Subscriber access provided by TEXAS A&M INTL UNIV
Article
Development of a novel process integrating the treatment of sludge reject water and the production of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) Nicola Frison, Evina Katsou, Simos Malamis, Adrian Oehmen, and Francesco Fatone Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.5b01776 • Publication Date (Web): 13 Aug 2015 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on August 24, 2015
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Title: Development of a novel process integrating
2
the treatment of sludge reject water and the
3
production of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs)
4 5
Nicola Frison,† Evina Katsou,†,‡ Simos Malamis,†,§ Adrian Oehmen,¥ Francesco Fatone*,†
6 7
†University of Verona, Department of Biotecnology, Strada Le Grazie 15, 37134 – Verona,
8
Italy
9
‡
Department of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering, Brunel University, Kingston
10
Lane, UB8 3PH Uxbridge, Middlesex, UK.
11
§
12
Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, 5 Iroon Polytechniou St., 15780,
13
Athens, Greece.
14
¥
15
Universidade Nova de Lisboa, 2829-516 Caparica, Portugal.
16
*Corresponding author: tel/fax: +39 045 8027965, e-mail:
[email protected].
Department of Water Resources and Environmental Engineering, School of Civil
UCIBIO, REQUIMTE, Departamento de Química, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia,
17 18
ABSTRACT. Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs) from activated sludge and renewable organic
19
material can become an alternative product to traditional plastics since they are biodegradable
20
and are produced from renewable sources. In this work, the selection of PHA storing bacteria
21
was integrated with the side stream treatment of nitrogen removal via nitrite from sewage
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 2 of 31
22
sludge reject water. A novel process was developed and applied where the alternation of
23
aerobic-feast and anoxic-famine conditions accomplished the selection of PHA storing
24
biomass and nitrogen removal via nitrite. Two configurations were examined: in
25
configuration 1 the ammonium conversion to nitrite occurred in the same reactor in which the
26
PHA selection process occurred, while in configuration 2 two separate reactors were used.
27
The results showed that the selection of PHA storing biomass was successful in both
28
configurations, while the nitrogen removal efficiency was much higher (almost 90%) in
29
configuration 2. The PHA selection degree was evaluated by the volatile fatty acid (VFA)
30
uptake rate (-qVFAs) and the PHA production rate, which were 239±74 and 89±7 mgCOD
31
per gram of active biomass (Xa) per hour, respectively. The characterization of biopolymers
32
after the accumulation step, showed that it was composed of 3-hydroxybutyrate (3HB) (60%)
33
and 3-hydroxyvalerate (3HV) (40%). The properties associated with the produced PHA
34
suggest that they are suitable for thermoplastic processing.
35 36
Keywords: polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA); feast and famine regime; nitrogen removal
37
via nitrite; sludge reject water
38 39
INTRODUCTION
40
Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) are biodegradable polymers that can be produced by many
41
different types of bacteria. Compared to conventional synthetic polymers, PHAs possess
42
obvious ecological advantages since they are completely biodegradable and nontoxic1,2 and
43
can be produced from a renewable source. PHAs, which encompass polyhydroxybutyrate
44
(PHB) homopolymers, polyhydroxybutyrate-co-hydroxyvalerate copolymers (PHB/V) and
45
other related linear polyesters, have significant opportunities for marketability. PHA
46
production from mixed cultures and renewable organic wastes as a carbon source
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
3,4,5
has
Page 3 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
47
become very attractive over the last years due to the decrease in the production cost of the
48
process6,7. Activated sludge from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) is a well-known
49
source of PHA-storing organisms that store these polymers as carbon and energy reserve for
50
biomass growth. PHA production from mixed cultures are accomplished by a sequence of
51
operations which are the following8,9: i) acidogenic fermentation to produce volatile fatty
52
acids (VFAs) from biodegradable organics; ii) selection of PHA storing biomass in a
53
sequencing batch reactor (SBR); iii) a batch process to maximise the PHA accumulation in
54
the bacteria.
55
The carbon excess and limitation strategy under feast and famine conditions has been found
56
to be favourable for the enrichment and long-term cultivation of PHA producing
57
communities. Nitrogen limitation is a successful strategy that can be employed to accomplish
58
high PHA contents during the PHA production step 10. However, these processes are aerobic
59
and thus are energy intensive; it is estimated that approximately 39 MJ are needed to produce
60
1 kg of PHA when the aerobic accumulation step is employed11,12.
61
The integration of nutrient removal in wastewater treatment systems with the PHA
62
production cycle is currently a challenge. Jiang et al. (2009)13, Morgan-Sagastume et al.
63
(2010)14 and Pittmann et al. (2014)15 evaluated the potential for the enrichment of PHA-
64
storing organisms and the PHA-storage capacity of fermented sludge under different
65
operational conditions. It was found that PHA producing organisms could be successfully
66
enriched using the fermented sludge as feedstock, although very high nutrient loads did limit
67
the maximum level of PHA accumulation14. Morgan-Sagastume et al. (2010)14 also examined
68
a new concept of WWTP operation, where the selection of PHA storing biomass was
69
accomplished based on the conversion of the readily biodegradable chemical oxygen demand
70
(COD) from municipal wastewater without its pre-conversion to VFAs16. However, post-
71
treatment was required, in particular for enhanced nutrient removal of the treated effluent.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
72
Anterrieu et al (2014)17 studied the integration of PHA production with conventional
73
nitrification and denitrification for the treatment of sugar beet factory waters, by operating an
74
anoxic feast and aerobic famine phase. In the sludge treatment line of municipal wastewater
75
treatment plants, however, the nutrient loads are typically much higher, and side-stream
76
treatment is an attractive option to avoid recycling these nutrients to the main treatment line.
77
Short-cut nitrogen removal processes via the nitrite pathway have been found to provide an
78
attractive means of achieving nutrient removal from sludge reject waters at lower operating
79
expenses compared to conventional nitrification-denitrification process18. Frison et al.
80
(2014)19 compared the potential PHA storage of sludge under nitrifying and non-nitrifying
81
conditions in batch reactors, and found PHA production yields of 0.6 Cmol PHA/Cmol VFA
82
in both systems. Nevertheless, the feasibility of integrating PHA production with nutrient
83
removal via nitrite has not been investigated.
84 85
In this work, a novel process treating sludge reject water that integrates the side-stream
86
biological nitrogen removal via nitrite process with the selection of mixed culture PHA
87
storing biomass is examined in large lab-scale reactors fed with real wastewater. A modified
88
pathway for nitrogen removal was developed and applied in order to induce a feast and
89
famine regime under aerobic and anoxic conditions, respectively. The novel approach is
90
based on (i) the selection of PHA storing biomass in a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) by the
91
alternation of aerobic feast conditions for ammonia conversion to nitrite followed by anoxic
92
famine conditions for denitritation driven by internally stored PHA as carbon source; (ii)
93
establishment of the desired COD/N ratio for the selection of PHA storing biomass by
94
controlling the dose of the external carbon source and the nitrogen contained in the sludge
95
reject water. A side-stream treatment technology able to integrate the conversion of
96
fermented sludge to PHAs with nutrient removal via nitrite would enable the simultaneous
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 31
Page 5 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
97
reduction of nutrient loads to the main line of the WWTPs, lowering operational costs, with
98
the recovery of a valuable resource, PHA, providing further economic advantages to the
99
WWTP.
100 101
MATERIAL AND METHODS
102 103
2.1 Experimental set-up
104
Figure 1 shows two alternative configurations applied for nitrogen removal via nitrite and the
105
selection of PHA storing biomass downstream from the anaerobic digester. In configuration 1,
106
the nitrogen removal through nitritation/denitritation and the PHA selection process occurred
107
in a single SBR by applying a feast and famine regime. Specifically, during aerobic
108
conditions, ammonium was oxidized to nitrite and the VFAs converted to PHA, while during
109
the anoxic famine conditions, nitrite was reduced to nitrogen gas (N2) using the internally
110
stored PHAs as carbon source (Figure 1a). Ideally, the aerobic reaction should coincide with
111
the feast phase and the anoxic reaction with the famine conditions. Good selection of PHA
112
storing biomass has been observed with the decrease of the feast/famine ratio24. However, in
113
this work, the aerobic reaction time should also be long enough to ensure adequate
114
availability of nitrite for denitritation. The external carbon source was only added during the
115
beginning of the aerobic phase. Consequently, an efficient famine condition under anoxic
116
conditions can occur when enough nitrite is available for the complete utilization of PHA, in
117
the absence of biodegradable organic matter. The theoretical stoichiometry of the process
118
imposes that the ratio of PHA stored (as COD) to the nitrite denitrified (i.e. gCODPHA/gNO2-
119
N), should not exceed the stoichiometric value of 1.72/(1-YHD). The heterotrophic yield
120
under anoxic conditions (YHD) is equal to 0.54 gCODproduced/gCODremoved27,31. In
121
configuration 2, the ammonium conversion to nitrite and the selection of the PHA storing
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
122
biomass (Figure 1b) were accomplished in two separate SBRs. Nitritation was carried out in a
123
dedicated SBR and then the liquid was fed to the selection reactor while operated under
124
famine conditions, accomplishing the denitritation using the stored PHA. In the selection
125
reactor, the COD/N ratio was adjusted by feeding the external carbon source based on the
126
sludge reject water fed, which was the main source of nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus).
127
The PHA accumulation step of the examined process was performed in a fed-batch reactor to
128
maximize the cellular PHA content of the biomass harvested from the selection stage. The
129
volatile fatty acids (VFAs) that are required for the feast conditions in the selection reactor
130
and the PHA accumulation in the batch reactor were recovered from the acidogenic
131
fermentation of sewage sludge. Fermented liquid from sewage sludge (SFL) was used as
132
VFA source. The process is described in detail in the work of Longo et al. (2015)20. The
133
technical details of the applied configurations are given below. In total the SBR was operated
134
for 150 days, where sludge inoculum was added only at day 1 of operation.
135 136
2.1.1 Configuration 1 (Figure 1a). This configuration combined the PHA biomass selection
137
and nitrogen removal via nitrite process in only one SBR. The SBR had a working volume of
138
26 L. Full details of the SBR are reported in the supporting information (SI). The cycles of
139
the SBR consisted of 5 min of feeding, 300 min of reaction phase (aerobic and anoxic), 15
140
min of settling and 5 min of discharge. As a first starting cycle, the length of the aerobic
141
phase was set up at the same length of the feast phase (50 min). Then, the length of the
142
anoxic phase (250 minutes) was derived by imposing a feast/famine ratio of 0.2, which is
143
recommended in order to achieve good selection of PHA storing biomass24.
144
The impact of combining the ammonium oxidation to nitrite, denitritation and selection of the
145
PHA storing biomass in a single reactor was evaluated by altering the percentage of the
146
aerobic versus the total cycle duration. The aerobic reaction duration varied from 17 to 30%
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 31
Page 7 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
147
(Period 1, days 0-50) and from 30 to 50% (Period 2, days 51-108) of the total cycle duration.
148
This variation was introduced in order to compare the effect of the availability of nitrite on
149
the process. Two experimental periods were performed using configuration 1 and adopting
150
different COD/N ratios (Table 1).
151 152
The target COD/N was achieved by supplying the same volume of sewage sludge
153
fermentation liquid (SFL) according to the organic loading rate of VFA (OLRVFA) of 623±55
154
(Period 1) and 684±43 gCODVFA/m3d (Period 2) and altering the volumetric nitrogen loading
155
rate (vNLR) by adjusting the feeding of the sludge reject water. The total organic loading rate
156
(total vOLR) applied to the system was 716±32 and 820±62 gCOD/m3d, respectively, for
157
Period 1 and Period 2, where the sludge reject water accounted for less than 25% of the total
158
vOLR applied. Table 1 reports the operating conditions adopted during the examined periods.
159
In the first period, the feast conditions were established at the beginning of the aerobic phase
160
by applying a COD/N ratio of 5.6±0.1 gCODVFA/gNH4-N, which was similar with others
161
using sewage sludge fermentation liquid as carbon source14,15. In the second period, the initial
162
COD/N was decreased to 2.1±0.02 gCODVFA/gNH4-N by the increase of the volumetric
163
nitrogen loading rate (vNLR) up to 380±29 gN/m3d. The solids retention time (SRT) was
164
kept within the range of 12-15 days throughout each experimental period. During period 1,
165
transient conditions prevailed as the process was not sustainable due to the very high
166
CODPHA/NO2-N at the beginning of the anoxic phase. To overcome this problem the length
167
of the aerobic phase was increased in order to promote nitritation, and some PHA
168
consumption. In Period 2, the length of the aerobic phase was maintained at 135±16 min,
169
which corresponded to 45±12% of the total cycle duration. The small variation in the length
170
of the aerobic period was introduced to balance the variability of the nitrification rate due to
171
temperature variations and thus have a similar nitrite concentration at the end of the aerobic
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
172
phase. In this way, the CODPHA/NO2-N ratio was maintained relatively constant when the
173
anoxic phase started during period 2, and was considered to be a key factor for defining the
174
SBR operational cycle.
175 176
(Table 1)
177
(Figure 1a and 1b)
178 179
2.1.2 Configuration 2 (Figure 1b). This Configuration involved two SBRs, one nitritation
180
SBR (N-SBR) dedicated solely to the nitritation process and another SBR for the selection of
181
PHA storing biomass and the denitritation process. The N-SBR was applied as a pre-
182
treatment stage to enhance the oxidation of ammonium to nitrite (nitritation). The N-SBR
183
was operated in the following sequence: 15 min feeding, 4 h aeration reaction phase, 30 min
184
settling, 15 min decanting. A detailed description of the operating conditions of the N-SBR is
185
given in the SI. The nitrified sludge reject water exiting from the N-SBR reactor contained
186
ammonium in the range of 25 to 67 mgN/L, while the average level of nitrite was
187
approximately 350 mgN/L. After settling, the clarified effluent from the N-SBR was
188
temporarily collected in a storage tank (80 L of volume) and was then fed to the selection
189
SBR during the first 10-12 minutes of the anoxic phase based on a volumetric nitrogen
190
loading rate of 530±11 gN/m3d, which corresponded to a volumetric nitrite loading rate of
191
423±95 gNO2-N/m3d. The loading rate of the carbon source during the feast was balanced
192
with the nitrite loading rate applied during the famine phase based on the ratio 2.2±0.1
193
gCOD/gNO2-N. The operational cycle of the selection SBR consisted of 50 minutes of
194
aerobic phase, followed by 250 minutes of anoxic conditions. The length for the feeding,
195
settling and discharging phases were respectively 15, 30 and 15 minutes. The SRT was kept
196
in the same range as for Configuration 1, 12-15 days.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 31
Page 9 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
197 198
2.2
199
The biomass was collected under famine conditions (end of the anoxic phase from the
200
selection SBR) and was concentrated gravimetrically by applying 30 min of settling. The aim
201
was to reduce the level of nutrients contained in the biomass obtained from the selection SBR.
202
Then, the biomass was placed in triplicate fed-batch glass reactors with working volumes of
203
1 L that were equipped with blowers, diffusers and probes for the measurement of the
204
dissolved oxygen (DO, type WTW, CellOx® 325), the pH (Polyplast Pro) and the
205
temperature (PT100). The on-line signals were automatically recorded. The DO level was
206
always maintained above 2 mg/L. The oxygen uptake rate (OUR) was determined using the
207
respirometer MARTINA (SPESS, Italy). The substrate was divided in fixed volume aliquots
208
in order to dose manually each time approximately 1 gCOD/L of VFAs. New aliquots were
209
dosed when consecutive OUR values were ~ 50% less than the previously recorded values. In
210
order to test different COD/N/P ratios during the PHA accumulation, three different carbon
211
sources were applied; a synthetic mixture of VFA (COD/N/P 100:0:0), sewage sludge
212
fermentation liquid (SFL) (COD/N/P 100:9.7:2.1) and sewage sludge fermentation liquid
213
with wollastonite (WSFL) (COD/N/P 100:7.8:0.06). In the latter, the use of wollastonite
214
during fermentation improves the CODVFA/NH4-N/PO4-N ratio, since it limits the net release
215
of nutrients (ammonium and phosphate). The duration of the accumulation test was 6-8 h.
PHA accumulation
216 217
2.3
218
In this study the VFAs concentration, expressed as mgCOD/L, was calculated as follows:
219
Calculations
VFAs=∑ (HAc + HPr + HBt+ iso-HBt + HPt + isoHPt + HHe + HHp)
(1)
220
where: HAc is acetic, HPr is propionic, HBt is butyric, iso-HBt is iso-butyric, HPt is
221
pentanoic, isoHPt is iso-pentanoic, HHe is hexanoic and HHp is heptaoic acid.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 10 of 31
222
The PHA concentration was converted into COD units following the oxidation stoichiometry:
223
1.67 mgCOD/mgPHB, 1.92 mgCOD/mgPHV and 2.10 mgCOD/mgPHH. The total PHA
224
concentration was calculated as sum of PHB, PHV and PHH concentrations:
225
PHA (mgCOD/L) =∑(PHB+PHV+PHH)
(2)
226
The amount of PHA (g/L) was subtracted from the VSS (g/L) to calculate the concentration
227
of non-polymer biomass, or active biomass (Xa, g/L). The latter was transformed as COD
228
concentration by the stoichiometric ratio of 1.42 gCOD/gVSS26.The fraction of the PHA in
229
the biomass was calculated considering the following equation: PHA(%) =
230
ୌ ୗୗ
× 100
(3)
231
where the gPHA and the VSS were respectively the PHA and the volatile suspended solids of
232
the biomass. The specific VFA uptake rate (-qVFA, mgCOD/gXah) and the PHA storage rate
233
(qPHA, mgCOD/gXah), were determined by linear regression analysis by plotting the
234
concentration of VFAs and PHA as a function of time. The results were normalized for the
235
active biomass concentration Xa and reported at the same operating temperature of the
236
reactor,
237
gCODPHA/gCODVFA) and the growth yield (YX/VFA, gCODX/gCODVFA) were calculated as the
238
ratio between each maximum specific rate (qPHA and qX, respectively) and the -qVFA.
which
varied
between
21-27
°C.
The
PHA
storage
yield
(YPHA/VFA,
239 240
2.4
241
The concentrations of the mixed liquor suspended solids (MLSS), mixed liquor volatile
242
suspended solids (MLVSS), chemical oxygen demand (COD), soluble chemical oxygen
243
demand (sCOD), total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), ammonium (NH4-N), and total phosphorous
244
(TP) were determined according to standard methods22. Nitrite (NO2-N), nitrate (NO3-N) and
245
phosphate (PO4-P) concentrations were determined by the ion chromatograph Dionex ICS-
246
900 with AS14 as column, while the concentrations of HAc, HPr, HBt, iso-HBt, HPt, isoHPt
Analytical methods
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 11 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
247
and HHe and heptanoic acid were determined by liquid chromatography through a Dionex
248
ICS-1100 with IonPac ICE-AS1 as column. Samples of biomass were collected from the
249
selection and accumulation reactors and the liquor was removed through centrifugation. Then,
250
the thickened biomass was freeze-dried with a lyophilisation unit (Lio 5P, 5Pascal, Milano,
251
Italy) and analysed for the content of PHA using the method developed by Lanham et al.,
252
(2013)23. The specific ammonium uptake rate (sAUR) and specific nitrogen uptake rate
253
(sNUR) were determined in situ following the procedures that are given in SI. The sAUR and
254
sNUR were corrected to the reference temperature of 20oC using the Arrhenius equation. The
255
nitrogen mass balances were calculated for each experimental period (see SI).
256 257
The final biopolymers produced during the accumulation stage were also extracted from the
258
freeze-dried biomass by applying the chloroform method (50 mL/g of freeze-dried biomass)
259
followed by the addition of methanol as precipitation agent1. Then, the biopolymers were
260
analysed through size exclusion chromatography (SEC, Polymer Lab) in order to determine
261
the molecular number (Mn), average molecular weights (Mw) and the polydispersity indices
262
(PDI). The glass transition temperature (Tg), melting temperature (Tm) and melting enthalpy
263
(DHm) were determined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC, TA Instruments). More
264
information about the procedures are available in the SI.
265 266
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
267
3.1 Efficiency of the single stage reactor configuration
268
3.1.1 Period 1. At the beginning of period 1, the biomass showed a typical feast and famine
269
response. The duration of the feast phase was approximately 16% of the total cycle duration.
270
At the completion of the aerobic phase, the ammonium conversion to nitrite was 36±13%,
271
producing only 6.5 mgNO2-N/L. Figures 2a and 2b shows the ammonium, nitrite, nitrate,
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
272
OUR VFAs and PHAs profile for period 1. The OUR profile showed a dramatic decrease
273
once the VFAs were depleted. On one hand this showed that the famine period was reached
274
and also that the nitrification rate was very low. The main electron acceptor available during
275
the feast conditions was oxygen, while nitrite was the only electron acceptor present during
276
the famine period. In this period, steady state conditions were not achieved, which is pointed
277
out by the high variation (higher than 50%) of the average –qVFA during feast conditions
278
(Figure 4 and Table 2). Despite the relatively high DO concentration during the aerobic phase,
279
the nitrification activity of the biomass seems to be negatively affected by the presence of
280
VFAs during the feast phase, since the sAUR decreased from the initial value of 15-18
281
mgN/gXa h (measured in the inoculum) to 4.18±1.93 mgN/gXa h within 15 days of operation.
282
This is likely due to the faster biomass growth rate of VFAs consuming heterotrophic
283
organisms as opposed to nitrifying autotrophs27. As a consequence, the ratio between the
284
PHA stored (COD based) and the nitrite concentration at the beginning of the anoxic phase
285
was 15.5 gCODVFA/gNO2-N, which was too high to allow for complete PHA degradation
286
under famine conditions. The lack of nitrite availability under anoxic conditions resulted in
287
poor nitrogen removal efficiency for this period (Table 2). Under denitrifying famine
288
conditions, the efficiency of PHA consumption was not more than 41±1% due to the shortage
289
of nitrite as electron acceptor (Figure 4). As a result, the PHA accumulated in the selection
290
reactor up to 0.21 gCODPHA/gCODX (Figure 2b). Maintaining efficient famine conditions,
291
where the stored PHA is consumed, has been found to be of high importance in achieving a
292
selected culture with a high PHA storage capacity24. During the first period, the –qVFA
293
decreased down to 4 mgCOD/gXa h (day 28, Figure 4) and the YPHA/VFA from 0.31 to 0.07
294
gCOD/gCODVFA (Figure 4). To conclude, the process of PHA biomass selection and nitrogen
295
removal via nitrite was not sustainable due to the low availability of nitrite, and the resulting
296
low degradation of the PHA during the famine period.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 31
Page 13 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
297 298
To promote the growth of the PHA storing bacteria during the anoxic/famine conditions, the
299
ammonium conversion to nitrite was enhanced by doubling the duration of the aerobic phase,
300
while maintaining constant the applied vNLR and the total vOLR (days 29 to 50). The
301
amount of nitrite increased up to 26 mgNO2-N/L and the nitrogen removal efficiency was
302
70.1%. The higher duration of the aerobic phase favoured the degradation of the PHA up to
303
66% (Figure 4, day 39) under famine conditions, due to the more abundant presence of
304
electron acceptors. However, it was found that ~30% of the previously stored PHA was
305
consumed under aerobic/famine conditions before the anoxic-famine period initiated. The
306
increase in the aerobic period resulted in an aeration time that exceeded the feast phase
307
duration for the applied vOLR, leading to some aerobic PHA degradation. The PHA content
308
at the end of the anoxic famine conditions was constantly below 0.7 % (gPHA/gVSS).
309
Furthermore, at the end of period 1 (days 29-50), the –qVFA increased together with the
310
YPHA/VFA up to 110±63 mgCOD/gXa h and 0.23±0.01 gCODPHA/gCODVFA (Figure 4),
311
respectively.
312
3.1.2 Period 2. Once the duration of the feast and famine phases were maintained relatively
313
stable, with deviations in the order of 5-7% from the average value for at least 12 consecutive
314
days (corresponding to one SRT), the vNLR was increased to 380±29 gN/m3d in order to
315
enhance the treatment capacity of the system, while maintaining constant the vOLR. Slight
316
alterations of the duration of the aerobic reaction were implemented in order to ensure
317
sufficient conversion of ammonium to nitrite, and to control the CODPHA/NO2-N ratio
318
between 2.0 and 2.2 gCODPHA/gNO2-N at the start of the anoxic/famine phase. In this way,
319
the effects of changes in temperature and in reject water were counterbalanced. More
320
specifically, aerobic conditions were maintained for 45±12% of the total cycle duration. The
321
sAUR slightly increased up to 5.5±0.5 mgN/gXa h during the aerobic conditions, and the
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
322
nitrite concentration was 32±12 mgNO2-N/L. As a result, more pronounced PHA production
323
and consumption were observed in the feast and famine phases, respectively, during days 51-
324
108 (Figure 2 c and d). During the last 33 days (days 75-108) of period 2, pseudo-steady state
325
conditions prevailed, where the average –qVFA was 197±9 mgCOD/gXa h (Figure 4),
326
resulting in the decrease of the ratio of the feast to the total cycle length from 0.19-0.20
327
(period 1) to 0.15-0.18 (period 2). The higher capacity of the biomass to store PHA was
328
confirmed by the YPHA/VFA, which increased from 0.23±0.01 (period 1) to 0.40±0.01 (period
329
2) gCODPHA/gCODVFA (Figure 4). Furthermore, more than 80% of the PHA was degraded
330
during the aerobic and anoxic famine conditions (days 87-108, Figure 4). Although the
331
denitritation efficiency of the nitrogen available for denitrification was always higher than
332
94%, the average nitrogen removal was still very low (48.8±3.4%, average value, see SI)
333
since significant residual ammonium concentration remained. The performance of the process
334
would clearly be improved if the ammonium conversion to nitrite increased. Thus, an
335
alternate process configuration (Configuration 2) was studied in order to increase nitrogen
336
removal and augment PHA production further.
337
(Figure 2a, b, c, d)
338
(Figure 3a and 3b)
339
(Figure 4)
340 341
3.2 Efficiency of the configuration 2 with two separate reactors
342
To cope with the residual ammonium concentration, in configuration 2 a two stage process
343
was applied for nitritation and selection of PHA storing biomass. Ammonium was first
344
oxidized in the N-SBR (Figure 1b) and then the liquid was fed in the selection reactor when
345
the anoxic reaction phase started. Figure 3 (a and b) shows the typical profiles of ammonium,
346
nitrite, PHA, OUR and VFA concentration that were obtained in the selection SBR after
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 31
Page 15 of 31
Environmental Science & Technology
347
adopting configuration 2 (day 109 to 150). The period of higher stability of the process was
348
achieved during days 125-150, where pseudo-steady-state conditions were considered due to
349
the low variation of the average –qVFA, qPHA and YPHA/VFA during the feast phases. In this
350
period, the VFA were completely depleted within the first 30 min of the aerobic phase,
351
resulting in a –qVFA of 239±7 mgCOD/gXa h (Figure 4). Under feast conditions, the PHA of
352
the biomass rapidly increased at a qPHA of 89±7 mgCOD/gXa h, which is higher compared
353
to the respective value of configuration 1. The average YPHA/VFA of 0.42±0.04
354
gCODPHA/gCODVFA was similar compared to Period 2 of the previous configuration (Figure
355
4). However, in Configuration 2, a similar YPHA/VFA was accomplished with a substantially
356
higher vOLR (1394±112 gCOD/m3d), highlighting the advantage of operating with a separate
357
reactor for nitrification and PHA biomass selection. After 50 min of aerobic phase, the
358
anoxic-famine phase started by switching off the blower and feeding the effluent of the N-
359
SBR. In configuration 2, nitrite was the only electron acceptor for the PHA degradation for
360
denitritation during the famine conditions. Furthermore, this strategy allowed a better control
361
of the applied CODPHA/NO2-N, avoiding nitrite limitation in the famine phase and enabling
362
higher nitrogen removal efficiency (Table 2). Figure 3a shows the increase of the nitrite
363
content at the start of the anoxic phase (up to 75 mgNO2-N/L). At the end of the anoxic phase,
364
the PHA was consumed, reaching a minimum concentration of 0.6% (gPHA/gVSS) at the
365
end of the anoxic cycle. This fact indicates that almost all the stored PHAs were degraded.
366
The PHA consumption efficiency was high and stable during the days 118 to 150 (86±4%,
367
Figure 4). Additionally, during the anoxic famine phase, the ammonium nitrogen decreased
368
from 28 to 21 mgNH4-N/L; this reduction was correlated with the growth of the PHA storing
369
bacteria. The rate of PHA degradation during the famine phase has been found to be
370
independent of the type of electron acceptor present16. The famine (anoxic) duration and the
371
carbon stored were enough to achieve almost 90% of denitritation. The nitrite at the end of
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
372
the cycle decreased to 15 mgNO2-N/L. However, the nitrite concentration in the effluent was
373
7-10 mgNO2-N/L, indicating that denitritation also occurred during the sedimentation but
374
without any rising of sludge. This was confirmed by the low content of suspended solids in
375
the treated effluent (