Subscriber access provided by Warwick University Library
Article
Monitoring effect of SO2 emission abatement on recovery of acidified soil and stream water in southwest China Qian Yu, Ting Zhang, Xiaoxiao Ma, Ronghua Kang, Jan Mulder, Thorjørn Larssen, and Lei Duan Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.7b01147 • Publication Date (Web): 03 Aug 2017 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on August 4, 2017
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Monitoring effect of SO2 emission abatement on recovery of acidified
2
soil and stream water in southwest China
3 4 5
Qian Yu †, Ting Zhang†, Xiaoxiao Ma‡, Ronghua Kang§, Jan Mulder§, Thorjørn Larssen#, Lei Duan†,∇,*
6 7
†
Environment, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China;
8 9 10
State Key laboratory of Environmental Simulation and Pollution Control, School of
‡
State Grid Xingyuan Company Limited, Beijing 100761, China;
§
Department of Environmental Sciences, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Box 5003, NO-1432 Ås, Norway.
11 12
#
Norwegian Institute for Water Research, Gaustadalleen 21, 0349 Oslo, Norway;
13
∇
Collaborative Innovation Centre for Regional Environmental Quality, Tsinghua
14
University, Beijing 100084, China;
15 16
ABSTRACT: Following Europe and North America, East Asia has become a global
17
hotspot of acid deposition, with very high deposition of both sulfur (S) and nitrogen (N)
18
occurring in large areas in southwest and southeast China. Great efforts have been made
19
in reducing national emission of sulfur dioxide (SO2) since 2006 in China. However, the
20
total emission of nitrogen oxides (NOx) continued to increase until 2011. In order to
21
evaluate the effects of SO2 and NOx emission abatement on acid deposition and
22
acidification of soil and water, we monitored the chemical composition of throughfall,
23
soil water, and stream water from 2001 to 2013 in a small, forested catchment near
24
Chongqing city in Southwestern China. The deposition of S decreased significantly,
25
whereas N deposition increased in the recent years. This clearly showed the effect of
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
26
SO2 abatement but not of NOx. Overall the rate of acid deposition was reduced.
27
However, there was delay in the recovery of soil and surface water from acidification,
28
probably due to desorption of previously stored sulfate (SO42-) and increase in nitrate
29
(NO3-) leaching from soil. The average acid input by N transformations has greatly
30
exceeded the H+ input directly by atmospheric deposition. The reversal of acidification
31
with an increase in pH of soil water, requires additional abatement of emissions of both
32
SO2 and NOx.
33
KEYWORDS: sulfur deposition, nitrogen deposition; acidification; sulfur adsorption;
34
nitrogen saturation; Chongqing
35 36
INTRODUCTION
37
Atmospheric acid deposition has been shown to affect the chemistry of soils and
38
surface waters and accelerate their acidification. Trends of soil water in forested
39
catchments and other ecosystems sensitive to acid deposition in the late 1980s and in the
40
1990s, were analyzed in many countries in Europe and North America.1~4 After the
41
Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution to reduce emissions of
42
acidifying pollutants such as sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NOx) was
43
implemented, significant recovery of acidified soil water and surface water in forest
44
ecosystems was reported.5~8
45
Since emission control in Europe and North America has taken effect, East Asia has
46
become the global hotspot of acid deposition. Elevated deposition of both sulfur (S) and
47
nitrogen (N) occurs in southwest and southeast China.9~11 Acid deposition was first
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 37
Page 3 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
48
reported in China in the late 1970s, with the lowest annual average pH of rainwater and
49
highest S deposition in southwest China, especially around Chongqing city.12~14 After a
50
30-year continuous increase, the emissions of SO2 and NOx have been reduced at the
51
national scale in recent years, following the implementation of the National SO2 Total
52
Emission Control in 2006 and the National NOx Total Emission Control in 2011,
53
respectively.15 However, emissions of NH3 have continued to increase because of
54
technical and economic difficulties in controlling these emissions. So far, there have
55
been few long-term monitoring reports of the effects of acid deposition on soils and
56
waters in China.16
57
Much of our understanding of the effect of acid deposition on soils and waters is
58
based on work in temperate regions of Europe and North America, where mineral
59
weathering is the main acid-buffering process in soils.17 Further extension of acid
60
deposition to Eastern and Southern Asia, and South America in recent years,13,18,19
61
warrants the collection of long-term monitoring data on soil and water acidification in
62
these regions. Although acid forest soils in tropical and subtropical regions,
63
characterized by slow mineral weathering and thus limited acid-buffering capacity, are
64
potentially sensitive to acidification,20,21 both atmospheric base cation deposition,22,23
65
denitrification,16 and S accumulation and adsorption24 may enhance the acid neutralizing
66
capacity of these soils.
67
Here, we use long-term monitoring data from a forested catchment near Chongqing
68
city in southwest China during 2001-2013 to examine the trends in soil and water
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
69
acidification, and to assess the effect of recent reductions in national S and N emissions.
70
Accompanying the increasing importance of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and ammonia (NH3)
71
emissions, the acidifying effect of nitrogen (N) deposition has become a research and
72
management focus in recent years.25~27 The main objectives of this study were: (1) to
73
assess the effect of SO2 emission abatement on acid deposition, (2) to investigate the
74
response of soil water and stream water chemistry to changes in acid deposition, and (3)
75
to evaluate the contribution of NOx and NH3 emissions to soil and water acidification.
76 77
METHODOLOGY
78
Study site. Tieshanping (29°38′N, 106°43′E), one of the five long-term monitoring
79
catchments involved in the IMPACTS (Integrated Monitoring Program on Acidification
80
of Chinese Terrestrial Systems) project,9 is a 16-ha subtropical headwater catchment
81
about 25 km northeast from the center of Chongqing City in southwestern China (Fig.1).
82
As one of the biggest cities in southwest China, Chongqing has high emissions of both
83
SO2 and NOx. The SO2 emissions of Chongqing province (with an area of 8.24 Mha;
84
Chongqing as the capital city) reached the highest value in 2006 (0.86 Mt yr-1) and
85
decreased afterwards in response to the national SO2 emission abatement implemented
86
in 2006 (Fig. 2). The NOx emission increased until 2011, when the national NOx
87
abatement was implemented. Due to the relatively constant N fertilizer consumption in
88
Chongqing province since 2001, it is unlikely that the emission of NH3 changed much
89
during 2001-2013.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 37
Page 5 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
90
Annual mean temperature and precipitation (1971 to 2000) at the nearest
91
meteorological station in Chongqing was 18.2°C and 1105 mm, respectively. The
92
bedrock of the catchment is sandstone. The forest soil is locally called Yellow Earth
93
(corresponding to a Haplic Acrisol in FAO, and representative for this part of China),
94
with a thin (< 1 cm) O horizon and low pH value (3.7~4.1 from the O horizon to the
95
lower B horizon).24 Based on earlier studies, the Acrisol at Tieshanping has a dense
96
argic B horizon at about 30 cm soil depth which reduced hydraulic conductivity, thus
97
creating interflow along the hill slope.28 The major biogeochemical processes
98
determining water transport and S and N transformations in soil are thus limited to the
99
upper soil horizons (0-30cm). The vegetation is Masson pine (Pinus massoniana Lamb.)
100
dominated forest, which is widely distributed in the humid subtropical areas of south and
101
southwest China.29 The annual average pH of precipitation at the site ranged from 4.0 to
102
4.2 during 2001–2004, with elevated deposition of S (10 keq·ha−1·yr−1), N (3
103
keq·ha−1·yr−1, about two-thirds as NH4+ and the rest as NO3-) and calcium (Ca) (6
104
keq·ha−1·yr−1).17 The high acid deposition and ambient air SO2 concentration caused
105
acidification of soil and stream water, and impacted forest health.30 In general, the study
106
site could present sensitive forested catchment to acidification in this region.
107
Sampling and chemical analysis. In the catchment of Tieshanping we studied two 10
108
m by 10 m sampling plots named C, and L (Fig. 1), each of which had four throughfall
109
collectors placed in the corners and a set of ceramic suction lysimeters placed close to
110
the center of the plots, at two different depths (about 3 and 30 cm) for soil water
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
111
collection. The self-made throughfall collectors consisted of a 10-cm-diameter funnel to
112
collect throughfall and an opaque bottle to store water. Plot C is located at the foot of the
113
hillslope with an elevation of 560 m above sea level, near the stream, whereas plot L
114
(548 m in elevation) is located near the summit of the hillslope. Continuous sampling of
115
throughfall and soil water was performed weekly at both plots from 2001 to 2013 (Note
116
that in 2007, only throughfall was sampled and analyzed). Stream water was also
117
collected by fixed volume (500 mL) weekly (2001-2004, 2009-2013) at a dam (The dam
118
was moved from downstream of a pool to upstream in 2008), where a flow-measuring
119
flume was installed to record the stream water flux.
120
Every four weeks, the samples from all throughfall collectors, each lysimeter, and
121
stream were pooled into a bulk sample (monthly sample with volume proportion)
122
respectively for chemical analysis. All water samples were filtered (before filtration a
123
sub-sample was used for pH measurement) and analysed for major cations (Ca2+, Mg2+,
124
K+, Na+, and NH4+) and anions (NO3−, SO42−, Cl−, and F−) by ion chromatography.
125
Monomeric (mainly labile) aluminium (Ala) fraction of soil water and surface water was
126
determined by measuring the amount of 8-hydroxy-quinoline aluminium complex that
127
formed within 20 s.31 The organic fraction (Alo) of Ala was determined by passing the
128
sample through a pH-adjusted cation exchange column before 8-hydroxy-quinoline
129
complex formation. Inorganic monomeric Al (Ali) was calculated as the difference
130
between Ala and Alo.32 Al speciation, especially Al3+ concentration, was calculated by
131
the ALCHEMI program.33
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 37
Page 7 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
132
Data analysis. The flux of each ion was calculated from ion concentration and water
133
flux in each compartment. Since the water flux in soil was not directly measured in this
134
study, it was estimated on the basis of the Na+ balance assumption (The ratio of soil
135
water flux to throughfall water flux is assumed to equal the ratio of Na+ concentration in
136
throughfall to that in soil water). 24 It should be noted that Cl- is generally assumed to be
137
conservative, and thus can be used as a tracer to estimate soil water flux.34 However,
138
long-term monitoring in this catchment showed significant sink of Cl- in soil, as
139
indicated by similar or even lower Cl- concentration in soil water and stream water than
140
in throughfall water (Fig. S1 in Supplementary Information). In comparison with Cl-,
141
Na+ seemed more conservative in this catchment (Fig. S2). Considering the existence of
142
potential sources/sinks of Na+ in soil such as mineral weathering and cation exchange,
143
even extremely low in this catchment,24,35 the estimation of soil water flux based on the
144
real ratios of Na+ concentrations between throughfall and soil water might cause
145
uncertainty. Therefore, a fixed ratio of soil water flux to throughfall water flux was
146
assumed, 0.79 for S1 and 0.43 for S2, according to a fertilizing experiment by NaNO3
147
addition in the same catchment,24 where Na+ was more conservative than the untreated
148
soil because soil Na+ weathering or exchange could be ignored due to huge amount of
149
Na+ added.
150
The acid neutralizing capacity (ANC) was calculated as the sum of base cations (Ca2+
151
+ Mg2+ + K+ + Na+ + NH4+, in equivalent) minus the sum of acid anions (SO42- + NO3- +
152
Cl- + F-, in equivalent) based on the charge balance approach.36 The molar ratio of base
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
153
cation to Al3+, Bc/Al, was calculated as the sum of base cation (Ca2+ + Mg2+ + K+, in
154
molar concentration) divided by the molar concentration of Al3+. In addition to H+
155
deposition, N transformations may contribute to soil acidification (H+N):37
156
H+N = (NH4+i –NH4+o) + (NO3-o – NO3-i)
157
where NH4+i and NO3-i were throughfall fluxes of NH4+ and NO3- respectively, and
158
NH4+o and NO3-o were the leaching fluxed of NH4+ and NO3- in soil water.
159
Statistically significant temporal changes in the chemical composition of throughfall
160
and soil water was analyzed by the flow-adjusted, seasonal Kendall test (SKT) and the
161
Sen slope.38-40 The analysis was done for two periods, 2001-2006 and 2008-2013,
162
respect to the SO2 emission control since 2006. Monthly data of pH, SO42-, NO3-, Ca2+,
163
and Al3+ concentration were used for analysis. In addition, post hoc analysis using
164
one-way ANOVA was applied to analyze differences in water chemistry in different
165
periods (2001-2006 and 2008-2013). Difference were considered significant at the p ≤
166
0.05 level.
167 168
RESULTS
169
Throughfall. The monthly concentration of major ions, such as SO42-, NO3-, NH4+,
170
Ca2+, and Al3+ in throughfall water, as well as the water amount and pH of throughfall,
171
show clear seasonal variation (Fig. 3). The pH (annual average ranging from 3.35 to
172
4.53) was high in summer but low in winter, which coincided with the seasonal variation
173
of precipitation (shown by throughfall water amount). Throughfall pH was only greater
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 37
Page 9 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
174
than 5.6 during a few months in summer. The concentrations of SO42-, NO3-, and Ca2+
175
were all higher in winter than in summer. In general, lower concentrations of SO42- and
176
NO3- due to the diluting effect of abundant rain in summer might lead to higher pH. The
177
NH4+ concentration showed not only peaks in winter, but also some peaks in summer,
178
which reflected high NH3 emission from agricultural field in the growing season.
179
The pH of throughfall showed a significant trend of decrease during 2001-2006
180
(negative Sen slope by SKT; at a rate of -0.0953 yr-1), but a significant increase during
181
2008-2013 (at a rate of 0.1792 yr-1) (Table 1). Several ions had significant
182
increasing/decreasing trends in concentration values. For example, until 2006, the SO42-
183
concentration in throughfall increased significantly (at 97.25 µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1). However,
184
after 2008 the concentration of SO42- decreased (at a rate of -110.5 µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1). In
185
contrast, the NO3- concentration showed an increasing trend during the whole period (at
186
12.59 µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1); This rate became even higher in recent years. The concentration of
187
NH4+ and Ca2+ also showed increasing trends during the whole period. The faster rate of
188
SO42- concentration decreasing than the increasing rate of NO3- concentration after 2008
189
(while no significant trends in NH4+ and Ca2+) indicated decreasing trend of throughfall
190
water acidity, coincided with the increasing trend of pH.
191
Soil water and surface water. Temporal variations of monthly concentration of
192
SO42- and Ca2+ in soil water and stream water coincided with those in throughfall (with
193
some delay), but with smaller amplitude (especially in S2 and stream water) (Fig. 3).
194
Due to nitrification or uptake, little NH4+ occurred in soil water (especially in S2). As a
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
195
result of NO3- formation by nitrification, more frequent variation of NO3- concentration
196
was found in S1 than in throughfall, according to the peaks of DIN (NH4+ + NO3-) in
197
throughfall. The pH of soil water showed opposite trend to throughfall, i.e., lower in
198
summer but higher in winter. The stream water chemistry was even more stable than that
199
of soil water in the bottom layer (S2).
200
Unlike throughfall, soil water and stream water showed a decreasing trend of pH in
201
the whole period (at -0.0171, -0.0369 and -0.0877 yr-1 in S1, S2 and SW respectively)
202
(Table 1). The annual average pH of stream water was in the range of 3.96-4.85, which
203
was greater than that of soil water (S1, 3.39-4.03;S2, 3.59-4.30). Unlike the decreasing
204
trend of SO42- concentration in throughfall after 2008, the SO42- concentration of soil
205
water and stream water showed no significant trend during the same period, even
206
increasing trend during the whole study period (at 23.53 and 40.64 µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1 in S2 and
207
SW respectively). The concentration of NO3- and NH4+ in soil water and stream water
208
showed also an increasing trend, similar as in throughfall. The increase in Ca2+
209
concentration in stream water might neutralize the increase in SO42- concentration (i.e.,
210
the changing rates of Ca2+ and SO22- were similar), while decreasing pH coincided with
211
increasing NO3-. It should be noted that more variable stream water chemistry during
212
2009-2013 occurred than during 2001-2004 period (Fig. 3), because the dam for stream
213
water monitoring was moved from the downstream to upstream of a small pond.
214
Accompanying the decrease in pH, the Al3+ concentration in soil water showed an
215
increasing trend during the whole period (at 20.80 and 32.26 µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1 in S1 and S2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 10 of 37
Page 11 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
216
respectively) (Table 1). However, there was significant decline in the saturation of the
217
soil solution with respect to Al(OH)3, as can be seen from the significant decline in log
218
Q (defined as log Al + 3 pH)41 (Fig. 3).
219
Fluxes. Yearly fluxes of S, N, Ca + Mg, and H+ in throughfall, soil water, and stream
220
water showed also variation during 2001-2013 (Fig.4). The fluxes of S and Ca + Mg
221
showed generally a decreasing trend along the hydrological continuums (i.e., from
222
throughfall to soil water, then to stream water). In contrast, the fluxes of total inorganic
223
nitrogen (TIN) in top soil water (S1) were larger than that in throughfall. The average H+
224
depostion based on throughfall was significantly lower during 2008-2013 than during
225
2001-2006 (one-way ANOVA; Table S1), which coincided with the significantly higher
226
average pH of throughfall during 2008-2013 than during 2001-2006. However, the
227
average H+ flux in soil water (S2) was significantly higher during 2008-2013 than
228
during 2001-2006, while there is no significant difference in H+ flux in stream water.
229
There were no significant differences in fluxes of SO42-, NO3- and Ca2+ between the two
230
periods in stream water, with only exception of NO3- depostion, which was significantly
231
higher during 2008-2013 than during 2001-2006 (one-way ANOVA; Table S1).
232 233
DISCUSSION
234
Change of acid deposition. The significant declining trend of S depositon after 2008
235
found in this study is among the first to document a successful SO2 emission abatement
236
in China. During the monitoring period, the annual S deposition (based on throughfall)
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
237
increased to maximum values in 2004 and 2005 (>14 keq·ha-1·yr-1; Fig. 4). After 2008,
238
the S deposition showed a decreasing trend (significant negative Sen slope; Table 1),
239
reaching 7.7 keq·ha-1·yr-1 in 2013, which is smaller than in 2001. This temporal pattern
240
in throughfall deposition of S, with its decline after 2008, coincides with a decrease in
241
SO2 emission in Chongqing province (Fig. 2). In contrast, the annual N deposition
242
continued to increase, reaching 5.3 keq·ha-1·yr-1 in 2010 - 2012, which is twice as much
243
as in 2001 (2.5 keq·ha-1·yr-1) (Fig. 4). This trend also coincides with the fast increasing
244
NOx emission before 2011 (Fig. 2), which resulted in larger increase in NO3- than NH4+
245
in N deposition, and decrease in NH4+/NO3- ratio (Fig. 4). The net effect of the two N
246
species on throughfall was thus decrease in pH. The effect of decreasing NOx emission
247
after 2011 has not been seen yet.
248
Although S and N deposition at the site were large compared to values in Europe and
249
North America in 1980s,9 the precipitation was not exceptionally acidic, with annual
250
average pH of throughfall of 3.79, which is within the range of values reported for
251
typically acidified regions in North America and Europe (3.5~4.5).1~3,42 The annual
252
average pH of deposition would have been around 3.0 without the high deposition of
253
Ca2+ (and other base cations), which reflected the importance of the alkaline dust,
254
mainly from anthropogenic sources such as cement production and iron steel industry in
255
China.23 The annual Ca2+ deposition showed an increasing trend (due to increasing
256
anthropogenic emission of Ca-content dust),43 reaching a value as high as 8.2
257
keq·ha-1·yr-1. The annual Mg2+ deposition fluxes (see Fig. S3 for monthly variation in
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 37
Page 13 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
258
concentration) amounted to about 23% of Ca2+ deposition (Fig. 4), and also contributed
259
greatly to ANC. As a result of decreasing S deposition and increasing Ca deposition
260
since 2008, the H+ deposition decreased after reaching maximum values of about 4
261
keq·ha-1·yr-1 (Fig. 4).
262
S and N budet. The overall budget (i.e., the difference between throughfall
263
deposition flux and stream water output) indicated considerable retention of S, N and Ca
264
in the catchment (Table 2). The S output with soil water in the top layer (S1) was lower
265
than input by deposition, especially in the earlier years. This highlights a significant
266
SO42- sink in the upper soil. In a recent study we found that SO42- adsorption in the acid
267
soils was the most likely mechanism removing SO42- from soil water.24 The sulfate
268
adsorbed pool was 16.3-28.5 keq ha-1 in the upper 30 cm soil layer, and there might be
269
larger adsorption capacity in deeper soil layer.16 In addition, incorporation to organic
270
matter might be another important sulfate rentention mechanism, especially in the topper
271
soil with higer organic carbon content. The organic S pool was estimated to be 11 keq
272
ha-1 according to the ratio of organic S to organic C
273
soil.24 Since the S deposition was averaged to 11.5 keq ha-1 yr-1 during 2001-2006 (Table
274
S1), this SO42- sink in top soil (3.33 keq ha-1 yr-1 in Table2) amounted to about 29% of
275
the S deposition. As SO42- adsorption is a process of ligand exchange with OH-,44 it may
276
account for an increase in the ANC with about 3 keq ha-1 yr-1, which is larger than the
277
annual H+ depostion (2.60 keq ha-1 yr-1). Adsorption and desorption may also be
278
important to control short-term fluctuations of the SO42- flux, such as the observed
48
and the organic C content in
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
279
year-to-year variation. When S deposition decreased after 2008, the S sink in S1
280
decreased to 1.30 keq ha-1 yr-1, which accounted for only 12% of the S deposition
281
(averagely 11.0 keq ha-1 yr-1) during 2008-2013 (Table S1). In addition, much more S
282
retention occurred below the upper 30 cm soil layer (Table 2). Together with SO42-
283
adsorption in the deeper soil, SO42- reduction to sulfides in the wet soils of the
284
groundwater discharge zone (GDZ) may contribute significantly to S sink in the
285
catchment, which need be tested in the future.
286
In soil water, the flux of NH4+-N was very low, while that of NO3--N was large and
287
even exceeded the sum of the input of NH4+ and NO3- in throughfall (Fig. 4). This
288
indicates that most NH4+ derived from throughfall deposition and mineralization of soil
289
organic matter was nitrified. The large leaching of NO3--N from the top soil layer (S1)
290
indicates large N internal cycle, as illustrated by the rapid mineralization of annual
291
litterfall.45
292
decreased due to immobilization, nutrient uptake, and denitrification16. As a result, the
293
upper 30cm soil layer showed a slight N sink (averaged 1.38 keq ha-1 yr-1; according to
294
Table 2), which indicated little less N flux in soil solution (S2) than in throughfall
295
deposition. In addition, there were larger variations of N fluxes from year to year in the
296
soil solution; the fluxes were larger in the wet years, which can be attributed to
297
mineralized N from litterfall and soil organic matter at high moisture conditions (driven
298
by rainfall). It may be concluded that N saturation46 is extreme in hillslope soils at
299
Tieshanping with all N deposition leached. This is also shown in the studies of soil N
From the top layer (S1) to the lower layer (S2), the N flux in soil water
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 37
Page 15 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
300
status,45 N mass balances,24 natural 15N abundances47,48 and 15N tracer49 in the catchment.
301
Similar to S, a high N retention occurs in the groundwater discharge zone, that is, after
302
percolation water has left the upper 30 cm of soil but before the water leaves the
303
catchment as stream water at the weir (Table 2). Denitrification, especially in GDZ, may
304
be the key reason of N loss.16 Since loss of nitrate by denitrification provides ANC,
305
stream water was much less acidified than soil water, by nitrogen deposition.
306
Like S, Ca2+ sink mainly occurred in the upper 30 cm of the soil (Table 2). In China,
307
Ca2+ deposition is a major source of Ca2+ in soil water.16,23 The soil Ca2+ sink was too
308
large to be explained by plant uptake, since the Ca2+ uptake by forest trees at the site was
309
estimated to only 0.25-1.10 keq ha-1 yr-1.50 A possible mechanism might be the building
310
up of cation exchange capacity (CEC),16 possibly due to the increasing content of soil
311
organic matter caused by N and Ca deposition.27,51
312
Acidification and recovery. The concentration of SO42- and NO3- in soil water in the
313
catchment was very high, even one order higher than that seen in Europe in 1980s and
314
1990s.1~4 Although the concentration of base cations (especially Ca2+) was also very
315
high, it was not high enough to compensate for the negative charge associated with
316
SO42- and NO3-. Thus, the pH of soil water and stream water was relatively low.
317
The pH and the concentration (and deposition) of SO42- in throughfall showed
318
acidification of rainwater during 2001-2006, and recovery (not only alkalinisation
319
because of significant decrease in S deposition) after 2008. However, pH of soil water
320
did not show a significant increase in recent years, even with significant increase in pH
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
321
of stream water (Table 1 and Table S1). The delayed recovery of forest soil and surface
322
water from acidification was also widely found in Europe and North America, and
323
attributed to the release of previously stored SO42- from soil, coupled to the leaching of
324
Al3+ and base cations.3,4,52~54 The large adsorption of SO42- by soil on oxide surfaces
325
buffered soil acidity thus limiting the concentration of H+ in soil water, especially in the
326
earlier years (2001-2006). This occurred even with much NH4+ nitrified to produce
327
acidity. In recent years, accompanying the decrease in SO42- concentration in soil water
328
due to the decrease in S deposition, SO42- adsorption largely decreased and the
329
previously adsorbed sulfate outflowed from the upper 30 cm soil layer, which led to an
330
increase in ANC sink and thus a H+ source in this layer (Table 2). However, the total
331
SO42- sink remained unchanged because of the increase in SO42- adsorption in deeper
332
soil layer (Table 2).
333
Associated with the increasing N deposition, N transformations played an
334
increasingly important role in the acidification of soils and waters. The average acid
335
input by N transformation was 3.03 keq ha-1 yr-1, exceeding the H+ input directly by
336
atmospheric deposition (1.91 keq ha-1 yr-1) (Fig. 5). The exceedance was larger than the
337
previous findings.25 Since the S flux in soil water and stream water did not show
338
significantly increasing trend in recent years, the decrease in pH in stream water (Table
339
1) might be caused by increase in NO3- leaching. Actually, since NOx emission
340
abatement only began in 2011, its effect on acidification was not expected to see.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 16 of 37
Page 17 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
341
The Al3+ concentration of soil water did not change with the decrease of pH,
342
providing further evidence that gibbsite equilibrium does not present a good model to
343
describe the Al solubility.24,55,56 There was significant decline in log Q (defined as log
344
Al + 3 pH), while Al3+ concentration increasing (Table 1). The results may support the
345
earlier hypothesis that in strongly acidified forest soils complexion by solid phase
346
organics controls the solubility of Al, even in mineral soil layers, relatively low in
347
organic C.41,57
348
The Bc/Al in soil water is commonly used as a risk indicator for forest decline due to
349
acidification,58 and 1.0 is widely used as a critical limit in critical load assessments in
350
Europe.59 In this study, the molar ratios of Bc/Al in soil water of S2 were averaged to
351
2.42 at Tieshanping, much higher than the critical limit used. However, possible damage
352
to forest by acidification had occurred at this site due to high Al concentration. 32 This
353
implies that a higher critical limit should be applied in subtropical China.60 In addition,
354
no significant trend of increasing Bc/Al was found after 2008 than before 2006.
355 356
POLICY IMPLICATION
357
The long-term monitoring on throughfall, soil water and stream water during 2001 to
358
2013 in Tieshanping catchment, representing catchments sensitive to acidification in
359
southwest China, showed clear effect of emission abatement on recovery of acidified
360
soil and stream water. Coincided with the decrease in SO2 emission in Chongqing
361
province after 2006, a significantly decreasing trend of S deposition was detected during
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
362
2008-2013. In contrast, N deposition continued increasing in accordance with the
363
increase in NOx (until 2011) and NH3 emission. As a net effect, acid deposition had
364
been reduced, and the acidification of soil water and surface water had leveled off. The
365
trends of deposition in Tieshanping from 2001-2013 could represent the regional or even
366
national trends. It should be noted that high SO42- adsorption in the acid soil, together
367
very high deposition of base cations, especially Ca2+, provided large ANC to the
368
ecosystem. Those might be the main reasons that the soil water acidification in China
369
was not very serious in comparison with that in Europe and North America, even with
370
much higher S and N deposition. However, the recovery of acidified soil water and
371
surface water was delayed, due probably to desorption of previously stored sulfate
372
(SO42-) and enhanced leaching of nitrate (NO3-) from soil. Since soil acidification is still
373
very serious, shown by quite low pH in soil water, future emission abatement of both
374
SO2 and NOx should be strengthened.
375 376
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
377
Supporting Information
378
Additional information on the water chemistry during the periods and the calculation of
379
soil water flux are presented in a supplementary document.
380
AUTHOR INFORMATION
381
Corresponding Author
382
* Phone: +86 10 6278 3758; fax: +86 10 6277 3597; e-mail:
[email protected] 383
Notes
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 18 of 37
Page 19 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
384
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
385 386
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
387
The authors are grateful for the financial support of the National Natural Science
388
Foundation of China (21221004), the State Environmental Protection Public Welfare
389
Project of China (201209001) and the Research Council of Norway (209696/E10) to
390
carry out this study.
391 392
REFERENCE
393
(1) Meesenburg, H.; Meiwes, K. J.; Rademacher P. Long term trends in atmospheric
394
deposition and seepage output in northwest German forest ecosystems. Water, Air,
395
Soil Pollut. 1995, 85, 611-616.
396
(2) Kvaalen, H.; Solberg, S.; Clarke, N.; Torp, T.; Aamlid, D. Time series study of
397
concentrations of SO42- and H+ in precipitation and soil waters in Norway. Environ
398
Pollut. 2002, 117, 215-224.
399
(3) Moffat, A.J.; Kvaalen, H.; Solberg, S.; Clarke, N. Temporal trends in throughfall
400
and soil water chemistryat three Norwegian forests, 1986-1997. Forest Eco Manag.
401
2002, 168, 15-28.
402
(4) Fölster, J.; Bringmark, L.; Lundin, L. Temporal and spatial variations in soilwater
403
chemistry at three acid forest sites. Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 2003, 146, 171-195.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
404
(5) Lawrence, G. B.; Hazlett, P. W.; Fernandez, I. J.; Ouimet, R.; Bailey, S. W.;
405
Shortle, W. C.; Smith, K. T.; Antidormi, M. R., Declining Acidic Deposition
406
Begins Reversal of Forest-Soil Acidification in the Northeastern US and Eastern
407
Canada. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2015, 49, (22), 13103-13111
408
(6) Garmo, Ø. A.; Skjelkvåle, B. L.; Wit, H. A. d.; Colombo, L.; Curtis, C.; Fölster, J.;
409
Hoffmann, A.; Hruška, J.; Høgåsen, T.; Jeffries, D. S., Trends in Surface Water
410
Chemistry in Acidified Areas in Europe and North America from 1990 to 2008.
411
Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 2014, 225, (3), 1-14.
412
(7) Strock, K. E.; Nelson, S. J.; Kahl, J. S.; Saros, J. E.; Mcdowell, W. H., Decadal
413
trends reveal recent acceleration in the rate of recovery from acidification in the
414
northeastern U.S. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2014, 48, (9), 4681-9.
415
(8) Sutherland, J. W.; Acker, F. W.; Bloomfield, J. A.; Boylen, C. W.; Charles, D. F.;
416
Daniels, R. A.; Eichler, L. W.; Farrell, J. L.; Feranec, R. S.; Hare, M. P., Brooktrout
417
Lake case study: biotic recovery from acid deposition 20 years after the 1990 Clean
418
Air Act Amendments. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2015, 49, (5), 2665-74.
419 420
(9) Larssen, T.; Lydersen, E.; Tang, D. G.; et al. Acid rain in China. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2006, 40, 418-425.
421
(10) Zhao, Y.; Duan, L.; Xing, J.; Larssen, T.; Nielsen, C.; Hao, J. M. Soil acidification
422
in China: Is controlling SO2 emissions enough? Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43,
423
8021-8026.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 20 of 37
Page 21 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
424
(11) Zhao, B.; Wang, S. X.; Dong, X. Y.; Wang, J. D.; Duan, L.; Fu, X.; Hao, J. M.; Fu,
425
J. Environmental effects of the recent emission changes in China: Implications for
426
particulate matter pollution and soil acidification. Environ. Res Lett. 2013, 8,
427
024031.
428
(12) Zhao, D. W.; Sun, B. Z. Air pollution and acid rain in China. Ambio 1986, 15, 2-5.
429
(13) Galloway, J. N.; Zhao, D. W.; Xiong, J. L.; Likens. G. E. Acid rain: a comparison
430
of China, United States and a remote area. Science 1987, 236, 1559-1962.
431
(14) Hao, J. M.; Xie, S. D.; Duan, L.; Ye X. M. Acid deposition and ecosystem
432
sensitivity in China. In: Bashkin V., Park S. (eds.). Acid Deposition and Ecosystem
433
Sensitivity in East Asia. Nova Science Publishers, New York, 1998, pp267-311.
434
(15) MEP (Ministry of Environmental Protection) of China. Notice of the State Council
435
on Issuing the Twelfth Five-Year Plan for National Environmental Protection. 2011.
436
http://zfs.mep.gov.cn/fg/gwyw/ 201112/t20111221_221570.htm. (in Chinese)
437
(16) Larssen, T.; Duan, L.; Mulder, J. Deposition and leaching of sulfur, nitrogen and
438
calcium in four forested catchments in China: implications for acidification.
439
Environ. Sci. Technol. 2011, 45, 1192-1198.
440
(17) Sverdrup, H.; Warfvinge, P. Weathering of primary silicate minerals in the natural
441
soil environment in relation to a chemical weathering model. Water, Air, Soil Pollut.
442
1988, 38, 387-408.
443 444
(18) Figueredo, D. V. Influence of calcareous soil particulates on acid rain: Belo Horizonte Metropolitan Region, Brazil. Ambio 1999, 28, 514-518.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
445 446 447 448
(19) Bhattacharya, A.; Mudgal, R.; Taneja, A. Acid deposition and critical load analysis in Agra, India. J Hazard Mater 2004, 106, 157-160. (20) Duan, L.; Xie, S. D.; Zhou, Z. P.; Hao, J. M. Critical loads of acid deposition on soil in China. Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 2000, 118, 35-51.
449
(21) Lu, X. K.; Mao, Q. G.; Mo, J. M.; Gilliam, F. S.; Zhou, G. Y.; Luo, Y. Q.; Zhang,
450
W.; Huang, J. Divergent responses of soil buffering capacity to long-term N
451
deposition in three typical tropical forests with different land-use history. Environ.
452
Sci. Technol. 2015, 49, 4072-4080.
453
(22) Zhao, Y.; Duan, L.; Larssen, T.; Hu L. H.; Hao, J. M. Simultaneous assessment of
454
depositions of base cations, sulfur and nitrogen using an extended critical load
455
function for acidification. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2007, 41, 1815-1820.
456
(23) Zhao, Y.; Duan, L.; Lei, Y.; Xing, J.; Nielsen, C. P.; Hao, J. M. Will PM control
457
undermine China’s efforts to reduce soil acidification? Environ. Pollut. 2011, 159,
458
2726-2732.
459
(24) Huang, Y. M.; Kang, R. H.; Mulder, J.; Zhang, T.; Duan, L. Nitrogen saturation,
460
soil acidification and ecological effects in a subtropical pine forest on acid soil in
461
Southwest China. J Geophys Res. 2015, 120, 2457–2472.
462
(25) Chen, X. Y.; Mulder, J.; Wang, Y. H.; Zhao, D. W.; Xiang, R. J. Atmospheric
463
deposition, mineralization and leaching of nitrogen in subtropical forested
464
catchments, south China. Environ Geochem Hlth 2004, 26, 179-186.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 22 of 37
Page 23 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
465 466
(26) Liu, X. J.; Duan, L.; Mo, J. M.; et al. Nitrogen deposition and its ecological impact in China: an overview. Environ. Pollut. 2011, 159, 2251-2264.
467
(27) Lu, X. K.; Mao, Q. G.; Gilliam, F. S.; Luo, Y. Q.; Mo, J. M. Nitrogen deposition
468
contributes to soil acidification in tropical ecosystems. Glob. Change Biol. 2014, 20,
469
3790-3801.
470
(28) Sørbotten, L. Hill slope unsaturated flowpaths and soil moisture variability in a
471
forested catchment in southwest China. Master Dissertation, Norwegian University
472
of Life Sciences, Aas, 2011.
473
(29) Wu, Z. Y. China Vegetation. Science Press, Beijing, 1980. (in Chinese)
474
(30) Wang, Y. H.; Solberg, S.; Yu, P. T. Assessments of tree crown condition of two
475
Masson pine forests in the acid rain region in south China. Forest Ecol Manag,
476
2007, 242, 530-540.
477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484
(31) Barnes, R. B. The determination of specific forms of aluminium in natural water. Chem Geol 1975, 15, 177-191. (32) Driscoll, C. T. A procedure for the fractionation of aqueous aluminium in dilute acidic waters. Int J Environ An Ch 1984, 16, 267-283. (33) Schecher, W. D.; Driscoll, C. T. An evaluation of uncertainty associated with aluminium equilibrium calculations. Water Resour Res 1987, 23, 525-534. (34) Drever, J. I.; Clow, D. W. Weathering rates in catchment. Rev Mineral 1995, 31, 463-483.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
485
(35) Duan, L.; Liu, J.; Xin, Y.; Larssen, T., Air-pollution emission control in China:
486
Impacts on soil acidification recovery and constraints due to drought. Sci. Total
487
Environ. 2013, 463, 1031-1041.
488 489 490 491 492 493 494 495
(36) Reuss, J. O.; Christophersen, N.; Seip, H. M., A critique of models for freshwater and soil acidification. Water, Air, Soil Pollut. 1986, 30, (30), 909-930. (37) Van Breemen, N.; Mulder, J.; Driscoll, C. T. Acidification and alkalinization of soil. Plant Soil 1983, 75, 283–308. (38) Hirsch, R. M.; Slack, J. R. A nonparametric test for seasonal data with serial dependence. Water Resour Res 1984, 20, 727-732. (39) Sen, P. K. Estimations of the regression coefficient base on Kendall’s Tau. J Am Stat Assoc 1968, 63, 1379-1389.
496
(40) Hirsch, R. M.; Slack, J. R.; Smith, R. A. Techniques of trend analysis for monthly
497
water quality data. Water Resour Res 1982, 18, 107-121.Mulder, J.; Stein, A. The
498
solubility of aluminum in acidic forest soils: Long-term changes due to acid
499
deposition. Geochim Cosmochim Ac 1994, 58, 85-94.
500 501
(41) Likens, G. E.; Driscoll, C. T.; Buso, D. C. Long-term effects of acid rain: Response and recovery of a forest ecosystem. Science 1996, 272, 244-246.
502
(42) Lei, Y.; Zhang, Q.; He, K. B.; Streets, D. G. Primary anthropogenic aerosol
503
emission trends for China, 1990–2005. Atmos Chemd Phys 2011, 11, 931-954.
504
(43) McBride, M. B. Environmental Chemistry of Soils. Oxford University Press, New
505
York, 1994.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 24 of 37
Page 25 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
506 507 508 509
(44) Chen, X. Y.; Mulder, J. Indicators for nitrogen status and leaching in subtropical forest ecosystems, South China. Biogeochemistry 2007, 82, 165-180. (45) Aber, J. D.; Nadelhoffer K. J.; Steudler P.; Melillo J. M. Nitrogen saturation in northern forest ecosystems. BioScience 1989, 39, 378-386.
510
(46) Zhu, J.; Mulder, J.; Bakken, L.; Dorsch, P., The importance of denitrification for
511
N2O emissions from an N-saturated forest in SW China: results from in situ N-15
512
labeling experiments. Biogeochemistry 2013, 116, (1-3), 103-117.
513
(47) Yu, L.; Zhu, J.; Mulder, J.; Dörsch, P., Multiyear dual nitrate isotope signatures
514
suggest that N‐saturated subtropical forested catchments can act as robust N sinks.
515
Glob. Change Biol. 2016, 22, (11), 3662-3674.
516
(48) Yu, L.; Kang, R.; Mulder, J.; Zhu, J.; Dorsch, P., Distinct fates of atmogenic NH4+
517
and NO3- in subtropical, N-saturated forest soils. Biogeochemistry 2017, 133, (3),
518
279-294.
519
(49) Duan, L.; Huang, Y. M.; Hao, J. M.; Xie, S. D.; Hou, M. Vegetation uptake of
520
nitrogen and base cations in China and its role in soil acidification. Sci. Total
521
Environ. 2004, 330, 187-198.
522
(50) Luo, Y.; Duan, L.; Xu, G. Y.; Hao, J. M. Inhibition of mercury release from forest
523
soil by high atmospheric deposition of Ca2+ and SO42-. Chemosphere 2015, 134,
524
113-119.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
525
(51) Kopacek, J.; Hejzlar, J.; Porcal, P.; Posch, M., Sulphate leaching from diffuse
526
agricultural and forest sources in a large central European catchment during
527
1900-2010. Sci. Total Environ. 2014, 470, 543-550.
528
(52) Prechtel, A.; Alewell, C.; Armbruster, M.; et al. Response of sulphur dynamics in
529
European catchments to decreasing sulphate deposition. Hydrol Earth Syst Sc 2001,
530
5, 311-325.
531
(53) Robison, A. L.; Scanlon, T. M.; Cosby, B. J.; Webb, J. R.; Galloway, J. N., Roles
532
of sulfate adsorption and base cation supply in controlling the chemical response of
533
streams of western Virginia to reduced acid deposition. Biogeochemistry 2013, 116,
534
(1-3), 119-130.
535
(54) Gruba, P.; Mulder J. Relationship between aluminum in soils and soil water in
536
mineral horizons of a range of acid forest soils. Soil Sci Soc Am J 2008, 72,1150–
537
1157.
538
(55) Gruba, P.; Mulder J.; Brożek S. Modelling the pH dependency of dissolved calcium
539
and aluminium in O, A and B horizons of acid forest soils. Geoderma, 2013, 206,
540
85–91.
541
(56) Berggren, D.; Mulder, J. The role of organic matter in controlling aluminium
542
solubility in acidic mineral soils horizons. Geochim Cosmochim Ac 1995, 59,
543
4167-4180.
544 545
(57) Cronan, C. S.; Grigal, D. F. Use of calcium/aluminum ratios as indicators of stress in forest ecosystems. J Environ Qual 1995, 24, 209-226.
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 26 of 37
Page 27 of 37
Environmental Science & Technology
546 547
(58) Sverdrup, H.; Warfvinge, P.; Frogner, T.; Håøya, A. O.; Johansson, M.; Andersen, B. Critical loads for forest soils in the Nordic countries. Ambio 1992, 21, 348-355.
548
(59) Sverdrup, H., Warfvinge, P. Effect of Soil Acidification on Growth of Trees and
549
Plants as Expression by the (Ca+Mg+K)/Al Ratio. Report 2: 1993, Lund University,
550
Lund, 1993.
551
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
552
Page 28 of 37
Tables
553 554
Table 1 Sen slopes of throughfall (CTF), soil water (S1 and S2), and stream water (SW)
555
concentrationa Component
Period
pH
SO42-
NO3-
NH4+
Ca2+
Al3+
logQ
CTF
2001~2013
0.0073**
n.s.
12.59**
6.232*
16.69*
-
-
2001~2006
-0.0953**
97.25**
9.756**
n.s.
n.s.
-
-
2008~2013
0.1792**
-110.5**
12.78**
n.s.
n.s.
-
-
2001~2013
-0.0171**
n.s.
30.94**
2.681**
n.s.
20.80**
-0.0798**
2001~2006
-0.0073**
n.s
29.70*
n.s
n.s
43.80**
n.s.
2008~2013
0.0042*
n.s
n.s
n.s
n.s
n.s.
n.s.
2001~2013
-0.0369**
23.53**
26.18**
n.s
n.s.
32.26**
-0.0963**
2001~2006
-0.0263**
44.70**
35.54**
n.s.
n.s
32.57**
n.s.
2008~2013
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
2001~2013
-0.0877**
40.64**
9.452**
2.580**
40.82**
-
-
2001~2006
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2008~2013
-0.0713*
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
n.s.
-
-
S1
S2
SW
556
a
Analyzed by seasonal Kendall test (SKT), with change of concentration in µeq⋅L-1⋅yr-1, and change of pH in yr-1;
557
* Trend significant at P