EMPLOYMENT
Women in industry Another year brings more gains in C&EN’s annual survey of women serving at the top of the chemical industry ladder ALEXANDER H. TULLO, C&EN NEW YORK CITY
W
omen continue to make modest gains in the chemical industry. Women occupy 16.7% of 430 board of director seats at 42 U.S. firms with large chemical businesses, according to C&EN’s latest annual survey. This is an increase from the 16.2% posted a year ago. Similarly, on average, 1.7 women serve on each chemical company board, versus 1.6 in 2015. Women have made greater strides in the executive suite, according to the survey. They occupy 14.2% of the 402 executive officer positions at the 42 companies. In 2015, the same firms held 13.4% of such positions. To compile the survey, C&EN consults annual company reports as well as proxy statements and 10-K annual report forms filed with the Securities & Exchange Commission by publicly traded U.S. companies that have significant chemical businesses. Because chemical firms don’t often modify their boards or top management, the numbers move slowly. But over time, change accumulates. A decade ago, C&EN’s survey put the proportion of women serving on chemical boards and in executive suites at 11.1% and 8.8%, respectively. Still, the chemical industry is behind the rest of the corporate world. Catalyst, a New York City-based organization dedicated to the advancement of women in the workplace, released a survey in June of the corporate boards of companies that make up the Standard & Poor’s 500 stock index. It found that women occupy 19.9% of the board seats at these firms. In the survey, Catalyst also found that 9.5% of the top earners at S&P 500 firms
are women. This category lists those executives whose salaries are published in companies’ proxy statements. It is not a perfect comparison with C&EN’s survey because it tends to be a narrower category. For the second year, C&EN surveyed 13 large European chemical firms, finding that 28.6% of the 154 board seats are filled by women. Of the top executives at these firms, 10% are women. This comparison to the U.S. survey isn’t apples to apples. German companies tend to have union representation on their boards, which can be a source of female inclusion. On the other hand, European firms typically list fewer top executives in their annual reports—just the chief executive, financial officers and a couple others. This exclusive group is less likely to include women than the broader U.S. executive officer category. Below the survey results, C&EN profiles three women who have established rewarding mid-level careers in the chemical enterprise. Although the three have different roles, they all emphasize opportunity in describing factors critical to their success. And all three capitalize on opportunity when it’s presented to them.
Up again For the fourth straight year, women’s representation improved across the board. Women directors as percentage of board and executive ofcer positions 18
◼ ◼
Boards of directors Executive ofcers
12
6 0 2005
06
07
08
09
Source: C&EN
22
C&EN | CEN.ACS.ORG | AUGUST 29, 2016
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Top jobs Human resources and business responsibility comprise a majority of the roles for women. Administration 7% Human resources 33%
Financial 14%
Legal 18%
Business responsibility 28% Women in executive positions in 2016 = 57 Note: Data based on firms listed on pages 23 and 24.
Women at European firms The representation of women on European chemical boards inched up in 2016. SUPERVISORY BOARD
MANAGEMENT BOARD
COMPANY WOMEN TOTAL WOMEN TOTAL Air Liquide 5 11 1 14 AkzoNobel 2 7 1 7 Arkema 4 12 0 7 BASF 3 12 1 8 Bayer 4 22 1 9 DSM 3 7 1 4 Evonik 4 20 1 5 Industries Johnson 2 6 0 4 Matthey Lanxess 3 12 0 4 Linde 3 12 0 6 Solvay 5 16 0 5 Syngenta 3 9 2 8 Yara 3 8 1 9 TOTAL 44 154 9 90
2015
2016
Women directors 2.9 per company Women directors as % 24.1 of board positions Women execs per company 0.7 Women execs as % 10.0 of positions
3.4
Sources: Company documents
28.6 0.7 10.0
More gains
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Though representation has improved, seven companies surveyed still have no women in top management. BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Air Products & Chemicals 11 total, 2 women
EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
11 total, 1 woman
10 total, 1 woman
H. B. Fuller
9 total, 2 women
Goodyear
4 total, 0 women
W.R. Grace
Honeywell
5 total, 1 woman
12 total, 3 women
6 total, 1 woman
10 total, 2 women
Innophos
9 total, 3 women
8 total, 1 woman
8 total, 1 woman Beth Albright, senior VP, HR
9 total, 3 women Jean Marie Mainente, senior VP and chief HR ofcer; Kim Ann Mink, CEO; Susan Turner, VP, quality and regulatory
Wendy S. Jablow, senior VP, HR
8 total, 2 women
22 total, 1 woman Maria Csiba-Womersley, VP and chief information ofcer
Lori A. Johnston, exec. VP and chief administrative ofcer
10 total, 1 woman Katherine L. Adams, senior VP and general counsel
Huntsman Corp. 8 total, 1 woman
5 total, 1 woman Elizabeth C. Brown, VP, chief HR ofcer
6 total, 0 women
10 total, 3 women
7 total, 1 woman
Samantha M. Hanley, VP, general counsel, and secretary
Chemours
13 total, 1 woman Laura K. Thompson, CFO
9 total, 2 women
CF Industries
11 total, 4 women Heather A. Campe, VP, Asia-Pacific; Elin E. Gabriel, VP, global operations; Traci L. Jensen, senior VP, Americas adhesives; Ann B. Parriott, VP, HR
9 total, 1 woman Anne T. Schulmann, VP, chief information and administrative services ofcer
6 total, 1 woman Andrea E. Utecht, exec. VP, general counsel, and secretary
13 total, 2 women
12 total, 2 women
Celanese
4 total, 1 woman
10 total, 1 woman
Cambrex
7 total, 0 woman
Ferro
FMC
Cabot
21 total, 0 women
6 total, 2 women
10 total, 1 woman
Axiall
13 total, 2 women
Ann E. Killian, VP, HR
Susan Kelliher, senior VP, HR; Karen G. Narwold, senior VP, general counsel, corporate and government affairs, and corporate secretary
Ashland
ExxonMobil
5 total, 0 women
Albemarle
EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
Innospec 7 total, 0 women
7 total, 1 woman Catherine Hessner, senior VP, HR
Chemtura
8 total, 1 woman
8 total, 1 woman Billie S. Flaherty, exec. VP, general counsel, and secretary
Dow Chemical
13 total, 2 women
Kraton
9 total, 2 women
Stacy L. Fox, senior VP and general counsel
Ecolab
10 total, 0 women
17 total, 4 women
Kronos Worldwide 8 total, 1 woman
14 total, 2 women Laurie M. Marsh, exec. VP, HR; Jill S. Wyant, exec. VP and president, global food & beverage, and health care
10 total, 2 women Melinda S. Conley, VP, chief HR ofcer; Suzanne Pesgens, VP, chief procurement ofcer
7 total, 1 woman
Eastman Chemical 12 total, 2 women
14 total, 2 women Leslie S. Hyde, VP, risk management, and deputy general counsel; Louann E. Tronsberg-Deihle, treasurer
11 total, 2 women
9 total, 2 women
11 total, 1 woman Johanna Söderström, VP, HR and aviation
DuPont
Koppers
Note: CEO = chief executive officer. CFO = chief financial officer. VP = vice president. HR = human resources. Sources: Company documents
19 total, 4 women Kelly D. Luttmer, VP and global tax director; Janet G. Keckeisen, VP, corporate strategy and investor relations; Patricia A. Kropp, VP and director, global HR; Courtney J. Riley, VP, environmental affairs
AUGUST 29, 2016 | CEN.ACS.ORG | C&EN
23
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
LyondellBasell Industries 12 total, 3 women
EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
14 total, 4 women
11 total, 3 women
Jacquelyn H. Wolf, senior VP and chief HR ofcer
13 total, 2 women
13 total, 2 women
Quaker Chemical 11 total, 2 women
9 total, 1 woman Corrine D. Ricard, senior VP, HR
NewMarket
6 total, 1 women
Occidental Petroleum 11 total, 3 women
12 total, 1 woman
16 total, 2 women
11 total, 1 woman
8 total, 1 woman Anne P. Noonan, president, performance chemicals
PolyOne
11 total, 2 women
9 total, 2 women
Marilyn N. Horner, senior VP, HR; Catherine C. Maxey, VP, public affairs, sustainability and environment, health and safety
Tronox 9 total, 0 women
8 total, 1 woman Katherine C. Harper, CFO
Westlake Chemical 8 total, 1 woman
9 total, 0 women
TOTAL 430 total, 72 women 402 total, 57 women
13 total, 2 women Lisa K. Kunkle, senior VP, general counsel, and secretary; Ana G. Rodriguez, senior VP, chief HR ofcer
PPG Industries 11 total, 2 women
9 total, 0 women
Jennifer A. Hale, VP, general counsel and secretary; Debra A. Stefaniak, VP, business transformation
Trinseo
Dolores J. Ennico, VP, HR; Randee N. Sumner, VP and controller
Omnova
10 total, 2 women
7 total, 4 women
Olin
Mary Dean Hall, VP, CFO, and treasurer
8 total, 1 woman
Marcia E. Backus, senior VP, general counsel, chief compliance ofcer, and corporate secretary; Vicki A. Hollub, president and COO; Jennifer M. Kirk, VP and controller; Cynthia L. Walker, senior VP, marketing and midstream operations and development
11 total, 1 woman
Stepan
7 total, 0 women
8 total, 3 women Elizabeth T. Hirsch, VP and controller; Karen L. Keegans, VP, chief HR ofcer; Anne K. Roby, senior VP, supply systems, R&D, market development, operations, procurement, sustainability, safety & health, and environment
Janet M. Holloway, senior VP, chief of staff and community relations; Nicole M. Ringenberg, VP and controller
Mosaic
EXECUTIVE OFFICERS
Praxair
10 total, 1 woman
Monsanto
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Women directors per company Women directors as % of board positions Women execs per company Women execs as % of positions
2015
2016
1.6 16.2 1.3 13.4
1.7 16.7 1.4 14.2
6 total, 1 woman Cynthia A. Niekamp, senior VP, automotive coatings
Anca Rusu ▸ Project director, Pennsylvania
chemicals project ▸ Royal Dutch Shell In June, Royal Dutch Shell gave the green light to building a massive petrochemical plant in Monaca, Pa. As the oil and chemical firm’s largest North American project, the multi-billion-dollar investment will feature a new ethylene cracker and downstream
24
C&EN | CEN.ACS.ORG | AUGUST 29, 2016
polyethylene plants. It is currently the most well-developed large chemical project outside of the U.S. Gulf Coast meant to tap into low-cost U.S. shale gas. Anca Rusu is responsible for its construction. She has been involved with the planning since 2013, seeing it from frontend engineering and design through the final investment
Anca Rusu
decision by Shell’s board. She is currently working on preparing the site, which sits on the Ohio River not far from Pittsburgh. Construction will begin in earnest early next year. When activity peaks in 2018, she will lead a workforce of 6,000 people. “From the perspective of authority and accountability, this
CREDIT: SHELL
Three women in industry: C&EN takes a look at executives who climbed the ladder by seizing opportunity at every rung
CREDIT: MCGEAN (GLIOZZI); INNOPHOS (DUFF)
position is the highest I have had so far,” Rusu says. As a child, Rusu was inspired to become an engineer by listening to her father and uncle talk shop. Her father was a metallurgical engineer with an international reputation for commissioning facilities and solving tricky problems. Her uncle was a professor of chemical engineering in her native Bucharest, Romania. Hearing them fascinated and inspired Rusu. She wanted to equal or surpass what they had accomplished. She earned a double degree in mechanical and electrical engineering from University Politehnica of Bucharest in 1989. She managed a benzene plant in Romania for a few years. From there she headed to Canada, where she worked for the engineering firms Stone & Webster and WorleyParsons and completed her MBA at York University. She joined Shell in 2005, participating in front-end engineering for projects in Russia, India, Iran, and Algeria. She had a key role in Shell’s Antar gas exploration project in the United Arab Emirates. By far, Rusu’s largest project was Phase II of Shell’s Kashagan offshore oil project in the Caspian Sea off the coast of Kazakhstan. For that project, she led a 600-person design team in London for three years. “That’s one of the greatest things about Shell,” she says. “You get all sorts of big opportunities.” Rusu credits her own success to determination, commitment, optimism, and luck. “Luck to come across great people who believe in you and give you chances and push you and coach you and guide you,” she says. Rusu is trying to be that person for others at Shell. As a mentor to eight young men and women, she confronts some of the reasons why the oil and chemical industries can struggle to attract and retain talent. They are traditional industries, and younger people think they can cultivate their talents better at start-ups. Rusu tries to convince them that oil and chemistry are still innovative fields and that they offer opportunity—as they have for her—to do big things.
The 100-employee strong company makes Cee-Bee brand formulated products for aircraft maintenance—things such as lavatory cleaners and paint strippers. Longtime employee Mara Gliozzi observes that the company provides most every chemical used on an aircraft but the “deicers, paints, and fuels.” Gliozzi runs McGean’s specialty chemical business, which has manufacturing operations in Cleveland; Livonia, Mich.; and Wolverhampton, England. The company markets its own line of specialty chemicals and runs a custom manufacturing business. McGean’s chemicals business performs inorganic and organic synthesis, working with intermediates such as allyl chloride, benzyl chloride, and epiMara Gliozzi chlorohydrin. The firm has special expertise in handling chromium compounds, such as trivalent chromium intermediates. Gliozzi has been with McGean for 32 years. The company provided her first job out of high school and she stayed with it part-time while studying marketing and business administration at Cleveland State University. She remained part-time while her children were young, working 20 to 30 hours a week in marketing and customer service. Gliozzi began climbing the ladder when she was able to work full-time and has headed the specialty chemical unit for the past eight years. She credits McGean for her success. It gave her the opportunity to work part-time while she was educating herself and raising a family and has always been committed to work-life balance. Gliozzi appreciates that McGean is a close-knit company. “The ability to know each other, know everyone’s names, their spouses’ and children’s names, makes it easier to be able to support each other,” she says.
Mara Gliozzi
Sherry Duff
▸ Global business manager for specialty
▸ Vice president and chief marketing
chemicals
officer
▸ McGean
▸ Innophos
Cleveland-based McGean is one of the many niche chemical firms that fill the gaps between giants such as BASF, Dow Chemical, and Eastman Chemical by filling orders and earning profits in small-volume chemicals that the big firms don’t trouble themselves with.
Based in Cranbury, N.J., Innophos Holdings is one of the leading makers of phosphate chemicals. The company, once a part of the French giant Rhodia, offers phosphates for food, health, and industrial applications. Innophos is looking to expand the pie and move further into adjacent food and
nutritional markets after a string of small acquisitions in 2011–13. Earlier this year, industry veteran Sherry Duff was brought in to help. She will lead a marketing organization, which, in the words of Chief Executive Officer Kim Ann Mink, will “dovetail with technology” to foster this transformation. Duff was interested in chemistry from an early age. “What I enjoyed about chemistry was its ability to explain the world around us utilizing systematic scientific principles,” she recalls. She earned a bachelor’s degree in chemistry from the University of Connecticut in 1989. Duff joined chemical, ammunition, and brass maker Olin as a chemist but soon became fascinated with the commercial purposes of her projects. “I was interested in understanding the business of chemistry,” she says. Getting involved in technical service allowed her to “leap from the bench to the commercial world,” she says. While at Olin, Duff sealed her transformation with an MBA from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. Duff climbed the ranks at Olin, working in its electronic materials, chlor-alkali, hydrazine, and biocides businesses. She found herself at Arch Chemicals when it was spun off from Olin in 1999. Early on, Duff helped lead the diversification and growth of Arch’s personal care ingredients business, and from 2003 to 2006, she was the firm’s R&D director. Sherry Duff When Swiss fine chemicals maker Lonza signed an agreement to purchase Arch in 2011, Duff was working in strategic planning and business development. She left Arch before the deal closed to head Arista Laboratories, an analytical chemistry and toxicology lab business with expertise in smoke science. Parent company Molins sold the business last year, and Duff joined Innophos earlier this year. To Duff, cultivating a pipeline of female chemistry leaders means encouraging girls to take an interest in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics as early as elementary school. Once women are in the workforce, she says, advancement “starts with opportunities.” Women who are successful are an example for colleagues who are earlier in their careers, Duff says. ◾ AUGUST 29, 2016 | CEN.ACS.ORG | C&EN
25
