Subscriber access provided by Washington University | Libraries
Article
A net-zero energy model for sustainable wastewater treatment Peng Yan, Rongcong Qin, Jinsong Guo, Qiang Yu, Zhe Li, You-Peng Chen, Yu Shen, and Fang Fang Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b04735 • Publication Date (Web): 12 Dec 2016 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on December 13, 2016
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
2
A net-zero energy model for sustainable wastewater treatment
3
Peng Yan1* Rong-cong Qin1*, Jin-song Guo1**, Qiang Yu1, Zhe Li1, You-peng Chen1, Yu Shen1, Fang
4
Fang2
1
5
1
Key Laboratory of Reservoir Aquatic Environment of CAS, Chongqing Institute of Green and
6
Intelligent Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Chongqing 400714, China
7
2
8
400045, China
College of Urban Construction and Environmental Engineering, Chongqing University, Chongqing
9 10
* The two authors contributed equally to this work
11 12
**Corresponding Author
13
Prof. Jin-song Guo
14
Fax: +86-23-65935901, Tel: +86-23-65935901
15
Email:
[email protected] 16 17 18 19 20 21
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
22 23
Abstract: The large external energy input prevents the wastewater treatment from being
24
environmentally sustainable. A net-zero energy (NZE) wastewater treatment concept based on
25
biomass energy recycling was proposed to avoid wasting resources and promote energy recycling in
26
wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Simultaneously, a theoretical model and boundary condition
27
based on energy balance were established to evaluate the feasibility of achieving NZE in WWTPs;
28
the model and condition were employed to analyze data from 20 conventional WWTPs in China.
29
Six WWTPs can currently export excess energy, eight WWTPs can achieve 100% energy
30
self-sufficiency by adjusting the metabolic material allocation, and six municipal WWTPs cannot
31
achieve net-zero energy consumption based on the evaluation of the theoretical model. The NZE
32
model offset 79.5% of the electricity and sludge disposal cost compared with conventional
33
wastewater treatment. The NZE model provides a theoretical basis for optimization of material
34
regulation for effective utilization of organic energy from wastewater, and promotes engineering
35
applications of the NZE concept in WWTPs.
36 37 38
39
Keywords: net-zero energy; wastewater treatment; biomass energy recycling; theoretical model; anaerobic digestion
1. INTRODUCTION
40
Wastewater purification consumes a large amount of electricity.1 Treatment of wastewater
41
currently consumes approximately 4% of all electrical power produced in the United States,
42
whereas the electricity consumption of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in China is 1 × 1011
43
kWh.2,3 The electricity required for wastewater treatment will increase by 20% in the next 15 years 2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 29
Page 3 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
44
in developed countries, leading to significantly increased CO2 emissions and resource consumption,
45
because WWTPs have a large carbon footprint.4,5,6 The consequences of the massive energy
46
consumption of WWTPs include damage to the environment, depletion of natural resources, and
47
significant economic burden.7,8,9 Therefore, sustainable wastewater treatment processes must be
48
developed to decrease electricity consumption and the greenhouse gas (GHG) footprint of
49
WWTPs.4,10,11
50
Wastewater contains a significant amount of potential energy.12,13 The organic energy in
51
wastewater is approximately 9–10 times greater than that used to treat it.14 Wastewater treatment is
52
a complex microbial metabolic process, in which microbes utilize pollutants to achieve sustained
53
growth and propagation.15 Some organic energy is converted into biomass energy, while remaining
54
organic energy dissipates as heat.16 In conventional WWTPs, biomass energy is wasted with sludge
55
discard.5 Because the substantial energy in organic matter currently lost in conventional treatment
56
processes,1 intensive attention has been focused on recovering energy from wastewater to power
57
wastewater treatment and evaluating the energy efficiency of WWTP. Several energy recovery
58
methods developed with the aim of achieving energy self-sufficiency in WWTPs have been
59
discussed in previous reports.17 However, the most feasible approach to recovering internal energy
60
in existing treatment plants is using CH4 biogas produced during sludge anaerobic digestion as
61
biofuel to generate power and heat by cogeneration.12,18 If more organic energy is captured from
62
wastewater than is used for wastewater treatment, external energy input is not required; thus, an
63
independent and self-sufficient energy recycling system, with the characteristic of “net-zero energy”
64
(NZE), may be established. NZE has been partially or fully achieved in some WWTPs.19,20
65
Although these practical cases of energy self-sufficiency in WWTPs have been discussed in depth 3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
66
in previous studies, there have been no reports including statistical analysis of such cases and
67
mathematical derivation of energy utilization patterns; additionally, a theoretical model is urgently
68
needed to be developed to evaluate the feasibility of achieving NZE in WWTPs.
69
As earlier studies,21-22 the attention has been devoted to direct in-plant energy consumption and
70
generation in this paper (indirect energy use, energetic value of N and P as fertilizers, chemicals
71
input, etc. are not considered), and it seems to be more pertinent with respect of the direct energy
72
exploitation in WWTPs and the practical interest of stakeholders. The objective of the present study
73
is to establish a NZE theoretical model based on substance transformation and energy utilization to
74
systematically evaluate the feasibility and level of energy self-sufficiency of WWTPs, as well as to
75
obtain optimal organic matter allocation between catabolism and anabolism. The theoretical model
76
was employed to analyze data from 20 WWTPs in China to evaluate energy self-sufficiency based
77
on anaerobic digestion of excess sludge. Finally, a statistical analysis of NZE cases was conducted.
78
The results of this study provide a foundation for engineering applications of the NZE concept.
79
2. METHODS AND MATERIALS
80
2.1. Material-energy cycle of conventional and NZE WWTPs
81
Metabolism is typically divided into two categories: catabolism, the decomposition of organic
82
matter by cellular respiration with energy release; and anabolism, the synthesis of components of
83
microbial cells with energy utilization. Microorganisms decompose organic matter to sustain life
84
and reproduction via material-energy transformation in municipal WWTPs. Chemical energy from
85
organic matter is converted into biomass energy during biochemical treatment. 23
86
Organic matter, the main exploitable energy source in wastewater [represented as chemical 4
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 29
Page 5 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
87
oxygen demand (COD)], is completely biodegraded into simple molecules, such as CO2 and H2O,
88
during wastewater treatment. Two pathways transform COD into CO2 and H2O: (1) a conventional
89
pathway, in which COD is oxidized directly into CO2 by aerobic processes that require significant
90
input of external electrical energy; and (2) a sustainable pathway, in which COD is maximally
91
transformed into biomass (sludge) by bio-synthesis processes, after which the biomass is
92
biodegraded into CH4. CH4 is ultimately utilized to produce electricity, heat, and simple molecules
93
(CO2 and H2O). The conventional pathway is widely applied in existing WWTPs, in which most of
94
chemical energy from organic matter is expended by consuming electric energy in the pathway,
95
with CO2 escaping and energy depletion. The chemical energy in sludge is squandered with sludge
96
waste in conventional pathway (Figure. 1a); In contrast, in the sustainable pathway, most of the
97
chemical energy from organic matter is effectively utilized by sludge anaerobic digestion; therefore,
98
external energy consumption is offset by the electricity and heat generated by cogeneration,
99
reducing the cost and energy consumption associated with sludge treatment and disposal. Biomass
100
recycling and energy-saving are achieved by the sustainable pathway; thus, the NZE mode of
101
WWTPs is postulated based on the matter-energy cycle (Figure. 1b). A part of organic pollutants as
102
substrate were completely oxidized (O2) into simple, stable molecules (CO2 and H2O) by
103
microorganisms via catabolism with energy release. Remaining organic matter was directly used to
104
synthesize structural molecules and reproduce cells via anabolism; the energy required for
105
anabolism was provided by the energy released by catabolism. In order to ensure smooth
106
metabolism of microorganism, the organic matter allocated to anabolism cannot exceed 2/3 of the
107
total organic matter in bio-treatment unit.15 In the NZE WWTP model, an independent
108
energy-recycling system (no need for external energy input) for wastewater treatment was 5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 6 of 29
109
developed based on the biomass energy utilization. In addition, a mathematical formulation of the
110
energy supply-demand balance of wastewater treatment in the NZE wastewater treatment system
111
was established.
112
2.2 Establishment of the NZE WWTP theoretical model
113
2.2.1 Specific energy consumption and COD flow of anabolism
114
COD is more directly related to energy and carbon substrate is usually used in energy balance
115
calculation, therefore specific energy consumption µ was defined as the electricity consumption per
116
unit of COD removed (kWh/kgCOD), and it can be calculated with Eq. [1]:
117
µ =
118
where Ew represents the electricity consumption of wastewater treatment [kWh]. Mo (ton) represents
119
the total mass of organic matter removed as measured by COD (Equation [3]).
Ew 1000M o
(1)
120
In the NZE mode, sludge handling is the process of energy production based on self-energy
121
balance, and the Ew is only contributed by the energy for aeration (Eaera); therefore, Eaera can be
122
obtained by the function of the removed COD Mo (ton) with the specific energy consumption as
123
follows:
124
Eaera =1000µ M o
(2)
125
As presented in section 2.1, there are two material flows of COD, catabolism and anabolism,
126
which are represented by CODcata and CODana, respectively. Thus, the total mass of organic matter
127
was divided into two parts, which were consumed by catabolism Mcata and anabolism Mana, and
128
their quantitative relation was derived as Equation [3]. In addition, the total mass of organic matter
129
Mo was related to influent CODinf, effluent CODeff, and wastewater flow Qw (m3/d), which was 6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 7 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
130
expressed as Equation [4]:
131
M o = M cata + M ana
132
Mo =
133
where the units of COD and M were mg/L and ton/d, respectively.
(3)
(
Qw CODinf − CODeff 10
)
(4)
6
134
In this paper, the MLVSS/MLSS ratio of sludge in practical municipal WWTPs is considered
135
to be 0.75.24 The relationship between sewage sludge amount Mts (ton/d), organic matter Mvs (ton/d),
136
and inorganic matter Mis (ton/d) was derived as Equation [5] and Equation [6]:
137
M ts = M is + M vs
(5)
138
M vs = 0.75M ts
(6)
139
where Mvss is the sludge reproduced by anabolism of microorganisms, and it is assumed that
140
CODana contributes completely to MLVSS.
141
Microbial cells in sludge are typically expressed as C5H7O2N;16 the amount of oxygen required
142
to oxidize one microbial cell to carbon dioxide, water, and ammonia is given by:
143
C5 H 7 O2 N + 5O2 → 5CO2 + 2 H 2O + NH 3
144
(7)
According to Formula [7], one gram of C5H7O2N is equivalent to 1.42 grams of COD; thus,
145
Mana in sewage sludge was expressed as Equation [8]:
146
M ana = 1.42 M vs
147
2.2.2 Electricity and heat requirements of the anaerobic digestion system
(8)
148
Thermophilic digestion is more beneficial for energy utilization than mesophilic digestion. 25,26
149
Therefore, thermophilic digestion was adopted to generate energy, and the digestion temperature
150
was assumed to be 50 °C. The energy requirement of digestion stirring is related to the excess
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 8 of 29
151
sludge volume Qs (m3/d), which is a function of Mts (ton/d) (Equation [9]). In the calculation, the
152
moisture content of the sludge was assumed to be 96% (a common value), whereas the density of
153
the digested sludge ρs was assumed to be 1000 kg/m3 (approximately equal to that of water).
154
Equations [5] and [8] were substituted into Equation [9] to simplify the Equation. A digestion time
155
of 25 days and typical power per unit volume of stirring of 0.008 kW/m3 were chosen;27 after which
156
the energy for stirring Ediges (kWh) per day was obtained by Equation [10]:
157
Qs =
1000(kg/t) ⋅ M ts (t ) ρ s (kg / m3 ) ⋅ (1 − 96%)
(9)
3
= 25(0.7 M ana + M is ) (m / d ) 158
Ediges = 25( d ) ⋅ Qs ( m 3 / d ) ⋅ 0.008( kW / m 3 ) ⋅ 24( h / d ) = 4.8Qs ( kWh / d )
159
(10) The heat requirement includes heat loss of digesters and the heat necessary for raising the
160
incoming sludge temperature. To obtain the total heat demand of sludge digestion, an inlet ambient
161
sewage sludge temperature of 15 °C was assumed. Before feeding, the sludge was pre-heated to
162
30 °C through heat convection with high-temperature sludge discharged from digestion tanks.28 The
163
heat requirement Hs (MJ) for raising the sludge temperature to 50 °C was calculated using Equation
164
[11]. The heat loss of digesters is usually 2–8% of the heat requirement of the sludge.29 Thus, the
165
total heat requirement Ht (MJ) of complete digestion of 1 m3 of sludge was obtained by Equation
166
[12] (with 8% heat loss assumed):
167
H s = ρ s Qs cs ⋅ ( t s − to )
(11)
168
H t =( 1 + 8%) H s = 90.4Qs ( MJ )
(12)
169
where cs is the specific heat capacity of sludge (96% moisture), Qs is the volume of sludge, and ts
170
and to represent the final and initial temperature, respectively, of the input sludge.
171
2.2.3 Energy recovery of CHP system 8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 9 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
172
Energy production by anaerobic processes can be expressed in a simplified model as a function
173
of the mass of biodegradable organic compounds (Mana). Generally, the biogas yield of sludge and
174
its calorific value are assumed to be 0.35 m3/kg COD and 11 kWh/m3, respectively; thus, total
175
energy recovery Pt (kWh) is calculated as Equation [13].18,29-31 Fifty percent heat efficiency ηh and
176
40% electricity efficiency ηe of CHP are assumed, achieving an overall efficiency of 90%.32 All
177
design parameters of the NZE WWTP model are provided in Table S1.
178 179
180
181
182
183
Electricity recovery Pe (kWh) and heat recovery Ph (MJ) are calculated as Equation [14] and Equation [15], respectively:
Pt = 1000(kg / t )M ana × 0.35(m3 / kg ) ×11(kWh / m3 ) = 3850M ana (kWh)
Pe = ηe Pt
(13)
(14)
= 1540M ana (kWh) Ph = η h Pt × 3.6 ( MJ / kWh)
(15)
= 6930 M ana ( MJ )
2.2.4 NZE WWTP theoretical model
184
In the NZE WWTP model, energy self-sufficiency of 100% is assumed; thus, there exists an
185
energy balance between electricity production Pe and electricity consumption Eaera and Ediges
186
(Equation [16]). At the same time, the heat requirement should be provided by heat recovery, as
187
expressed by Inequality [17]. However, only some WWTPs can achieve 100% energy
188
self-sufficiency in reality. Anaerobic digestion was applied to recover energy based on the premise
189
that electricity production Pe and heat recovery Ph should meet the digestion energy consumption
190
(Ediges and Ht), presented as Inequality [17] and Inequality [18]. Inequality [18] always holds based
191
on Equations [16] (Eaera ≥0), therefore, Inequality [18] is not considered in this model. Equation [19]
192
and [20] can be obtained by substituting Equations [2], [9], [10], [12], [14], and [15] into Equations 9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 10 of 29
193
[16] and [17].
194
Pe = Eaera + Ediges
(16)
195
Ph ≥ Ht
(17)
196
Pe ≥ Ediges
(18)
197
1456M ana = 120 M is + 1000 µ M o
(19)
198
2.37 M ana ≥ M is
(20)
199
Inequality [20] is an energy boundary condition in the NZE WWTP model. The minimum of
200
Mvs/Mts (organic matter content of sludge) was obtained by solving Inequality [20] with Equation [5]
201
and Equation [8], yielding minimum of 0.23 which was selected as a comprehensive energy
202
boundary condition of energy self-sufficiency in the NZE WWTP model. The Mvs/Mts is generally
203
less than 0.9;33 therefore, an inequality regarding Mvs/Mts can be obtained (Inequality [21]).
204
Ultimately, Equation [19] and Inequality [21] constituted the NZE theoretical model.
205
0.23 ≤ M vs / M ts ≤ 0.9
206
Furthermore, the observed yield of excess sewage sludge was defined as follows:
207
208
Yobs =
(21)
M vs CODt
(22)
Where CODt is the total of removed COD in the wastewater treatment, and a large value of
209
Yobs indicates that material and energy flow are directed towards anabolism, yielding sludge.
210
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
211
3.1. Case studies
212
Twenty municipal WWTPs in China (Table S2) were investigated to validate the theoretical
213
model. Characteristic parameters of the WWTPs are shown in Table S3. In the matter-energy cycle, 10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 11 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
214
metabolic energy allocation corresponds to COD flow (material flow), and the amount of removed
215
COD is a relatively constant value during wastewater treatment. It is clear that increasing the
216
amount of COD allocated to anabolism benefits energy recovery; however, the maximum benefit is
217
achieved when anabolism of COD utilizes 2/3 of the total COD in the bio-treatment process.15
218
Figure 2 shows the COD flow of anabolism and catabolism in twenty WWTPs. The CODana/CODt
219
ratios of municipal WWTPs were in the range of 0.34–0.66 (average = 0.53). Only 6 WWTPs had
220
CODana/CODt ratios greater than 0.6 (close to the extremum). These results indicate that there is
221
significant potential to reduce energy dissipation by improving the CODana/CODt ratios in the
222
WWTPs. To avoid energy waste, WWTPs need optimized strategies to regulate the COD flow
223
between catabolism and anabolism; the NZE model provided a theoretical basis to optimize such
224
allocation.
225
According to the NZE theoretical model, when given a specific value of Mvs/Mts, the
226
relationship between specific electricity consumption µ and the material allocation ratio Mana/Mo
227
(represented as the CODana/CODt ratio) may be obtained by substituting Eqs. [5] and [8] into Eq.
228
[19]. Consequently, in the range of 0.23 to 0.9, each specific Mvs/Mts corresponds to an NZE
229
equation for µ and the CODana/CODt ratio, which can be shown as a line in a graph. As the Mvs/Mts
230
ratio changed, a series of lines was drawn to show the relationship between µ and CODana/CODt
231
(Figure 3A). The frontiers of these curves are the lines obtained when Mvs/Mts was its most extreme
232
values of 0.23 and 0.9. Changing the value of CODana/CODt can alter the amount of recovered
233
energy so that it meets the energy needs of water treatment.
234
The Mvs/Mts ratio (organic matter content of the sludge) in the wastewater treatment process is
235
usually determined as 0.75, and the corresponding zero energy curve was drawn to analyze the 11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
236
sample points (Figure. 3B). Because the maximum of Mana/Mo is 2/3 (0.67), the maximum specific
237
energy consumption was calculated to be 0.95. The sample points were categorized as type A, type
238
B, or type C according to the probability of realizing NZE status (Table 1).
239
Type A cases were those in which specific energy consumption was greater than 0.95
240
irrespective of CODana regulation [region (a) in Figure 3B]; 100% energy self-sufficiency cannot be
241
achieved in these WWTPs, which require external energy. The low influent CODinf and high Ew led
242
to the phenomenon in these WWTPs (Table S3). However, biomass energy can be recovered by
243
anaerobic digestion with cogeneration to compensate for some external power consumption by
244
these WWPTs. The energy self-sufficiency rates of the municipal WWTPs of Degan, Xiyong,
245
Jijiang, Changshou, Jiuquhe, and Jiangdong are 94.6%, 79.4%, 73.9%, 93.8%, 87.4%, and 88.0%,
246
respectively.
247
Type B cases can currently achieve NZE status and export excess energy [region (b) in Figure
248
3B]. The energy self-sufficiency rates of the municipal WWTPs in Zhouping, Xiaojiahe, Wushan,
249
Chengebei, Dajiu, and Chayuan are 158.2%, 127.9%, 103.4%, 122.4%, 101.7%, and 112.9%,
250
respectively.
251
Type C cases are those in which municipal WWTPs can achieve 100% energy self-sufficiency
252
by adjusting CODana; these WWTPs must increase the value of CODana to increase sludge yield.
253
Ultimately, the energy produced by increasing sludge yield will offset the energy requirement of
254
wastewater treatment.
255
There are eight municipal WWTPs can achieve 100% energy self-sufficiency and six
256
municipal WWTPs can export excess energy in the investigated twenty municipal WWTPs in this
257
study. The theoretical model of NZE wastewater treatment was successfully employed to evaluate 12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 29
Page 13 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
258
the feasibility and level of energy self-sufficiency in practical wastewater treatment cases, and the
259
mode can be utilized to conserve resources by biomass energy recycling during wastewater
260
treatment, allowing WWTPs to achieve environmental sustainability.
261
3.2. Statistical analysis of specific energy consumption and CODana/CODt in the NZE model
262
In order to assess the predicted values of µ and CODana/CODt calculated using the NZE
263
WWTP model using real-life examples, the µ (kWh/kgCOD) values of 53 municipal WWTPs
264
(Table S4) were subjected to normality tests and statistical description. The Shapiro-Wilk test
265
yielded the following results: w = 0.97118, p-value = 0.2268 (>α, 0.05). Therefore, the null
266
hypothesis can be accepted, indicating that specific energy consumption is distributed normally
267
(Figure 4a; mean = 0.69, standard deviation = 0.28).
268
According to the µ distribution, the sample size was enlarged to 1000 by generating random
269
numbers, which were substituted into the NZE WWTP model to obtain corresponding
270
CODana/CODt ratios. The obtained CODana/CODt ratios were filtered under the condition of 0