Effect of Atmospheric Mercury Deposition on Selenium Accumulation

Subscriber access provided by UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN LIBRARY

Article

Effect of atmospheric mercury deposition on selenium accumulation in rice (Oryza sativa L.) at a mercury mining region in Southwestern China Chao Zhang, Guangle Qiu, Christopher William Noel Anderson, Hua Zhang, Bo Meng, Liang Liang, and Xinbin Feng Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/es505827d • Publication Date (Web): 17 Feb 2015 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on February 18, 2015

Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.

Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.

Page 1 of 29

Environmental Science & Technology

1

Effect of atmospheric mercury deposition on selenium accumulation

2

in rice (Oryza sativa L.) at a mercury mining region in Southwestern

3

China

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24

Chao Zhang1, 2, Guangle Qiu1,*, Christopher W. N. Anderson3, Hua Zhang4, Bo Meng1, Liang Liang1, 2, Xinbin Feng1,* 1

State Key Laboratory of Environmental Geochemistry, Institute of Geochemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences,

Guiyang 550002, P.R. China 2

Graduate University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, P.R. China

3

Soil and Earth Sciences, Institute of Agriculture and Environment, Massey University, Palmerston North, New

Zealand 4

Contaminants in Aquatic Environments, Norwegian Institute for Water Research (NIVA), Gaustadalleen 21, Oslo

0349, Norway

*Corresponding Author: Xinbin Feng Phone: +86-851-5895728 Fax: +86-851-5891721 Email: [email protected]

25

1

ACS Paragon Plus Environment


26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46

Abstract: Selenium (Se) is an important trace element for human nutrition, and has an interactive effect on mercury (Hg) uptake by plants and Hg toxicity in animals. Rice (Oryza sativa L) is the dominant source of dietary Se in China, however the effect of soil Hg contamination on the Se concentration in rice is unknown. We collected 29 whole rice plant samples and corresponding soils from across an active artisanal mercury mining area and an abandoned commercial mercury mining area. The soil Se concentration was similar across the two mining areas and greater than the background concentration for China. However, the Se concentration in rice grain was dramatically different (artisanal area 51±3 ng g-1; abandoned area 235±99 ng g-1). The total gaseous mercury (TGM) concentration in ambient air at the artisanal mining site was significantly greater than at the abandoned area (231 ng m-3 and 34 ng m-3 respectively) and we found a negative correlation between TGM and the Se concentration in grain for the artisanal area. Principal component analysis (PCA) indicated that the source of Se in rice was the atmosphere for the artisanal area (no contribution from soil), and both the atmosphere and soil for the abandoned area. We propose that TGM falls to soil and reacts with Se, inhibiting the translocation of Se to rice grain. Our data suggests that Se intake by the artisanal mining community is insufficient to meet Se dietary requirements, predisposing this community to greater risk from Hg poisoning.

TOC/Abstract Art

47 48

2


Page 2 of 29

Page 3 of 29


49 50

1. Introduction: Selenium (Se) is an essential trace element for mammalian physiology. However symptoms

51

of deficiency or toxicity are apparent outside of the narrow concentration range that is considered

52

adequate for physiological function.1 Selenium is recognized to have specific function in cellular

53

defense against reactive oxygen species, to protect against carcinogenesis, and to maintain the

54

activity of the thyroid hormone.2-3 Selenium is also thought to protect against infection with the

55

HIV virus and to inhibit the progression of this virus to AIDS.1, 4

56

Human exposure to Se occurs through the diet. Cereals, vegetables and meat have potential to

57

deliver adequate levels of dietary intake, however this will depend on the Se concentration in food

58

and the amount consumed.5-6 The concentration of Se in food is primarily dependent on the

59

concentration and speciation of Se in soil, and the ability of plants to accumulate Se from the soil

60

into edible tissues. 7 Consumption of foods that contain less than 0.1 µg g-1 Se will generally lead

61

to Se-deficiency, while a concentration greater than 1.0 µg g-1 will result in toxicity.7 The

62

recommended dietary allowance (RDA) of Se for humans in the USA and countries of the

63

European Commission is 55 µg day-1 for both men and women, while an upper tolerable nutrient

64

level (UL) for adults is 400 µg day-1.8-9 China has a maximum food standard limit of 300 ng g-1 Se

65

in cereal grains such as rice, and the concentration of Se in rice is regularly assessed as this cereal

66

is considered to the staple food for the majority of the Chinese population. Therefore, for much of

67

China, daily Se intake is dependent on the Se concentration in rice.10

68

Selenium is a rare element in our planet. The mean concentration of Se in igneous bedrock

69

(50 ng g-1) is less than any other essential nutrient element.11The provenance of rocks that weather

70

to form soil therefore leads to a varied distribution of the Se concentration in soil, and this, in turn,

71

affects the concentration of Se in rice (See Supporting Information for details). The global 3



72

background concentration of Se in soil is 200 ng g-1, while the background concentration of Se in

73

rice is 95 ng g-1.12-13 However, the Se concentration in rice shows large variations across China,

74

especially when known areas of seleniferous soil are compared to non-seleniferous areas (See

75

Supporting Information for details).

76

Plant uptake of Se is dependent on the speciation of Se in the soil. Two species of Se can be

77

present under ambient environmental conditions; selenite which is strongly retained to soil

78

colloids through the mechanism of specific adsorption, and selenate, which is weakly retained to

79

soil colloids due to electrostatic repulsion.14 Selenate is therefore generally more available to

80

plants than selenite and is the predominant form of Se in soil under alkaline or well-oxidized

81

conditions. However, in highly anoxic and reduced soil, selenite can become the principle species

82

of soil Se and this is poorly available to plants.15 Selenate competes with sulfate for uptake by

83

plants because of the chemical similarity between selenate and sulfate, and it has been proposed

84

that uptake of both species occurs by way of a sulfate transporter in the root plasma membrane.16

85

The translocation of Se from root to stem is also highly dependent on the speciation of Se with

86

selenate being much more easily transported than selenite or organic Se.17 Plants can also

87

accumulate (absorb) Se from the atmosphere via leaf surfaces.16 In the Yangtze River Delta of

88

China, a foliage spray of sodium selenite is regularly used to rectify the problem of low Se content

89

of rice grains.18

90

To protect against an excessive Se concentration in crop plants such as rice, maximum

91

guidelines exist for Se in soil. In China the maximum allowable limit for Se in agricultural soil is

92

290 ng g-1, a concentration that is coincidental with the soil Se background concentration for all of

93

China.19 However, at contaminated locations, total soil Se concentrations can exceed this limit. 4


Page 4 of 29

Page 5 of 29


94

The Wanshan Hg mining area of eastern Guizhou Province is one area that has been contaminated

95

with Se. Mercury has been recovered from cinnabar ore in the Wanshan area since the Qin

96

Dynasty (211 B.C.). Selenium is present at high concentration in the ore20 and has historically

97

been released into the environment during ore processing. The background level of Se in soil

98

across all of Guizhou Province is 390 ng g-1, 21 higher than the soil Se background value for all of

99

China (290 ng g-1)22 and the world (200 ng g-1).23 Commercial-scale mining was closed in 2001,

100

but some artisanal and small scale mercury mining is ongoing in the Wanshan mining area

101

releasing mercury into the atmosphere today. However, the greatest legacy of mercury pollution is

102

from historical and now abandoned large-scale smelting activities. Within the Wanshan area it is

103

therefore possible to differentiate between lands that has been subject to historically high Se (and

104

Hg) input, and land that is subject to current day Se (and Hg) flux from artisanal and small-scale

105

mining. Paddy rice is the dominant crop species grown throughout the Wanshan region and

106

monitoring the Se and Hg concentration in rice grains is important to protect public health.24-25

107

Few studies have investigated the uptake and translocation of Se in cereal crop plants

108

growing in mining areas with high flux of Hg and Se. These two elements are known to have an

109

interactive effect on uptake and the subsequent concentration of these elements in cereal

110

grains.25-26 In the current study we have investigated the influence of the nature of Se and Hg

111

contamination (i.e. historic soil contamination or current day atmospheric contamination) on the

112

concentration of Se in tissues of paddy rice (Oryza sativa L). Specifically, we have investigated

113

the influence of Hg concentration and flux on the uptake and translocation of Se in rice. This work

114

has been carried out in order to provide mechanistic insight into the process of Se uptake by paddy

115

rice growing in Hg-contaminated soil. 5



116

2. Materials & Methods

117

2.1 Study area

118

Formal Hg mining in the Wanshan area ceased at the end of 2001. However, illegal artisanal

119

mining and smelting activities have continued to produce Hg to the current day. During the

120

retorting of cinnabar ore (from both industrial and artisanal activity), mercury and other elements

121

present within the ore, including Se (0.02 – 0.87% of the ore), 20 are released into the environment.

122

During the current study, rice and soil at a current-day artisanal mining area (sixteen sites), and a

123

now-abandoned industrial-scale mining area (thirteen sites) were sampled. All sampling was

124

conducted during the rice growing season of 2009. Small-scale smelting was ongoing throughout

125

the sampling period, with the consequential released of mercury to the atmosphere. Mining at the

126

industrial area ceased in 2001, however, historical large-scale Hg smelting released serious Hg

127

contamination to the ambient air, water, soil, sediment, and biota. Wanshan has a subtropical

128

monsoon humid climate with an average annual rainfall of 1200-1400 mm and the annual mean

129

temperature of 17°C. The altitude of this area ranges from 205 to 1149 m above sea level.

130 131

2.2 Sampling

132

Twenty- nine samples of whole rice plant (Oryza sativa L) and corresponding soil samples (from

133

10-20 cm depth) were collected by hand from across the study area (Figure 1). The whole rice

134

plant samples were washed in the field with tap water to remove soil particles that had adhered to

135

the plants’ surface. All rice and soil samples were then sealed in clean polyethylene bags and

136

stored in a cooler before being carried to the laboratory.

137

In the laboratory, the whole rice plant samples were carefully washed with deionized water 6


Page 6 of 29

Page 7 of 29


138

three times, and divided into root, stem, leaf, and seed components with Teflon scissors, then

139

freeze dried (EYELA FDU-1100, Tokyo Rikakikai Co. LTD, Japan). The mass of root, stem, leaf,

140

and seed was recorded, and these components accounted for 3%, 31%, 10%, and 56% (average) of

141

total plant biomass, respectively. The seed was separated into husk and brown rice using a huller.

142

A rice milling machine was then used to separate the bran from the brown rice to yield white rice.

143

Rice grain, white rice, bran, and husk accounted for 57%, 12% and 31%, respectively of seed

144

biomass. All samples were ground to 150 mesh (IKA-A11 basic, IKA, Germany). The grinder and

145

huller were thoroughly cleaned before/after processing each sample with ethanol to avoid

146

cross-contamination during sample preparation. The powdered samples were kept in sealed

147

polyethylene bags.

148 149

Soil samples were freeze-dried (EYELA FDU-1100) and ground to pass through a 200 mesh sieve using an agate mortar and pestle.

150 151

2.3 Analysis

152

The experimental protocol employed for plant digestion and soil digestion, the analysis of Se

153

concentration in rice plant tissues and soil, the analysis of the total Hg concentration in plants, and

154

the analysis of total gaseous mercury (TGM) concentration are described in the Supporting

155

Information.

156 157

2.4 Quality assurance and quality control

158

Quality assurance and quality control were validated by using duplicates, method blanks, matrix

159

spikes, and certified reference materials (CRMs). Details of the protocols employed are presented 7



160

in the Supporting Information.

161 162

3. Results and discussion

163

3.1 Se in the soil

164

The mean concentration of total Se in soil was two-fold greater for the abandoned mining area

165

(2,200 ng g-1) than for the current-day artisanal mining area (990 ng g-1)(Table 1). These

166

concentrations are 2.6 and 5.6 fold greater than the soil background level of 390 ng g-1 Se for

167

Guizhou province, 21 but lower than the soil Se concentration recorded for seleniferous areas such

168

as Enshi in Hubei of China (See Supporting Information for details). The higher concentration of

169

Se in soil for the abandoned mining area can be attributed to the extent of historical large-scale Hg

170

smelting activities in this area. The cumulative release of elements to soil at the abandoned mining

171

areas exceeds that at the current-day artisanal mining area.27

172 173

3.2 Se in rice tissues

174

The Se concentration varied between the tissues of rice plants collected from the two areas (Table

175

2 and Figure 2). For plants collected from the artisanal area, the highest concentration of Se was

176

found in roots (average 220 ng g-1), whereas the lowest concentration was found in the polished

177

grain (40 ng g-1). In rice plants collected from the abandoned area the Se concentration in root

178

ranged from 80 to 1700 ng g-1, with a mean of 520 ng g-1, whereas the concentration in grain

179

ranged from 27 to 970 ng g-1 with a mean of 240 ng g-1. Figure 2 shows that the concentration of

180

Se in rice tissues collected from both the artisanal and abandoned areas follows the trend root >

181

leaf > stem >grain, an observation that is in agreement with the recent findings of Qin et al who 8


Page 8 of 29

Page 9 of 29


182

investigated the distribution of Se in rice at Enshi in Hubei Province.28

183

There are also differences in the concentration of Se in the various parts of the rice grain,

184

with plants from the abandoned area exhibiting a higher concentration of Se in all parts of the

185

cereal. The highest concentration of Se in the different components of rice grain was recorded for

186

the bran at both areas. The Se concentration of the bran was 3.2- and 2.1-fold higher than the Se

187

concentration in white rice and husk for the artisanal area, and 4.3- and 3.5-fold higher than the Se

188

in white rice and husk for the abandoned area. Our results are in agreement with those of a

189

previous investigation in the Wanshan area which showed that the Se concentration in whole rice

190

grain ranged from 20 to 670 ng g-1 with an average of less than 100 ng g-1.26 When compared to

191

the global average concentration of Se in white rice 95 ng g-1,13 rice from the abandoned areas

192

exceeds the global average, but rice from the artisanal areas is lower (40 and 160 ng g-1 for the

193

artisanal and abandoned areas respectively). However, the Se concentrations in the polished rice

194

samples collected in this work were much lower than those recorded from the Enshi seleniferous

195

region (range: 160 to 10200 ng g-1).28

196

According to the mass proportion of root, stem, leaf, and grain in a whole rice plant, and the

197

mass proportion of polished rice, bran, and husk in a whole grain, we calculated the relative mass

198

distribution of Se throughout rice plants collected from the two areas (Figure 4). Selenium was

199

predominantly accumulated in the above-ground parts of rice plants. For the artisanal area, 10% of

200

accumulated Se was stored in roots, while 90% was stored in the aerial tissues. These values were

201

5% and 95% for the abandoned area. For both areas, the greatest sink of plant Se was in the grain,

202

with Se in the grain predominantly accumulated in the polished rice, followed by bran and husk.

203

The relative distribution of Se between plant components was similar, despite the large difference 9



204

in Se concentration for rice plants collected from the two areas. This indicates that the plant

205

actively distributes accumulated Se throughout the various organs.

206

The bioaccumulation factors (BAF) of Se in the various tissues of the rice plant are presented

207

in Table 2. The BAF of Se in root for both areas was similar. However there was a significant

208

difference in the BAF of Se in stem and grain for plants collected from the two areas. In particular,

209

the BAF for Se in grain from the abandoned area was double that for the artisanal area (Table 2).

210

For both areas the highest BAF was observed in root, followed by leaf, stem and grain, with the

211

BAF in all the rice tissues greater at the abandoned area than at the artisanal area.

212 213

3.3 Investigating the source of Se in rice plants

214

Principal component analysis (PCA) is a multivariate statistical technique that reduces a large

215

number of variables to a small number of factors (principal components or PCs) that can be used

216

to explain the relationships and associations among objects and variables.29-31 For example, Shan

217

et al.32 applied PCA to extract hidden subsets from a dataset in order to detect possible sources of

218

heavy metals in agricultural soils (see Supporting Information). In order to identify the likely

219

origin of Se in the plants sampled from the two mining areas, we analyzed the Se concentration of

220

soil and the various tissues of rice plants collected from the two areas using PCA statistical

221

software (SPSS 18.0).

222

Principal Component Analysis of Se concentrations at the artisanal area defines three

223

components (PC1, PC2 and PC3) which account for 84% of the variance in the data set (Table 3).

224

PC1 expressed high positive loadings on leaf and grain and we interpret the inclusion of these two

225

variables in one component to indicate a common origin of Se. Selenium can be accumulated as a 10


Page 10 of 29

Page 11 of 29


226

function of stomata uptake of gas phase Se or foliar absorption from particulate material. 33-35 We

227

therefore propose that PC1 can be used to infer that the source of Se in the aerial tissues of rice

228

plants collected from artisanal area is the ambient air. There is precedent for this inference in

229

previous studies that have investigated how atmospheric Se flux can affect plants. Component

230

PC2 expressed a high positive loading for stem and a highly negative loading for soil. We interpret

231

this to represent an internal phytophysiological transfer process for Se absorbed from the

232

atmosphere. PC 3 expressed high positive loadings for all components: root, grain, stem and soil.

233

As the stem is the transport channel connecting the root to the grain, we propose that PC3 for the

234

artisanal area is an indicator for soil derived Se. The lower total variance described by PC3

235

indicates that soil is a minor source for Se uptake by rice plants at the artisanal area.

236

Principle Component Analysis of the Se concentrations for the abandoned area defined two

237

components which together accounted for 98% of total variance in the data set (PC1 58% and PC2

238

40%) (Table 4). Due to high loadings on grain, stem and leaf, but relatively low loading on root,

239

we infer that PC1 again describes ambient air as the source of Se. However, the positive loading

240

on soil for PC1 indicates that soil has an influence on PC1 for the abandoned area. We propose

241

that this influence may be Se volatilized from soil that is subsequently adsorbed by the aerial plant

242

tissues; however, the validity of this assumption must be further tested. PC2 has a high loading on

243

soil, root and leaf. As these are the two plant components with the highest BAF (Table 2) we infer

244

that soil is again the source of Se for PC2. PCA of Se for the abandoned area suggests that there is

245

no clear distinction between soil and air as the primary source of this element in rice and describes

246

an apparent interaction between these two sources that is not observed for the artisanal area.

247

Artisanal smelting of cinnabar ore was ongoing during the rice growing season in 2009 and 11



248

therefore there was release of Hg into the atmosphere throughout this period. Monitoring of the

249

total gaseous mercury (TGM) concentration in air recorded a mean concentration of 231 ng m-3

250

which was significantly higher than the mean concentration recorded for the abandoned area (34

251

ng m-3). During smelting other volatile components of the ore will also have been released into the

252

atmosphere, including Se. The elevated TGM concentration for the artisanal area relative to the

253

abandoned area therefore suggests a differential concentration of Se in the atmosphere between the

254

two areas and supports the PCA modeled differential primary origin of Se in rice between the two

255

areas. Further research is needed to substantiate this interpretation of the PCA data. Measurement

256

of the total gaseous selenium concentration at the two areas and isotopic fingerprinting would

257

achieve this aim.

258 259

3.4 Wanshan daily dietary Se intake via rice consumption

260

Dumont et al.7 indicated that if the concentration of Se in food is less than 100 ng g-1, symptoms

261

of deficiency can be expected in human populations. Across the sampling sites in this study, the Se

262

concentration of polished rice exceeded 100 ng g-1 for only 17% of the 29 locations. The potential

263

magnitude of this problem can be further considered through analysis of rice consumption habits.

264

According to the National Bureau of Statistics of China, the daily per capita consumption of

265

rice in 2010 in China was 200 g dry weight per day for adults with an average weight of 60 kg.

266

Assuming that 100% of the ingested Se is absorbed in the body, we can approximately calculate

267

the adult daily intake of Se via rice consumption in each of the two study areas. For an adult,

268

consuming 200 g rice per day containing an average Se concentration of 40 and 160 ng g-1 for the

269

artisanal and abandoned mining areas respectively, total daily Se intake will be 8 and 32 µg 12


Page 12 of 29

Page 13 of 29


270

respectively (intake will be lower if absorption is not 100%; these values are therefore

271

conservative). Based on these calculations, Se intake from rice in the abandoned mining area will

272

exceed the WHO/FAO/IAEA guideline level of 30 µg day-1 for women and is close the guideline

273

level for men (40 µg day-1).4 However, Se intake from rice in the artisanal mining area is

274

considerably lower than the guideline level for both men and women.

275

The soil Se concentration at both areas exceeded the Chinese guideline concentration for Se

276

in soil. Therefore, the low concentration of Se in rice at the artisanal site cannot be attributed to a

277

low soil Se concentration. Instead, we believe the high concentration of Hg in the atmosphere is

278

inhibiting Se uptake from soil. Zhang et al.24 , proposed a new criterion for Se and Hg exposure

279

assessment, based on their understanding of the interaction between Se and Hg; the physiology

280

and toxicology of Se; and the toxicology of Hg. According to Zhang et al., daily dietary Se intake

281

can have an important mitigating impact on the toxicity of Hg exposure. However, assessment of

282

Se intake alone without considering the potential for interactions with Hg may inadequately reflect

283

the Se status of individuals. Applying Zhang et al.’s criterion, the low Se intake predicted for the

284

artisanal mining area may lead to both a deficiency of Se and increased risk of Hg toxicity in the

285

population.

286

3.5 Conceptual model to explain the effect of atmospheric Hg on Se uptake by rice

287

According to the Principle Component Analysis, the source of Se in rice across the artisanal

288

area is the atmosphere, with little to no accumulation of Se from soil, despite the presence of a

289

significant concentration of soil Se. However, across the abandoned area, PCA indicates that rice

290

accumulates Se from both the atmosphere and the soil. We believe that the factor controlling the

291

uptake of Se from soil is the total gaseous mercury (TGM) concentration in ambient air. Where the 13



292

TGM concentration in ambient air is low, rice plants are able to accumulate Se from the soil and to

293

translocate this to grain. However, where the TGM concentration in ambient air is high, uptake of

294

Se from soil and translocation is restricted. Supporting this hypothesis is a negative correlation

295

(R2=0.242, P=0.074) between TGM concentration in ambient air and the concentration of Se in

296

grain for the artisanal area only (Figure 3). No similar correlation was found for the abandoned

297

area. The rationale for using the correlation between TGM concentration in ambient air and Se

298

concentration in grain to qualify the effect of TGM concentration in ambient air is further

299

explained in the supporting information.

300

Previous work has shown that a high TGM concentration in ambient air due to artisanal and

301

small-scale mining will lead to a high flux of mercury to soil through both particulate mercury

302

deposition and the presence of dissolved Hg in precipitation.36 Meng et al.36 described how freshly

303

deposited inorganic mercury from artisanal and small-scale mining is more chemically reactive

304

than Hg that has been in soil for an extended period of time and is readily methylated in soil. This

305

MeHg is then accumulated by rice plants, and concentrates in rice grain. Zhang et al.24 showed

306

that chemically reactive Hg in soil will readily precipitate Se as a stable and insoluble Hg-Se

307

complex in the rhizopshere or on the root surface of rice plants. We therefore propose that the lack

308

of Se uptake by rice plants from soil at the artisanal area is due to the removal of bioavailable Se

309

from soil solution by chemically reactive Hg that was being released to the atmosphere and falling

310

to the ground through the rice sampling period of our study. This mechanism was unique to the

311

artisanal area, as there was no active Hg mining across the abandoned area at the time of sampling.

312

The abandoned area was characterized by a relatively low TGM concentration in ambient air and

313

therefore limited deposition flux of fresh (and chemically reactive) Hg to soil. 14


Page 14 of 29

Page 15 of 29


314 315

3.6 Implications of this model for Wanshan public health

316

The two mining areas described in this paper are typical mining areas across the Wanshan region

317

of Guizhou, China. The Se concentration in soil varies across Wanshan, but is much higher than

318

the global soil Se background level (200 ng g-1).12 Despite the elevated Se concentration in soil,

319

the Se concentration in rice is not always high. We have shown that the Se concentration in rice

320

grain across the artisanal area is low and may lead to Se deficiency in the human population.

321

Foods that contain less than 100 ng g-1 Se will generally lead to Se-deficiency.7 Using this

322

criterion value, rice across the artisanal mining area was Se deficient (average concentration 51 ng

323

g-1), whereas rice collected from the abandoned areas was sufficient (average concentration 235 ng

324

g-1). We do not believe that the explanation for this difference in Se concentration in rice is the Se

325

concentration in the soil as soil Se should not be a limiting factor for uptake. Instead we propose

326

that the limiting factor for Se concentration in rice is the current-day concentration of Hg in the

327

atmosphere, and subsequently, the deposition flux of Hg to the soil. This same deposition flux of

328

mercury to soil is now recorded as the source of significant Hg (as MeHg) exposure to inland

329

communities of China who consume rice.

330

Ralston et al.37 suggested the ratio of Hg to Se may be the critical factor in determining the

331

toxicity of Hg. Based on rodent data, Hg exposure that might otherwise produce toxic effects can

332

be counteracted by Se, particularly when Se/Hg molar ratios approach or exceed 1:1. At this ratio

333

there is adequate Se to prevent Hg toxicity.38 The scenario where artisanal and small scale mining

334

leads to a high deposition flux of inorganic mercury to soil may therefore lead to both excessive

335

exposure of the local population to Hg (as MeHg), and deficiency of the local population in Se. 15



336

We therefore propose that in the context of rice production in artisanal mining areas, Hg

337

contamination of the air is a significant threat to the Se nutrition of the mining communities. The

338

combined effect of elevated Hg and Hg-induced Se deficiency in rice may be leading to more

339

excessive exposure of the artisanal mining communities to Hg toxicity than is currently

340

recognized. The interactive effect of these two elements, especially the profound effect of Hg on

341

Se uptake into rice grain, should be assessed more fully in the context of public health. Studies on

342

the effect of Hg on the uptake and accumulation of Se in plants and the underlying mechanisms of

343

this effect, especially phytophysiological processes, should be considered in the future.

344 345

Acknowledgments

346

This research was financed by National Key Basic Research Program of China (973 Program

347

2013CB430004), Natural Science Foundation of China (41073098, 41203091, 41073062,

348

41173126, and 11105172), and also financed by the 135 project of IGCAS.

349 350 351

Supporting Information Available

352

Detailed information of sample analysis; detailed information of QA/AC; literature precedent for

353

applying PCA to extract hidden subsets from a dataset in order to detect possible sources;

354

explanation of the correlation between TGM and Se concentration in grain; one tables. This

355

information is available free of charge via the Internet athttp://pubs.acs.org/

356

16


Page 16 of 29

Page 17 of 29


357

References

358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399

1. Litov, R. E.; Combs, G. F. Selenium in pediatric nutrition. Pediatrics. 1991, 87 (3), 339-357. 2. Kohrle, J.; Jakob, F.; Contempre, B.; Dumont, J. E. Selenium, the thyroid, and the endocrine system. Endocr. Rev. 2005, 26 (7), 944-984. 3. Bridges, C. C.; Zalups, R. K. Molecular and ionic mimicry and the transport of toxic metals. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 2005, 204 (3), 274-308. 4. Rayman, M. P. The importance of selenium to human health. Lancet. 2000, 356 (9225), 233-241. 5. Wolf, E.; Kollonitsch, V.; Kline, C. H. A survey of selenium treatment in livestock production. J. Agr. Food. Chem. 1963, 11 (4). 6. Chen, X. S.; Yang, G. Q.; Chen, J. S.; Chen, X. C.; Wen, Z. M.; Ge, K. Y. Studies on the relations of selenium and Keshan disease. Biol. Trace. Elem. Res. 1980, 2 (2), 91-107. 7. Dumont, E.; Vanhaecke, F.; Cornelis, R. Selenium speciation from food source to metabolites: a critical review. Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 2006, 385 (7), 1304-1323. 8. Monsen, E. R. Dietary Reference intakes for the antioxidant nutrients: Vitamin C, vitamin E, selenium, and carotenoids. J. Am. Diet. Assn. 2000, 100 (9), 1008-1009. 9. WHO.; FAO. Vitamin and mineral requirements in human nutrition (2nd edition), World Health Organization and Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: Rome, Italy. 2004. ISBN 92 4 154612 3. 10. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Website; http://www.fao.org/ newsroom/en/news/2006/1000267/index.html. “Rice Is Life”: International Rice Commission Meets in Peru. 2006. 11. Fordyce, F. M. Selenium deficiency and toxicity in the environment. In: Selinus, O., (ed.) Essentials of medical geology. Elsevier, 2005. 12. Swaine, D. J. The trace element content in soil; Technical communication of the Commonwealth Bureau of Soil Science, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureau, England, 1995. 13. Williams, P. N.; Lombi, E.; Sun, G. X.; Scheckel, K.; Zhu, Y. G.; Feng, X. B.; Zhu, J. M.; Carey, A. M.; Adomako, E.; Lawgali, Y.; Deacon, C.; Meharg, A. A. Selenium Characterization in the Global Rice Supply Chain. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43 (15), 6024-6030. 14. Barrow, N.; Cartes, P.; Mora, M. Modifications to the Freundlich equation to describe anion sorption over a large range and to describe competition between pairs of ions. Eur. J. Soil. Sci. 2005, 56 (5), 601-606. 15. Arvy, M. P. Selenate and selenite uptake and translocation in bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris). J. Exp. Bot. 1993, 44 (6), 1083-1087. 16. Terry, N.; Zayed, A. M.; De Souza, M. P.; Tarun, A. S. Selenium in higher plants. Annu. Rev. Plant. Biol. 2000, 51 (1), 401-432. 17. Zayed, A.; Lytle, C. M.; Terry, N. Accumulation and volatilization of different chemical species of selenium by plants. Planta 1998, 206 (2), 284-292. 18. Cao, Z. H.; Wang, X. C.; Yao, D. H.; Zhang, X. L.; Wong, M. H. Selenium geochemistry of paddy soils in Yangtze River Delta. Environ. Int. 2001, 26 (5-6), 335-339. 19. CNEMC. (China National Environmental Monitoring Center). Background concentrations of elements in soils of China. China Environmental Science Press: Beijing. 1990 (in Chinese). 20. Bao, Z. X.; Bao, J. M. The occurrences of selenium in the western Hunan-eastern Guizhou 17



400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443

mercury ore belt. Geol. Explor. Nonferr. Metal. 1995, 4 (1), 30-34 (in Chinese). 21. Wang, G. L.; Zhu, X. Q. A background survey on seleniun in soil of Guizhou Provience. Res. Environ. Sci. 2003, 16 (1), 23-26. 22. Zhu, Z. M.; Lu, L. N.; Liu, W. The element background of Chinese soil; China Environmental Science Press: Beijing, 1990 (in Chinese). 23. Lisk, D. J. Trace metals in soils, plants, and animals. Adv. Agron. 1972, 24, 267-325. 24. Zhang, H.; Feng, X. B.; Chan, H. M.; Larssen, T. New insights into traditional health risk assessments of mercury exposure: implications of selenium. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2014, 48 (2), 1206-1212. 25. Zhang, H.; Feng, X. B.; Jiang, C. X.; Li, Q. H.; Liu, Y.; Gu, C. H.; Shang, L. H.; Li, P.; Lin, Y.; Larssen, T. Understanding the paradox of selenium contamination in mercury mining areas: High soil content and low accumulation in rice. Environ. Pollut. 2014, 188 (0), 27-36. 26. Zhang, H.; Feng, X. B.; Zhu, J. M.; Sapkota, A.; Meng, B.; Yao, H.; Qin, H.; Larssen, T. Selenium in soil inhibits mercury uptake and translocation in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 10040-10046. 27. Meng, B.; Feng, X. B.; Qiu, G. L.; Cai, Y.; Wang, D. Y.; Li, P.; Shang, L. H.; Sommar, J. Distribution Patterns of Inorganic Mercury and Methylmercury in Tissues of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Plants and Possible Bioaccumulation Pathways. J. Agr. Food Chem. 2010, 58 (8), 4951-4958. 28. Qin, H. B.; Zhu, J. M.; Liang, L.; Wang, M. S.; Su, H. The bioavailability of selenium and risk assessment for human selenium poisoning in high-Se areas, China. Environ. Int. 2013, 52, 66-74. 29. Wold, S.; Esbensen, K.; Geladi, P. Principal component analysis. Chemometr. Intel. Lab. Syst. 1987, 2 (1), 37-52. 30. Jackson, J. E. A user's guide to principal components. Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics, John Wiley & Sons Inc., 2005. 31. Jolliffe, I. T. Principal component analysis (2nd edition), Springer Series in Statistics, Springer: New York, U. S., 2002.. 32. Shan, Y. S.; Tysklind, M.; Hao, F. H.; Ouyang, W.; Chen, S. Y.; Lin, C. Y. Identification of sources of heavy metals in agricultural soils using multivariate analysis and GIS. J. Soil. Sediment. 2013, 13 (4), 720-729. 33. Haygarth, P. M.; Cooke, A. I.; Jones, K. C.; Harrison, A. F.; Johnston, A. E. Long-term change in the biogeochemical cycling of atmospheric selenium-deposition to plants and soil. J. Geophys. Res. 1993, 98 (D9), 16769-16776. 34. Haygarth, P. M.; Harrison, A. F.; Jones, K. C. Plant seleniun from soil and the atmosphere. J. Environ. Qual. 1995, 24 (4), 768-771. 35. Liu, G. J.; Zhang, Y.; Qi, C.; Zheng, L. G.; Chen, Y. W.; Peng, Z. C. Comparative on causes and accumulation of selenium in the tree-rings ambient high-selenium coal combustion area from Yutangba, Hubei, China. Environ. Monit. Assess. 2007, 133 (1-3), 99-103. 36. Meng, B.; Feng, X. B.; Qiu, G. L.; Liang, P.; Li, P.; Chen, C. X.; Shang, L. H. The Process of Methylmercury Accumulation in Rice (Oryza sativa L.). Environ. Sci. Technol. 2011, 45 (7), 2711-2717. 37. Ralston, N. V. C.; Ralston, C. R.; Blackwell, J. L.; Raymond, L. J. Dietary and tissue selenium in relation to methylmercury toxicity. Neurotoxicology. 2008, 29 (5), 802-811. 38. Peterson, S. A.; Ralston, N. V. C.; Peck, D. V.; Van Sickle, J.; Robertson, J. D.; Spate, V. L.; 18


Page 18 of 29

Page 19 of 29


444 445

Morris, J. S. How Might Selenium Moderate the Toxic Effects of Mercury in Stream Fish of the Western US? Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43 (10), 3919-3925.

446

19



447

Table 1 Concentration of total Se in tissues of rice plant as a function of the two sampling areas

448

(ng g-1)

449

Table 2 Bioaccumulation factors (BAF) of Se in tissues of the rice plant as a function of sampling

450

area. BAF is calculated as the Se concentration in the tissues of rice plant/Se concentration in soil.

451

Table 3 Rotated factor loadings and percent variance for the two principal components (PC) of Se

452

in rice tissues and soil for the artisanal area

453

Table 4 Rotated factor loadings and percent variance for the two principal components (PC) of Se

454

in rice tissues and soil for the abandon area

455

20


Page 20 of 29

Page 21 of 29


456

Table 1 Tissues, ng g-1

Artisanal area

Abandoned area

Mean±Std.E

Range

Mean±Std.E

Range

Polished

40±6

17-130

160±64

13-650

Bran

99±10

42-180

680±290

52-2900

Husk

52±4

26-82

200±75

36-820

Grain

51±3

23-76

235±99

27-970

Root

220±19

70-340

520±160

80-1700

Stem

66±7

27-120

330±140

35-1600

Leaf

150±15

67-280

440±150

63-1500

Soil

990±92

370-1900

2200±660

540-8900

457 458

21



459

Table 2 Tissues Grain Root Stem Leaf

Artisanal area

Abandoned area

0.05 0.22 0.07 0.15

0.11 0.24 0.15 0.2

460

22


Page 22 of 29

Page 23 of 29


Table 3 461

462 463 464

Se

PC 1

PC 2

PC 3

Grain Stem Leaf Root Soil % of variance explained cumulative % of total variance

0.657 -0.410 0.922 0.127 -0.371 29

0.383 0.812 0.048 0.041 -0.791 29

0.442 0.390 0.036 0.936 0.262 26 84

Extraction method: principal component analysis. Rotation method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.

23



465

466 467 468 469 470

Page 24 of 29

Table 4 Se

PC 1

PC 2

Grain Stem Leaf Root Soil % of variance explained cumulative % of total variance

0.921 0.940 0.747 0.722 0.325 58

0.375 0.339 0.655 0.664 0.943 40 98

Extraction method: principal component analysis. Rotation method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.

24


Page 25 of 29


471

Figure 1. The study area and location of the sampling sites (Area A is the artisanal area, Area B is

472

the abandoned area)

473

Figure 2. Total Se concentration in different tissues of rice plant collected from the two areas

474

(with Std. Error) (Area A is the artisanal area, Area B is the abandoned area)

475

Figure 3. Concentration of Se in the grain as a function of TGM for the two areas (Area A is the

476

artisanal area, Area B is the abandoned area)

477

Figure 4. The relative distribution of Se in the tissues of rice plants from the artisanal area (Area

478

A) and abandoned area (Area B)

479

25



480

Figure 1.

481 482

26


Page 26 of 29

Page 27 of 29


Figure 2.

1000

1000

800

800

600

700

200

-1

Total Se concerntation (ng g )

700

100

600

-1

900

900

Total Se concerntation (ng g )

483

Area A Area B

0

500

Polished

Bran

Husk

Tissues of grain

400 300 200 100 0 Grain

Stem

Leaf

Root

Tissues of rice plant

484 485

27



Figure 3. Concentrations of Se in grain (ng/g)

486

Page 28 of 29

A

80

B

1000

R2=0.242, P=0.074

70

2

R =3E-05, P=0.921

800

60 600 50 400

40

200

30

0

20 0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

20

TGM (ng/m3)

30

40

50

60

TGM (ng/m3)

487 488

28


70

80

Page 29 of 29


489

Figure 4.

490 491

29


Effect of Atmospheric Mercury Deposition on Selenium Accumulation

Recommend Documents