BUSINESS
SOLAR MARKET POWERS SILICON Polysilicon shortages are boon to manufacturers, bane of solar energy industry JEAN-FRANCOIS TREMBLAY, C&EN HONG KONG
H
IGH PROFITS AND LOW RISK.
That is the sweet spot that polysilicon producers find themselves in these days now that their product, key to the manufacture of photovoltaic solar panels, is in desperately short supply. In July, for example, the Chinese photovoltaic cell maker Suntech committed to buy at least $5 billion worth of polysilicon over 10 years from St. Peters, Mo.-based silicon wafer producer M E M C . Suntech also agreed to make interest-free loans to M E M C to help it build new plants needed to fulfill the contract. The deal is not unusual. Solar energy is a relatively new market
for polysilicon manufacturers. They traditionally made polysilicon, known more formally as polycrystalline silicon, mostly for the semiconductor industry, which uses it to produce silicon wafers. They sold solar cell companies either surplus polysilicon or off-spec material that was not sufficiently pure for semiconductor fabrication. In recent years, demand from solar cell manufacturers has grown to a point where it outstrips the ability of polysilicon manufacturers to supply them. Industry executives are increasingly optimistic about the prospects for the solar industry. "Growth has been averaging 35-40% annually for more than five years," says Richard S. Doornbos, president and chief executive
officer of Hemlock Semiconductor, the world's largest producer of polysilicon. "A lot of analysts believe, and I do too, that there are some pretty strong fundamental drivers for the growth of solar industry," Doornbos adds. Like others, he expects that within two years, the solar industry will consume more polysilicon than the semiconductor industry. The large and growing requirements of the solar industry are giving rise to a wave of capacity expansion announcements by polysilicon companies this year. According to the stock brokerage PiperJaffray, the solar industry will consume more than 30,000 metric tons of polysilicon in 2008, compared with 27,000 for the semiconductor industry. Last year, the solar industry used 17,500 metric tons while the semiconductor sector used 21,500. Hemlock is spending $400 million to $500 million to expand polysilicon capacity at its main site in Hemlock, Mich. The firm, a joint venture of Dow Corning, ShinEtsu Chemical, and Mitsubishi Materials, is also undertaking a search for a new site somewhere else in the world in order to set up a second plant within five years. Wacker Chemie, the world's number two producer of polysilicon, announced this
We're talking about making the world's purest materials. One should not underestimate the technology challenges/' 30
C&EN
/ OCTOBER
2,
2006
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
THE ALTERNATIVE The solar cell market has been growing at over 35% annually for the past five years, leading to severe shortages of polysilicon. Pictured is a 100-MW SunPower system installed in Geneva.
summer that it would build a 4,500-metricton-per-year plant in Burghausen, Germany, to supply solar cell manufacturers. Also in Germany, Deutsche Solar, the solar wafer subsidiary of solar cell manufacturer SolarWorld, is teaming up with Degussa to bring on-line an 850-metric-ton polysilicon plant that makes use of a new process. Most of the new facilities under construction will come on-line in 2008 or 2009. In the meantime, manufacturers of solar cells have to manage the shortages as best they can. Peter Woditsch, CEO of Deutsche Solar, tells C&EN that it's obvious why polysilicon supply has fallen so far behind demand: the cautiousness of the companies that make it. Spurred by bullish forecasts provided by semiconductor manufacturers during the Internet boom of the late 1990s, polysilicon
companies made significant investments in expanding their production capacities. But the semiconductor boom turned to bust in 2001, causing an oversupply of polysilicon. This experience of not so many years ago has made silicon producers conservative about investing. But the risks involved in expanding capacity appear to be particularly minimal these days. Polysilicon producers have the luxury of starting construction on new plants after having signed supply contracts that commit most of the output for several years. "The commodity suppliers realize that they have a pretty good situation at hand, and they take advantage of it in a mostly constructive way," says Julie Blunden, vice president of external affairs at SunPower, a major manufacturer of solar cells based in California.
EARLIER THIS YEAR, SunPower signed a contract with DC Chemical, a diversified chemical producer based in South Korea. Under the agreement, SunPower will buy at least $250 million worth of polysilicon over four years and will prepay for the shipments to help DC finance the construction of a new plant that is expected to open in 2008. GOING DOWN Surprisingly, DC has never produced Established polysilicon producers will polysilicon, and this does not worry Sunlose market share over next few years Power. "We're not a chemical company, but they are, and there is a lot of expertise associated with being a chemical company," Blunden says, noting that DC already produces the precursor gases needed to make polysilicon. Blunden says the deal with DC adds another supplier to the list of companies already supplying polysilicon to SunPower. In the spring, the California firm increased to $500 million and extended by two years an existing supply agreement with Japan's M.Setek, an established polysilicon producer. 2004 market = 28,830 metric tons Jesse W. Pichel, a senior analyst who covers the semiconductor and solar power industries for PiperJaffray, believes that polysilicon producers are enjoying huge profit margins these days. He estimates that it costs about $30 to produce a kilogram of solar-grade polysilicon at present. The contract sale price, meanwhile, is $70 per kg on average, "if you're lucky to have a contract," he says. As for the spot market price, it's as much as $200 per kg. Pichel notes that there are many producers of solar cells in China and that they meet about half of 2009 market = 71,370 metric tons their polysilicon requirements from the SOURCE: Piper Jaffray spot market. Hemlock's Doornbos cautions that
Tel: 86-411-62787369 Fax:86-411-62787370 E-maii:
[email protected] www.allychem.com
tt» AllyChem
-J^O
LILrS
Co.Ltd..Dalian,China
Request more at AdlnfoNow.org
N-Iodosuccinimidei
Used for iodination with other reagents to give specific iodinated derivatives of many compounds in high yields. Reagent for o x i d i m e t r i c titration of sulfur functions Available from S T O C K
ORGANOyFlNM € i p M I C ALJ 207, Anand Bhuvan?Princess Strletl Mufnbai - 400 002. INDI; Tel.: 2201 69 68^2206 75 21 • fax|22Q5 92 997 2208 31 84
[email protected];* Website: www.orqano.in
v We solicit yourproposal for , CUSTOM SYNTHESIS & TOLL MANUFACTURING
Request more at AdlnfoNow.org WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
C & E N / OCTOBER 2. 2006
31
BUSINESS CHINA
Rivals Team Up For Basic Silicon Production
P
olysilicon for solar cell manufacturing is not the only hot topic in silicon chemistry these days. On a sunny day in September, Peter-Alexander Wacker and Stephanie Burns, the chief executive officers of Wacker Chemie and Dow Corning, respectively, stood together in their best suits for the groundbreaking of their Chinese silicon chemicals project. The alliance had been in the works foryears. The two companies are putting $600 million on the ground in Zhangjiagang, a midsized city on the Yangtze River, two hours by car from Shanghai. They will build two facilities making silicon-based materials. One is a siloxane plant that is due to be fully operational in 2010 and the other a fumed silica plant that will start production at the end of
margin estimates made by outside organizations are not reliable "because it's hard to get the information."
next year. The siloxane plant will start producing some material next year to feed the silica plant. Siloxanes are basic materials that can be polymerized into hundreds of industrial and consumer silicone products. Fumed silica acts as a filling material in the making of silicone elastomers. It is also a widely used viscosity-adjusting agent. Dow Corning will provide the technology for the siloxane plant, and Wacker that for the fumed silica facility. The two companies will buy most of the output of both plants to feed existing or future downstream operations in China. Speaking with reporters at the event, the Wacker CEO said his company had initiated the talks with Dow Corning that led to their partnership. He said Wacker had a basic concept in mind, and the two companies
Pichel expects the tight supply conditions to prevail for some time. He estimates that as much as 98% of the polysilicon that will
Experts in Fluorochemical Analysis Experience Analyzing C1-C13 Perfluorinated Acids and Sulfonates in air, blood plasma & serum, water, soil, raw materials, manufactured intermediates, finished products, and articles of commerce
Extensive Capacity 19 LC-MS/MS systems
Proven Results Exygen methods published in "Journal of Chromatography," "Analytical Chemistry," and "Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene"
Proven Quality Methods validated under FDA and EPA GLPs
www.exygenresearch.com ito(a)exygen .com
quickly agreed to team up. In the three years that followed, the two firms engaged in detailed planning and sought government approvals for the project, Wacker said. Dow Corning and Wacker already operate two siloxane plants apiece. Both of Wacker's plants are in Germany, whereas Dow Corning has one in the U.S. and one in the U.K. The derivative plants that will be fed by the new siloxane facility will be operated separately by Wacker and Dow Corning. That the siloxane plant will serve the Chinese market alone marks a change in thinking at Dow Corning. Ten years ago, the company had initiated the process of searching for a suitable site for an Asian siloxane plant that would serve the whole region. China was one of three countries where it might have been built, the others being Malaysia
be produced in 2007 has already been allocated to buyers under forward contracts and that 95% of 2008's polysilicon is also preallocated. He says no manufacturer except MEMC has any significant amount of capacity to spare, and he expects MEMC to soon supplement its Suntech deal with a supply agreement with another major company. Owing to the huge margins and strong demand forecasts, many firms are trying to set themselves up as manufacturers of polysilicon. Besides major chemical companies such as DC Chemical, smaller firms in China are also trying their hands at producing the material. Hemlock's Doornbos contends that new entrants will face some real challenges in mastering the processes involved. "We're talking about making the world's purest materials," he says. "One should not underestimate the technology challenges." Making polysilicon is "quite different from the typical chemical industry processing," Doornbos adds. He expects that several of the new entrants will ultimately become successful players but doubts this will happen quickly. Polysilicon is cumbersome to make. The raw material is metallurgical-grade silicon, obtained from the reduction of mined silicon dioxide. This silicon is then reacted with hydrogen chloride to form trichlorosilane. A Wacker spokesman tells C&EN that in the traditional Siemens process, trichlorosilane and hydrogen gas are sent into a reactor containing thin silicon rods. The rods are heated to 1,000 °C, causing the
Request more at AdlnfoNow.org 32
C&EN
/ OCTOBER
2,
2006
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
and South Korea. In her comments to reporters, Burns said the rapid growth of the Chinese market is the main reason that the new siloxane plant wilt serve China only. Underscoring China's importance to Dow Corning, Chris Bowyer, an executive vice president who is the company's second-most-senior manager, moved to Shanghai earlier this the year. A few years ago, Dow Coming's most senior executives in Asia were based in Tokyo. Bowyer told C&EN that he moved from the U.S. to China to keep closer tabs on changes in the local market. He said his presence has also expedited negotiations with government officials over the setup of the Zhangjiagang project. As to why it took so long for Dow Corning to finally move on the long-considered Asian plant, he said, "The time is right." He added he's confident that the facility will provide the proper amount of silicon to the market, with neither shortages nor oversupply.
to encourage households and businesses to invest in solar energy generation. The subsidies are the result of a collective desire to protect "the Earth we borrowed from our children," he says. The subsidies are necessary, he maintains, because at present, "the cost of electricity produced by a photovoltatic process is not competitive against electricity produced by depreciated power stations." The growing list of U.S. states and countries that subsidize solar energy in a similar
way to Germany now includes California, NewJersey, France, Greece, Italy, Portugal, South Korea, and Spain. Woditch adds that the solar industry's relative immaturity is one reason the cost of producing solar energy is so high. "It is not well-developed, it is not large-scale, and production is not automated. It's a handicraft," he says. The porysilicon shortage is prompting companies to look at new ways to make solar cells. Whereas last year the solar cell
Sometimes the reason for demanding the quality and reliability of Parr Pressure Reactor Systems is rather transparent.
trichlorosilane to decompose and deposit itself as polycrystalline silicon. Semiconductor wafer manufacturers and some solar cell manufacturers require monocrystalline silicon. This higher grade material is obtained by crushing porysilicon, melting it, and then growing it into an ingot with a singular crystal orientation. Boron or phosphorus can be added to improve connectivity. Because they are sold out ofporysilicon at present, major players such as Wacker and Hemlock do not compete for customers. But normally, Doornbos says, competitive differences are found in the refinements to the Siemens process that each firm has come up with over the years. These refinements allow better control of the production process and the quality of the silicon produced. He adds that the reputation each firm has developed over the years is another differentiating factor between companies. And if there weren't a shortage, says Piper Jaffa-ay's Pichel, the main basis of competition would be each firm's cost of production. "Whoever has the lowest cost of making porysilicon wins," he says. THE BOOMING demand for solar cells worldwide is the result of many factors. Rising prices for fossil fuels and concerns over their availability, Doornbos says, are spurring interest in solar energy. In addition, nations that signed the Kyoto protocol are looking for ways to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases. Deutsche Solar's Woditch points to the regime of subsidies pioneered by Germany
Parr Low Pressure Reactor Systems are ideal for direct observation of mixing action, color changes, or changes of state at elevated temperatures and pressures. And each system comes standard with Parr's world-class sales and support staff. Call us today.
Parr Instrument Company • 1-800-872-7720 www.parrinst.com Request more atAdlnfoNow.org
WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
C&EN
/
OCTOBER
2. 2 0 0 6
33
BUSINESS industry grew 30% as measured in terms of new wattage produced, growth this year will be only 5%. Until last year, Pichel says, solar cell manufacturers could still get their polysilicon from the stockpiles of material accumulated in the industry glut of 2001-02. In particular, thin-film technology is gathering steam, Pichel says. Its prime advantages are that it allows solar cells to be produced at a lower cost and that it does not consume any polysilicon. Instead, the key material on the surface of the cells is amorphous silicon, which is obtained from silane gas, or an alloy like copper indium gallium. Thin-film solar cells are made by U.S. companies Energy Conversion Devices and First Solar, as well as a handful of companies in Germany. Thin films already represent 5% of the solar energy market, Pichel estimates. Dow Corning announced in early September that it had developed a grade of metallurgical silicon that could be blended with traditional polysilicon to make solar cells. The company said the availability of the material could help relieve polysilicon supply shortages. Dow Corning CEO
PURITY Polysilicon is made in ingots, which are later cut into wafers. Stephanie Burns tells C & E N that commercialization of solar-grade metallurgical silicon is an important achievement that Dow Corning had been working toward for a number of years.
Opinions are divided on how widely Dow Coming's metallurgical silicon will be accepted. At SunPower, Blunden says the availability of solar-grade metallurgical silicon is a welcome development that will help reduce supply pressures in the industry. But she says SunPower will stick with its monocrystalline silicon process and has no intention of using metallurgical silicon. Piper Jaffray's Pichel does not see the point of using metallurgical silicon in a solar cell, calling it far less efficient at generating electricity than polysilicon. He says the efficiency of a cell decreases in proportion to the amount of metallurgical silicon that is added to it. "The last thing you want to do ifyou're a solar cell producer is to lower the efficiency of your cell," he says. Even though new materials may be promising, it will take many years for them to become a credible alternative to polysilicon. As a result, shortages ofpolysilicon will continue until at least 2008 when new facilities come on-line. And if the cost of producing solar-based electricity ever becomes competitive with traditional means, Pichel predicts that "there will never be enough polysilicon to go around." •
Yamazen, the Leader in Automated Flash Chromatography in Japan Input the TLC Rf value, and the optimum method is automatically set.
• Dual Channel & Fast SPEED: double the power, boost the separation speed & efficiency • User Friendly Automatic Method Set-up • Modular System: easy to maintain and service • Optimum Chromatographic Method Development
The target compound always elutes toward the end of the Rf gradient (indicated by arrows)
•xv—-ft^iS
...the next generation Dual Channel Independent or Simultaneous
Chromatography
YAMAZEN f
Ihe 'Epqtert of Chromatography since 1977
903 Sneath Lane, Suite 125, San Bruno, CA, U.S.A. Phone: (650) 877-7750
www.yamazenusa.com
Request more atAdlnfoNow.org 34
C&EN
/
OCTOBER
2,
2006
WWW.CEN-0NLINE.ORG
