Subscriber access provided by NEW YORK UNIV
Article
Significance of Anthropogenic Factors to Freely Dissolved Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Freshwater of China Yao Yao, Chun-Li Huang, Ji-Zhong Wang, Hong-Gang Ni, ZeYu Yang, Zhi-Yong Huang, Lian-Jun Bao, and Eddy Y. Zeng Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • Publication Date (Web): 27 Jun 2017 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on June 27, 2017
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 28
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Significance of Anthropogenic Factors to Freely Dissolved
2
Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Freshwater of China
3 4
Yao Yao,†,¥ Chun-Li Huang,‡ Ji-Zhong Wang,§ Hong-Gang Ni,║ Ze-Yu Yang,⊥
5
Zhi-Yong Huang,‡ Lian-Jun Bao,*,‡ and Eddy Y. Zeng†,‡
6
†
7
Chinese Academy of Sciences, Guangzhou 510640, China
8
‡
9
and Guangdong Key Laboratory of Environmental Pollution and Health, Jinan University,
State Key Laboratory of Organic Geochemistry, Guangzhou Institute of Geochemistry,
School of Environment, Guangzhou Key Laboratory of Environmental Exposure and Health
10
Guangzhou 510632, China
11
§
12
Hefei, 230009, China
13
║
14
University, Shenzhen 518055, China
15
⊥
16
Ottawa, K1A0H3, Canada
17
¥
School of Resources and Environmental Engineering, Hefei University of Technology,
Shenzhen Key Laboratory of Circular Economy, Shenzhen Graduate School, Peking
Emergencies Science and Technology Section, Environment and Climate Change Canada,
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100049, China.
18 19
ABSTRACT: Assessment of surface water pollution by organic pollutants is a top priority
20
in many parts of the world, as it provides critical information for implementing effective
21
measures to ensure drinking water safety. This is particularly important in China, where
22
insufficient data of national scale have been acquired on the occurrence of any organic
23
pollutants in the country’s water bodies. To fill the knowledge gap, we employed passive
24
samplers to survey polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in 42 freshwaters throughout 1 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Environmental Science & Technology
25
the country. The dissolved ∑24PAH concentrations ranged from 0.28 to 538 ng L-1, with the
26
highest and lowest values obtained in Southern Lake in Wuhan and in the Nam Co Lake in
27
Tibet, respectively. Average ∑24PAH concentrations in West, Central and East China
28
correlated well with the population densities in these regions. The composition profiles of
29
PAHs showed a mixed PAH source of coal combustion, fossil fuel combustion and oil spills.
30
In addition, all dissolved PAH concentrations were below the water guidelines developed by
31
the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the European Union and the Canadian
32
government, except for anthracene in Southern Lake. Our results also demonstrated the
33
feasibility of establishing a global network of monitoring organic pollutants in the aquatic
34
environment with passive sampling techniques.
2 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Page 2 of 28
Page 3 of 28
35 36
Environmental Science & Technology
INTRODUCTION The United Nations estimates that more than two-thirds of the global population will
37
live in cities by 2050.1 Rapid urbanization has created overpopulated metropolis, resulting in
38
inadequate waste treatment and disposal capacity, deterioration of water quality, shortage of
39
drinking water and other health issues.2-6 Intensified human activities have aggravated water
40
pollution, because organic pollutants of anthropogenic origin can deposit in marine and
41
freshwater systems through effluent discharge, atmospheric fallout, surface runoff and other
42
means.7 One of the most important groups of organic contaminants, polycyclic aromatic
43
hydrocarbons (PAHs), have been shown to cause adverse effects on humans and wildlife
44
because of their widespread occurrence, toxic potency and bioaccumulative ability through
45
the aquatic food web.8-10 In many cases, often the freely dissolved or bioavailable
46
concentration instead of total concentration is directly related to bioaccumulation and human
47
exposure to organic contaminants.11-13
48
Yet measurement of freely dissolved organic contaminants on a large spatial scale,
49
which is critical for identifying trends and patterns, is no trivial task. Passive sampling
50
approach, capable of simultaneously sampling in a large range of areas, is beneficial in this
51
aspect.11 Among the available passive samplers, devices with low density polyethylene
52
(LDPE) as the sorbent phase have been recommended as a preferred alternative for sensing
53
organic contaminants in aquatic environments because they are consistent, biomimetic,
54
inexpensive, and convenient for field deployment.14-16
55
Enormous economic development and urbanization in China has created severe water
56
pollution issues, which however has not been adequately monitored.12, 17 One of the reasons
57
is obviously that China’s vast territorial area, amounting to more than 960 million square
58
kilometers, is posing a great challenge to any monitoring effort. On the other hand, China’s
59
variable geographical settings and population distribution patterns present an unparalleled
3 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Environmental Science & Technology
60
opportunity for examining whether freshwater quality has been significantly impacted by
61
anthropogenic activities. Building on our previous efforts in development of robust passive
62
samplers for sensing organic contaminants in open waters,18, 19 we conducted a large-scale
63
survey to examine water quality in China using passive sampling techniques. The present
64
campaign was also a preliminary study for a recent effort to establish the Aquatic Global
65
Passive Sampling (AQUA-GAPS) network.11
66
The objectives of the present study were to (1) better understand the geographical
67
distribution of freely dissolved PAH concentrations in freshwater systems of China; (2)
68
examine the relationship between freely dissolved PAH concentrations and regional
69
population densities to elucidate the impacts of anthropogenic activities on water quality and
70
(3) diagnose the potential sources of PAHs in the freshwater systems under investigation. In
71
the last decade, numerous studies have been conducted on the occurrence of organic
72
contaminants in freshwater of China, which however were largely focused on East China,
73
such as the Yangtze River Delta and the Pearl River Delta.12, 20, 21 To accomplish the
74
objectives mentioned above, we deployed a self-developed passive sampler in a wide range
75
of regions in West, East and Central China with large gradients in population densities and
76
levels of economic development. The passive sampler with LDPE as the sorbent phase and a
77
copper box as protecting mechanism was demonstrated to be a useful tool for quantifying
78
freely dissolved organic contaminants in seawater (Hailing Bay) and in freshwater lakes of
79
Antarctica.18, 19
80 81 82
MATERIALS AND METHODS Passive Sampler Preparation. Materials, passive sampler preparation and
83
deployment procedures, geographic information and characteristics of each sampling site are
84
listed in the Supporting Information Text S1 and Tables S2-S3. Briefly, samplers were
4 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Page 4 of 28
Page 5 of 28
Environmental Science & Technology
85
deployed at 42 sites, located mainly in Northeast (Songhua River Basin and Liaohe River
86
Basin), Central and East (Yangtze River Basin) and Northwest (lakes and reservoirs of the
87
Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region) China in July to November, 2013 and Southwest (lakes
88
of the Tibet Plateau) China in May to September, 2015. All LDPE strips were spiked with
89
the performance reference compounds (PRCs), i.e., anthracene-d10, benzo[a]anthracene-d12,
90
benzo[a]pyrene-d12, PCB-29, PCB-61, PCB-155, p,p′-DDT-d8, p,p′-DDD-d8 and p,p′-DDE-d8,
91
by soaking in a mixed solution (Vmethanol:Vwater = 50:50) for 30 d before deployment (placed
92
on a shaking bed at 200 r min-1 in dark). The prepared LDPEs were wrapped in clean
93
aluminum foil and kept in ice chests during transport to the sampling sites. At each sampling
94
site, at least three passive samplers were deployed approximately one meter below the water
95
surface for 15 d with 100 m or longer distance from each other depending on the sizes of the
96
target lakes or reservoirs. To reduce inshore influences, the samplers were placed as far away
97
as possible from the watersides. Upon retrieval, the sampling devices were disassembled,
98
and the LDPE strips were retrieved and maintained in ice chests during transport to the
99
laboratory. A total of 40 top surface (0‒5 cm) soil samples were collected at the same time
100
when passive samplers were deployed; soil samples were not available at several sites. The
101
procedures for collecting and extracting soil samples are described in Text S2.
102
Extraction of Polyethylene Strips. The LDPE strips were rinsed with purified water
103
and cut into small pieces (about 2 cm × 2 cm), wrapped in filter paper (sonicated with
104
dichloromethane and methanol three times each and dried before use) and extracted three
105
times by soaking in 200 mL of hexane for 24 h. The surrogate standards were added to each
106
sample before extraction. Three extracts from each sample were combined and concentrated
107
to approximately 10 mL with a Zymark Turbo Vap II (Hopkinton, MA) at 30 °C. After
108
dehydration with sodium sulfate, the extract was reduced to 0.5 mL with the Zymark Turbo
109
Vap II and purified on a glass column (8 mm inner diameter), packed with neutral alumina
5 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Environmental Science & Technology
110
(0.8 g), neutral silica gel (0.8 g) and sodium sulfate (0.5 cm) from bottom to top. The eluate
111
was condensed to 100 µL and spiked with internal standards, i.e., fluorene-d10, pyrene-d10,
112
dibenzo[a,h]anthracene-d14, PCB-24, PCB-82 and PCB-189 prior to instrumental analysis.
113
Specifically, fluorene-d10, pyrene-d10 and dibenzo[a,h]anthracene-d14 were used to quantify
114
PAHs, whereas PCB-24, PCB-82 and PCB-189 were used to determine the concentrations of
115
PCB or DDT compounds. Detailed instrumental analysis are described in Text S1.
116
Quality Assurance and Quality Control. One field blank and one initial PRC
117
concentration blank were processed at each sampling site and one laboratory blank were
118
processed for every batch of 20 samples. Overall, there were 39 sampling sites with 134 field
119
samples and 62 blank samples retrieved (including field, field-trip and laboratory blank
120
samples). The concentrations of target PAHs in blank samples were lower than 10% of those
121
in the corresponding field samples. The concentrations of PAHs in field samples were blank-
122
subtracted using each specific field blanks from the corresponding site but not corrected for
123
the surrogate standard recoveries. Because naphthalene was quite abundant in several LDPE
124
samples, it was excluded from further analyses. The recoveries of the surrogate standards,
125
i.e., naphthalene-d8, acenaphthene-d10, phenanthrene-d10, chrysene-d12, PCB-67 and PCB-191,
126
were 52±10%, 79±13%, 100±13%, 112±21%, 98±25% and 77±22% in all blank samples and
127
47±11%, 84±10%, 104±12%, 108±20%, 98±20% and 77±19% in the field samples. The
128
reporting limit (RL) was calculated from the lowest calibration level divided by the mass of
129
LDPE (about 4 g for each passive sampler). It was 1.25 ng g-1 for each LDPE passive
130
sampler for all target analytes except IcdP, DahA and BghiP (the abbreviations of PAH
131
compounds are listed in Table S1), which had a RL of 2.5 ng g-1 for their relatively low mass
132
spectral responses. The concentrations of target PAHs were all below RLs in re-extracted
133
LDPE samples.
6 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Page 6 of 28
Page 7 of 28
134
Environmental Science & Technology
Data Analysis. To determine dissolved PAH concentrations (Cw), the sampling rate
135
(Rs) of a target analyte at each sampling site was calculated via a kinetically diffusion-
136
controlled quantitation method,16, 22 i.e.,
137
Cw =
Cpe Rs t K pew 1 − exp(− ) K pew M pe
(1)
138
where Cpe is the analyte concentration in LDPE at sampling time t, Kpew is the equilibrium
139
partition coefficient of the target analyte between LDPE and water, Rs is the sampling rate
140
and Mpe is the LDPE mass.16 The Kpew values of PAHs (Table S1) were adopted from the
141
results of Reitsma et al.23 under ambient conditions (25 oC and 0 psu), similar to the
142
conditions in the present study. Rs can be estimated by the dissipation rates of pre-loaded
143
PRCs using linear regression and molecular volume adjustment (Table S4). Procedures for
144
calculating Cw and associated errors were detailed in our previous study.18
145
Ratios of several paired PAH isomers with similar physicochemical properties have
146
been employed to diagnose emission sources of PAHs derived from passive sampling
147
techniques, such as Flu/(Flu+Pyr), Ant/(Ant+Phe) and BaA/(BaA+Chr).14, 15, 24-26 If the
148
dissolved concentrations of individual PAH isomers were below the reporting limits, such as
149
Phe, Ant and BaA at TI-1 and TI-3 sites, BaA at LH-3 and XJ-8 sites and Phe at YR-7 site,
150
the corresponding paired PAH diagnostic ratios were excluded for source assessment.
151 152 153
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Spatial Trend of Freely Dissolved PAH Concentrations. Sampling rates (Rs) of
154
PAHs varied at different sampling sites, and the average Rs was 6±4 L d-1 for Ant, 155±98 L
155
d-1 for BaA and 1025±650 L d-1 for BaP. They increased with increasing log Kpew, which was
156
similar to the results of other studies.14, 15 It should be noted that equilibrium partitioning
157
between LDPE membrane and water may be reached for lighter PAH compounds with lower
7 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Environmental Science & Technology
158
sampling rates than Ant, such as 2-mNap, 1-mNap, 2, 6-dimNap, ∑C2-Nap, BP, Acy, Ace
159
and Flo at some sampling sites. On the other hand, the PAH concentrations in our sampling
160
sites (most lakes and reservoirs) were assumed not to vary considerably during the 15-d
161
sampling period. No floods and large point source inputs to the sampled water bodies were
162
recorded during the sampling period. Thus the measured concentrations of these light PAHs
163
may be taken as the water concentrations over the whole sampling period.
164
The concentration data for individual PAHs, along with the sums of the 24 target PAHs
165
specifically targeted in the present study (∑24PAH), 15 priority PAHs (∑15PAH) designated
166
by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) except naphthalene and 7
167
carcinogenic PAHs (∑7PAH; the sum of BaA, BbF, BkF, BaP, IcdP, DahA and BghiP)
168
classified by the USEPA, are presented in Tables S5-S10. The ∑24PAH, ∑15PAH and
169
∑7PAH concentrations in lakes and reservoirs along Songhua River and Liaohe River located
170
in the Northeast China (Figure 1) were in the ranges of 1.7−11.3 ng L-1 (mean: 7.2 ng L-1),
171
1.2−5.9 ng L-1 (mean: 3.9 ng L-1) and not detected (ND)−67 pg L-1 (mean: 18.5 pg L-1),
172
respectively.
173
Compared to Songhua River and Liaohe River, the PAH concentrations in lakes and
174
reservoirs of the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region located in Northwest China (Figure 1)
175
were lower, i.e., the ∑24PAH, ∑15PAH and ∑7PAH concentrations were in the ranges of
176
1.3−16.4 ng L-1 (mean: 6 ng L-1), 0.7−6.7 ng L-1 (mean: 3 ng L-1) and ND−32 pg L-1 (mean:
177
11 pg L-1), respectively. The PAH concentrations in the Yangtze River flowing through
178
Central and East China (Figure 1) were the highest among all the regions, i.e., the ∑24PAH,
179
∑15PAH and ∑7PAH concentrations were 4−538 ng L-1 (mean: 56 ng L-1), 1.4−294 ng L-1
180
(mean: 29 ng L-1) and 7.4−503 pg L-1 (mean: 58 pg L-1), respectively. The greatest
181
concentration among all sampling sites occurred at Southern Lake, an urban lake within
182
Wuhan heavily polluted by urban wastewater derived from surrounding factories and
8 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Page 8 of 28
Page 9 of 28
Environmental Science & Technology
183
residents.27 Southern Lake was therefore identified as a point source and excluded from the
184
following discussions. The PAH concentrations in lakes of Tibet located in Southwest China
185
(Figure 1) were the lowest among all sampling regions, with the∑24PAH, ∑15PAH and
186
∑7PAH concentrations in the ranges of 0.28−0.8 ng L-1 (mean: 0.54 ng L-1), 0.01−0.05 ng L-1
187
(mean: 0.03 ng L-1) and ND−0.52 pg L-1 (mean: 0.3 pg L-1), respectively.
188
Anthropogenic Impacts on Levels of Freely Dissolved PAHs. Freshwater PAH
189
levels (average ∑24PAH) gradually increased from west to east, i.e., 5.4±4.3, 11±11 and
190
12±13 ng L-1, in Western (Tibet and Xinjiang), Central (the upper and middle reaches of the
191
Yangtze River) and Eastern (the lower reaches of the Yangtze River, Liaohe River and
192
Songhua River) China (Figure 1). This spatial pattern was correlated well with the
193
distribution of regional population densities (Table S11), with the determination coefficients
194
(r2) between the concentrations of ∑24PAH, ∑15PAH and ∑7PAH and the population densities
195
at 0.95 (p < 0.0001), 0.87 (p < 0.0005) and 0.36 (p = 0.07) (Figure 3). Similarly, the
196
concentrations of ∑24PAH and ∑15PAH also correlated well with the ratio of gross domestic
197
product/land area (billion km-2; Table S11), with the determination coefficients (r2) at 0.97 (p
198
< 0.0001) and 0.97 (p < 0.0001), respectively (Figure S1). The correlation between ∑7PAH
199
concentrations and the ratio of gross domestic product/land area was not significant (r2 = 0.25
200
and p = 0.25; Figure S1). The use of more target compounds appeared to yield better
201
correlation, which implies that (1) dissolved PAHs in the freshwater bodies may have derived
202
from multiple sources related to complicated anthropogenic activities and (2) there is an
203
urgent need to identify suitable parameters for better describing anthropogenic activities.
204
McDonough et al.14 also obtained a significant correlation between the concentrations of
205
gaseous PAHs and population densities in the lower Great Lakes. In addition, the correlation
206
between the concentrations of dissolved PAHs in surface water and PAHs in the surrounding
9 Environment ACS Paragon Plus
Environmental Science & Technology
207
soil was poor (r2 < 0.1; Figure S3), suggesting no significant contribution from nearby soil to
208
the occurrence of PAHs in freshwaters.
209
Besides population density, industrialization may also be an important factor. The
210
population densities of Songhua River Basin and Liaohe River Basin are quite similar to each
211
other (263 and 292 persons km-2, respectively),28, 29 but the ∑7PAH concentrations in
212
Songhua River Basin were one to two orders of magnitude higher than those in Liaohe River
213
Basin, with high levels around the city of Jilin (Figure 1). Government data30 showed that the
214
amounts of industrial wastewater discharged to Songhua River Basin were much greater than
215
those discharged to Liaohe River Basin over the years of 2004−2006 and 2011−2012 (Figure
216
2). A great number of factories are situated along the banks of Songhua River, including
217
steel, petrochemical, pulp and paper and machinery mills.30 These manufacturing plants
218
discharge large amounts of insufficiently treated wastewater to Songhua River. Accidental
219
spills have also been identified as input sources of organic chemicals, heavy metals, nitrogen-
220
containing substances and other pollutants.31-33
221
Worldwide Comparison of Freely-Dissolved PAH Levels. The concentrations of
222
freely dissolved PAHs in the present study were in the middle range of those reported
223
worldwide (Table 1). After excluding samples collected from the middle and lower Yangtze
224
River, however, the concentrations of ∑15PAH (0.4‒10 ng L-1) in the present study were
225
much lower than those reported previously in freshwaters. For example, concentrations of
226
∑15PAH were 8.6‒48 ng L-1 in the Meuse-Marne Canal downstream of Paris, France,34
227
9.5‒66 ng L-1 in rivers close to Johannesburg of South Africa24 and 2.8‒29 ng L-1 in the
228
Danube river between Vienna and Bratislava.35 Our previous study also obtained low
229
concentrations of ∑15PAH (