Subscriber access provided by UNIVERSITY OF THE SUNSHINE COAST
Article
Plutonium partitioning behavior to humic acids from widely varying soils is related to carboxyl-containing organic compounds Peng Lin, Chen Xu, Saijin Zhang, Nobuhide Fujitake, Daniel I. Kaplan, Chris Yeager, Yuko Sugiyama, Kathleen A. Schwehr, and Peter H. Santschi Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.7b03409 • Publication Date (Web): 21 Sep 2017 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on September 23, 2017
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Plutonium partitioning behavior to humic acids from widely varying soils is related to
2
carboxyl-containing organic compounds
3 4
Peng Lin1*, Chen Xu1, Saijin Zhang1, Nobuhide Fujitake2, Daniel I. Kaplan3, Chris M. Yeager4,
5
Yuko Sugiyama5, Kathleen A. Schwehr1, Peter H. Santschi1
6 7
1
8
77553, United States
9
2
Department of Marine Science, Texas A & M University at Galveston, Galveston, Texas
Division of Agroenvironmental Biology, Graduate School of Agriculture Science, Kobe
10
University, Kyoto, 606-8501, Japan
11
3
Savannah River National Laboratory, Aiken, South Carolina 29808, United States
12
4
Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545, United States
13
5
School of Human Science and Environment, University of Hyogo, 1-1-12 Shinzaike-Honcho,
14
Himeji, Hyogo, 670-0092, Japan
15 16
*Corresponding Author: Peng Lin (
[email protected])
17 18
For resubmission to Environmental Science & Technology
19
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
20
Abstract:
21
In order to examine the influence of the HA molecular composition on the partitioning of Pu,
22
ten different kinds of humic acids (HAs) of contrasting chemical composition, collected and
23
extracted from different soil types around the world were equilibrated with groundwater at
24
low Pu concentrations (10-14 M). Under mildly acidic conditions (pH~5.5), 29±24% of the
25
HAs were released as colloidal organic matter (>3kDa to 0.45 µm),
94
colloidal (3 kDa to 0.45 µm) and truly dissolved (< 3 kDa) HA fractions. Additionally,
95
correlations were evaluated between the Pu partitioning parameters and elemental and functional
96
groups abundance of organic matter among these three phases. As the remobilization of soil OM
97
(e.g., HAs) occurs during soil erosion of natural or man-induced episodic flooding, the intent of
98
this work was to make inferances about the tendency for HAs to behave as a sink or a source for
99
Pu during these events. That is, Pu bound to colloidal HA could potentially act as a source
100
because it would presumably be more mobile than the larger particulate fraction. Conversely, Pu
101
bound to the particulate fraction could potentially act as a sink because it would presumably be
102
less mobile and remain strongly bound to soil. We present here novel results from controlled
5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
103
laboratory experiments conducted using environmentally relevant Pu concentrations to document
104
a relationship between size-fractionated carboxyl-containing or organic nitrogen compounds and
105
the Pu activity among particulate, colloidal, and dissolved phases.
106 107
MATERIALS AND METHODS
108
Sampling of humic acid substances
109
Ten soils from around the world were carefully selected to represent a wide range of origins,
110
with respect to soil order (i.e., soil genesis), land use, and geography (Table 1). Additionally, we
111
chose these soils, because they contain a wide range of concentrations of N and different organic
112
functional groups (e.g., N ranges from 1.18% to 6.59%, and Alkyl C ranges from 5.5% to 23.8%,
113
and COO C varies from 13% to 20%, Table 1). Nitrogen-containing organic compounds have
114
been reported to be an important component of NOM responsible for binding Pu.20-23 The six soil
115
included Podzols, that are infertile acid soils; Chernozyoms, that are rich black soils and
116
considered as excellent agricultural soils; Andisols found in volcanic areas; Histosols that are
117
composed primarily of organic matter; Cambisols that are very young soils that have not yet
118
developed well defined horizons; and Luvisols which are commonly found in forested regions.
119
We also attempted to include soils from varying land uses, including forest, arable land, and
120
grassland. Finally, the soils originated from four continants, South America, Europe, Africa, and
121
Asia. The HAs from these soils were isolated and further purified according to the alkaline
122
extraction method from the International Humic Substance Society (IHSS).25,26 It should be
123
noted that 1) chemical and physical alteration of the soil organic matter likely occurred during
124
the alkaline extraction; 2) the alkaline extractant (i.e., the humic acids as defined) is likely not
125
capable of representing the whole soil organic matter.27 However, IHSS recommended these HA
126
extraction procedures that were used in our study because they are standardized, making
127
comparisons between different scientific studies possible, and they have been widely accepted by
128
the scientific community as represented by the IHSS. In addition, the results and the correlations
129
obtained from this study (see below) should be independent from the “artifacts” of the extraction
130
method and still imply the one of the responsible functional groups in the soil for Pu binding.
131
Briefly, the dried soil was pre-treated with a 1 M HCl solution to separate fulvic acid
132
(supernatant) from the soil. The resulting soil pellet was dissolved by adding 0.1 M KOH under
133
N2 purging and 0.3 M K+, as KCl. The supernatant was acidified (pH 1.0) using 6 M HCl to
6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 29
Page 7 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
134
precipitate HAs, which were pelleted by centrifugation and then suspended in a 0.1 M HCl/0.3 M
135
HF solution overnight for five times to minimize ash content. After HF digestion, the HA was
136
washed repeatedly with Milli-Q water to minimize ions. After the purification, the abundance of
137
organic C and N in HAs was determined, and their molecular composition was chemically
138
characterized by solid state 13C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy (Table 1); this
139
HA characterization data was previously reported elsewhere.24, and the purified HAs were
140
provided from Division of Agroenvironmental Biology, Graduate School of Agriculture Science,
141
Kobe University. All HA samples for the HA-groundwater resuspension experiments described
142
below were stored frozen at -5 ºC.
143 144 145
HA-groundwater resuspension experiment Artificial groundwater27 was used as the medium for the HA-groundwater suspension
146
experiments. An average groundwater composition was chosen in these experiments rather than
147
varying groundwaters representative of the soil’s origin, in order to simplify interpretation of the
148
results. The implications of this simplification are that they may not represent site-specific
149
conditions, but they ease comparisons of results between the 10 soils. To simplify the
150
experimental approach, we used an averaged groundwater composition at a constant pH, which
151
is the most important variable for the metal partitioning to soils, although the groundwater
152
composition can change in different HA-source areas. This artificial groundwater has low salt
153
concentrations (10-2 M), no organic matter, and low carbonate concentrations because of its
154
mildly acidic pH of 5.5, the average pH of natural rainwater28 and also the background
155
groundwater pH at the Savannah River Site (SRS), USA.29 The HA-groundwater suspension
156
batch experiments were conducted at room temperature (~20 ºC) under oxic condition, basically
157
similar to previously reported procedure.30 In brief, prior to adding a Pu isotopic tracer, 5-6 mg
158
of the purified HAs were pre-equilibrated in artificial groundwater in a 15-mL polypropylene
159
centrifuge tube for 48 h. 238Pu (as Pu(V) oxidation state) was amended to noncomplexing PIPBS
160
(piperazine-N,N”-bis(4-butane sulfonic acid); GFS chemicals, Cat 2360) buffer (pH of 5.5) in
161
order to neutralize the acidic Pu tracer and maintain this pH during the incubation period. The
162
use of noncomplexing buffers avoids the formation of polymeric or colloidal Pu oxide
163
particles.30-32 The 238Pu-amended PIPBS was then added to the HA-groundwater mixture to a
164
final volume of 4 mL and Pu concentration of 8.4 × 10-14 M.8,33-35 The 238Pu-HA-groundwater
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
165
slurry was then mixed continuously for 7 days in the dark with an end-over-end mixer to ensure
166
that quasi-equilibrium was attained.30 It should be noted that some recent studies36 have
167
suggested that viewing soil organic matter as a continuum (soil continuum
168
model, SCM) does not allow one to consider concentration as varying parameter in the
169
interpretation of data. Rather, known concentrations of HA or known HA:groundwater (w/v
170
ratios) are needed in laboratory experiments to observe comparable and accurate data in metal
171
partitioning experiments. High concentrations of HAs were also needed to mimic the soil
172
erosion, since during the soil erosion and runoff events, pond discharge or rainwater passes
173
through surface soil environments, where organic-rich soils predominate and the HA
174
concentration is thus high in the resulting slurry system.
175
The experiments mentioned above were conducted in duplicate. Two controls were included,
176
1) a Pu tracer control (i.e., Pu-groundwater suspension without the HAs) to monitor Pu loss
177
during the incubation due to adsorption to labware including centrifuge tubes and filters, and 2) a
178
HA control (i.e., HA-groundwater suspension without Pu) to monitor organic matter released
179
from the HA over the course of the experiment to ease the elemental analysis of different soil
180
fractions without Pu tracer.
181
After a 7-day incubation period, particulate (> 0.45 µm), colloidal (3 kDa to 0.45 µm), and
182
truly dissolved (< 3kDa) phases were separated through 0.45 µm centrifugal filter tubes followed
183
by ultrafiltration with 3 kDa Microsep centrifugal filter tubes (Millipore). Each fraction was
184
analyzed for Pu activity and organic carbon and nitrogen concentrations, as described below. On
185
the other hand, it should be mentioned that potential experimental artifacts, such as the
186
aggregation of colloidal into particulate fractions or re-partitioning, may happen during a one-
187
week resuspension experiment. Nevertheless, our observation showing the predominance of
188
colloidal Pu and strong binding of Pu with organic matter (see discussion below) would suggest
189
negligible influence from aggregation and re-partitioning during such an experiment.
190 191 192
Determination of plutonium activity concentrations 238
Pu activities were determined by alpha-spectroscopy as previously described.16,21 Briefly,
193
after resuspension experiment and separation as mentioned above, 242Pu was added into each
194
fraction, as the yield tracer of Pu purification. The samples were oven-dried, then heated at 600
195
ºC overnight in a ceramic crucible. The resulting ash was then digested in Teflon tubes overnight
8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 29
Page 9 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
196
in concentrated HNO3 and HCl (1:1) at 85 ºC. The remaining solid residue was collected by
197
centrifugation and disadarded, and the supernatant was further evaporated to incipient dryness. to
198
convert all Pu to Pu(IV), a FeSO4•7H2O (0.2 g/mL) solution, followedby the 0.25 g NaNO2,
199
were added to each sample, and the final volume of sample was 3 mL. Samples were then run
200
through an UTEVA column (Cat. #: UT-C50-A, Eichrom, USA) to separate Pu from other alpha-
201
emitting radionuclides (e.g., 238U, 241Am). After washing the column with a 8 M HNO3 solution,
202
the 238,242Pu was eluted using freshly-prepared 0.02 M NH2OH HCl/0.02M ascorbic acid in 2M
203
HNO3. The Pu-containing eluent was evaporated and re-constituted in 0.4 M (NH4)2SO4 (pH~2.6)
204
for electroplating onto a stainless steel planchet at 0.6 Amps current for 2 h. Sample-bearing
205
planchets were then analyzed via alpha spectroscopy for at least one week to obtain counting
206
errors (1 sigma) lower than 5%. The detection limit for 238Pu and 242Pu is 6 × 10-5 Bq and 2.5 ×
207
10-4 Bq, respectively.
208 209 210
Measurement of organic carbon and nitrogen Concentrations of organic carbon and nitrogen in the colloidal and truly dissolved fractions
211
were determined using a Shimadzu TOC-L analyzer and a high temperature combustion
212
method.37 The organic carbon and nitrogen concentrations in the particulate phase of the HA-
213
groundwater suspension were calculated as the difference between the total carbon/nitrogen
214
contents of the added HAs and the sum of colloidal and truly dissolved phases.
215 216
Partitioning coefficient values of Pu
217
The traditional partitioning coefficient (Kd value) was used to describe the partitioning of Pu
218
between particulate (>0.45 µm) and dissolved phases (0.45 µm), Ac and Ad
229
represent the activity concentration of Pu in the colloidal (3 kDa to 0.45 µm) and truly dissolved
230
phases (0.45 µm), colloidal (3 kDa to 0.45 µm) and truly
236
dissolved phases (3 kDa; Equation 2) were three orders of magnitude greater, on average, than the logKd
251
values (>0.45 µm; Equation 1) (logKdc = 5.05 ± 0.17 vs. logKd = 1.83 ± 0.29; Figure 1b).
252
Based on the data shown in Figure 1, different HAs can have different influence on the
253
distribution of Pu in particulate and colloidal fractions, resulting in a considerable range for
254
particulate and colloidal Pu activity percentages, e.g., 70 ± 1% in the HA-1 (originating from
255
Valence Lake, Hungary) to 92 ± 1.7% in the HA-4 (Karcag, Hungary) for the colloidal phase and
256
4 ± 0.7% in the HA-7 (Gyosei, Japan) to 14 ± 1.3% in the HA-8 (Ichijima, Japan) for the
257
particulate phase (ANOVA, p < 0.01). Moreover, if normalized by the concentrations of
10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 10 of 29
Page 11 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
258
particulate or colloidal organic carbon, specific activity concentrations of Pu on POC and COC
259
(Par-Pu/POC and Col-Pu/COC) can range from 9 Bq/g-POC to 27 Bq/g-POC and from 110
260
Bq/g-COC to 1384 Bq/g-COC, respectively (Table S1), further indicating the preference of Pu
261
for colloidal HAs. In contrast, with such widely contrasting soil origins from different soils on
262
different continents, the results exhibit a relatively narrow range and similar magnitude of
263
partitioning coefficient values for Pu, especially the logKdc values, if minimum and maximum
264
points were not considered (4.90 ± 0.13 to 5.22 ± 0.07, Table 1, Figure 1b, ANOVA, p >0.05).
265
This may be partially attributed to how we operationally defined the colloidal fraction and logKdc
266
values (Eq. 2), but most importantly, it was basically due to the the fact that, the vast majority of
267
Pu parititioned to the colloidal phase at pH of 5.5, a potentially more mobile Pu fraction,
268
regardless of the type of the soil from which the HA was extracted. Only a minor portion of Pu
269
was associated with the particulate phase, suggesting that soil erosion caused by natural or
270
anthropogenic processes can trigger the release of Pu isotopes. By virtue of its size, it is expected
271
that the colloidal fraction would be more mobile than the particulate fraction.
272
Such Pu mobilization would be largely associated with the release and remobilization of
273
organic macromolecules (i.e., colloidal organic matter, COM) from the HAs. The results indicate
274
that our HAs samples behaved differently, with different organic macromolecules being released
275
differently when they were resuspended in the groundwater. For example, the released COC and
276
CON concentrations varied from 45 to 532 mg/L and from 0 to 54 mg/L, respectively,
277
corresponding to colloidal percentages in the bulk organic C and N pool ranging from 5% to 74%
278
for COC and from 0% to 74% for CON (Table S1). With such a wide range in both Pu activity
279
percentages and organic matter concentrations, the possible correlations can be interpreted as
280
indicating the extent of Pu binding to organic matter. As shown in Figure 2, the concentrations of
281
colloidal organic nitrogen (CON in terms of mg/L, Figure 2b) and carbon (COC, Figure 2e)
282
strongly and positively correlated with the colloidal Pu fraction. Similarly, the activity
283
percentage of particulate Pu was also positively correlated with the contents of particulate
284
organic-nitrogen (Figure 2a) and -carbon (Figure 2d), suggesting that the organic matter still
285
associated with particulate HAs after one week of equilibration in artificial groundwater, also
286
exhibited a significant influence on the fixation and immobilization of Pu. Furthermore, the
287
adsorption behavior of Pu on particulate HAs (i.e., logKd) is strongly regulated by the
288
partitioning between potentially-immobile and mobile organic compounds during the HA-
11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
289
groundwater mixing period, as indicated by the positive relationship between Pu logKd and
290
organic nitrogen or carbon between particulate and dissolved phases (i.e., logKd-ON in Figure 2c
291
and logKd-OC in Figure 2f. POC or PN concentrations were calculated by the ratio of the sum of
292
colloidal and truly dissolved organic carbon or nitrogen concentrations and the total mass
293
concentration of the added HA concentration). Although the relationship of colloidal partitioning
294
between Pu and organic nitrogen/carbon cannot be tested due to the unknown concentrations of
295
total colloidal matter, we propose that the partitioning between colloidal and truly dissolved Pu
296
during the HA-groundwater interactions (e.g., logKc) can be also controlled by the relative
297
distribution of colloidal and truly dissolved organic nitrogen (i.e., logKc-ON).
298
The results of our laboratory HA-groundwater mixing experiments demonstrated a direct
299
relationship of the organic carbon, and more importantly the organic nitrogen with the Pu
300
activity concentration, which are consistent with and confirm previous field observations.20-23
301
More importantly, with our size fractionation among particulate, colloidal and dissolved
302
fractions, the results provide novel and direct evidence supporting the essential role of particulate
303
organic compounds in immobilizing Pu in contaminated areas. Although these correlation data
304
can not provide direct evidence for the complete cause of Pu remobilization in the real soil
305
environments, our results still imply that colloidal organic compounds can enhance Pu
306
remobilization in contaminated soils. This implies that a duel influence from both POM and
307
COM on Pu behavior may occur during storm runoff and discharge events in natural
308
environments. In comparison, the colloidal organic fraction provides more surface availability of
309
complexing ligands or higher specific surface areas for Pu mobilization than the particulate
310
organic fraction did for Pu binding, as indicated by a greater amount of Pu existing in a colloidal
311
form. This was the case even though the abundance of COM relative to POM was lower in terms
312
of carbon (e.g., 29 ± 24% on average for COC in the bulk carbon pool, Figure S1 and Table S1).
313
It was also possible that at weak acidic pH (5.5) condition, smaller molecules containing higher
314
aromaticity can be better solubilized into colloidal fraction than those larger molecules
315
containing less aromaticity. Furthermore, this characteristic of colloidal organic compounds can
316
directly reduce the Pu binding ability of residual particulate HAs, as is evident from the negative
317
correlation between logKd values and the proportion of released CON or COC from the bulk
318
organic matter pool (Figure 3). In natural environments the soil-erosion derived remobilization
319
of organic macromolecules from sedimentary organic matter can vary with soil type and/or
12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 29
Page 13 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
320
composition.40,41 Accordingly, in the present study the proportion of released organic matter
321
from the initial HAs also varied among different HAs (Figure S1), consequently causing the
322
variation in the resultant logKd values of Pu among different HAs. For instance, more organic
323
matter was released from Chernozems-type HA (greater aromaticity) into the colloidal fraction,
324
while the opposite was observed for Cambisols-type HA (less aromaticity) (Table 1 and Figure
325
S1). Together, our observations not only confirm the role of natural organic matter (NOM) to
326
convert Pu from a sink to a source during soil erosion, but also suggest that the desorption
327
behavior of Pu from sedimentary organic matter is largely dependent on how much organic
328
matter would be released into the colloidal fraction during a given soil erosion event.
329 330 331
Supporting evidence of carboxylate groups responsible for Pu partitioning behavior Given the essential role of NOM in controlling the partitioning of Pu, as mentioned above,
332
we further explore and characterize the organic functional moieties of the two organic fractions
333
and attempt to correlate them to Pu partitioning coefficients. Through solid state 13C nuclear
334
magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy measurements,26 the main carbon functionalities of
335
HAs had been identified and quantified, as consisting of alkyl, O-alkyl, aryl, O-aryl, COO and
336
CO associated compounds, and composing 16 ± 7%, 20 ± 7%, 35 ± 13%, 8 ± 2%, 17 ± 2% and 3
337
± 1% of the total organic carbon pool, respectively (Table 1).
338
Among these organic ligands, only the abundance of the major COO group moiety (i.e., the
339
carboxylate group) was found to significantly and positively correlate with the Pu partitioning
340
between surface-bound (>3 kDa) and truly dissolved fractions (i.e., logKdc values, Figure 4a,
341
Table 1), suggesting that the carboxylate group can be a specific functional group responsible for
342
the relatively constant specific activity concentrations of Pu in particulate and colloidal phases as
343
mentioned above. To futher evaluate this correlation in particulate and colloidal phases, we
344
assumed that the carboxyl-containing molecules in the initial HA samples have the same
345
releasing ability to the colloidal fraction as the bulk organic carbon pool does (i.e., 29 ± 24% of
346
organic carbon was released from initial HAs into colloidal fraction, Figure S1) although this
347
assumption might possibly bias the correlation. However, because of their pKa values below the
348
pH of the water, the carboxyl groups are mostly dissociated and thus, impart a negative charge to
349
the HAs, and giving them a solubilizing effect. The results showed that the particulate or
350
colloidal Pu activity concentrations can positively correlate with the concentrations of particulate
13
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
351
or colloidal carboxyl-containing molecules, respectively (Figures 4b and 4c). In addition, in
352
terms of partitioning coefficient, the positive relationship between Pu and carboxyl-containing
353
molecules in the particulate-dissolved partitioning is also evident (Figure 4d), similar to those
354
observed for organic carbon and nitrogen contents (Figures 2c and 2f). These tight correlations
355
between Pu and carboxyl-containing molecules, regardless of being in the particulate or colloidal
356
phase, further suggest that the bulk organic carboxylate functionality is related to the main Pu
357
complexing agent for particulate and colloid organic matter, even though carboxylates were not
358
the predominant carbon functionality in our HAs samples (Table 1, which may also explain why
359
the correlation between organic carbon/nitrogen contents and logKdc values was weak).
360
Clustered carboxylate groups can have strong binding properties for metal ions in natural
361
waters, like the binding of actinide metals (e.g., thorium) with carboxyl-containing acid
362
polysaccharides.42-46 Previous studies using electrospray ionization combined with Fourier-
363
transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (ESI-FTICR-MS) and multi-NMR
364
demonstrated that the predominant Pu carrying macromolecules in soil contained more N than
365
the bulk soil colloidal organic matter and were also abundant in carboxylic chelating functional
366
groups.20,22,23 Therefore, by combining our observations on the significant relationship between
367
Pu partitioning and organic nitrogen or carboxyl-containing compounds (Figures 2 and 4), our
368
results not only support the observed relation between organic nitrogen compounds and Pu
369
binding from natural soils, but also provides additional evidence supporting the conclusion that
370
carboxylate containing compounds, in both particulate and colloidal phases, appear to be
371
important moieties related to Pu complexation by NOM in natural environments. Importantly,
372
these relationships were derived from HA compounds extracted from NOM-containing soils
373
collected from different world-wide regions. Thus, the interaction between HAs with other
374
components could happen in natural soils, which can potentially affect the HAs’ nature and their
375
interaction with Pu and warrants further studies.
376
The strongest known naturally occurring binding agents for Pu containing carboxyl groups
377
have previsouly been reported as hydroxamates,20,22,47-49 which are siderophore compounds with
378
–NOH and COO- moieties, whereby Pu is directly bound to the O of the –NO- group. Because
379
hydroxamate compounds chelate Pu, this results in the greatest association constants for Pu
380
known in nature.50 Although it is likely that hydroxamate siderophores contributed to the positive
381
relation between the partitioning of Pu and organic nitrogen or carboxyl-containing organic
14
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 29
Page 15 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
382
compounds observed in our study, the present study can not provide any direct evidence. This
383
was due to the fact that the hydroxamate contents in the present study could not be quantified
384
due to interferences from the high concentrations of HAs and the universally low abundance of
385
hydroxamates in the bulk organic matter pool (e.g., 0.019– 13.671 mg-C/g-C for a contaminated
386
soil in Savannah River Site20). Further studies are required to identify other potentially abundant
387
organic compounds that can be responsible for the binding and remobilization of Pu in soils.
388 389
Implications on Pu environmental behavior
390
Our laboratory equilibration experiments were carried out under slightly acidic conditions
391
(pH ~5.5), which resulted in 76 ± 12% of total Pu and 29 ± 24% of organic matter partitioning
392
into the colloidal phase (Figure 1 and Figure S1). Considering that increases in pH promote
393
COM release during extreme soil saturation events and strong Pu binding with COM,30,51-53
394
enhanced COM-derived remobilization of potentially mobile Pu would be expected to be more
395
pronounced under less acidic conditions during natural or anthropogenic events such as base
396
injection remediation, intense rainstorms or flooding. Under these conditions, the Pu bound to
397
OM would potentially behave as a contaminant source to the surrounding environments30.
398
To our knowledge, this is the first controlled laboratory experiment conducted using
399
environmentally relevant Pu concentrations to document a relationship between size-fractionated
400
carboxyl-containing or organic nitrogen compounds and the Pu among particulate, colloidal, and
401
dissolved phases. HAs with different molecular compositions and varying organic matter
402
abundance (Table 1) that were collected from widely contrasting soil origins exhibited
403
remarkably similar Kd (Equation 1) or Kdc (Equation 2). Furthermore, Pu partitioned to the HA
404
extremely strongly, showing significant correlations with organic carbon or nitrogen (Figures 2
405
and 3), supporting the regulating role of NOM in complexing and binding of Pu. In detail, the
406
present study further suggests that Pu binding to soil OM is directly or indirectly (e.g.,
407
carboxylate groups can be considered as proxies for other functional groups that occur in
408
relatively fixed proportions) controlled by carboxyl-containing compounds (Figure 4). These
409
latter results support field observations from natural soil environments in different continents,
410
including the Savannah River Site, USA,20 Fukushima Prefecture area, Japan21 and Rocky Flats
411
Environmental Technology Site, USA22-23 where N-containing compounds such as strongly Pu
412
complexing N-containing hydroxamates were present in a Pu enriched fraction. In addition, the
15
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
Page 16 of 29
413
tendency of Pu to adsorb to colloidal HAs was much greater than to particulate HAs. Because
414
colloidal HA is typically more mobile than particulate HA, these results have implications on
415
whether NOM acts as a Pu source or sink during natural or man-induced episodic flooding
416
events. Most importantly, strong Pu binding to soil OM compounds such as HAs also reverses
417
the pH dependency of Pu sorption to soils.30,49 Nevertheless, the limitation of the present study,
418
such as not considering the existence of inorganic materials in the natural soil mixture, and
419
possible experimental artifacts that alkaline extractions of HA from SOM (e.g., harsh extractants)
420
could potentially bias the conformation of the organic matter, might require more comprehensive
421
studies in the future.
422
16
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 17 of 29
Environmental Science & Technology
423
Author Information
424
Corresponding Author
425
*Phone: +1-409-740-4530; fax: 1-409-740-4787; email:
[email protected].
426 427
Acknowledgments
428
This work was funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science Subsurface
429
Biogeochemistry Research program (ER65222-1038426-0017532), DOE SBR grant #DE-
430
ER64567- 1031562-0014364, DOE SBR award # DEeSC0014152, and DOE contract DE-AD09-
431
96SR18500. Work was also supported by DOE’s contract DE-AC09-08SR22470 with Savannah
432
River Nuclear Solutions, LLC. Yuko Sugiyama was supported by JSPS Bilateral Joint Research
433
Projects with USA and Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research #24248027. Nobuhito Ohte was
434
partly supported by a grant for River Management Research (FY2014, 2015) from the River
435
Foundation (Kasen Zaidan, Japan).
436 437
Associated Content:
438
The Supporting Information is available:
439
Partitioning and concentration of organic carbon and nitrogen in the particulate and colloidal
440
phases after HA-groundwater resuspension
441 442
17
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
443
Page 18 of 29
References:
444
1. Bunzl, K.; Kracke, W.; Schimmack, W. Migration of fallout 239+240Pu, 241Am and 137Cs in
445
the various horizons of a forest soil under pine. J. Environ. Radioact. 1995, 28, 17-34.
446
2. Zheng, J.; Tagami, K.; Watanabe, Y.; Uchida, S.; Aono, T.; Ishii, N.; Yoshida, S.; Kubota,
447
Y.; Fuma, S.; Ihara, S. Isotopic evidence of plutonium release into the environment from
448
the Fukushima DNPP accident. Sci. Rep. 2012, 2, 304.
449
3. Schneider, S.; Walther, C.; Bister, S.; Schauer, V.; Christl, M.; Synal, H. A.; Shozugawa,
450
K.; Steinhauser, G. Plutonium release from Fukushima Daiichi fosters the need for more
451
detailed investigations. Sci. Rep. 2013, 3, 2988; DOI:10.1038/srep02988.
452
4. Riley, R. G.; Zachara, J. M.; Wobber, F. J. Chemical contaminants on DOE lands and
453
selection of contaminant mixtures for subsurface science research. US-DOE, Energy
454
Resource Subsurface Science Program, 1992, Washington, DC, USA;
455
DOI:10/2172/10147081.
456
5. Oughton, D. H.; Fifield, L. K.; Day, J. P.; Cresswell, R. C.; Skepperud, L.; Di Tada, M.
457
L.; Salbu, B.; Strand, P.; Drozcho, E.; Mokrov, Y. Plutonium from Mayak: measurement
458
of isotope ratios and activities using accelerator mass spectrometry. Environ. Sci. Technol.
459
2000, 34, 1938-1945.
460
6. Buesseler, K. O.; Kaplan, D. I.; Dai, M.; Pike, S. Source-dependent and source-
461
independent controls on plutonium oxidation state and colloid associations in
462
groundwater. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43, 1322-1328.
463
7. Kersting, A. B.; Efurd, D. W.; Finnegan, D. L.; Rokop, D. J.; Smith, D. K.; Thompson, J.
464
L. Migration of plutonium in ground water at the Nevada Test Site. Nature 1999, 397
465
(6714), 56-59.
466
8. Novikov, A. P; Kalmykov, S. N.; Utsunomiya, S.; Ewing, R. C. Colloid transport of
467
plutonium in the Far-Field of the Mayak production. Science 2006, 314, 638-641.
468
9. Demirkanli, D. I.; Molz, F. J.; Kaplan, D. I. Fjeld, R. A. A fully transient model for long-
469
term plutonium transport in the Savannah River site vadose zone: root water uptake.
470
Vadose Zone J. 2008, 7, 1099-1109.
471
10. Ovsiannikova, S.; Papenia, M.; Voinikava, K. Brown, J. Kipperud, L.; Sokolik, G.;
472
Svirschevsky, S. Migration ability of plutonium and americium in the soils of Polessie
473
State Rediation-Ecological Reserve. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem. 2010, 286, 409-415.
18
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 19 of 29
474
Environmental Science & Technology
11. Schwantes, J. M.; Santschi, P. H. Mechanisms of plutonium sorption to mineral oxide
475
surfaces: new insights with implications for colloid-enhanced migration. Radiochimica
476
Acta 2010, 98, 737-742.
477 478 479 480 481
12. Bu, W.; Zheng, J.; Guo, Q.; Uchida, S. Vertical distribution and migration of global fallout Pu in forest soils in southwestern China. J. Environ. Radioact. 2014, 136, 174-180. 13. Orzel, J.; Komosa, A. Study on the rate of plutonium vertical migration in various soil type of Lublin region (Eastern Poland). J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem. 2014, 299, 643-649. 14. Asbury, S. M. L.; Lamont, S. P.; Clark, S. B. Plutonium partitioning to colloidal and
482
particulate matter in an acidic, sandy sediment: implications for remediation alternatives
483
and plutonium migration. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2001, 35, 2295-2300.
484
15. Kalmykov, S. N.; Batuk, O. N.; Bouby, M.; Denecke, M. A.; Novikov, A. P.; Perminova,
485
I. V.; Shcherbina, N. S. Plutonium speciation and formation of nanoparticles with natural
486
organic matter in contaminated environment. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 2010, 74 (12),
487
A490−A490.
488 489
16. Santschi, P. H.; Roberts, K. A.; Guo, L. Organic nature of colloidal actinides transported in surface water environments. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2002, 36 (17), 3711−3719.
490
17. Eyrolle, F.; Charmasson, S. Importance of colloids in the transport within the dissolved
491
phase (0.45 µm), colloidal (3 kDa to 0.45 µm), and truly
619
dissolved phases (3 kDa); b) Partitioning
620
coefficient values of Pu between particulate (>0.45 µm) and dissolved phases (3 kDa) and truly
622
dissolved phase (