Subscriber access provided by CORNELL UNIVERSITY LIBRARY
Article 2
2
HO production in microbial electrochemical cells fed with primary sludge Dongwon Ki, Sudeep C. Popat, Bruce E. Rittmann, and César Iván Torres Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • Publication Date (Web): 09 May 2017 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on May 11, 2017
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
1
H2O2 production in microbial electrochemical
2
cells fed with primary sludge
3 4
Dongwon Ki*†, Sudeep C. Popat‡, Bruce E. Rittmann†, and César I. Torres†,§
5 6
†
7
P.O. Box 875701, Tempe AZ 85287-5701, USA
Biodesign Swette Center for Environmental Biotechnology, Arizona State University,
8 9 10
‡
Department of Environmental Engineering and Earth Sciences, Clemson University,
USA
11 12
§
13
E. Tyler Mall ECG 301, Tempe, AZ 85287, USA
School for Engineering of Matter Transport and Energy, Arizona State University, 501
14 15
Corresponding Author
16
*(D. Ki) Phone: +1 480 727 0848; fax: +1 480 727 0889
17
Email:
[email protected] 18
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
19
ABSTRACT: We developed an energy-efficient, flat-plate, dual-chambered microbial
20
peroxide producing cell (MPPC) as an anaerobic energy-conversion technology for
21
converting primary sludge (PS) at the anode and producing hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) at
22
the cathode. We operated the MPPC with a 9-day HRT in the anode. A maximum H2O2
23
concentration of ~230 mg/L was achieved in 6 hours of batch cathode operation. This is
24
the first demonstration of H2O2 production using PS in an MPPC, and the energy
25
requirement for H2O2 production was low (~0.87 kWh per kg H2O2), compared to
26
previous studies using real wastewaters. The H2O2 gradually decayed with time due to
27
the diffusion of H2O2-scavenging carbonate ions from the anode. We compared the
28
anodic performance with a H2-producing microbial electrolysis cell (MEC). Both cells
29
(MEC and MPPC) achieved ~30% Coulombic recovery. While similar microbial
30
communities were present in the anode suspension and anode biofilm for the two
31
operating modes, aerobic bacteria were significant only on the side of the anode facing
32
the membrane in the MPPC. Coupled with a lack of methane production in the MPPC,
33
the presence of aerobic bacteria suggests that H2O2 diffusion to the anode side caused
34
inhibition of methanogens, which led to the decrease in COD removal. Thus, the
35
Coulombic efficiency was ~16% higher in the MPPC than in the MEC (64% vs 48%,
36
respectively).
37 38
Keywords: Primary sludge; Hydrogen peroxide; Decomposition, Carbonate, Energy
39
input
2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 30
Page 3 of 30
40
Environmental Science & Technology
TABLE OF CONTENTS/ABSTRACT ART:
41
3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
42
INTRODUCTION
43
Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is a useful chemical in wastewater treatment due to its
44
strong oxidizing properties. H2O2 can be used in the Fenton process or be combined with
45
UV for generation of free radicals to achieve tertiary treatment and disinfection of
46
wastewater.1,2 The conventional method for H2O2 production, the Anthraquinone
47
Oxidation (AO) process, is energy-intensive. Moreover, anthraquinone and its
48
derivatives are potential carcinogens.1,3 Electrochemical technologies have been
49
proposed as alternatives for H2O2 production since the early 1990s.4-9
50
Microbial electrochemical cells (MxCs) can produce H2O2 at the cathode.10 The
51
H2O2 concentrations generated by an MxC can be well suited for on-site use within a
52
wastewater-treatment facility: e.g., cleaning membranes, tertiary treatment, reducing
53
odors, and pre-treating sludge or wastewater, or post-treating sludge. H2O2 may turn out
54
to be a more useful MxC output in the wastewater-treatment setting than the more
55
commonly studied MxC outputs: electrical power in a microbial fuel cell (MFC) or H2
56
gas in a microbial electrolysis cell (MEC).
57
We found ten studies addressing H2O2 production in MxCs.10-19 Depending on
58
the type of MxC and its operation, the H2O2 concentration and production rate varied
59
widely, from 8.5×10-5 to 9.7 g L-1 and from 7.9×10-4 to 18.6 g L-1 d-1 respectively.19
60
Recent research on H2O2 production in MxCs has focused on materials for cathodes and
61
membranes, as well as on improving oxygen diffusion to the cathode catalysts.17-18 Most
62
of these studies were carried out with synthetic medium (e.g., acetate or glucose) fed to
63
the anode.
4
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 30
Page 5 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
H2O2 production with real wastewater has been reported in only four studies.12-
64 65
14,17
66
H2O2 production with real wastewater was lower in terms of concentrations produced and
67
the rates of production, and energy inputs were notably high (> 2 kWh per kg H2O2). The
68
deficiencies in performance reflect on the importance of reactor design and operation to
69
improve voltage efficiency.20,21 Also, cathodic H2O2 production efficiency (PPE), which
70
is the fraction of electrons used and measured as H2O2 generation to the electrons
71
captured as Coulombs, was variable, ranging from 5% to 70%.12-14,17
72
Compared with synthetic medium (mostly acetate) as substrate for the MxC anode,
In previous studies, we optimized flat-plate MECs for H2 production.21-23 Here,
73
we used the same flat-plate design for the anode, but we modified it for H2O2 collection,
74
with passive air diffusion to the cathode. We used primary sludge (PS) to provide
75
electron donor at the anode. The first goal of the study was to provide a proof-of-concept
76
of H2O2 production with PS using an optimized design for a microbial peroxide-
77
producing cell (MPPC).
78
Past MPPC studies using domestic wastewater showed low anodic Coulombic
79
efficiency (CE) of 6-22% with a 6-minute hydraulic retention time (HRT)13 and 2-4%
80
with a 2~10-hour HRT,17 even though COD removal was 39-68% in the latter case.17 In
81
a recent review,24 MEC studies using real wastewater at even higher HRTs showed better
82
performance in terms of COD removal (67-90%) and CE (11-27%). Thus, the second
83
goal of this study was to compare the anodic and cathodic performance -- including COD
84
removal, anodic CE, and PPE -- between an MPPC and an MEC.
85 86
Finally, we compared energy conversion and evaluated the microbial communities formed within MEC and MPPC. We used this information to gain a 5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
87
mechanistic understanding of the difference in performance between the two modes of
88
operation.
6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 30
Page 7 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
89
MATERIALS AND METHODS
90
Primary sludge
91
We collected PS from the Greenfield Water Reclamation Plant (GWRP), Gilbert,
92
AZ, USA. We treated the PS with a pulsed electric field (PEF) unit (the FP alpha unit) in
93
the laboratory, and we stored it in a temperature-controlled room at 4°C before use in
94
order to minimize hydrolysis and fermentation during storage.22,25 The PS was diluted
95
~3.8-fold with distilled water, and the influent PS fed to the MxCs had ~7.6 g/L of TCOD
96
and ~3.8 g/L of VSS. Detail characteristics of PS are provided in Table S1 in Supporting
97
Information.
98 99 100
Design and operation of microbial electrochemical cells We operated a flat-plate microbial electrochemical cell with anode and cathode
101
separated by an anion exchange membrane (AEM), AMI-7001 (Membranes
102
International, Inc.). Following the same design as in Ki et al. (2016; 2017),21,23 one
103
central anode chamber contained two anodes, and the anode chamber was flanked by two
104
separate cathode chambers with one cathode each. The same electrochemical cell was
105
used as an MEC and an MPPC. The anodes were exactly the same, but the electrodes
106
used for cathodes and the cathode chambers were modified for the MPPC. Experiments
107
were first conducted in MEC mode, followed by MPPC mode. Enough time was allowed
108
for operation under each condition to reach a pseudo-steady state: ~30 days for MEC and
109
~10 days for MPPC.
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
110
The anodes were fabricated using carbon fibers (24K Carbon Tow, FibreGlast,
111
OH, USA) woven as a mesh through a titanium plate current collector (Ultra-Corrosion-
112
Resistant Titanium Grade 2, 0.035" of thickness, McMaster-Carr, USA). The geometric
113
surface area of each anode was 100 cm2, and the anode chamber was 500 mL. The
114
cathode for the MEC for H2 production was the same as before,21,23 but the cathode
115
chamber for the MPPC for H2O2 production consisted of a serpentine flow field having a
116
~120 mL volume between the AEM and cathode. Details on parts, configuration, and
117
assembly of MPPC are provided in Figure S1 of the Supporting Information.
118
We used stainless-steel meshes (Super-Corrosion-Resistance Type 316,
119
McMaster-Carr, USA) as the cathodes for H2 production in the MEC. The cathodes for
120
H2O2 production in the MPPC were prepared with a carbon-cloth support (GDL-CT, Fuel
121
Cells Etc, TX, USA), coated with a slurry of Vulcan carbon powder on the liquid-
122
exposed side, and with a 30% PTFE microporous layer (MPL) on the air-exposed side;
123
this was the same as used in Young et al. (2016).19 The area of each cathode was ~79
124
cm2 (8.8 cm x 8.8 cm).
125
The distance between the anode and cathode was less than 0.5 cm in the MEC21
126
and ~1 cm in the MPPC. We included a reference electrode (Ag/AgCl, MF-2052,
127
Bioanalytical Systems, Inc., USA), which was at a ~2 cm distance from each of the
128
anodes. We used a multi-channel potentiostat (VMP3, BioLogic Science Instruments,
129
Knoxville, TN) to control the anode potential at -0.3 V (versus Ag/AgCl) and recorded
130
current, and anode and cathode potential, every two minutes with the EC-Lab software
131
(v. 10.37).
8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 30
Page 9 of 30
132
Environmental Science & Technology
We fed the MEC and the MPPC with PS semi-continuously at a 9-day HRT and
133
with one feeding cycle per day; for example, we removed ~56 mL from the anode
134
chamber and added the same volume of PS to the anode chamber every day. At each
135
feeding, we maintained the pH of ~7.0 in the anode chamber with the addition of 5-M
136
sodium hydroxide (NaOH) as needed.23 The electrolyte for the cathode (the catholyte)
137
for MEC was 100-mM NaOH. The catholyte in the MPPC was 50-mM NaOH. We
138
delivered the catholyte continuously in the serpentine cathode chamber of the MPPC with
139
an ~1.5-h HRT for 18 days, and then we changed to batch mode with a one-day cycle.
140
We collected catholyte samples of ~1 mL at 1.5, 3, 6, 12, and 24 hours during batch
141
operation to measure pH, alkalinity, and H2O2 concentration.
142 143 144
Analytical methods We characterized PS for total chemical oxygen demand (TCOD), semi-soluble
145
COD (SSCOD), total suspended solids (TSS), and volatile suspended solids (VSS)
146
according to Standard Methods.26 Semi-soluble COD was measured on filtrate passed
147
through a 1.2-µm glass-fiber filter (WhatmanTM, UK).22 We used colorimetric methods
148
to determine the H2O2 concentration in the catholyte of the cathode chamber.27 Briefly,
149
the chemical solutions and samples were prepared in 1.5-mL cuvettes in the following
150
order: 10 µL of sample (including H2O2 standard), 2 mL of HCl (50 mM), 0.2 mL of KI
151
(1 M), 0.2 mL of ammonium molybdate (1M) in H2SO4 (0.5 M), and 0.2 mL of a starch
152
solution (1%) as the indicator. H2O2 measurements were performed at a 570-nm
153
wavelength using a Cary 50-Bio UV-Visible spectrophotometer (Varian, Palo Alto, CA).
9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
154
Total alkalinity was measured using spectrophotometric methods by HACH kit and
155
spectrophotometer (DR2700, HACH, Loveland, CO).
156 157 158
Calculations We calculated Coulombic recovery (CR), anodic Coulombic efficiency (CE), and
159
H2O2 production efficiency (PPE). CR and CE were calculated as described in the
160
previous study.22 The PPE was calculated for the batch-mode operation from the
161
measured H2O2 concentration, the volume of the cathode chamber, and the recorded
162
cumulative Coulombs as electrical current using Eq. (1), % =
× × ×
× 100 1 163
where n is the number of moles equivalent to moles of H2O2 (n = 2 here), F is the
164
Faraday constant (96,485 Coulombs mol-1), CH2O2 is the measured concentration of H2O2
165
(mol L-1), and V is the volume of cathode chamber. If all the cumulative Coulombs
166
measured were utilized for production of H2O2, the PPE would equal 100%.
167 168 169
Molecular microbial ecology We collected biomass samples for analysis of microbial community structure in
170
the anodes of the MEC and the MPPC; the samples were from the anode suspension
171
(AnS), biofilm from the anode side facing the chamber (BfC), and biofilm from the anode
172
side facing the membrane (BfM) on the carbon fiber electrodes. A schematic showing 10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 10 of 30
Page 11 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
173
the sampling locations is provided in Figure S2 of the Supporting Information. We
174
centrifuged suspension samples to obtain pellets for DNA extraction. For the biofilm
175
samples, we scraped off the anode surface using a pipette tip for at least 5 different
176
positions. We prepared 0.17~0.27 gram of wet biomass by combining pellets or biofilm
177
solids for each sample, and we added the combined biomass it to the bead tubes provided
178
by a Power Soil DNA extraction kit (MoBio laboratories, Inc., Carlsbad, CA). We
179
extracted DNA per the instructions provided with the kit, quantified DNA concentration
180
with Nanodrop spectrophotometer, and stored DNA at -20 °C before sequencing.
181
We sent the extracted DNA to the Microbiome Analysis Laboratory at Arizona
182
State University for Illumina MiSeq sequencing. Amplicon sequencing of the V4 region
183
of the 16S rRNA gene was performed with the barcoded primer set 515f/806r designed
184
by Caporaso et al. (2012).28 Data received from the testing laboratory were analyzed
185
using QIIME29 after discarding sequences shorter than 25 bp, longer than 450 bp, or
186
labeled as chimeric sequences. After screening, primer sequences were trimmed off, and
187
taxonomic classification was performed using RDP classifier at the 80%-confidence
188
threshold.30 Operating taxonomic units (OTUs) were picked using the Greengenes
189
database by UCLUST algorithm based on ≥97% identity.31 We aligned the
190
representative sequences for each OTU to the Greengenes database using PYNAST.32,33
191
Then, we made the OTU table and removed singletons. Lastly, the OTU table was
192
rarefied to the minimum number of sequences among 6 samples (35,928 sequences); the
193
total number of sequence reads for each sample after screenings were: MEC AnS =
194
58,557, MEC BfC = 64,681, MEC BfM = 56,365, MPPC AnS = 35,928, MPPC BfC =
195
58,902, and MPPC BfM = 55,570. 11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
196
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
197
H2O2 production and efficiency
Page 12 of 30
198
Figure 1a shows H2O2 concentrations (theoretical and measured) and H2O2
199
production efficiency (PPE, based on Eq (1)) during batch operation of the cathode in the
200
MPPC. The H2O2 concentration increased up to ~230 mg L-1 by 6 hours, but then
201
decreased to ~121 mg L-1 by 24 hours. The theoretical H2O2 produced, based on the
202
electrical current produced at the anode, increased linearly up ~2300 mg L-1, indicating
203
that the PPE kept decreasing with time, from 72% at 1.5 hours to 5% at 24 hours. Clearly,
204
H2O2 decomposition became increasingly important in the cathode chamber over 1 day
205
of batch cathode operation.
206
Catholyte pH in the MPPC decreased with time from ~12.6 (0 hour) to 10.4 (24
207
hour), as shown in Figure 1b. This is contrary to the expected pH increase with time,
208
since O2 reduction to H2O2 generates OH-:
209
O2 + 2H2O + 2e- → H2O2 + 2OH-
210
or, above the pKa of H2O2/HO2- (11.8),
211
O2 + H2O + 2e- → HO2- + OH-
212
Ion migration caused the decline in pH. Possible mechanisms of ion migration between
213
the anode and cathode chambers are illustrated schematically in Figure S3 of Supporting
214
Information. Specifically, OH- could have diffused from the cathode to the anode due to
215
the large pH difference (~12.6 at the cathode and ~7 at the anode), and HCO3- could have
216
diffused from the anode to the cathode due to its concentration gradient. Either transport
217
mechanism would have contributed to a pH decrease at the cathode: loss of alkalinity
218
due to OH- transport out of the cathode and pH buffering due to import of HCO3-. Based
(2)
(3)
12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 13 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
219
on the measured pH and total alkalinity of the catholyte (Figure 1b), OH- decreased
220
significantly, while other alkalinity species (CO32- and HCO3-) increased with time. Thus,
221
both ion-migration mechanisms appear to have been at work. During the first ~6 hours, the total alkalinity stayed approximately constant, while
222 223
OH- and CO32- drastically decreased and increased, respectively, especially during the
224
first 3 hours. The increase in CO32- indicates that HCO3- was moving from the anode to
225
the cathode, and the stability of total alkalinity means that transport of OH- to the anode
226
was off-setting the generation of OH- at the cathode and the input of HCO3- from the
227
anode.
228
After ~6 hours, the pH was ≤ 11, and HCO3- steadily increased due to a
229
combination of an increase of the concentration of inorganic C and a shifting of the
230
speciation of inorganic carbon towards, HCO3-, since the pKa of the HCO3-/CO32- couple
231
is ~10.3. Due to continued import of HCO3- and generation of base, the CO32- alkalinity
232
remained high. High CO32- is important, because CO32- can be responsible for H2O2
233
decay (Lee et al., 2000); this is discussed more below.
13
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
234
235 236
Figure 1. Results of cathode batch operation of a microbial peroxide producing cell
237
(MPPC): (a) theoretical and measured H2O2 concentrations based on 100% conversion
238
from cumulative coulombs and detection method, respectively, and H2O2 production
239
efficiency (PPE) (number of measurements, N = 3). The inset zooms in on the first 6
240
hours’ operation in the MPPC. (b) pH and alkalinity of catholyte over the 24-hour batch
241
runs. 14
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 30
Page 15 of 30
242
Environmental Science & Technology
The decrease in H2O2 concentration after 6 h means that the H2O2-decay rate was
243
faster than the H2O2-generation rate at the cathode. H2O2 decay could have been
244
accelerated by four mechanisms: 1) metal cations in PS diffusing from anode to the
245
cathode and catalyzing H2O2 auto-decay, 2) membrane degradation with consumption of
246
H2O2, 3) reaction of H2O2 with carbonate ions, and 4) diffusion of the HO2- ion to the
247
anode. Direct movement of metal cations should not have been important, because we
248
used an anion exchange membrane. As exemplified in Figure S4, we saw no evidence of
249
membrane deterioration or chemical deposits after running 27 days in the MPPC fed with
250
PS. Thus, the first two mechanisms were unlikely.
251
Accelerated loss of H2O2 by reaction with carbonate is supported by prior studies
252
and special tests we carried out. Lee et al. (2000) reported that the rate of decomposition
253
of H2O2 loss was ~9-fold faster in a carbonate solution than in a caustic solution (NaOH)
254
when the pH was 10~10.6, the temperature was 30~50 ˚C, and the ionic strength was
255
1.5~3 M.34 Since the mechanism of H2O2 decay in the presence of carbonate ions has not
256
been elucidated yet, we performed H2O2-decay tests to confirm that accelerated H2O2
257
decay was linked to the carbonate concentration. Figure S5 in Supporting Information
258
shows that H2O2 decomposed quickly during ~1 day in a sodium carbonate solution.
259
Finally, produced H2O2 can dissociate to HO2- ion at high pH (pKa ~ 11.8)19, and
260
the HO2- anions could have diffused to the anode chamber. We explore below evidence
261
supporting this mechanism.
262 263
Comparison of MEC and MPPC operation
15
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
264
Figure 2 shows current densities and applied voltages over three one-day feeding
265
cycles for the MEC and the MPPC pseudo-steady state operation periods. The pattern of
266
current density was the same for both modes: high current at start of a one-day cycle and
267
a decrease due to the consumption of PS-COD. The maximum current densities were
268
similar, ~1 A m-2.
269 270
Figure 2. Current densities and applied voltages in the MEC and MPPC operated with
271
semi-continuous feeding (one-day cycle) and a 9-day HRT. Data are for the last 3 days
272
of operation after the current stabilized for successive cycles.
273 274
The applied voltage for the MPPC was ~0.2 V, a value much lower than that of
275
the MEC, ~1.04V. The theoretical applied voltage for H2 production in MEC is 0.14 V,21
276
which means that the total over-potential in the MEC was 0.9 V. Likewise, the
277
theoretical potential for H2O2 production in MPPC is +0.56 V,10 making the total over-
278
potential 0.76 V, a value smaller than with the MEC. In our previous study,21 we
279
characterized the applied voltage of the same design of flat-plate MECs and categorized 16
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 16 of 30
Page 17 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
280
into anode over-potential (ηan), cathode over-potential (ηcat), Ohmic over-potential
281
(ηOhmic), pH-related concentration over-potentials (ηpH), and theoretical voltage (Eth).
282
The largest over-potentials were ηcat and ηpH, and that should be the same here for an
283
MEC and an MPPC. Since we poised the anode potential at -0.3 V (vs Ag/AgCl) in both
284
cases and used the same substrate, ηan should be similar. ηOhmic should be small for
285
current densities of ~1 A m-2 (in both reactors), although the distance between anode and
286
cathode was ~0.5 cm larger with the MPPC. Thus, the observed improvement of ~0.14 V
287
of total over-potential with the MPPC should have been related to better cathodic
288
catalysis with H2O2 production, compared to H2 production in the MEC.19,21
289
Figure 3 summarizes performance parameters for the effluent from the MPPC and
290
MEC. Influent concentrations did not differ much between the two conditions (Table
291
S1), but the COD-removal in MPPC was 49 (±1)% and 62 (±5)% in the MEC. This
292
difference was due to inhibition of methanogenesis in the MPPC, since the anode
293
chamber of the MEC produced 27 ± 4 mL d-1 of biogas, versus only 2 ± 4 mL d-1 for the
294
MPPC. CH4 generation accounted for higher COD removal in the anode of the MEC.
295
Although CRs were similar in the MEC and MPPC, ~30%, the CE was higher in the
296
MPPC: 64% versus 48%. Higher CE in the MPCC was from lower COD removal
297
efficiency due to the decline in methanogenesis.
298
Inhibition of methanogenesis could have been caused by H2O2 and O2 diffusion
299
into the anode chamber through the membrane from the air-cathode. Most MFC studies
300
using an air-cathode reported high COD-removal efficiency, but low CE, because O2
301
diffusing into the anode chamber allowed rapid aerobic biodegradation, which out-
302
competed anode respiration.35-37 Since the MPPC in our study had lower COD removal 17
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
303
than the MEC, the difference in performance between the MPPC and MEC probably was
304
caused by diffusion of H2O2, not O2.
305 306
Figure 3. COD-removal efficiency, CR, and CE for the MEC and MPPC for a 9-day
307
HRT during semi-continuous operation with one-day feeding cycle of PS.
308 309 310
Microbial phylotypes relevant to community structure and function Figure 4 shows the taxonomy of the microbial communities, classified at the order
311
level, in 6 samples: anode suspension (AnS) and two sets of biofilm samples for the
312
MEC and the MPPC. Biofilm samples were taken from the chamber side (BfC) and
313
membrane side (BfM) of the anode. The AnS and BfC communities were similar
314
between the MEC and MPPC, but the BfM communities were significantly different.
18
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 18 of 30
Page 19 of 30
315
Environmental Science & Technology
The dominant phylotype in AnS was Bacteroidales, which includes bacteria well-
316
known for carrying out hydrolysis and fermentation of complex organics.38,39 For the
317
anode biofilm of the chamber side (BfC) in both systems, Desulfuromonadales and
318
Desulfobacterales were dominant orders. Geobacter, unclassified Pelobacteraceae, and
319
unclassified Desulfobulbaceae were dominant at the genus level. These genera contain
320
species that typically are found in anode biofilms.38,40-42
321
Despite being at the same anode surface, the BfM communities were different
322
from the BfC communities of each system, and the two BfM communities (MEC vs
323
MPPC) were very different from each other. Natranaerobiales was the most abundant
324
phylotype in the MEC BfM, with Dethiobacter (Family Anaerobrancaceae) and
325
unclassified Anaerobrancaceae being the largest fractions at the genus level, 23 and 25%,
326
respectively. Dethiobacter alkaliphilus, which is 96% similarity to the representative
327
sequence in the MEC BfM, is an obligate anaerobe that uses H2 as an electron donor and
328
thiosulfate, elemental sulfur, and polysulfide as electron acceptors in high-pH (~10) and
329
high-salt (~0.6 M of sodium) environments.43
330
In contrast, Oceanospirillales and Rhizobiales were predominant in the MPPC
331
BfM, and Halomonas and Parvibaculum were the largest fractions at the genus level, 17
332
and 16%, respectively. Halomonas species are aerobes living in saline conditions. Some
333
species, such as Halomonas salaria sp. and Halomonas denitrificans sp., have a yellow
334
or brown-yellow color44 that corresponded to the appearance of the membrane-side anode
335
at the end of the experiments with the MPPC, shown in Figure S6. Parvibaculum
336
lavamentivorans DS-1 also is an aerobe known for biodegrading synthetic laundry
337
detergents (e.g., linear alkylbenzenesulfonate, LAS).45 19
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
338
The different community structures of BfM from BfC in the MEC and MPPC
339
correlate to the very different environments of the cathode chamber. In particular, BfM
340
in the MPPC included a majority of aerobic bacteria, since O2 and H2O2, which can
341
degrade to O2, diffused through the air-cathode and AEM. Although H2O2 and O2
342
diffusion was not significant enough to change the microbial community structure of AnS
343
and BfC or divert electron flow away from anode respiration (similar CRs of ~30%,
344
Figure 3), it profoundly altered the BfM community.
345
346 347
Figure 4. Microbial community structure at the order level for anode suspension (AnS),
348
biofilm of chamber side (BfC), and biofilm of membrane side (BfM) in the MEC and
349
MPPC at the end of operation.
350 351 352 353
Low energy requirement With a 6-hour cathode HRT that produced ~230 mg H2O2 L-1 in the MPPC, the cathode potential was around -0.5 V (vs. Ag/AgCl). Since the anode potential was fixed 20
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 20 of 30
Page 21 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
354
at -0.3 V (vs. Ag/AgCl), the applied voltage was 0.2 V, resulting in ~0.87 kWh per
355
kgH2O2 for ~1 A m-2 current density. This value is consistent with the ~1 kWh per kg
356
H2O2 measured by Young et al. (2016)19 using the same reactor design (flat-plate MEC),
357
but fed with acetate as the electron donor. This energy requirement for H2O2 production
358
is relatively low compared to other published studies using actual wastewaters: 2.5-78
359
kWh per kg H2O2 using real wastewater,12-14,17 and similar to when using synthetic
360
wastewater (acetate) of ~0.93, 3, and 0.659 kWh per kg H2O2.10,13,15 The low energy
361
input can be attributed to the relatively small distance (~1 cm) between the anode and
362
cathode, which minimized the energy loss of ion transport.19,21
363
Modin and Fukushi (2013) demonstrated production of > 9 g L-1 of H2O2 (highest
364
concentration reported so far using MPPC fed with acetate) with a rate of > 11 g L-1 d-1.13
365
However, they needed a high energy input, ~3 kWh per kg H2O2. Even though we
366
demonstrate that we can produce H2O2 at ~1 kWh per kg H2O2, H2O2 can be theoretically
367
produced with the production of power or at least with little or no energy input.10,19 A
368
systematic investigation of cell design and materials (e.g., membranes, catalysts) may
369
lead to a higher concentration of H2O2 with lower or zero net energy input.19 The energy
370
input for H2O2 production using MPPC would be a significant improvement compared to
371
conventional H2O2 production methods: 2-10 kWh per kg H2O2 by anthraquinone
372
oxidation and 4-5 kWh per kg H2O2 by electrochemical technologies.46-49 However,
373
continuous H2O2 production in an MPPC using real wastewater needs to be studied and
374
optimized in the future.
375
In summary, we demonstrated H2O2 production using PS in a flat-plate, dual-
376
chambered MPPC. The maximum H2O2 concentration was achieved ~230 mg/L in 6 21
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
377
hours of batch catholyte operation, but H2O2 net decomposed for longer catholyte times;
378
the main cause of H2O2 loss was reaction with carbonate ions that moved from the anode
379
to the cathode and to diffusion of H2O2 from the cathode to the anode. The energy
380
requirement for H2O2 production was relatively low, ~0.87 kWh per kgH2O2, compared
381
to other H2O2-producing microbial electrochemical cells using real wastewater. While
382
the MPPC and an MEC achieved ~30% Coulombic recovery, the Coulombic efficiency
383
was ~12% higher in the MPPC than in the MEC, due to lower TCOD removal from
384
suppression of methanogenesis in the MPPC. Even though the microbial communities of
385
the anode suspension and anode biofilm for both cells were similar, aerobic bacteria were
386
significant only on the side of the anode facing the membrane in the MPPC. The
387
presence of aerobic bacteria and the suppression of methanogenesis in the MPPC support
388
that H2O2 diffused to the anode side. Transport of ions across the membranes was of importance in producing H2O2
389 390
when using real wastewater. When we use an AEM, carbonate/bicarbonate ions can
391
move from the anode to the cathode; if we were to use a cation exchange membranes
392
(CEM), other cations, such as K+, Na+, and metals, would diffuse from the anode to the
393
cathode to maintain electroneutrality. Transport of the cations would bring about two
394
possible negative effects: 1) lowering the pH below an acceptable threshold for ARB,
395
and 2) accelerated H2O2 decay with metal catalysis.
396 397
398
Supporting Information
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
22
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 22 of 30
Page 23 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
399
MPPC design (Figure S1), schematic view for the sampling locations for microbial
400
community (Figure S2), possible mechanisms ion migration and diffusion, anion
401
exchange membrane used during MPPC (Figure S3), abiotic H2O2 decay tests in different
402
salt solutions (Figure S4), solid biomass on carbon fiber anodes (Figure S5), PS
403
characteristics (Table S1), a summary of H2O2-producing microbial electrochemical cell
404
studies using real wastewater (Table S2), are all available in the Supporting Information.
405 406
AUTHOR INFORMATION
407
Corresponding Author
408
*(D. Ki) Phone: +1 480 727 0848; fax: +1 480 727 0889
409
Email:
[email protected] 410 411
Notes
412
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
413 414 415
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We acknowledge the Department of Defense’s SERDP program (project # ER-
416
2239) for providing the funding for this study. We also acknowledge Mike Davis for
417
assistance obtaining primary sludge samples at GWRP.
23
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
418
REFERENCES
419
(1)
Campos-Martin, J.M., Blanco-Brieva, G., Fierro, J.L.G. 2006. Hydrogen peroxide
420
synthesis: An outlook beyond the anthraquinone process. Angewandte Chemie-
421
International Edition, 45, 6962-6984.
422
(2)
Wagner, M., Brumelis, D., Gehr, R. 2002. Disinfection of wastewater by hydrogen
423
peroxide or peracetic acid: development of procedures for measurement of residual
424
disinfectant and application to a physicochemically treated municipal effluent.
425
Water Environment Research, 74, 33-50.
426
(3)
Acta Chemica Scandinavica, 53, 745-750.
427 428
(4)
Otsuka, K., Yamanaka, I. 1990. One-step synthesis of hydrogen-peroxide through fuel-cell reaction. Electrochimica Acta, 35, 319-322.
429 430
Pletcher, D. 1999. Indirect oxidations using electrogenerated hydrogen peroxide.
(5)
Yamanaka, I., Otsuka, K. 1991. The partial oxidations of cyclohexane and benzene
431
on the FeCl3-embedded cathode during the O2-H2 fuel-cell reactions. Journal of the
432
Electrochemical Society, 138, 1033-1038.
433
(6)
using an alkaline fuel cell. Journal of the Electrochemical Society, 145, 3444-3449.
434 435
(7)
Otsuka, K., Yamanaka, I. 1998. Electrochemical cells as reactors for selective oxygenation of hydrocarbons at low temperature. Catalysis Today, 41, 311-325.
436 437
Alcaide, F., Brillas, E., Cabot, P.L. 1998. Electrogeneration of hydroperoxide ion
(8)
McLean, G.F., Niet, T., Prince-Richard, S., Djilali, N. 2002. An assessment of
438
alkaline fuel cell technology. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 27, 507-
439
526.
24
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 24 of 30
Page 25 of 30
440 441 442
Environmental Science & Technology
(9)
Yamanaka, I., Murayama, T. 2008. Neutral H2O2 synthesis by electrolysis of water and O2. Angewandte Chemie-International Edition, 47, 1900-1902.
(10) Rozendal, R.A., Leone, E., Keller, J., Rabaey, K. 2009. Efficient hydrogen peroxide
443
generation from organic matter in a bioelectrochemical system. Electrochemistry
444
Communications, 11, 1752-1755.
445
(11) Fu, L., You, S.-J., Yang, F.-l., Gao, M.-m., Fang, X.-h., Zhang, G.-q. 2010.
446
Synthesis of hydrogen peroxide in microbial fuel cell. Journal of Chemical
447
Technology and Biotechnology, 85, 715-719.
448
(12) Modin, O., Fukushi, K. 2012. Development and testing of bioelectrochemical
449
reactors converting wastewater organics into hydrogen peroxide. Water Science and
450
Technology, 66, 831-836.
451
(13) Modin, O., Fukushi, K. 2013. Production of high concentrations of H2O2 in a
452
bioelectrochemical reactor fed with real municipal wastewater. Environmental
453
Technology, 34, 2737-2742.
454
(14) Arends, J.B.A., van Denhouwe, S., Verstraete, W., Boon, N., Rabaey, K. 2014.
455
Enhanced disinfection of wastewater by combining wetland treatment with
456
bioelectrochemical H2O2 production. Bioresource Technology, 155, 352-358.
457
(15) Chen, J.-Y., Li, N., Zhao, L. 2014. Three-dimensional electrode microbial fuel cell
458
for hydrogen peroxide synthesis coupled to wastewater treatment. Journal of Power
459
Sources, 254, 316-322.
460
(16) Chen, J.-Y., Zhao, L., Li, N., Liu, H. 2015. A microbial fuel cell with the three-
461
dimensional electrode applied an external voltage for synthesis of hydrogen
462
peroxide from organic matter. Journal of Power Sources, 287, 291-296. 25
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
463
(17) Sim, J., An, J., Elbeshbishy, E., Ryu, H., Lee, H.-S. 2015. Characterization and
464
optimization of cathodic conditions for H2O2 synthesis in microbial
465
electrochemical cells. Bioresource Technology, 195, 31-36.
466
(18) Li, N., An, J., Zhou, L., Li, T., Li, J., Feng, C., Wang, X. 2016. A novel carbon
467
black graphite hybrid air-cathode for efficient hydrogen peroxide production in
468
bioelectrochemical systems. Journal of Power Sources, 306, 495-502.
469
(19) Young, M.Y., Links, M.J., Popat, S.C., Rittmann, B.E., Torres, C.I. 2016. Tailoring
470
microbial electrochemical cells for production of hydrogen peroxide at high
471
concentrations and efficiencies. ChemSusChem, 9, 3345-3352.
472 473
(20) Popat, S.C., Torres, S.C. 2016. Critical transport rates that limit the performance of microbial electrochemistry technologies. Bioresource Technology, 215, 265-273.
474
(21) Ki, D., Popat, S.C., Torres, C.I. 2016. Reduced overpotentials in microbial
475
electrolysis cells through improved design, operation, and electrochemical
476
characterization. Chemical Engineering Journal, 287, 181-188.
477
(22) Ki, D., Parameswaran, P., Popat, S.C., Rittmann, B.E., Torres, C.I. 2015. Effects of
478
pre-fermentation and pulsed-electric-field treatment of primary sludge in microbial
479
electrochemical cells. Bioresource Technology, 195, 83-88.
480
(23) Ki, D., Parameswaran, P., Popat, S.C., Rittmann, B.E., Torres, C.I. 2017.
481
Maximizing Coulombic recovery from primary sludge by changing retention time
482
and pH in a flat-plate microbial electrolysis cell. Environmental Science: Water
483
Research and Technology, 3, 333-339.
484
(24) Escapa, A., Mateos, R., Martinez, E.J., Blanes, J. 2016. Microbial electrolysis cells:
485
An emerging technology for wastewater treatment and energy recovery. From 26
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 26 of 30
Page 27 of 30
Environmental Science & Technology
486
laboratory to pilot plant and beyond. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews,
487
55, 942-956.
488
(25) Ki, D., Parameswaran, P., Rittmann, B.E., Torres, C.I. 2015. Effect of pulsed
489
electric field (PEF) pretreatment on primary sludge for enhanced bioavailability and
490
energy capture. Environmental Engineering Science, 32, 831-837.
491 492 493
(26) American Public Health Association. 2012. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, Washington D.C., 20th edn. (27) Graf, E., Penniston, J.T. 1980. Method for determination of hydrogen-peroxide,
494
with its application illustrated by glucose assay. Clinical Chemistry, 26, 658-660.
495
(28) Caporaso, J.G., Lauber, C.L., Walters, W.A., Berg-Lyons, D., Huntley, J., Fierer,
496
N., Owens, S.M., Betley, J., Fraser, L., Bauer, M., Gormley, N., Gilbert, J.A.,
497
Smith, G., Knight, R. 2012. Ultra-high-throughput microbial community analysis
498
on the Illumina HiSeq and MiSeq platforms. ISME Journal, 6, 1621-1624.
499
(29) Caporaso, J.G., Kuczynski, J., Stombaugh, J., Bittinger, K., Bushman, F.D.,
500
Costello, E.K., Fierer, N., Pena, A.G., Goodrich, J.K., Gordon, J.I., Huttley, G.A.,
501
Kelley, S.T., Knights, D., Koenig, J.E., Ley, R.E., Lozupone, C.A., McDonald, D.,
502
Muegge, B.D., Pirrung, M., Reeder, J., Sevinsky, J.R., Tumbaugh, P.J., Walters,
503
W.A., Widmann, J., Yatsunenko, T., Zaneveld, J., Knight, R. 2010. QIIME allows
504
analysis of high-throughput community sequencing data. Nature Methods, 7, 335-
505
336.
506 507
(30) Cole, J.R., Wang, Q., Cardenas, E., Fish, J., Chai, B., Farris, R.J., Kulam-SyedMohideen, A.S., McGarrell, D.M., Marsh, T., Garrity, G.M., Tiedje, J.M. 2009. The
27
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
508
Ribosomal Database Project: improved alignments and new tools for rRNA
509
analysis. Nucleic Acids Research, 37, D141-D145.
510 511 512
(31) Edgar, R.C. 2010. Search and clustering orders of magnitude faster than BLAST. Bioinformatics, 26, 2460-2461. (32) DeSantis, T.Z., Hugenholtz, P., Larsen, N., Rojas, M., Brodie, E.L., Keller, K.,
513
Huber, T., Dalevi, D., Hu, P., Andersen, G.L., 2006. Greengenes, a chimera-
514
checked 16s rRNA gene database and workbench compatible with ARB. Appl.
515
Environmental Microbiology, 72, 5069-5072.
516
(33) Caporaso, J.G., Bittinger, K., Bushman, F.D., DeSantis, T.Z., Andersen, G.L.,
517
Knight, R., 2010. Pynast: a flexible tool for aligning sequences to a template
518
alignment. Bioinformatics, 26, 266-267.
519 520 521
(34) Lee, H.H.B., Park, A.-H., Oloman, C. 2000. Stability of hydrogen peroxide in sodium carbonate solutions. TAPPI Journal, 83, 94-101. (35) Angosto, J.M., Fernández-López, J.A., Godínez, C. 2015. Brewery and liquid
522
manure wastewaters as potential feedstocks for microbial fuel cells: a performance
523
study. Environmental Technology, 36, 68-78.
524
(36) Ge, Z., Zhang, F., Grimaud, J., Hurst, J., He, Z. 2013. Long-term investigation of
525
microbial fuel cells treating primary sludge or digested sludge. Bioresource
526
Technology, 136, 509-514.
527
(37) Zhuang, L., Yuan, Y., Wang, Y., Zhou, S. 2012. Long-term evaluation of a 10-liter
528
serpentine-type microbial fuel cell stack treating brewery wastewater. Bioresource
529
Technology, 123, 406-412.
28
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 28 of 30
Page 29 of 30
530
Environmental Science & Technology
(38) Jia, J., Tang, Y., Liu, B., Wu, D., Ren, N., Xing, D. 2013. Electricity generation
531
from food wastes and microbial community structure in microbial fuel cells.
532
Bioresource Technology, 144, 94-99.
533
(39) Rismani-Yazdi, H., Carver, S.M., Christy, A.D., Yu, Z., Bibby, K., Peccia, J.,
534
Tuovinen, O.H. 2013. Suppression of methanogenesis in cellulose-fed microbial
535
fuel cells in relation to performance, metabolite formation, and microbial
536
population. Bioresource Technology, 129, 281-288.
537
(40) Kiely, P.D., Cusick, R., Call, D.F., Selembo, P.A., Regan, J.M., Logan, B.E. 2011.
538
Anode microbial communities produced by changing from microbial fuel cell to
539
microbial electrolysis cell operation using two different wastewaters. Bioresource
540
Technology, 102, 388-394.
541
(41) Torres, C.I., Krajmalnik-Brown, R., Parameswaran, P., Marcus, A.K., Wanger, G.,
542
Gorby, Y.A., Rittmann, B.E. 2009. Selecting anode-respiring bacteria based on
543
anode potential: phylogenetic, electrochemical, and microscopic characterization.
544
Environmental Science and Technology, 43, 9519-9524.
545
(42) Wang, Z., Lee, T., Lim, B., Choi, C., Park, J. 2014. Microbial community structures
546
differentiated in a single-chamber air-cathode microbial fuel cell fueled with rice
547
straw hydrolysate. Biotechnology for Biofuel, 7, 9-18.
548
(43) Sorokin, D.Y., Tourova, T.P., Mußmann, M., Muyzer, G. 2008. Dethiobacter
549
alkaliphilus gen. nov. sp. nov., and Desulfurivibrio alkaliphilus gen. nov. sp. nov.:
550
two novel representatives of reductive sulfur cycle from soda lakes. Extremophiles,
551
12, 431-439.
29
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
552
(44) Kim, K.K., Jin, L., Yang, H.C., Lee, S.-T. 2007. Halomonas gomseomensis sp nov,
553
Halomonas janggokensis sp nov, Halomonas salaria sp nov and Halomonas
554
denitrificans sp nov, moderately halophilic bacteria isolated from saline water.
555
International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology, 57, 675- 681.
556
(45) Schleheck, D., Weiss, M., Pitluck, S., Bruce, D., Land, M.L., Han, S., Saunders, E.,
557
Tapia, R., Detter, C., Brettin, T., Han, J., Woyke, T., Goodwin, L., Pennacchio, L.,
558
Nolan, M., Cook, A.M., Kjelleberg, S., Thomas, T. 2011. Complete genome
559
sequence of Parvibaculum lavamentivorans type strain (DS-1T). Standards in
560
Genomic Sciences, 5, 298-310.
561
(46) Althaus, H., Chudacoff, M., Hischier, R., Jungbluth, N., Osses, M., Primas, A.
562
2007. Life cycle inventories of chemicals. Ecoinvent Report No. 8, v2.0.
563
(47) Goor, G., Glenneberg, J., Jacobi, S. 2000. Ullmann’s encyclopedia of industrial
564 565
chemistry, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany. (48) Eul, W., Moeller, A., Steiner, N. 2001. Hydrogen peroxide, Kirk-Othmer
566
encyclopedia of chemical technology.
567
DOI: 10.1002/0471238961.0825041808051919.a01.pub2
568
(49) Foller, P., Bombard, R. 1995. Processes for the production of mixtures of caustic
569
soda and hydrogen peroxide via the reduction of oxygen, Journal of Applied
570
Electrochemistry, 25, 613-627.
30
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 30 of 30