I
INSTRUMENTATION
Advisory Panel Jonathan W. Amy Glenn L. Booman Robert L. Bowman
Jack W. Frazer G.Phillip Hicks Donald R. Johnson
I
Howard V. Malmstadt Marvin Margoshes William F. Ulrich
Mulheim Computer System for Analytical Instrumentation Engelbert Ziegler, Dieter Henneberg, and Gerhard Schomburg
Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Kohlenforschung, Mulheim/Ruhr, Germany
The close connection of an analytical on-line system t o a large computational system will certainly stimulate the application of advanced analytical methods
DVRIKG
THE PAST few years a number of different approaches in the computerization of analytical instruments have been described. &lost commonly the instruments are connected to small “dedicated” computers. Another approach consists of a medium-sized computer system (e.g., IBM 1800) servicing several not too dissimilar instruments simultaneously (1,.2). A different solution has been developed a t the Max-Planck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung in Mulheim, Germany ( 3 , 4). This institute is a research institute for organometallic chemistry and radiation chemistry with extended analytical, physical, and physicochemical laboratories. A large time-sharing computer (PDP 10) has been installed t o meet t)he computational requirements for both general off -line computations and realtime acquisition and analysis of data from a variety of on-line analytical instruments. This paper describes the hardware configuration of the Miilheim computer system and the basic structure of the analytical on-line system incorporated into the interactive, conversational PDP 10 timesharing mode.
Computational Requirements
There are two distinct areas of computer applications a t the hliilheim institute: (1) Off-line computations for X-ray diffractometry Molecular orbital calculations Chemical kinetics Spectra simulations and iterations Documentation and search of spectra Documentation of literature Administration (2) Real-time data acquisition and analysis for ( a ) “Slow” instruments (data rates I 20 Ha) 20-30 Gas chromatographs 1 Mass spectrometer 2-3 Nmr instruments 1 Ir-spectrometer 1 Raman spectrometer 1 Esr instrument 1 Spectropolarimeter ( b ) “Fast” instruments (data rates between 1.25 and 20 kHz) 2 Low-resolution, fast-scan mass spectrometers 1 Pulsed nmr instrument Hardware Configuration (Figure 1)
The hardware Of the PDP lo central processing unit includes re-
r
I
--3---2K 1
:Expansion:
(36 bit)
paper tape
(5000K) 2 magnetic tapes
contact scanner
,nstr
with multiplexer
Figure 1. Hardware configuration of the Mulheim Computer System Dashed lines indicate the main expansions scheduled for 1970
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
51 A
Instrumentation
location and protection registers, floating-point and bit-handling instructions and seven levels of priority-nested interrupts. Core memory consists of 32K words of 36 bits (1 psec cycle time) and is connected through a fast data channel to a fixed-head disk with 1 7 msec of average access time, 13 psec transfer time per word and a capacity of 500K words. User programs are temporarily transferred from core memory to this disk (swapping), whenever core space becomes too small for all of the concurrently running programs. But part of the disk is also used for data storage and for system programs such as compilers, assemblers, and text editors. The present set of peripheral devices includes a line printer, card reader, plotter, magnetic tape units, paper tape units, and 14 teletype terminals. Several special devices are interfaced to the PDP 10 for the realtime data acquisition. There is one A / D converter (analog-to-digital) to service up to 32 slow, simultaneously running instruments connected through a multiplexer. This ADC provides 13 bits of resolution within a useful dynamic range of about lo6 subdivided into 11 different gain ranges. The maximum over-all data rate of this device is 8 kHz with programmed selection of gain ranges and 3.3 kHz with automatic range selection. AutoCircle
52A
No.
17
on Readers’ Service Card
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
matic (hardware) selection is slower because the range for the full conversion is determined by an additional preceding conversion cycle. For fast instruments, fastscan mass spectrometers, another A / D converter is used, capable of data rates between 1.25 and 20 kHz. This ADC provides 10 bits of resolution within a dynamic range of 2.5 X lo5 subdivided into three gain ranges. A multiplexer connects eight data lines to this -4DC. But, to avoid conflicts with the general time-sharing system, only one fast instrument is allowed to transmit data a t any given time. Because of the very short time 2 or 3 secperiods-typically when such a fast instrument will be active, this restriction is not a serious one. The timing for the real-time data acquisition is provided by a realtime clock, operating with 20 kHz pulses and R preset counter for each A/D converter, loaded by program. A contact scanner and a line driyer are able to control 72 external relay contacts each. With these devices, the operating system services start and stop requests, as well as certain instrument control functions. The capability of the contact scanner to interrupt the processor allows discontinuously scanning instruments, such as infrared spectrometers, to request an A/D conversion by closing the associated external relay.
One man can analyze 50 chromatograms a day.
Simply inject your sample The computer-based lets you sum several peaks together and treat GLC-8 will type out an accurate, reproducible them as a single component Data can be stored chromatographic analysis as soon as the run is for re-analysis finished You can use the GLC-8 profitably with as few as 5 chromatographs A n d you can expand to 64 chroThe GLC-8 is the lowest priced system of its type - easy to use thoroughly tested, ready now The matographs on the same system Send for our first G L C - 8 system installed 18 months ago runs booklet and we'll tell you all about it 24 hours a day, 7 days a Write or call Bradley Dewey week - 3000 analyses per Please send me complete information on the GLC-8 I l l , Digital Equipment Corsystem for automatic analysis of gas-liquid chrornamonth. 146 Main Street, poration, tographic data. The GLC-8 permits the use Maynard, Massachusetts Name of mu It i ple reference peaks 01 754. T e l e p h o n e : (61 7) a n d i n t e r n a l s t a n d a r d s . It 897-51 11. Title Company
Phone
Address-
-_
_UvlIPUTERS
City
~
Stat-e-
2p i-
MOOU, E 5
Circle No. 31 on Readen' Service Card
Introducing new Chromosorb105
Instrumentation Time-Sharing Organization
The present system allows up to 15 concurrently running jobs (each job may run one program), which are initiated and controlled by the various teletype terminals distributed all over the institute. The hardware protection of the central processor provides the possibility of keeping several jobs in core separated, without interference, by allowing only “legal” memory references. Jobs may be shuffled in core or swapped out to the disk and located into different core areas when brought in again, because memory references are displaced by adding the contents of the relocation register during execution. Commands from the teletype terminals are interpreted by the operating system “monitor.” The monitor also determines the job which is actually run by the central processor, and controls the allocation of the system resources t o the various jobs. Whenever a running job becomes unrunnable-for instance, when starting input or output activities via one of the seven interrupt levels-or after certain time slices, the monitor looks for another job to run. Because of this time-sharing capabiIity, the system is flexibIe enough to handle simultaneously many analytical instruments requiring different data acquisition and different data analysis methods. Software Organization
Chromosorb 105 is a polyaromatic porous resin developed by Johns-Manville for use as chromatographic packing. As one of the Chromosorb “Century Series,” it has intermediate polarity. With proper handling, it is stable to 250” C and provides efficient separation of aqueous mixtures containing formaldehyde, acetylene from lower hydrocarbons, and most gases and organic compounds in the boiling range up to 200” C. For more specific information, write for our bulletin FF-194A. Johns-Manville, Box 1960, Trenton, New Jersey. Chromosorb 105 is also available in Canada and overseas. Cable: Johnmanvil.
Johns-Manville
!ila
Chromosorb I S a Johns-Manville registered trademark for its brand of products developed for use as support material or adsorbents for gas chrornotography. Circle No. 63 on Readers’ Service Card
54A
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
The analytical instrumentation software is of course different for the slow and the fast instruments. These two software packages are each subdivided into (1) Code within the monitor (2) D a t a acquisition programs (3) Basic-analysis programs (4) Refined-analysis programs (5) Miscellaneous auxiliary programs (e.g., data plotting and testing programs) Software for Slow Instruments
Within the monitor a special routine looks a t start or stop requests of any instruments every 20 msec. Every 50 msec (thus limiting the maximum data rate for a single instrument to 20/sec), a list of slow instruments is created, for which a
New from Coleman-fast-scanning Double-beam, UV-VIS Spectrophotometer with LINEAR absorbance readout.
Coleman's Model 124 brings YOU rapid scanning speeds and the only linear absorbance readout ever offered in a (OWcost, double-beam grating instrument. With the new Model 124 Hitachi Spectrophotometer you can now do fully automatic ratio recording in the 190 to 800 m p ra nge, without logarithmic scales. M o d e I 124 presentation is linear in both absorbance and transmittance. Now, for the first time, you get maximum readability with both high and low absorbance values. You can obtain readings in Oto 2.0absorbance, or expand your readings with the 0 to 1.0 absorbance range.
You'll get three times as much work done, too. Model 124 operates at four scanning speeds up to 240 rnp per minute. Scans the entire visible range in less than two minutes, with PerfOrrYlanCe comparable to that Of Slower Scanning instruments. There's much more to Model 124. plug-in, solid-state circuitry. Automatic filter sys. tern. A large sample compartment that accepts cells up to rnm, Quick switching to single-beam manual operation. A new, companion Model 165 Linear Recorder that matches the speed, precision and linearity of Model 124. Learn more about the outstanding perforr'nance characteristics of this new spectrophotometer, available in two ranges190 to 700 mp and 190 to 800 mp, Send today for Coleman Bulletin A-312.
"Visit Booths 280-281-Natl. Chemical Exposition" Write to Coleman Instruments Division, The Perkin-Elmer Corporation, 42 Madison St., Maywood, Illinois 60153 Circle No. 22 on Readers' Service Card
PERKIN-ELMER
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
55A
instrumentation
conversion has to be started. When a conversion is completed, the data word from the ADC is brought in on interrupt level and stored into buffers of the data acquisition job. This data job ( G C D I R ) is started a t system-setup time and put into a deactivated status. Whenever one of the data buffers has been filled with A D C data, this program is activated by the monitor to empty the accumulated data into files on the disk, It is important t h a t no reduction or analysis of ADC data is performed a t this stage. Because ADC data are generated continuously, the data job may not be swapped but has to stay resident in core. I n this aspect, this job differs from normal time-sharing jobs. There is only one data job to service all of the slow instruments, but various different analysis programs may be started by the analyst in the laboratories a t any time. The basic-analysis programs process the files of unreduced ADC data after an instrument run has been stopped. These programs may be initiated as to check a t certain time periods automatically for any finished runs and they may control a large number of instruments which are using the same analysis methods, such as a group of gas chromatographs. The flexibility of this kind of software organization can be illustrated by gas chromatography. But the procedure with spectroscopic methods is quite similar. If a technician wants to run a gas Chromatogram, he first starts a parameter - type - in program (PARAM) from the teletype in his laboratory. If no parameters are specified, those of the previous chromatogram on the same channel are taken for the new run. The conversational parameter program asks him for the channel number, the data rate, the run time, and for report headings. Then he may inject his sample and start the acquisition of data by pressing the start button of the proper channel. The run is stopped either by the technician’s pressing the corresponding stop button or if the specified run time has elapsed. If the channel is under automatic control of a basic analysis program Circle No. 97 on Readers Service Card
56A
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
(GCAN), then this program will print an analysis report on the teletype and on to the disk. This report consists of a list of peaks with peak positions, intensities, normalized area percentages, peak half widths, and information about peak overlapping and shoulders. If the analyst is not satisfied with this basic analysis, he may request a more sophisticated one by starting one of the so-called refined analysis programs. For instance, he may wish to apply any special standardization, such as a determination of Kovats indices ( I N D E X ) , or he may want to discard several regions of the chromatogram, or he may want to start the analysis on the tail of a large peak to determine the areas of small peaks on the tail with better accuracy. All this refined analysis is performed without requiring a rerun of the chromatogram, because all the unreduced ADC data, as well as the report of the basic-analysis program, remain on the disk until the end of the next run on the same channel. This type of operation (analyzing the different chromatograms individually with a set of programs dependent on the result of the basic analysis) is especially suited for a laboratory in a research and development environment with a variety of different problems. I n the case of industry-type routine chromatography, some standard steps of the refined analysis would be incorporated into the basic-analysis program. A detailed description of the gas chromatography system and its performance and results will be given in a further paper. Software for Fast Instruments
The organization of the software for fast instruments differs in some aspects from that described for the slow instruments. For each fast instrument on-line an extra dataacquisition program is used, whereas all slow lines are handled by a single data job. As soon as a run of a fast instrument, such as a fast-scan mass spectrometer, is requested by closing one of the contacts controlled by the contact scanner, the data job associated with the requesting instrument is brought into core to accept all the data
from the ADC and stays in core as long as the instrument runs-just for a few seconds. During this period, no other start requests from fast instruments are accepted, because only one fast line is allowed to be active a t any given moment. The data acquisition of the simultaneously running slow instruments, of course, continues as well as timesharing response, for other jobs and service of computational programs are still guaranteed. This is possible because all input and output activities occur on different hardware interrupt levels and are accomplished within short periods of time, The normal data rate for fast-scan mass-spectrometer runs is 5 kHz. Thus, every 200 psec, a data word from the ADC is transferred. But the transfer itself takes only 6 psec, leaving the remaining 194 psec available for other tasks. Up to now, one fast-scan, lowresolution mass spectrometer ( M A T CH4) and a spin-echo nmr setup are connected on-line. For the latter, the data job just transfers the ADC data without any reduction to the disk. A time-averaging program or a Fourier transform program then reads the data from there. For the mass spectrometer, the associated data job performs a data reduction and writes these reduced data on the disk. Similar to the organization of the slow instruments, the analysis program is running in parallel to the data job waiting for any finished runs. -1 considerable amount of work has been put into the development of programs for the fast-scan lowresolution mass spectrometer. 1. D a t a reduction program
For pure water in the lab, you gain more than 15% by using the IWT Duplex Mounting fixture. With the Duplex, tap water enters the left (primary) cartridge, then the right side cartridge. So when the resin color change line drops to the warning line of the label, you can ignore it until it touches bottom. Then it's easy to return to full potential: throw away the used cartridge; shift the right side cartridge over; place a new one on the right side. Simple. Sure. Another advantage, the color change gives an advance idea when you must change cartridges; and the Duplex gives you time to do it yet keep the pure water pure as 15 megohms/cm. (.04ppm).
( BISDA4T) By preliminary peak-search, the 10,000 samples of a low resolution mass spectrum are reduced to 50-1000 intensities and poB u l 268 I S q u i t e e x p l i c i t about m o d e l s sitions of potential peaks, dep u r i t y levels resins fixtures and costs pending on intensity and mass W e w o u l d like to send y o u this 4-color range of the spectrum 4-page b r o c h u r e please ask f o r i t 2. Calibration of mass scale (MASCAL) Out of the reduced data of a ILLINOIS WATER TREATMENTCOMPANY i polyfluoro kerosine mass spec840 CEDAR ST., ROCKFORD, ILL. 61 105 trum, a list of positions of masses 1-1000 is created automatically 3. Evaluation of spectra out of reduced data (RIACO) I
1
Circle No. 54 on Readers' Service Card
58A
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
Masses and intensities of sharp peaks and metastables are determined peak intensities with a dynamic range of 3.104 4. Spectra are printed out in a normalized form as table on the line printer (REALAS) Presently a Varian-Statos recorder is interfaced to the system to provide fast output of spectra in the form of bargraphs in two different intensity scales simultaneously 5. A set of programs has been developed to test and to analyze unreduced ADC data and to check the performance of analysis algorithms. The operational procedures and the algorithms used for analysis and calibration purposes will be described later. The most difficult application incorporated into the hliilheim System is the automatic operation of a GC/RIS combination. I n this setup, high-resolution capillary-gas chromatography is applied, causing fast narrow peaks within the chromatogram. Therefore the system response time is a very critical parameter for this application. When a start of the mass spectrometer is necessary, the corresponding data job to receive the ADC data from the spectrometer normally resides on the swapping area of the disk. Some time is lost until this job is brought back into core memory. T o achieve the required response times of less than 1 sec, special modifications of the time-sharing monitor were necessary. I n the present implementation, the monitor checks a t certain time intervals for beginning and end of peaks iyithin the signal from the total ion current (representing the chromatogram) which is recorded via one line of the slow ADC system. Between the beginning and end of a peak, the monitor starts successive mass spectra. Up to now, this application is the only case in which, not only a real-time data acquisition, but also a realtime data analysis is performed. However, this mode of operation will be changed as soon as the core memory of the system is expanded. Then during the entire experiment, successive mass spectra will be started every 5 sec with cycling magnetic field (2-sec duration of
Du Pont puts the pressure on differential scannin calorimetry ith its exclusive Pressure DSC The Pressure Differential Scanning Calorimeter is the latest example of our continuing program to keep the
ow it is the first wit
Circle No. 30 on Rea
instrumentation
New 1 and 5 p l micro syringes eliminate the readability gap. Tired of squinting and guessing with conventional syringes? With Unimetrics’ patented Micro Syringes, you read the scale like a ruler not a thermometer. Parallax and glare are completely eliminated. One-point
Unimetrics featu
No Repair Proble
Status of Real. 7XA at 11:51:20 on 20=Feb=70 Uptime 17:17:20, 93%. Null Time Job
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Who
**, ** 30,50
** **
11, 30
** ** ** ** 15, 35 50, 101 14, 34
10
** **
11 12 13 14
52, 102 5, 11 13, 33 22, 42
Where
What
Size
State
Run time
DET TTY0 DET TTY15 DET DET TTYlL TTYM TTY3 CTY TTYl TTY6 TTY5 TTYll
GCDl R PIP TRADAT INDEX DSKILL MSDAT REMAS TECO TECO SYSTAT PIP PIP GCAN PARAM
2K 4K 3K 5K 1K 8K 6K 2K 2K 1K 4K 4K 13K 1K
SL
00: 00: 27 00:02:15
detailed brochure.
Unimetrics
Unimetrics Universal Corporation 1853 Raymond Avenue Anaheim, California 92801 (714) 879-3777
Circle NO. 106
60A
on Readers’ Senice Card
SL TT
IO SL tC TT tC RN TT tC TT TT
00: 00: 01 00: 00: 23 00: 00: 14 00: 00: 35 00:07:50 00: 04: 52 00:00:19 00: 00: 00 00: 02: 25 00:00:17 00: 00: 37 00: 00: 01
Figure 2. “System snapshot” illustrating the variety of simultaneously active timesharing jobs: GCDIR (job 1) is the data acquisition program for “slow” on-line instruments; TRADAT (job 3) transfers data from the fast ADC to the disk (used for pulsed nmr); MSDAT (job 6) transfers reduced mass spectra to the disk; GCAN (job 13) and REMAS (job 7) are analysis programs for gas chromatography and mass spectrometry; INDEX (job 4) is a refined analysis program for gc; PARAM (job 14) a parameter-specification program for runs of slow instruments
the active data transfer), but only valuable spectra are transferred t o the disk by the data acquisition and reduction program (MSDAT). During the remaining 3 sec, another mass spectrometer or fast instrument may be started. The G C / M combination is not yet running in a routine fashion, because some work on the analysis methods, especially for the intensity corrections of mass peaks with the total ion current, has still t o be done. Present System Performance
comes exa
tC
As the data acquisition is independent of the spectroscopic method, any instrument may be connected to the system, which delivers voltage signals betveen -10 and +IO V and runs either with data rates of 20 Hz and less or with rates between 1.25 and 20 kHz. Up t o now, one fast-scan, low-resolution mass spectrometer and one pulsed-nmr instrument are connected to the “fast” ADC, whereas 10 gas chromatographs (the electronic cleanup of the other gas chromatographs is not yet accomplished), 1-nmr, 1-ir spectrometer, and 1 spectropolarimeter are on-line via the slow ADC. The reliability of the system is improving after some difficulties in the beginning (mostly hardware
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
failures of the special real-time devices and a few, but nevertheless, disturbing monitor malfunctions). As a n average the system has one hardware breakdown every three weeks and about three software “crashes” every week. As shown by the null time in the system snapshot (Figure 2 ) , the central processor is far from being used t o its full capacity. But nevertheless there are two bottlenecks in the present system causing difficulties under heavy system load : (1) As the installation is not only used for the real-time applications, the present core memory is too small for the number of simultaneous users. The time-sharing monitor including the real-time code resides in 16K of core. T o allow up to 32 simultaneously running slow on-line instruments, the associated data job needs 3K of core permanentIy. Temporary restriction t o 20 simultaneously active lines saves 1K. But the remaining 14K of core is not sufficient for 15 concurrent jobs (even, if larger computational programs are run during the nights with a very small monitor), because too much processor time is wasted by swapping actions, and time-sharing response is decreased considerably, especially for programs with many input/output actions ( e . g . ,
Fortran compilations). Therefore the system is now being expanded by 32K of core. As swapping does not need C P U time, even during swap periods, the processor is available t o other programs which are in core. B u t if core memory is too limited no other programs will fit into the remaining core when large programs are being swapped. (2) The capacity (500K words) of the disk is too small for extensive data storage for all the users and especially for extensive storage of real-time data. Furthermore the future development of documentation systems for molecular spectra will need a large bulk of backup storage. Therefore the system will be expanded by the addition of disk packs. Discussion of System Layout
When we consider the system economics, we should keep in mind t h a t the Miilheim system had been designed to handle both off-line and on-line applications in theoretical and analytical chemistry. The purchase price of the system without the special devices for t h e realtime applications totals $450,000. This system would have been necessary for the off-line applications anyhow. The costs of the additional real-time hardware are about $65,000. The availability of resources such as a line printer, plotter, magnetic tapes, and disk, as well as the high computing power of a large computer system, proved t o be extremely useful in the development of the analytical instrumentation software. The use of high-level languages, such as Fortran, text editors, and debugging aids facilitate the writing, testing, and modifying of programs. T o find suitable algorithms for the analysis programs, a close look a t the unreduced A D C data is necessary. This can be accomplished by especially developed test programs. T h e fact t h a t all this program development could be done within the interactive time-sharing mode, thus avoiding long turn-around times of batch systems or tedious loading and testing procedures on small computers, has, without doubt, accelerated the development of programs. It seems to be obvious t h a t there
will be a n increasing need in the future for large computational programs in the field of analytical chemistry ( e . g . , extensive spectra iterations, spectra identification by documentation systems, “artificial intelligence’’ programs), which will use the output data from on-line systems for input. The close connection of the analytical on-line system t o a large computational system will certainly stimulate the application of advanced analytical methods. As far as the special hardware for the real-time data acquisition is concerned, some improvements t o the Miilheim system are possible. I n the present layout, all ADC data are handled by the C P U of t h e PDP 10, which has t o perform all the bookkeeping and sorting of these data. Connecting the slow A D C and its multiplexer to a small satellite computer as a data concentrator would decrease the load on the PDP 10 processor. T h e satellite could overtake most of this bookkeeping and data formatting and transfer the A D C data blockwise to the PDP 10 ( 5 ) . T h e Mulheim system will most certainly be modified in this way, if by increasing computational requirements the CPU time of the PDP 10 should be used to a much higher degree than it is now. Small satellites could also become desirable if the need for more realtime experimental control arises, It is difficult to incorporate extensive real-time functions into the timesharing monitor, and modifications to this code are tedious. Therefore small satellites are suited more for this type of application.
Until now you couldn’t get power, precision, l o w cost and small size all In one power supply.
ISCO has changed all that. The ISCO Model 490 Power Supply provides either constant current or constant voltage with unusual stability, compactness, and light weight. Any current from 0 to 150 ma can be obtained a t any voltage from 0 to 1,000 volts. Constant voltage or constant current output will not vary more than +0.3% throughout the entire range. RMS ripple and noise are less than .02%. The instrument iscompletelysolid state and is protected against overvoltage, overcurrent, and short circuits.
References
(1) Sederholm, C. H., Frindl, P. J., and Lusbrink, T. R., Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, March 1968. (2) Sederholm. C. H., 21st ACS Annual Summer Symposium on Analytical Chemistry, Penn State University, June 18-21, 1968. (3) Ziegler, E., Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy. March 1969. (4) Ziegler, E., Henneberg, D., and Schomburg, G., Pittsburgh Conference on Bnalytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, March 1970. ( 5 ) For a more general discussion : J. W. Frazer, Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, March 1970.
Please request brochure PS3 1 for complete information. INSTRUMENTATION SPECIALTIES CO. 4100 SUPERIOR LINCOLN, N E I R A S U 88504 PHONE 14011 41C0131 WILE ISCOUB LINCOLN
Circle NO. 57 on Readers’ Service Card
ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 42, NO. 9, AUGUST 1970
61 A