogas fermentation leading to anaerobic conditions are conducive to CH4 production.38
223
Retaining the CH4 produced is not beneficial as it can escape at a later stage; therefore,
224
burning or combusting the collected CH4 for electricity or heat production is the most
11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
225 226
desirable option.38 The total CO2 emissions from a semi-coupled system are 481.9 kg CO2 per ton of milk.
227
The CO2 emissions from the FCIIC and FCICW are reduced by 31% and 42%, respectively,
228
compared with a semi-coupled system (Figure 2c). Using solid manure N reduces the CO2
229
emissions from chemical fertilizer production by 20%, and using liquid manure N reduces
230
CO2 emissions from chemical fertilizer production by another 24%. Substituting biogas for
231
fossil fuels to produce electricity or heat avoids another 90.7 kg of CO2 emissions per ton
232
of milk.
233
The total GHG emissions in a semi-coupled system are 1197.4 kg CO2e per ton of
234
milk. The total GHG emissions in the FCIIC and FCICW are 24% and 36% lower,
235
respectively, than a semi-coupled system (Figure 2d, Figure S9). The GHG emissions from
236
manure management in fully-coupled systems in China are even lower than those in some
237
developed countries (Table S12, and S13). Although most of the developed countries have
238
recoupled crop and livestock production, there are still improper practices in manure
239
management that cause substantial pollution. Modern fully-coupled systems are also
240
needed for developed countries to further reduce gaseous pollutants.
241
Ammonia emissions. The NH3 emissions from a semi-coupled system are 10.7 kg
242
NH3 per ton of milk. The NH3 emissions from the FCIIC and FCICW are 14% and 33%
243
lower, respectively, than a semi-coupled system (Figure 2e, Figure S10). Ammonia is
244
rapidly lost from manure and the emissions rate declines exponentially with exposure time
245
(Figure 3c, 3f). According to the cumulative emissions – exposure time curve we
12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 36
Page 13 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
246
established through the literature review (Figure 3f), the mitigation effectiveness of
247
shortening the exposure time from several months to one month during composting is
248
approximately 14%. In fully-coupled systems, storage coverings and anaerobic digestion
249
that can shorten the subsequent compost period to 3~7 days39 further mitigate NH3 release.
250
Additionally, CWs can lower their NH3 emissions during plant growth through strong
251
artificial management, appropriate structures, and physicochemical environment regulation.
252
For example, subsurface flow CWs often have lower ammonia volatilization than surface
253
CWs: 0.2%−0.9% of the N loading is lost by NH3 volatilization in subsurface flow CWs,
254
while an average of 0.3%−36% (with an average of 15.6%) is lost by NH3 volatilization in
255
surface flow (Table S14). However, FCICW has higher NH3 emissions (7.2 kg per ton of
256
milk) than low-emission countries (3.3−5.0 kg per ton of milk) in Europe (Table S12),
257
which has rigid regulations on NH3 emissions.7 Fully-coupled systems need to combine
258
other mitigation techniques such as emissions-free housing systems, application of lignite,
259
and precision fertilization to further reduce NH3 emissions in China, but the safety,
260
economic feasibility, and willingness of feedlot and farm owners to apply them in an
261
accurate and timely fashion are priorities.31,40,41
262
Nitrogen discharge into water. The N discharge into water from a semi-coupled
263
system is 14.1 kg N per ton of milk and that from FCIIC and FCICW are 29% and
264
50%lower, respectively, than a semi-coupled system (Figure 2f, Figure S11). In a
265
semi-coupled system, 34.6% of excreta N is recycled to feed crop lands, and in a
266
fully-coupled system, 76.4% of excreta N is recycled. However, if not managed well,
13
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
267
applying liquid manure that can more easily penetrate the soil can increase the risk of N
268
leaching. CWs lined with a waterproof membrane are practical alternatives in areas
269
suffering severe groundwater pollution.27,28 In the FCICW, the N leaching from liquid
270
manure applications would approach zero (Table S15). Furthermore, treated water from
271
CWs can be reused to clean animal houses thereby reducing the use of clean water and
272
ensuring that there is no N runoff to the surface water. Some European countries also
273
discharge large amounts of N into water from milk production (Table S12). In addition,
274
phosphate pollution of groundwater caused by manure recycling to the soil has even forced
275
the Netherlands to substantially reduce its number of dairy cows in 2017.42 With a
276
waterproof membrane at the bottom, CWs should be an effective way to mitigate
277
groundwater pollution caused by phosphate as well as nitrate leaching.
278
Ecosystem services. Synthesizing environmental performance (regulating services
279
and dis-services) and milk production (provisioning services), we quantified the net
280
ecosystem services (Figure S7) of dairy feedlots (Table S16) and the entire milk production
281
systems (Table 1). The net services of surveyed dairy feedlots that employ semi-coupled
282
mode equal 1.5 thousand USD ha-1 on average (Table S16). The net services of dairy
283
feedlots employing fully-coupled mode equal 21.1 thousand USD ha-1 on average (Table
284
S16; Figure S12). Since the separate improvement of a single process may transfer the
285
environmental burden of that process to another process, we also calculated the net
286
ecosystem services at the milk production system level where nutrient recycling occurred.
287
All the surveyed semi-coupled systems provide negative net services, with an average of
14
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 36
Page 15 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
288
-663.3 USD ha-1 (Table 1). Transforming from semi-coupled to fully-coupled systems not
289
only reduces dis-services but also provides some other services. For example, fully-coupled
290
systems reuse liquid waste and thus save irrigation water for feed crops. Transforming to
291
the FCIIC, 9% of these systems would turn to provide positive net services, and
292
transforming to the FCICW, 66% of these systems would turn to provide positive net
293
services (Figure S12). The average net services of the FCIIC and FCICW are improved to
294
-289.7 and 28.6 USD ha-1, respectively (Table 1).
295
In addition to fully recycling animal manure, diversifying grain cropping systems with
296
grasslands and forage crops can further mitigate the negative environmental impacts of feed
297
crop production.18-20 Grass-crop rotation can reduce N leaching from subsequent intensive
298
cropping systems. A nine-year experiment on water nitrate levels in five cropping/grassland
299
systems demonstrated that the introduction of grasslands into arable crop rotation reduced
300
N leaching to groundwater by ~50%, and the longer the period that grasslands were within
301
the rotation the more the nitrate concentration was reduced.43 Legume-crop rotation, such
302
as the introduction of alfalfa into maize fields, can reduce mineral fertilizer inputs while
303
maintaining the available N for crops, thus mitigating the GHG and NH3 emissions caused
304
by industrial synthesis without a loss in feed crop yield.44,45 Combining the benefits from
305
fully recycling manure with these agronomic services provided by converting from
306
continuous monoculture to forage-crop rotation, the net ecosystem services of a more
307
integrated system are -145.1 USD ha-1, which is an intermediate value between the FCIIC
308
and FCICW (Table 1). Forage-crop rotation can also provide some other ecosystem services,
15
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
309
such as a reduction in soil loss, an increase in soil organic carbon levels, improved soil
310
fertility and biodiversity, and weed and pest population control.17,20
311
Recoupling has more benefits in specific locations, and different coupling modes can
312
be adopted according to local conditions. Recycling manure on higher value crops such as
313
fruits and greenhouse vegetables is more economical than recycling manure on forage
314
crops.23 According to our survey in Yangling, Shaanxi, receiving manure from a dairy
315
feedlot helps a kiwifruit orchard increase its yield and improve the taste of kiwifruit. In
316
another case study in Shaoxing, Zhejiang, located in the coastal area of eastern China,
317
applying liquid manure from a dairy feedlot nearby improves the buffering capacity of the
318
soil and reduces its alkalinity. In locations of low soil fertility, manure recycling and the
319
introduction of leguminous forage into grain crop systems are more valuable. Grass-based
320
rotation is also recommended to control soil erosion, especially on sloping land.20,46 Dairy
321
feedlots near water courses near major urban populations often cause water quality
322
deterioration and impacts to human health, especially on rainy days, and the FCICW is
323
suitable for these areas to reduce water pollution.
324
Economic feasibility. The cost-benefit analysis of dairy feedlots shows that
325
transforming from a semi- to fully-coupled system increased the cost of manure treatment
326
facilities and labor inputs for manure collection and storage, offsetting the benefits gained
327
by selling manure and saving energy (Table S17), thus reducing its economic attractiveness.
328
Although the decline in net profit is not substantial (a decrease of 2.4% from a semi- to
329
fully-coupled system), feedlot owners are reluctant to improve manure management, and
16
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 16 of 36
Page 17 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
330
they illegally discharge wastes. As feed costs account for ~70% of the total cost of a dairy
331
feedlot (Table S17), feedlot owners are more willing to invest in feed management, which
332
directly links to milk yield and net profit. For feed crop farmers, reusing manure reduces
333
the cost of chemical fertilizers: 20% of chemical fertilizer N is replaced by manure in a
334
semi-coupled system, and 44% is replaced in a fully-coupled system (Table S18). However,
335
the application of manure requires more labor than chemical fertilizer.13,23 The increased
336
costs for manure transport and application are higher than chemical fertilizer savings in
337
fully-coupled systems (Table S18) and thus constrain the recycling of manure, especially
338
large volumes of liquid manure.
339
Fortunately, with lower environmental externalities, fully-coupled systems justify the
340
provision of greater financial incentives to encourage expansion (Figure S13). In fact, for
341
the construction of biogas digesters on some dairy feedlots, owners can receive subsidies
342
from central and local governments, equivalent to 40-60% of the total construction costs.47
343
For CWs, although the construction and maintenance costs are high, most of the costs
344
should come from government subsidies considering the role of CWs in reducing regional
345
environmental pollution.48 To accelerate the reuse of animal waste, the Chinese government
346
has set a target that more than 95% of industrial feedlots will be equipped with waste
347
treatment facilities by 2020, and China issued the first guidance document on animal waste
348
treatment and utilization in June 2017.49 This document enhances the financial support for
349
feedlots with improved manure treatment facilities and for the organization of social
350
services to provide technical guidance and assistance. In addition, the Chinese government
17
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
351
is strengthening environmental regulations for the livestock sector.36,49 For crop growers,
352
forage-crop rotation is promoted by China’s “grain for forage” policy,50 which includes a
353
new information on the structure adjustment of China’s agriculture. Grass-crop or
354
forage-grain rotations not only contribute to the self-sufficiency of feed for ruminant
355
production but also improve the quality of the soil. In addition, redirecting the current
356
subsidies for the fertilizer industry towards manure application would promote manure
357
recycling and stabilize the use of mineral fertilizer to achieve the “Zero Fertilizer Growth
358
by 2020” goal.35 Under the support from a variety of policies, it is expected that the
359
fully-coupled systems will expand quickly in the near future.
360
Land requirement. The institutional policy whereby feedlot owners have right to use
361
neighboring farmlands is another major prerequisite. Our field survey showed that many
362
industrial dairy feedlots in China are in regions with enough farmlands for recycling animal
363
manure (see SI for details, Figure S14). However, most of these lands cannot be used for
364
recoupling due to the limitation of land-use rights for feedlot owners. This is different to
365
dairy farms in developed countries where vast areas of farmlands can be owned by a single
366
individual.13,51 China's land ownership dictates that Chinese farmers can only have land-use
367
rights but not the land ownership. The lands around the feedlots are usually dispersed to
368
many farmers, leading to low levels of per capita land availability. Fortunately, the Chinese
369
government has begun to address these land issues by improving land-use policies. Farmers
370
can rent or contract with other people through land transfer for land management. The
371
guidance document on animal waste treatment and utilization issued in June 2017 suggests
18
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 18 of 36
Page 19 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
372
improving land-use policies for industrial feedlots, taking into account the land requirement
373
for manure management in overall land-use planning, and constructing new industrial
374
feedlots according to the supporting land area.49 These policies will contribute to the
375
recycling of animal manure. The alternative solution of not reducing the feedlot size is
376
meant to introduce land-saving technologies. For example, according to our calculations, a
377
dairy feedlot needs 0.14 ha of farmlands (or CWs) to support one head of dairy cow. If
378
recoupled with greenhouses (industrial farmlands equipped with plastic or glass cover) for
379
vegetable cultivation, which requires more fertilizer input per unit area due to the extended
380
cultivation season,34 the amount of land required would be only 0.02 ha per cow. In
381
addition, recoupling dairy feedlots with greenhouses is a solution to recycling animal
382
manure in cold regions and cold seasons.
383
Improvement potential of fully-coupled systems. Industrial dairy feedlots in China
384
contributed approximately 46% to the domestic milk production in 2011, and the
385
percentage is predicted to reach 85% by 2020 (Figure S15, S16). Total milk production will
386
increase by 12% from 2011 to 2020, while the total NH3 emissions and N discharge into
387
water show a slight decreasing trend due to a higher degree of industrialization assumed in
388
the BAU scenario. To produce one ton of milk, the industrial system with improved
389
production efficiency generates less environmental impacts than the non-industrial systems
390
(Figure S17). However, GHG emissions continue to increase from 2011 to 2020 in the
391
BAU scenario. If all Chinese industrial dairy feedlots were fully-coupled with industrial
392
farmlands by 2020 (Scenario 2), GHG and NH3 emissions and N discharge into water from
19
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
393
the entire milk production chain would decrease by 22%, 10%, and 28%, respectively,
394
compared with the BAU scenario (Figure 4). A fully-coupled system with CWs (Scenario 3)
395
would reduce GHG and NH3 emissions and N discharge into water by 30%, 25.7%, and
396
42%, respectively.
397
As all industrial feedlots face similar challenges in terms of handling excess liquid
398
waste, fully-coupling industrial feedlots with industrial farmlands is a viable solution to
399
reduce the environmental impacts of global milk production. Advanced technology
400
deployment and appropriate policy instruments will facilitate opportunities for sustainable
401
livestock production. We believe that the fully-coupled paradigms are not only applicable in
402
China but also can provide a model for other nations facing environmental pressures caused
403
by livestock industrialization.
404 405
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
406
Supplementary Information
407
The Supporting Information is available free of charge on the ACS Publications website.
408
Details on the data, methods, and model used for calculating the environmental impacts,
409
ecosystem services, and land use and supporting figures and tables as mentioned in the
410
text (PDF) are in the Supporting Information.
411 412
AUTHOR INFORMATION
413
Corresponding Author
20
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 20 of 36
Page 21 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
414
* College of Life Sciences, Zhejiang University, 866 Yuhangtang Road, Hangzhou 310058,
415
PR China.
416
Tel & Fax: +86 571 8820 6466. E-mail:
[email protected] 417
Notes
418
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
419 420
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
421
We thank Y. Min, F. Mao, W. Yang and M. Mikkilä for their comments on an earlier version
422
of the manuscript or assistance during manuscript preparation, and C.C. Huang, C.B. Zhang,
423
S.Y. Li, Ri-e Bu, X.P. Ge, M. Chang, Y. Geng, Z.L. Qu, W.J. Han, R.H. Xu, C.D. Fang, B.
424
Luo, Z.Y. Zhao, K.X. Pan, C.C. Yu, M.M. Shi, K.D. Zhu and T. Zhou for assistance in the
425
field experiments. We thank J.X. Liu for consultation on dairy cow breeding. This work
426
was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC 31670329, 31470463,
427
31770434).
428 429
REFERENCES
430
(1) FAOStat: Food and Agriculture Data, Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO).
431
http://faostat3.fao.org/browse/Q/QL/E (accessed December 20, 2016)
432
(2) Alexandratos, N.; Bruinsma, J. World Agriculture Towards 2030/2050: The 2012
433
Revision. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Rome 2012.
21
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
434
(3) Herrero, M.; Thornton, P. K.; Gerber, P.; Reid, R. S. Livestock, livelihoods and the
435
environment: understanding the trade-offs. Curr. Opin. Environ. Sustain. 2009, 1,111-120.
436
(4) Steinfeld, H.; Gerber, P.; Wassenaar, T. D.; Castel, V.; de Haan, C. Livestock's long
437
shadow: environmental issues and options. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO),
438
2006.
439
(5) Bai, Z. H.; Ma, L.; Oenema, O.; Chen, Q.; Zhang, F. S. Nitrogen and phosphorus use
440
efficiencies in milk production in China. J. Environ. Qual. 2013, 42, 990-1001.
441
(6) Tilman, D.; Cassman, K. G.; Matson, P. A.; Naylor, R.; Polasky, S. Agricultural
442
sustainability and intensive production practices. Nature 2002, 418, 671-677.
443
(7) Aneja, V. P.; Schlesinger, W. H.; Erisman, J. W. Farming pollution. Nat. Geosci. 2008, 1,
444
409-411.
445
(8) Owen, J. J.; Silver, W. L. Greenhouse gas emissions from dairy manure management: a
446
review of field‐based studies. Global change boil. 2015, 21(2), 550-565.
447
(9) Naylor, R.; Steinfeld, H.; Falcon, W.; Galloway, J.; Smil, V.; Bradford, E.; Alder, J.;
448
Mooney, H. Losing the links between livestock and land. Science 2005, 310, 1621-1622.
449
(10) Stokstad, E. Ammonia pollution from farming may exact hefty health costs. Science
450
2014, 343(6168), 238-238.
451
(11) Wu, Y. Y.; Gu, B. J.; Erisman, J. W.; Reis, S.; Fang, Y. Y.; Lu, X. H.; Zhang, X. M.
452
PM2.5 pollution is substantially affected by ammonia emissions in China. Environ. Pollut.
453
2016, 218, 86-94.
454
(12) Hilimire, K. Integrated Crop/Livestock Agriculture in the United States: A Review. J.
22
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 22 of 36
Page 23 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
455
Sustain. Agr. 2011, 35, 376-393.
456
(13) Russelle, M. P.; Entz, M. H.; Franzluebbers, A. J. Reconsidering integrated
457
crop-livestock systems in North America. Agron. J. 2007, 99, 325-334.
458
(14) Lemaire, G.; Franzluebbers, A.; Carvalho, P. C. D. F.; Dedieu, B. Integrated crop–
459
livestock systems: Strategies to achieve synergy between agricultural production and
460
environmental quality. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 2014, 190, 4-8.
461
(15) Ryschawy, J.; Choisis, N.; Choisis, J. P.; Joannon, A.; Gibon, A. Mixed crop-livestock
462
systems: an economic and environmental-friendly way of farming? Animal, 2012, 6,
463
1722-1730.
464
(16) Xia, L.; Lam, S. K.; Yan, X.; Chen, D. How does recycling of livestock manure in
465
agroecosystems affect crop productivity, reactive nitrogen losses, and soil carbon balance?
466
Environ. Sci. Technol. 2017, 51, 7450-7457.
467
(17) Franzluebbers, A. J. Integrated Crop–Livestock Systems in the Southeastern USA.
468
Agron. J. 2007, 99, 361-372.
469
(18) Sulc, R. M.; Tracy, B. F. Integrated Crop–Livestock Systems in the U.S. Corn Belt.
470
Agron. J. 2007, 99(2):431-446.
471
(19) Lemaire, G. Intensification of animal production from grassland and ecosystem
472
services: a trade-off. CAB Reviews 7, 2012, 12, 1-7.
473
(20) Lemaire, G.; Gastal, F.; Franzluebbers, A.; Chabbi, A. Grassland–cropping rotations:
474
An avenue for agricultural diversification to reconcile high production with environmental
475
quality. Environ. Manage. 2015, 56, 1065.
23
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
476
(21) Oenema, O.; Oudendag, D.; Velthof, G. L. Nutrient losses from manure management
477
in the European Union. Livest. Sci. 2007, 112(3), 261-272.
478
(22) Sutton, M. A.; Oenema, O.; Erisman, J. W.; Leip, A.; van Grinsven, H.; Winiwarter, W.
479
Too much of a good thing. Nature 2011, 472, 159-161.
480
(23) Ju, X.; Zhang, F.; Bao, X.; Römheld, V.; Roelcke, M. Utilization and management of
481
organic wastes in Chinese agriculture: Past, present and perspectives. Sci. China, Ser. C
482
2005, 48, 965-979.
483
(24) Bai, Z. H.; Li, X. X.; Lu, J.; Wang, X.; Velthof, G. L.; Chadwick, D.; Luo, J. F.;
484
Ledgard, S.; Wu, Z.G.; Jin, S. Q.; Oenema, O.; Ma, L.; Hu, C. S. Livestock Housing and
485
Manure Storage Need to Be Improved in China. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2017, 51,
486
8212-8214.
487
(25) Peyraud, J. L.; Taboada, M.; Delaby, L. Integrated crop and livestock systems in
488
Western Europe and South America: A review. Eur. J. Agron. 2014, 57, 31-42.
489
(26) Regan, J. T.; Marton, S.; Barrantes, O.; Ruane, E.; Hanegraaf, M.; Berland, J.;
490
Korevaar, H.; Pellerin, S.; Nesme, T. Does the recoupling of dairy and crop production via
491
cooperation between farms generate environmental benefits? A case-study approach in
492
Europe. Eur. J. Agron. 2017, 82, 342-356.
493
(27) Liu, D.; Ge, Y.; Chang, J.; Peng, C. H.; Gu, B. H.; Chan, G. YS.; Wu, X. F.
494
Constructed wetlands in China: recent developments and future challenges. Front. Ecol.
495
Environ. 2008, 7, 261-268.
24
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 24 of 36
Page 25 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
496
(28) Liu, D.; Wu, X.; Chang, J.; Gu, B. J.; Min, Y.; Ge, Y., Shi, Y.; Peng, C. H.; Wu, J. G.
497
Constructed wetlands as biofuel production systems. Nat. Clim. Change 2012, 2, 190-194.
498
(29) Dunne, E. J.; Culleton, N.; O’Donovan, G.; Harrington, R.; Olsen, A. E. An integrated
499
constructed wetland to treat contaminants and nutrients from dairy farmyard dirty water.
500
Ecol. Eng. 2005, 24, 219-232.
501
(30) Knight, R. L.; Payne, V. W.; Borer, R. E.; Clarke, R. A.; Pries, J. H. Constructed
502
wetlands for livestock wastewater management. Ecol. Eng. 2000, 15, 41-55.
503
(31) Ndegwa, P. M.; Hristov, A. N.; Arogo, J.; Sheffield, R. E. A review of ammonia
504
emission mitigation techniques for concentrated animal feeding operations. Biosyst. Eng.
505
2008, 100(4), 453-469.
506
(32) Wang, Y.; Dong, H. M.; Zhu, Z. P.; Gerber, P. J.; Xin, H. W.; Smith, P.; Opio, C.;
507
Steinfeld, H.; and Chadwick, D. Mitigating greenhouse gas and ammonia emissions from
508
swine manure management: a system analysis. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2017, 51(8),
509
4503-4511.
510
(33) MA. Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis. World Resources Institute. Island
511
Press, Washington, DC. (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment) (2005).
512
(34) Chang, J.; Wu, X.; Liu, A. Q.; Wang, Y.; Xu, B.; Yang, W.; Meyerson, L. A.; Gu, B. J.;
513
Peng, C. H.; Ge, Y. Assessment of net ecosystem services of plastic greenhouse vegetable
514
cultivation in China. Ecol. Econ. 2011, 70, 740-748.
25
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 26 of 36
515
(35) Ministry of Agriculture (MOA): “Zero growth of fertilizer and pesticide use” started.
516
http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2015-03/18/content_2835617.htm
517
December 10, 2016)
518
(36) Ministry of Agriculture (MOA): Development Plan of China’s Dairy (2016-2020)
519
http://www.moa.gov.cn/govpublic/XMYS/201701/P020170109560926642126.ceb
520
Chinese, accessed February 10, 2017)
521
(37) Han, W. J.; Chang, J.; Fan, X.; Du, Y. Y.; Chang, S. X.; Zhang, C. B.; Ge, Y. Plant
522
species diversity impacts nitrogen removal and nitrous oxide emissions as much as carbon
523
addition in constructed wetland microcosms. Ecol. Eng. 2016, 93, 144-151.
524
(38) Gerber, P. J.; Henderson, B.; Makkar, H. P. S. Mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions
525
in livestock production: A review of technical options for non-CO2 emissions. Food and
526
Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, 2013.
527
(39) NY/T 2374-2013. Technical code of post-treatment of digested sludge and slurry from
528
biogas plant. Ministry of Agriculture of the People’s 891 Republic of China 2013.
529
(40) Erisman, J. W.; Bleeker, A.; Hensen, A.; Vermeulen, A. Agricultural air quality in
530
Europe and the future perspectives. Atmos. Environ. 2008, 42, 14, 3209-3217.
531
(41) Chen, D.; Sun, J.; Bai, M.; Dassanayake, K. B.; Denmead, O. T.; Hill, J. A new
532
cost-effective method to mitigate ammonia loss from intensive cattle feedlots: application
533
of lignite. Scientific reports 2015, 5, 16689.
26
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
(in
Chinese,
accessed
(in
Page 27 of 36
534
Environmental Science & Technology
(42)
Dutch
dairy
cull
plan
agreed
by
EU.
535
http://www.fwi.co.uk/business/dutch-dairy-cull-plan-agreed-u.htm (accessed November 20,
536
2017)
537
(43) Kunrath, T. R.; Berranger, C. D.; Charrier, X.; Gastal, F.; Carvalho, P. C. D. F.;
538
Lemaire, G.; Emile, J. C. How much do sod-based rotations reduce nitrate leaching in a
539
cereal cropping system? Agr. Water Manage. 2015, 150:46-56.
540
(44) Ballesta, A.; Lloveras, J. Nitrogen replacement value of alfalfa to corn and wheat
541
under irrigated Mediterranean conditions. Span. J. Agric. Res. 2010, 8, 159-169.
542
(45) Soussana, J. F.; Lemaire, G. Coupling carbon and nitrogen cycles for environmentally
543
sustainable intensification of grasslands and crop-livestock systems. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ.
544
2014, 190(2):9-17.
545
(46) Jankauskas, B.; Jankauskiene, G. Erosion-preventive crop rotations for landscape
546
ecological stability in upland regions of Lithuania. Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 2003, 95,
547
129-142.
548
(47) Jiang, X.; Sommer, S. G.; Christensen, K. V. A review of the biogas industry in China.
549
Energ. Policy 2011, 39, 6073-6081.
550
(48) Gu, B. J.; Fan, L. C.; Ying, Z. C.; Xu, Q. S.; Luo, W. D.; Ge, Y.; Scott, S. and Chang, J.
551
Socioeconomic constraints on the technological choices in rural sewage treatment. Environ.
552
Sci. Pollut. R. 2016, 23(20):1-8.
553
(49) The General Office of the State Council. Opinions of speeding up the utilization of
554
livestock
and
poultry
27
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
waste.
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 28 of 36
555
http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2017-06/12/content_5201790.htm
556
accessed June 20, 2017)
557
(50) Ministry of Agriculture (MOA). The Ministry of Agriculture issued the
558
"implementation
559
http://www.moa.gov.cn/zwllm/tzgg/tz/201705/P020170527591691316913.ceb (in Chinese,
560
accessed August 20, 2017)
561
(51) Bell, L. W.; Moore, A. D. Integrated crop–livestock systems in Australian agriculture:
562
Trends, drivers and implications. Agr. Syst. 2012, 111, 1-12.
plan
of
grain
563
28
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
(in
for
Chinese,
forage".
Page 29 of 36
564
Environmental Science & Technology
Figure captions
565 566
Figure 1. Flow of nitrogen in the entire milk production chain. a. the industrial feedlot
567
is semi-coupled with farmlands; b. the industrial feedlot is fully-coupled with industrial
568
farmlands (FCIIC); c. the industrial feedlot is fully-coupled with constructed wetlands
569
(FCICW). Arrows represent N flow: blue- feed production process; orange- feed processing;
570
gray- dairy cow rearing (S: solid manure, L: liquid manure); yellow- milk processing;
571
black- N loss to environment. Values are kilograms of N in the production of one ton of
572
milk.
573 574
Figure 2. Intensities of GHGs and NH3 emissions and N discharge into water in milk
575
production systems. N2O, CH4, CO2, total GHG, and NH3 are shown in a-e, and N
576
discharge is shown in f. Blue- feed crop production process; orange- feed processing; gray-
577
dairy cow rearing; yellow- milk processing. Bars are standard errors of the entire chain
578
including the four processes. Different letters denote significant differences among the
579
three coupling modes. FCIIC: fully-coupled industrial dairy feedlots with industrial
580
farmlands. FCICW: fully-coupled industrial dairy feedlots with constructed wetlands.
581 582
Figure 3. Gaseous emissions from dairy wastes management. a-c, daily emission rates
583
(normalized) of N2O, CH4, and NH3. The regression analyses between gas emissions and
584
exposure time of solid or liquid manure to the air are displayed as follows: for solid manure,
29
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
585
N2O = -0.008x2 + 0.480x + 38.578, R2 = 0.10, P < 0.001; CH4 = 0.001x2 - 0.435x + 42.266,
586
R2 = 0.11, P < 0.001; NH3 = 79.229 × e -0.064x, R2 = 0.14, P < 0.001; for liquid manure, N2O
587
= 0.017x2 + 0.956x -13.241, R2 = 0.46, P = 0.085; CH4 = -0.027x2 + 2.559x - 7.884, R2 =
588
0.41, P < 0.001; NH3 = 58.705 × e -0.067x, R2 = 0.12, P = 0.008. d-f, cumulative emissions of
589
N2O, CH4, and NH3, dashed lines indicate the half loss point for each gas.
590 591
Figure 4. Milk production and its environmental impacts from 2002 to 2020 in China.
592
Milk production is shown in a, the total GHG and NH3 emissions and N discharge into
593
water are shown in b-d. Red dots represent milk production and environmental impacts
594
from 2002 to 2011; black triangles represent the scenario for semi-coupled systems to
595
continue to 2020; blue dots represent fully-coupled systems of all industrial dairy feedlots
596
with industrial farmlands (FCIIC); and green dots represent fully-coupled systems of all
597
industrial dairy feedlots with constructed wetlands (FCICW).
598 599 600
30
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 30 of 36
Page 31 of 36
601
Environmental Science & Technology
Figure 1
602
603
604 605 606
31
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
607
Figure 2
608
609 610
32
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 32 of 36
Page 33 of 36
611
Environmental Science & Technology
Figure 3
612
613 614
33
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
615 616
Figure 4
617 618
34
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 34 of 36
Page 35 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
619
Table 1. Ecosystem services provided by industrial milk production systems under
620
four coupling modes (USD ha-1 yr-1) Item
Semi-coupled
FCIIC
FCICW
FCIIC-R
1144.8±17.4
1112.1±16.9
1098.5±16.7
1143.9±17.4
Water saving
0.0
4.0±0.1
4.0±0.1
4.0±0.1
Water regulation
0.0
0.0
50.6±0.8
0.0
GHG emissions
-925.6±17.6
-650.6±14.6
-542.4±11.5
-559.6±14.4
NH3 emissions
-815.5±16.1
-709.8±15.6
-550.2±11.0
-700.8±15.7
N discharge into water
-67.2±1.5
-45.4±1.5
-31.9±0.9
-32.5±1.2
-663.3±21.3
-289.7±19.1
28.6±12.9
-145.1±18.8
Provisioning services Fresh milk Regulating services
Net ecosystem services 621
An industrial milk production system includes two directly coupled components: a dairy
622
feedlot and farmlands (or CWs). FCIIC: fully-coupled industrial dairy feedlots with
623
industrial farmlands, FCICW: fully-coupled industrial dairy feedlots with constructed
624
wetlands. FCIIC-R: fully-coupled industrial dairy feedlots with forage-crop rotation. Values
625
are mean ± SE (n = 108).
626
35
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
627
An art piece as a visual abstract for the Table of Contents
628
629
36
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 36 of 36