COVE R STORY WELL DEFINED
CAMAG
The components of common horsetail, a dietary supplement used as a diuretic or for osteoporosis, can be separated by HPTLC.
MODERNIZING TLC New instrumentation, materials, and analysis techniques take lab staple into HIGH-PERFORMANCE ARENA JYLLIAN KEMSLEY, C&EN WEST COAST NEWS BUREAU
THIN-LAYER chromatography (TLC) has
long been a staple of the organic laboratory, and its silica-on-glass plates are familiar even to undergraduate chemistry majors. But for advanced applications, TLC has lagged in popularity behind column chromatography, which offers better reproducibility and the ability to interface with identification techniques like mass spectrometry (MS). Now, new planar chromatography instrumentation and stationary phases and improvements in MS are opening up TLC to applications that go far beyond a mere quick check on the progress of a chemical reaction. To separate a mixture by TLC, a small amount of sample is spotted onto a thin layer of adsorbent, called the stationary
phase, that’s coated over a sheet of glass, plastic, or other material. The plate is placed into a solvent reservoir, and a liquid, called the mobile phase, ascends the plate by capillary action. Key factors that have changed conventional TLC into high-performance TLC (HPTLC) include better plates, instrumentation, and standardized methodology, says Eike Reich, who heads the research laboratories for instrument manufacturer Camag. All three lead to better, more reproducible performance and an improved ability to validate methods. These are critical characteristics for advanced TLC applications, such as determining when Artemisia annua plants should be harvested for artemisinin, used to treat malaria. The plants are grown in large plots
in Asia, and local labs need to be able to determine quickly when the artemisinin content reaches a maximum, Reich says. Analyzing for the molecule requires separating it from a complex plant matrix and finding a reliable way to identify and quantify it, even though it doesn’t have a chromophore that would enable convenient spectroscopic detection. Camag, which develops TLC methods and instrumentation, developed an HPTLC procedure to separate the mixtures and then stain the bands with anisaldehyde to selectively detect and quantitate artemisinin (J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. Technol. 2007, 30, 2209). Camag also has been working with the Official Food Control Authority of the Canton of Zurich to look for azo dyes that might be illegally added to spices, such as curry pow-
Key factors that have changed conventional TLC into high-performance TLC include better plates, instrumentation, and standardized methodology. WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
11
MAY 18, 2009
COVE R STORY
Find Known Compounds in LC/MS and GC/MS Data with ACD/IntelliTarget
conditions such as humidity, chamber saturation with mobile-phase vapor, and extent of mobile-phase migration can make a big difference in reproducibility of results, Reich says. Silica, a common TLC adsorbent, is always in equilibrium with the humidity of the laboratory atmosphere. Because humidity affects the activity of silica, plates run in different locations worldwide, or in a cold, dry winter versus a hot, humid summer, can give strikingly different results. Controlling the humidity of the development chamber can go a long way toward mitigating those differences, Reich says. Controlling the degree of saturation of the plate development chamber with mobile-phase vapor is also a critical factor in getting reproducible results. Simply opening the chamber to insert a plate disturbs the equilibrium of the chamber’s atmosphere, potentially leading to irregular zones on the plate or a solvent front that’s banana-shaped, instead of straight, the way it should be. “When you have the chamber saturation under control, you have straight COURTESY OF RANIA BAKRY
der or paprika, to enhance their color. “These toxic dyes have actually entered food-processing plants and ended up in sausage or meat products and have to be detected there,” Reich says. The complex nature of either the spice or the food sample makes detection a challenge to which HPTLC is well suited, Reich says, and TLC also makes it convenient to separate, or run, a number of samples quickly in parallel. Methods developed by Camag and Zurich Food Control scientists can MONOLITH Porous difficult to do with colquantitatively detect the dyes down to polymers can be umn chromatography, used to separate 2 ppm (J. Liq. Chromatogr. Relat. TechReich adds. And after a large peptides and nol. 2009, 32, 1273). run, samples remain on the proteins. An advantage of TLC for such applate—so a scientist can plications is that it makes it easy to reevaluate the results or analyze samples side-by-side rather even do additional maniputhan sequentially, as with column chromalations, such as chemical derivatization, tography, Reich says. This means greater rather than just revisiting a scanned image flexibility and higher throughput with relaor chromatogram. tively little expense, he notes. Instrumentation improvements have With TLC one can also see compounds played a major role in turning conventional that weren’t separated because they ran TLC into HPTLC. TLC plates are run in with the solvent front or perhaps didn’t enclosures called plate development chammigrate at all—something that’s typically bers. Using automated chambers to control
Are You Using MS to Identify Unknowns?
Specify a list of compounds by formula or mass and quickly find out if they are present or not. Apply to full scan LC/MS or GC/MS data in most major vendor file formats. Extract trace level components and those that are co-eluting. Automate IntelliTarget to screen batches, or to monitor samples on-the-fly.
Single Quad GC/MS LC/MS
TOF qTOF Orbitrap FT ICR
QTRAP LXQ LTQ
100x better mass accuracy; Formula ID fully enabled
95% of incorrect formulas eliminated
50x better mass accuracy; Formula ID enabled
Extending the limits of mass spectro m e t r y
Find out how targeted qualitative analysis can work for you. www.acdlabs.com/intellitarget/
Visionary Software
14 Commerce Dr. • Danbury, CT 06810 USA • Tel 203-312-1150 Email
[email protected] • www.cernobioscience.com
Advancing Research
WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
12
MAY 18, 2009
LOOKING FOR CUSTOM MANUFACTURING CAPACITY? WHY INVEST CAPITAL IN NEW FIXED ASSETS?
¾
¾ ¾
¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾
¾ ¾ ¾ ¾ ¾
Intermittent or steady production campaigns, supply agreements, or long-term facility lease arrangements possible. Inquiries welcome for Custom / Toll processing from any industry segment with batch chemical processing requirements and high quality standards (Cosmeceutical, Nutraceutical, Pharmaceutical, Specialty Materials, …)
ANOTHER BUDDING instrumentation trend involves taking TLC
down to the nanoscale, which requires smaller plates, smaller spotting devices, and imaging or identification capability that can cope with nanoscale spots. Gertrud Morlock, a professor of food and analytical chemistry at the University of Hohenheim, in Germany, is collaborating with Michael Brett, a professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of Alberta, in Edmonton, to produce plates in sizes from 1 × 1 cm to 4 × 4 cm, with stationary phases from 100 to 1,000 nm thick. Although the researchers are currently using standard stationary-phase materials such as silica, they could in principle use nearly any material, Brett says. Nanoscale TLC would use smaller amounts of solvent, allow faster analysis times, and enable higher throughput on smaller instruments, Morlock says. Nanoscale TLC is in its infancy, she notes, but early results look promising. In addition to developing instrumentation to enhance TLC performance, researchers are also working on new stationary phases for planar applications. Silica, the most common stationary phase, separates molecules by polarity—polar compounds interact more strongly with silica and thus migrate more slowly than nonpolar compounds. Use of so-called reverse stationary phases such as C18- functionalized silica has long extended TLC to separation of nonpolar molecules. More recent work is expanding the range of TLC to biomolecules. Typical TLC layers can separate small peptides or oligonucleotides with molecular weights below about 2 to 3 kilodaltons, but such layers aren’t suitable for larger biomolecules. An alternative approach uses porous polymers, or monoliths, which are also used in column chromatography (C&EN, Dec. 11, 2006, page 14). Rania Bakry, a professor of analytical and radiochemistry at the University of Innsbruck, in Austria, and Frantisek Svec, director of the Molecular Foundry at Lawrence Berkeley National Labora-
Operational Details Manufacturing facility located in Albany OR. Over 20,000 gallons of flexible batch and continuous flow capacity in stainless steel and glass-lined reactor trains up to 4,000 gallons Operating temperature from - 80°C to 160 °C in reactors ranging from 50-2000 gallons. Large scale, high temperature fractional distillation capabilities Bulk handling of flammables with solvent tank farm Solids handling and drying capabilities Broad small molecule and polymer technology platform Handling of hazardous, air/moisture sensitive and specialty reagents (e.g. thionyl chloride, anhydrous ammonia, cyanide, metal hydrides, organometallics, hydrogen gas etc.) On-site wastewater treatment facility Commercial scale freeze drying capacity Fully equipped R&D and QC instrumentation capabilities including: Wet chemistry, LC, LCMS, GC, GCMS, FTIR, etc. Excellent EHS and Quality systems track record cGMP manufacturing facility fully compliant with regulatory permits for air & water quality and hazardous material shipping.
ENERGIZING In PPEC, a hydraulic ram (yellow tube) puts pressure on
a TLC plate, while electrodes (connected to the alligator clips) create an electric field to induce electroosmotic flow of the mobile phase.
COURTESY OF DAVID NUROK
¾
zones across the plate,” Reich says. Automated chambers allow reequilibration before placing a plate in contact with the mobile phase to start a run, and they may also include sensors to detect the advance of a solvent front so a plate can be automatically withdrawn and dried at a specific point.
SYNTHETECH, INC. Tel: 541.967.6575 Fax: 541.967.9424 Email:
[email protected] WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
14
MAY 18, 2009
COVE R STORY
tory, are using photopolymerization to generate new stationary phases for planar separations of biomolecules. By carefully controlling conditions, they can generate stable layers 20 to 200 µm thick with a well-defined porous structure. In their early development work, they used a layer made of poly(butyl methacrylate-coethylene dimethacrylate) to separate and identify the components of a mixture of large biomolecules—insulin, cytochrome c, lysozyme, and myoglobin (Anal. Chem. 2007, 79, 486). Monoliths can also be used for twodimensional separations to get better resolution of mixture components. Svec is experimenting with grafting hydrophilic, sulfonic acid-lined channels onto superhydrophobic monoliths. Aqueous mixtures of peptides can be run in the channels and separated through an ion-exchange mechanism. Once that separation is achieved, the researchers can distinguish the peptides further by turning the plate 90 degrees, switching to an organic mobile phase, and running the peptides through the monolith itself to separate them by polarity. ADVANCES IN instrumentation and stationary phases notwithstanding, one fundamental drawback of planar chromatography is that the rate that the mobile phase advances diminishes with time, thereby slowing down the analysis. “Typically, the mobile phase moves rapidly the first few millimeters but by the end of a separation it may be moving very slowly,” says David Nurok, a chemistry professor at Indiana UniversityPurdue University Indianapolis. One way to speed up TLC analyses is to put the TLC plate on a wheel, with the mobile phase at the center, and spin the plate so that centrifugal force drives the solvent outward. But even here, the movement of the solvent front still continues to slow as it migrates. Another approach, called overpressured-layer chromatography (OPLC), is to cover the surface of the plate with a membrane that is under pressure, so the mobile phase can be pumped through the stationary phase. OPLC keeps the mobile phase moving at a constant rate and improves analysis time over traditional TLC, but scientists would still like to achieve even faster turnover, Nurok says. A third technique, called planar electrochromatography, uses an electric field across the stationary phase to induce electroosmotic flow of the mobile phase. This
speeds up separation, but the electroosmotic force also drives the mobile phase to the surface of the plate, where liquid can accumulate and cause spot smearing. The movement of ions in the electric field also generates heat, and if the plate gets hot enough it will dry. Nurok, in collaboration with Robert E. Santini, a senior scientist at the Jonathan
Amy Facility for Chemical Instrumentation at Purdue University, has developed a technique called pressurized planar electrochromatography (PPEC) that addresses these drawbacks of electrochromatography and enables faster analysis than with OPLC. With PPEC, electrochromatography is carried out in a temperature-controlled, pressurized environment. The pressure prevents
now available
the new spectrum catalog
HDV\WRUHDGSDJHV FKHPLFDOV ODERUDWRU\VXSSOLHVDQGHTXLSPHQW QHZSURGXFWV YLVLWRXUZHEVLWHWRUHJLVWHUDQGUHFHLYH\RXUFRS\
when it comes to chemicals and laboratory products,
you do have choices...
MISSION STATEMENT:
:HPDQXIDFWXUHDQGGLVWULEXWH¿QHFKHPLFDOVDQGODERUDWRU\ SURGXFWVZLWKTXDOLW\DQGGHOLYHU\\RXFDQFRXQWRQHYHU\WLPH
800-772-8786 www.spectrumchemical.com
WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
15
MAY 18, 2009
©2009 GL Sciences, Inc. USA www.inertsil.com
GIVE US YOUR TIRED CHEMISTS, YOUR POOR CHROMATOGRAPHY, YOUR ACIDS, YOUR BASES, THE OCCASIONAL ZWITTERIONS.
LET INERTSIL SHOW YOU SUCCESS LIKE NEVER BEFORE. INTRODUCING THE NEW INERTSIL ODS-4. GL Sciences’ new Inertsil ODS-4 columns provide a gateway to a new world of chromatographic freedom and productivity. The combination of our products and your ingenuity can solve all of your most challenging analytical problems. Contact GL Sciences to obtain your passport to newfound success – and a FREE ODS-4 sample column to try in your own lab. Give us a call at 310.265.4424 or send an email to
[email protected].
GL SCIENCES
©2009 GL Sciences, Inc. USA www.inertsil.com
Good peak shape on Inertsil ODS-4 indicates full base deactivation and full end capping of silanols.
Inertsil ODS-4
Dextromethorphan (Basic Compound)
1
1
GL Sciences’ newly-developed chemical bonding technology allows Inertsil ODS-4 to provide high efficiency and good peak shape where competitive columns fail.For example, in the example at left, Inertsil ODS-4 is compared with competitive ODS phases for the analysis of dextromethorphan, a basic compound. Where other columns show poor peak shape, often with secondary interactions that result in prolonged retention, Inertsil ODS-4 delivers symmetric peaks with high efficiency.
1
1
2
2
2
Hypersil® GOLD 1
Intermediate Retention and Exceptional Peak Shape
2
Sunfire® 1
Zorbax® Eclipse Plus C18 1
Of course, chances are you probably won’t be analyzing dextromethorphan, so your question remains, “How will Inertsil ODS-4 help me with my sample?” Contact GL Sciences and let us arrange for you to evaluate Inertsil in your lab under your particular constraints, without risk (i.e. free of charge). We know you’ll be glad you tried this new technology.
2
2 2 Capcell® Pak MG III
YMC®-Pack Pro C18
1
1
TSK®-Gel ODS-100V 1
Dextromethorphan Test Probe for Bonded Phase Deactivation
2
2 2
Atlantis® T3
Symmetry® C18
Columns: As indicated, 250 x 4.6mm; Eluent: MeCN: 25mM Phosphate Buffer, pH 7.0, 40:60; Flow Rate: 1.0 mL/min Temp: 40C; Detection: 210nm; Sample: 1. phenol, 2. dextromethorphan
Luna® C18(2)
Ordering Information USA Part No. 1503L033W021 1503L033W046 1503L050W021 1503L050W046 1503L100W046 1503L150W046 1505L050W046 1505L150W046 1505L250W046
Phase Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4 Inertsil ODS-4
Particle Size 3 micron 3 micron 3 micron 3 micron 3 micron 3 micron 5 micron 5 micron 5 micron
Column Dimensions 33 x 2.1mm 33 x 4.6mm 50 x 2.1mm 50 x 4.6mm 100 x 4.6mm 150 x 4.6mm 50 x 4.6mm 150 x 4.6mm 250 x 4.6mm
* Qualified respondents to the special offer include end-use, potential customers of Inertsil HPLC columns, and do not include competitors or their agents, consultants, or anyone in any way involved in the selling of HPLC columns. **2 micron columns to be available by mid-year, 2009. Trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
TRY INERTSIL ODS-4 FREE! An absolutely FREE ODS-4 analytical column will be provided to the first 100 qualified C&E News readers who email
[email protected] with their complete company shipping address, phone number, and company email address included*.
*This offer is available to end-use, analytical chemists who are customers or potential customers of GL Sciences, Inc. USA, and is available only in the USA. This offer is not available to competitors, chromatography manufacturers, resellers, or anyone deemed unqualified at the sole discretion of GL Sciences, Inc. GL Sciences, Inc. reserves the right to refuse service to anyone. Limit one per customer and one per lab site. Not available to anyone who has received a sample column from GL Sciences, Inc. within the last 90 days.
COVE R STORY
liquid from accumulating on the plate surface, and the pressurizing medium acts as a heat sink to prevent temperature buildup. The end result is that separations are quick and efficient. In their proofof-concept studies, Nurok, Santini, and colleagues separated all compounds of a nine-component mixture in a mere two minutes (Anal. Chem. 2006, 78, 2823) and
an array of nine five-component samples in just one minute (Anal. Chem. 2004, 76, 1690). Recently, the two have formed a company, InChromatics, to commercialize the technology. Once a mixture has been separated by TLC, it becomes critical to identify unknown components, by using a technique like MS. Developments in open-air ioniza-
FROM CONCEPTION TO FABRICATION, WE ENGINEER IDEAS INTO REALITY. An independent, family-owned company, J.G. Finneran Associates designs, engineers and manufactures unique sample handling products.
In addition to glass and plastic vial manufacturing, our capabilities include vacuum forming, decorating, lining and custom packaging.
Contact us today to receive a free sample pack and our product catalog.
IN DEVELOPING MS-friendly plates, it’s
important to ensure that binders and additives on the TLC surface don’t interfere with MS performance, Van Berkel says. Surfaces must also be robust. “With DESI, you have a miniature power washer,” Van Berkel says. “If you destroy the surface you may still be able to do the analysis, but you’ll blow stuff all over,” compromising the methods and instrumentation. As the qualities of HPTLC become better known, Camag’s Reich expects to see it become popular in areas ranging from environmental analysis, wastewater treatment, dietary supplements, and cosmetics. For rapid screening of unknown contaminants, “I think it’s a very important tool for the future because it’s simple and very sensitive,” Reich says. Perhaps HPTLC will soon be just as essential to the analytical lab as simple silica TLC plates have been to organic labs and chemistry majors. ■
J.G. Finneran. Driven to improve performance in your lab.
Visit our website! Compare products on-line to find the best fit for your application.
www.jgfinneran.com WWW.CEN-ONLINE.ORG
tion methods H (C&EN, Oct. 8, 2007, page 13) O have enabled sigO O nificantly better H H coupling of TLC O with MS than was O previously possible. Whereas MS Artemisinin of TLC plates used to involve cutting the plate and putting the pieces in a vacuum chamber, various techniques can now be used to extract material from intact TLC plates on the benchtop. These include laser desorption, liquid or gas jet desorption, and extraction by a liquid stream. Ionization can be done after desorption or can be coupled with it, such as with desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) or matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI). Gary J. Van Berkel, head of the organic and biological mass spectrometry group at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, is working with collaborators to develop TLC stationary phases that are more amenable to MS analysis. He points to protein separation as an area where TLC-MS might be helpful. “MS analysis of materials from gels can be a time-consuming and costly process,” he says. “If you could replace a normal 2-D gel electrophoresis separation of proteins with something that’s done on a TLC-like medium” and then use MS to identify proteins directly “without having to punch spots and do extensive sample clean-up, that would have an immediate application.”
18
MAY 18, 2009
