Subscriber access provided by University of Sussex Library
Characterization of Natural and Affected Environments
Stereoisomer-specific Trophodynamics of the Chiral Brominated Flame Retardants HBCD and TBECH in a Marine Food Web, with Implications for Human Exposure Yuefei Ruan, Xiaohua Zhang, Jian-Wen Qiu, Kenneth M.Y. Leung, James C.W. Lam, and Paul K.S. Lam Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.8b02206 • Publication Date (Web): 25 Jun 2018 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on June 26, 2018
Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.
Page 1 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
1
Stereoisomer-specific Trophodynamics of the Chiral Brominated
2
Flame Retardants HBCD and TBECH in a Marine Food Web, with
3
Implications for Human Exposure
4
Yuefei Ruan†, Xiaohua Zhang‡, Jian-Wen Qiu§, Kenneth M.Y. Leung , James
5
C.W. Lam†,‡,*, Paul K.S. Lam†, ,*
6
‖
⊥
†
State Key Laboratory in Marine Pollution (SKLMP), Research Centre for the Oceans
7
and Human Health, Shenzhen Key Laboratory for the Sustainable Use of Marine
8
Biodiversity, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
9
‡
Department of Science and Environmental Studies, The Education University of Hong of Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
10 11
§
12
‖ The Swire Institute of Marine Science and School of Biological Sciences, The
Department of Biology, Hong Kong Baptist University, Hong Kong SAR, China
University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
13 14
⊥
Department of Chemistry, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
James C. W. Lam*
Paul K. S. Lam*
Department of Science and
State Key Laboratory in Marine
Environmental Studies, The Education
Pollution, Department of Chemistry,
University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
City University of Hong Kong, Hong
SAR, China
Kong SAR, China
Tel: +852-2948-8537
Tel: +852-3442-6828
Fax: +852-2948-7676
Fax: +852-3442-0303
E-mail:
[email protected] E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] 15
1
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
16
ABSTRACT
17
Stereoisomers of 1,2,5,6,9,10-hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD) and 1,2-dibromo-4-
18
(1,2-dibromoethyl)-cyclohexane (TBECH) were determined in sediments and 30
19
marine species in a marine food web to investigate their trophic transfer. Lipid content
20
was found to affect the bioaccumulation of ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH in these species.
21
Elevated biomagnification of each diastereomer from prey species to marine mammals
22
was observed. For HBCD, biota samples showed a shift from γ- to α-HBCD when
23
compared with sediments and technical mixtures; trophic magnification potential of
24
(‒)-α- and (+)-α-HBCD were observed in the food web, with trophic magnification
25
factors (TMFs) of 11.8 and 8.7, respectively. For TBECH, the relative abundance of γ-
26
and δ-TBECH exhibited an increasing trend from abiotic matrices to biota samples;
27
trophic magnification was observed for each diastereomer, with TMFs ranging from 1.9
28
to 3.5; the enantioselective bioaccumulation of the first eluting enantiomer of δ-TBECH
29
in organisms at higher TLs was consistently observed across samples. This is the first
30
report on the trophic transfer of TBECH in the food web. The estimated daily intake of
31
HBCD for Hong Kong residents was approximately 16-times higher than that for the
32
general population in China, and the health risk to local children was high based on the
33
relevant available reference dose.
34
KEYWORDS
35
HBCD; TBECH; Enantiomer; Food web; Trophic Transfer; Biomagnification
36
2
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 2 of 36
Page 3 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
37
INTRODUCTION
38
Concerns over brominated flame retardants (BFRs) have been growing since the
39
1990s, as many exhibit environmental persistence, bioaccumulation, and toxicity, in
40
wildlife and humans.1,2 Numerous studies have reported that two kinds of extensively
41
used
42
hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD), are globally distributed in the environment and
43
have been found in different environmental matrices, including biota, indicating the
44
liver and thyroid hormone homeostasis as the main targets for toxicity.3–5 For most other
45
BFRs, such as 1,2-dibromo-4-(1,2-dibromoethyl)-cyclohexane (TBECH), however,
46
only limited data are available on their production and use, exposure status, and
47
toxicological information.6–8 Considering that all formulations of commercial PBDE
48
mixtures and HBCD technical products were recently included under the Stockholm
49
Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) in Annex A for global elimination,
50
research is shifting toward the use of the other BFRs as alternatives, as these alternatives
51
have not been ascertained to be safer for environmental and public health.9,10
BFRs,
polybrominated
diphenyl
ethers
(PBDEs)
and
1,2,5,6,9,10-
52
Several kinds of BFRs, including HBCD and TBECH, can exhibit optical activities
53
as chiral compounds. For instance, HBCD theoretically includes 6 diastereomeric pairs
54
of enantiomers and 4 meso forms, and commercial mixtures mainly consist of α-
55
(~12%), β- (~9%), and γ-diastereomers (~79%);11–13 TBECH exhibits stereochemical
56
diversity as 4 diastereomeric pairs of enantiomers, and the technical formulation
57
contains equimolar amounts of α- and β-diastereomers.14 Many studies have revealed
58
that HBCD exhibits high diastereo- and enantio-selectivity in organisms.3,15,16 A
59
diastereomeric shift from γ- to α-HBCD was frequently observed in biota at higher
60
trophic levels (TLs), whereas the preferential bioaccumulation of (−)-α-HBCD was
61
revealed more often in certain animal species, independent of biological factors, such 3
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
62
as body composition, age/sex variation, nutritive condition, and tissue distribution.15–17
63
Although TBECH is increasingly detected in the environment and biota globally,
64
TBECH concentrations are primarily quantified as the sum of all stereoisomers
65
(ΣTBECH), due to difficulties in the chromatographic separation of every
66
diastereomer.18–20 No study has investigated TBECH enantiomeric patterns in any
67
environmental matrix, except our recent work on cetacean blubber.21 The trophic
68
transfer of POPs and POP-like pollutants in food webs is a vital component for
69
assessing their ecological and health risks. Biomagnification of HBCD has been
70
observed through correlation between the TL and the concentration in organisms.22–30
71
However, most studies do not fully consider the precise predator-prey feeding
72
relationships, and even fewer focus on the trophodynamics of different HBCD
73
enantiomers.31,32 Up to now, the biomagnification potential of TBECH is still
74
uncharacterized.
75
Our recent study reported on the occurrence of HBCD enantiomers and meso isomers
76
as well as TBECH enantiomers in two resident species of marine mammals ― finless
77
porpoises (Neophocaena phocaenoides) and Indo-Pacific humpback dolphins (Sousa
78
chinensis) ― in the South China Sea.21 Elevated accumulation of these chiral BFRs
79
with the preferential enrichment of specific stereoisomers was observed in these marine
80
top predators. To build on this earlier work, the present study aims to (1) determine the
81
occurrence and trophodynamics of specific HBCD and TBECH stereoisomers in the
82
marine food web with the marine mammals as apex predators and (2) assess the food
83
web magnification potentials of these stereoisomers and the potential role of diet on
84
their levels in the marine mammals. Particular emphasis is placed on understanding the
85
behavior and fate of chiral BFRs in marine ecosystems.
86
MATERIALS AND METHODS 4
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 4 of 36
Page 5 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
87
Sample Collection. A total of 34 surface sediments were collected from Hong
88
Kong waters in June, 2012, from sampling sites corresponding to the Environmental
89
Protection Department’s regular sediment monitoring stations.33 Marine organisms,
90
including 5 mollusk species, 6 crustacean species, and 19 fish species, were collected
91
via bottom trawling in Hong Kong waters from July to November, 2012 (Table 1).
92
These marine species, together with the two previously studied cetacean species from
93
this region, constitute a marine food web pertaining to low-trophic-level marine lives
94
to the marine top predators.34 The sampling area covered the western, southern, and
95
eastern Hong Kong waters. Further details for the samples and sampling sites are
96
presented in Table S1 and Figure S1 in the Supporting Information (SI).
97
Sample Preparation and Instrumental Analysis. Details of the standards,
98
reagents and solvents can be found in the SI. Sample extraction was accomplished using
99
previously established methods with modest modifications, as described in the SI.
100
HBCD stereoisomers were analyzed by liquid chromatography‒tandem mass
101
spectrometry using an Eclipse Plus C18 column (4.6 mm i.d. × 100 mm, 3.5 μm)
102
coupled to a NUCLEODEX β-PM column (4 mm i.d. × 200 mm, 5 μm) for separation,
103
and TBECH enantiomers were determined using gas chromatography–mass
104
spectrometry using a CHIRALDEX B-TA capillary column (30 m × 0.25 mm i.d., 0.12
105
µm film thickness) for separation. More information on the instrumental analysis is
106
provided in the SI.
107
Quality Assurance and Quality Control (QA/QC). The limit of detection
108
(LOD) was defined as an instrument signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of ≥ 3:1. Detailed
109
QA/QC measures for calibration curves, procedure blanks, and matrix recovery tests
110
are given in the SI. The LODs of the samples ranged from 0.05 to 0.2 ng/g dry weight
111
(dw) in sediments and 0.3 to 0.8 ng/g lipid weight (lw) in biota for HBCD stereoisomers, 5
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
112
and from 0.1 to 0.5 ng/g dw in sediments and 0.8 to 1.8 ng/g lw in biota for TBECH
113
stereoisomers. Matrix recoveries ranged from 83% to 110% for sediments and 72% to
114
106% for bio-samples. Surrogate recoveries ranged from 78% to 95%, and the
115
concentration data were corrected by the surrogates.
116
Stable Isotope Analysis and TL Determination. Information on the stable
117
isotope analysis is given in the SI. TLs of individual organisms were determined based
118
on the assumption that zooplankton occupies TL 2.0 using the following equation:
119
TL consumer = 2.0 + (δ15N consumer – δ15N primary consumer) / 3.8
120
where δ15N primary consumer is the stable nitrogen isotope value of zooplankton (9.7) and
121
3.8 is the isotopic trophic enrichment factor.35,36
122
Biota–Sediment Accumulation Factor (BSAF), Bioaccumulation Factor
123
(BMF), and Trophic Magnification Factor (TMF) Calculations. The BSAF
124
calculation was based on the assumption that sediment is the dominant exposure
125
pathway for benthic organisms using the following equation:
126
BSAF = C biota (ng/g, lw) / C sediment [ng/g, total organic carbon (TOC)]
127
where C biota is the average lipid-normalized concentration in benthos and C sediment is the
128
TOC-normalized concentration in sediments.37 BMF was defined as the ratio of the
129
average lipid-normalized concentration between predator and prey.37 TMF was used to
130
describe the biomagnification, and the calculation was based on the correlations
131
between average lipid-normalized concentrations and TLs using the following equation:
132
ln C biota (ng/g, lw) = a + b × TL
133
where a and b represent the constant and the slope of the linear regression, respectively.
134
Slope b was used to calculate TMF using the equation TMF = e b.38
135
Estimated Daily Intake (EDI) Assessment. The consumption rates (CRs) of
136
marine crustaceans, mollusks, and fishes in the Hong Kong population were obtained 6
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 6 of 36
Page 7 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
137
from a dietary survey of the general population conducted in Hong Kong in 2005-2007
138
and were 27.51 g wet weight (ww)/day, 23.17 g ww/day, and 65.98 g ww/day,
139
respectively.39 The average body weight (BW) was 66.2 kg for adults and 21.1 kg for
140
children in China.29 All the marine organisms investigated in this study are popular
141
seafood items in Hong Kong. To evaluate human exposure to HBCD and TBECH via
142
seafood consumption, the EDI for local residents was calculated using the following
143
equation:
144
EDI = CR × C biota (ng/g, ww) / BW
145
Statistical Analysis. Statistical analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel
146
2016 to generate descriptive statistics, and all other statistical procedures were
147
conducted using IBM SPSS Statistics 20.0 and OriginLab OriginPro 2015. Different
148
data treatments for values below the LOD, i.e., excluding values below the LOD, using
149
1/2 the LOD instead, or setting those values to zero, was confirmed to have no effect
150
on the conclusion and interpretation of the results. Thus, values below the LOD were
151
replaced with 1/2 LOD, as was done in our previous studies.21,40 Enantiomer fractions
152
(EFs) were used to describe enantiomeric patterns. Methods used for statistical analysis
153
and detail information on the EF calculation are provided in the SI.
154
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
155
Levels of ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH in Sediments and Biota. ΣHBCD and
156
ΣTBECH were detected in most of the sediment samples. ΣHBCD was detected in all
157
the sampled biota species, while ΣTBECH was detected in 26 of the 30 investigated
158
species. These results indicate the widespread occurrence of HBCD and TBECH in the
159
marine environment of Hong Kong. No significant spatial differences (p > 0.05) were
160
found in the concentrations of ΣHBCD or ΣTBECH in biota species with similar TLs
7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
161
among different sampling areas (SI Table S1). Thus, concentrations from the same
162
marine species were pooled for data analysis. ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH concentrations in
163
sediments (dw) from different sampling areas and in each marine species (dw and lw)
164
are summarized in Table 1 and illustrated in SI Figure S2.
165
In Hong Kong waters, surface sediment concentrations were between < 0.1 (below
166
the LOD) and 239 ng/g dw for ΣHBCD, and were between < 0.5 and 5.10 ng/g dw for
167
ΣTBECH. ΣHBCD levels were approximately 1 order of magnitude higher than those
168
of ΣTBECH. Considering the median concentrations, surface sediments from central
169
waters accumulated more ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH than the other areas. The correlation
170
between TOC content and sediment concentration was not significant for both ΣHBCD
171
and ΣTBECH (p > 0.05), implying the minor role of TOC in shaping the sediment
172
partitioning of HBCD and TBECH. These findings suggest a domination of local
173
sources of HBCD and TBECH from human activities accounting for their occurrence
174
in sediments from the study region. A strong positive correlation was found between
175
the ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH concentrations in sediments (p < 0.0001), indicating their
176
probably similar emission source and/or pathway. Following the method of Liu et al.
177
(2014),41 for the Hong Kong’s 12 coastal council districts relevant to our sampling sites,
178
a significant positive correlation was found in this study between the population density
179
and the average BFR (ΣHBCD + ΣTBECH) concentration (p < 0.05). Since the 1980s,
180
the dominant industry in Hong Kong has shifted from manufacturing to services.
181
Therefore, BFRs in sediments from Hong Kong waters may have arisen from
182
urbanization (e.g., using BFR-containing products). Overall, ΣHBCD concentrations in
183
sediments from Hong Kong waters in this study were relatively high compared with a
184
previous study on their occurrence in sediments from the Pearl River Delta (PRD)
185
region collected in 2013, whereas ΣTBECH concentrations in our study were slightly 8
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 8 of 36
Page 9 of 36
186
Environmental Science & Technology
lower compared with that study.42
187
In biota, the lipid content varied largely between the sampled marine species, and the
188
values ranged from 4.9% to 29%. The concentrations of ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH in these
189
biota on dry weight basis were significantly positively correlated with the lipid contents
190
(Pearson’s r = 0.695 and 0.498, respectively, p < 0.01) (SI Figure S3), indicating that
191
lipid content plays a vital role in the bioaccumulation of HBCD and TBECH.
192
Accordingly, the concentrations below are expressed in ng/g lw. No significant
193
difference in ΣHBCD concentrations was found among fishes, crustaceans, and
194
mollusks (p > 0.05), while ΣTBECH levels were significantly higher in mollusks than
195
the other groups (p < 0.05). Tao et al. reported higher levels of ΣTBECH than ΣHBCD
196
found in wild fish species including mackerel and tuna.10 In the present study, ΣHBCD
197
concentrations in all three biota groups were all significantly higher than those of
198
ΣTBECH (p < 0.05, SI Figure S2), in conformity with a previous finding of the lower
199
bioaccumulation potential of TBECH than HBCD in zebrafish (Danio rerio) after
200
dietary exposure.43 This may also reflect the higher production/use of HBCD than
201
TBECH in the PRD in recent years.
202
Data for HBCD levels in marine organisms have been documented for a number of
203
areas and species. In marine fishes and invertebrates, the reported HBCD levels ranged
204
from low ng/g lw up to 5,200 ng/g lw, with high levels typically found in recent years
205
in Asian countries, especially China.3,29,30,44 The ΣHBCD concentrations in bio-samples
206
in our study (3.01–93.2 ng/g lw) were approximately 1 order of magnitude higher than
207
those in marine fish samples collected along the Chinese coastline in 2008 (0.57–10.1
208
ng/g lw),45 but were 1–2 orders of magnitude lower than those reported in marine
209
species collected from several estuaries in Bohai Sea, East China.29,30,46 Overall, the
210
ΣHBCD levels in marine organisms in our study are among the moderate levels reported 9
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
211
worldwide. Very limited information is available for TBECH in wild aquatic species.
212
The ΣTBECH concentrations in bio-samples in our study (n.d.–13.9 ng/g lw) were
213
slightly higher than those reported in Nordic mussels and fishes (up to 1.6 ng/g ww)
214
and in Canadian Arctic beluga blubber (0.9–11.3 ng/g lw).47,48 The current results
215
suggest that marine organisms in the marine environment of Hong Kong are susceptible
216
to considerable TBECH exposure.
217
BSAFs and BMFs in Marine Organisms. In this study, BSAFs were determined
218
for the estimation of contaminant uptake by biota from sediment, and BMFs between
219
prey species and marine mammals were calculated to further investigate the
220
accumulation of contaminants from diet to top predators. The dataset of the marine
221
mammals was published previously.21 The assessed BSAFs for crustaceans and
222
mollusks are given in SI Table S2, while the identified prey list and calculated BMFs
223
for the two cetacean species are given in SI Table S3.
224
The BSAFs of ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH ranged from 0.02 to 0.28 and from 0.02 to
225
0.08, respectively, i.e., none of these crustacean and mollusk species exhibited a BSAF
226
greater than 1. The BSAF ranges of ΣHBCD for invertebrates in our study overlap with
227
those reported in marine bivalves from South Korea (0.01–0.15),49 but are much lower
228
than those determined from a laboratory study on bivalves assembled from brackish
229
coastal bays (log BSAF > 1.25).50 This discrepancy is likely ascribed to the large
230
variations between field and laboratory exposure. At the present time, there are no
231
available BSAFs of TBECH for comparison.
232
Considering the BSAFs of HBCD diastereomers (α, β, and γ), α-HBCD contributed
233
the most to the bioaccumulation of ΣHBCD in each invertebrate species, whereas γ-
234
HBCD always accounted for the least. This provides a pathway for α-HBCD to be the
235
most readily transferred HBCD diastereomer in the marine food web as shown in this 10
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 10 of 36
Page 11 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
236
study. For TBECH, no significant differences in BSAFs were found among the four
237
diastereomers. However, this does not necessarily indicate an identical bioaccumulation
238
potential for different TBECH diastereomers in these organisms, as BSAF represents
239
an integrated consequence of various processes, including bioavailability, uptake and
240
depuration, as well as bioisomerization.15
241
The feeding habits of finless porpoises (N. phocaenoides) and Indo-Pacific
242
humpback dolphins (S. chinensis) in Hong Kong waters were identified in two previous
243
studies via the examination of stomach contents collected from stranded cetaceans.51,52
244
These marine mammals are the top predators in this investigated food web, and there is
245
some dietary overlap between the two cetacean species, sharing some important prey
246
items (e.g., anchovies and croakers). Notwithstanding, porpoises and dolphins have
247
dissimilar prey preferences, which can be reflected in their distribution around Hong
248
Kong: porpoises prefer cephalopods and usually appear in deeper and clearer saline
249
waters (mainly in the southern and eastern waters of Hong Kong), whereas dolphins
250
prefer demersal and shoaling fishes of the murky and brackish waters of estuaries, i.e.,
251
mostly in northwestern waters of Hong Kong close to the Pearl River Estuary (PRE).53
252
Among the collected marine species in our study, 11 pairs of predator-prey relationships
253
were identified for each cetacean species (SI Table S3).
254
For the predator-prey pairs of porpoises, the BMFs of ΣHBCD and ΣTBECH were
255
all above 1 and ranged from 15.0 to 192 and from 2.23 to 19.8, respectively, suggesting
256
the biomagnification of HBCD and TBECH from the studied prey to porpoises. Much
257
higher BMFs were observed for the predator-prey pairs of dolphins (SI Table S3), with
258
values ranging from 325 to 4,160 for ΣHBCD and from 9.80 to 111 for ΣTBECH. This
259
signifies that dolphins have greater potential to accumulate HBCD and TBECH via
260
food chains as compared to porpoises. For the 8 common preys between porpoises and 11
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
261
dolphins, much higher BMFs were observed in ΣHBCD than in ΣTBECH. Therefore,
262
similar to the BSAF results, ΣHBCD exhibited higher biomagnification potential than
263
ΣTBECH in cetacean species. Future studies should examine the influence of other
264
biological factors, such as age/sex variations and nutritive conditions.
265
Considering BMFs for HBCD diastereomers (α, β, and γ), the BMFs of α-HBCD
266
were the largest, in accordance with this diastereomer predominating cetacean species,
267
as reported in our previous study.21 Although the BMFs of β-HBCD also suggest its
268
high biomagnification potential, it was detected in marine mammals at relatively low
269
levels, possibly because this diastereomer is present in relatively small quantities in
270
technical products and is susceptible to biotransformation.54,55 For TBECH, the BMFs
271
of α- and β-TBECH were significantly lower than those of γ- and δ-TBECH (p < 0.01).
272
The large BMFs of γ- and δ-TBECH are in agreement with the rapidly increasing
273
proportions of these diastereomers in cetacean species, as described in our previous
274
study.21 In comparison, although the BMFs of α- and β-TBECH suggest their relatively
275
“low” biomagnification potential, these diastereomers still prevailed in cetacean
276
samples, partially because α- and β-TBECH are generally the exclusive components in
277
commercial mixtures.
278
Trophic Transfer in the Marine Food Web. To assess the trophic transfer of
279
HBCD and TBECH in the investigated food web, regression analysis was conducted
280
between the lipid-normalized concentrations (ln-transformed) and the TLs, and TMF
281
was derived from the slope of the regression line. Only species with detectable
282
contaminants were selected for this analysis. Thus, 32 species and 28 species (each
283
including two cetacean species) were included in the TMF calculation for HBCD and
284
TBECH, respectively. The results of the regression analysis are shown in Table 2. Note
285
that TMF > 1 indicates that the contaminant is biomagnified. 12
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 12 of 36
Page 13 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
286
The increase in the ΣHBCD concentration with the TL was statistically significant,
287
with a TMF of 7.9 (p < 0.0001). In addition, the concentrations of (±)-α-, (+)-α-, and
288
(–)-α-HBCD were significantly positively correlated with the TL (p < 0.0001), with
289
TMFs of 10.3, 8.7 and 11.8, respectively, indicating the strong preferential
290
biomagnification of α-HBCD in this food web. There were no significant correlations
291
in the concentrations of (±)-β- and (±)-γ-HBCD with the TL. The trophodynamics of
292
HBCD enantiomers in this food web are consistent with the observation in the eastern
293
Canadian Arctic marine food web and in a freshwater food web from an electronic
294
waste recycling site in South China.31,32 Compared with the reported TMFs of α-HBCD
295
(mostly 2~3) in other studies,23,25,26,28–32 our TMFs were approximately 4-fold higher
296
and comparable to the most biomagnified organic contaminants [e.g., 2,2',3,3',4,4'-
297
hexachlorobiphenyl (PCB-128) and oxychlordane, with reported average TMFs of 8.72
298
and 10.31, respectively].56 Our results indicate that α-HBCD can be substantially
299
magnified in the present food web and transferred to top predators. Although β- and γ-
300
HBCD were not trophic-magnified, the BMFs observed in this study indicate their
301
biomagnification potential. It is important to note that this is the first investigation on
302
the trophodynamics of HBCD in a subtropical marine food web.
303
ΣTBECH was also found to be trophic-magnified in the investigated food web, with
304
a TMF of 2.2 (p < 0.05). Additionally, the concentrations of α-, β-, γ- and δ-TBECH
305
were significantly positively correlated with the TL (p < 0.05), with TMFs of 2.2, 1.9,
306
3.4 and 3.5, respectively, suggesting the possible preferential biomagnification of γ- and
307
δ-TBECH in this food web. However, the obtained TMF can be influenced by
308
interspecies ecological (e.g., variations in food intake) and organismal parameters such
309
as metabolism, reproductive status, migration, and age.57 This is the first study that
310
demonstrates the trophic transfer of TBECH in a food web. There are no available field 13
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
311
data on TMF of TBECH for further comparison. The observed TMF for ΣTBECH in
312
the present study was much lower than that of ΣHBCD, revealing the lower
313
bioaccumulation potential of TBECH in organisms at higher TL. However, the TMFs
314
of TBECH diastereomers were comparable to the abovementioned TMFs of α-HBCD
315
in other studies, which is likely due to the difference in food web configuration. It
316
should be noted that the range of TLs in our study (with apex predators included) was
317
broader than that in most of other studies, possibly resulting in a higher TMF obtained.
318
Reports on TMFs for non-PBDE and non-HBCD BFRs are scarce. Trophic
319
magnification was observed for hexabromobenzene (HBB) in a freshwater food web
320
from an electronic waste recycling site in South China, with a reported TMF of 1.76,
321
while trophic dilution (TMF < 1) through this food web was found for 1,2-bis(2,4,6-
322
tribromophenoxy)ethane (BTBPE) and pentabromotoluene (PBT).32,58 Trophic dilution
323
for BTBPE was also observed in the Lake Maggiore (Italy) food web.27 In the Lake
324
Winnipeg (Canada) food web, BTBPE concentrations were not significantly correlated
325
with the TL, while decabromodiphenyl ethane (DBDPE) was biomagnified with a
326
reported TMF of 8.6.23 The above findings indicate that several unregulated BFRs, such
327
as TBECH, HBB, and DBDPE, can have high trophic magnification potentials. The
328
magnification of TBECH diastereomers provides clear evidence of an expanding class
329
of bioaccumulative substances that urgently require assessment for their potential
330
ecological risks.
331
HBCD and TBECH Diastereomeric Profiles and Enantiomeric Patterns.
332
Figure 1 shows the diastereomeric compositions in the collected samples for all
333
examined HBCD and TBECH diastereomers. The samples were sorted into six groups:
334
technical products, sediments, mollusks, crustaceans, fishes, and cetaceans. For HBCD
335
[Figure 1 (A)], the γ-diastereomer was the predominant component in technical 14
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 14 of 36
Page 15 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
336
products, accounting for 85.3% of ΣHBCD. In sediments and crustaceans, γ-HBCD still
337
exhibited the principal abundance, but the contribution of α-HBCD in sediments
338
(19.2%) and crustaceans (32.8%) was much higher than that in technical products
339
(8.5%). In mollusks and fishes, a diastereomeric shift in the relative abundance from γ-
340
to α-HBCD was observed, where α- and γ-HBCD accounted for approximately 75%
341
and 20% of ΣHBCD, respectively. In cetaceans (apex predators), α-HBCD showed a
342
superlative preponderance (97.1%), while γ-HBCD existed only in a trace proportion
343
(1.1%), similar to the compositions of β-, δ-, and ε-HBCD. The stereoselective
344
biomagnification changed the diastereomeric compositions in these marine organisms.
345
A significant positive correlation was observed between the α-HBCD proportion and
346
the TL (Pearson’s r = 0.416, p < 0.05), while significant negative correlations were
347
found for the proportions of β- and γ-HBCD (Pearson’s r = –0.406 and –0.403,
348
respectively, p < 0.05). The δ-HBCD meso form has been found in samples of fish and
349
birds, previously reported by other studies.59–61 However, apart from our previous study
350
on marine mammals,21 to the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on the
351
presence of ε-HBCD in biota. Although δ- and ε-HBCD were widespread in our
352
collected samples, they existed at trace levels in general, and no significant correlations
353
were observed between the proportions of these two meso isomers and the TL (p > 0.05).
354
The percentage of α-HBCD to ΣHBCD increased with the TL in these marine organisms.
355
Among α-, β-, and γ-HBCD, the α-diastereomer had the highest uptake efficiency, the
356
lowest depuration rate, and the longest half-life, which could explain the prevalence of
357
α-HBCD in higher TL organisms.62–64 Other explanations may include the rapid
358
biotransformation of β- and γ- to α-HBCD and/or the preferential metabolism of β- and
359
γ- over α-HBCD.54,55,65
360
For TBECH [Figure 1 (B)], α- and β-TBECH were almost the exclusive components 15
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
361
in technical products, accounting for 57.3% and 42.5%, respectively, of ΣTBECH. In
362
sediments and marine organisms, except cetaceans, the composition of β-TBECH
363
remained almost unchanged (roughly 40~45%), while the proportion of α-TBECH
364
decreased by nearly 10%, and the contribution of γ- and δ-TBECH (approximately 5%
365
and 7%, respectively) was much higher than that in technical TBECH products (each
366
0.1%). In cetaceans, the composition of α-TBECH remained almost unaltered
367
compared with that in sediments and organisms at lower TLs, while a sharp decrease
368
by over 10% in the proportion of β-TBECH was observed, along with roughly doubled
369
proportions of γ- and δ-TBECH. These findings were at variance with those reported in
370
Canadian arctic beluga blubber,48 in herring gull egg pools,66 and in UK supermarket
371
fish,10 where the proportions of β-TBECH were higher than those of α-TBECH. The
372
changes observed in the diastereomeric compositions of TBECH in our marine
373
organisms might result from stereoselective biomagnification. A significant negative
374
correlation was found between the β-TBECH proportion and the TL (Pearson’s r = –
375
0.583, p < 0.01), while significant positive correlations were observed for γ- and δ-
376
TBECH (Pearson’s r = 0.571, p < 0.01 and Pearson’s r = 0.633, p < 0.001, respectively).
377
No significant correlation was found for α-TBECH (p > 0.05). Overall, the relative
378
abundance of γ- and δ-TBECH exhibited an increasing trend from technical products to
379
abiotic matrices and finally to biota samples, and the higher TMFs of γ- and δ-TBECH
380
may allow their facile transfer to top predators. A previous study suggested that β-
381
TBECH was metabolized much faster than technical TBECH mixtures by human liver
382
microsomes.67 This could partially explain the sharp decrease in the proportion of β-
383
TBECH rather than α-TBECH in the studied marine mammals.
384
A pair of enantiomers for a compound has identical physicochemical properties, and
385
the integrity of racemates is preserved (i.e., EF = 0.5) when the enantiomeric pair is 16
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 16 of 36
Page 17 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
386
subjected to achiral interactions, such as abiotic environmental processes.59 Deviation
387
from an EF of 0.5 indicates an enantiomeric enrichment from biologically-mediated
388
processes. SI Figure S4 shows the EFs in the collected samples, which were sorted into
389
the same six groups as those for the diastereomeric profiles.
390
Although the preferential enrichment of specific enantiomers of HBCD occurred in
391
some samples of technical products, sediments, mollusks, and crustaceans [SI Figure
392
S4 (A)], the average EFs for each HBCD diastereomer did not significantly deviate
393
from the EF ranges in standard solutions (p > 0.05) and were considered racemic
394
residues of HBCD enantiomers. Most of the samples of fishes and cetaceans had
395
significantly lower EFs than the range in standard solutions (p < 0.05), indicating that
396
the statistically selective enrichment of (–)-enantiomers relative to (+)-enantiomers
397
occurred for α-, β-, and γ-HBCD in these species.
398
A previous study suggested that cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYP450) played a
399
prominent role in the enrichment of (−)- over (+)-α-HBCD via in vitro metabolism
400
rather than stereoisomerization by human liver microsomes.65 If this also occurs in vivo
401
for other mammals and fishes which share certain similarities in xenobiotic-
402
metabolizing CYP450 with humans,68 the result could partially explain the preferential
403
bioaccumulation of (−)- over (+)-α-HBCD in the marine fishes and mammals examined.
404
The selective enrichment of (−)-α-HBCD could also arise from the higher
405
bioaccumulation potential of (−)- relative to (+)-α-HBCD, and the comparatively higher
406
TMF reported in this study further lends support to this idea. Additionally, a plot of the
407
EF of α-HBCD versus the TL (Figure 2) reveals a small but significant (p < 0.05)
408
decrease in the EF with the TL and suggests the enantioselective enrichment of (−)-α-
409
HBCD. Possible mechanisms for the preferential enrichment of (−)-β- and (−)-γ-HBCD
410
are still unknown, and more studies are needed. 17
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
411
Samples of technical products, sediments, mollusks, and crustaceans exhibited
412
racemic residues of TBECH enantiomers (p > 0.05) [SI Figure S4 (B)]. In most of the
413
fish samples, only the EFs of δ-TBECH were significantly different from (higher than)
414
the EF ranges in standard solutions (p < 0.05), indicating that the preferential
415
enrichment of the first eluting enantiomer of δ-TBECH (E1-δ-TBECH) relative to the
416
second eluting enantiomer (E2-δ-TBECH) occurred in our fish species. In cetaceans,
417
the EFs of α- and δ-TBECH were significantly higher than the EF ranges in standard
418
solutions, while the EFs of γ-TBECH were significantly lower (p < 0.05), indicating the
419
preferential enrichment of E1-α-TBECH, E2-γ-TBECH, and E1-δ-TBECH in these
420
species, whereas no significant deviations were observed for β-TBECH (p > 0.05). Two
421
trends consistent across samples are the enantioselective bioaccumulation of E1-δ-
422
TBECH in organisms at higher TLs and the virtually unchanged β-TBECH
423
enantiomeric composition. The enantioselectivity of TBECH could be potentially
424
attributed to the differences in uptake, metabolism, and excretion in biota, which
425
necessitates further investigation. For the first time, the enantioselectivity of TBECH
426
in a food web was reported.
427
Human Exposure to HBCD and TBECH Diastereomers via Seafood
428
Consumption. Dietary intake is one of the main routes for human exposure to
429
chemical pollutants, including several BFRs.4 In Hong Kong, seafood is one of the main
430
food sources for local residents. Accordingly, a preliminary estimation of the dietary
431
exposure of the Hong Kong population to HBCD and TBECH diastereomers through
432
seafood consumption was conducted based on the dataset of mollusks, crustaceans, and
433
fishes acquired from the present study. It should be noted that the EDI for children
434
might be overestimated because the consumption rate is the average for the local
435
population, and the local population may intake HBCD and TBECH through 18
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Page 18 of 36
Page 19 of 36
Environmental Science & Technology
436
consumption of other foods or other pathways such as inhalation, dust ingestion, and
437
dermal absorption (occupational exposure is not expected to be significant in Hong
438
Kong).69
439
As shown in Table 3, the total EDIs of ΣHBCD via seafood consumption for children
440
and adults were 4.07 and 1.30 ng/kg/day, respectively. This estimated exposure for local
441
adults in our study was approximately 16-times higher than the value for the general
442
Chinese population via aquatic animal-origin food consumption (0.08 ng/kg/day),70 but
443
was slightly lower than that for the Scottish population via shellfish consumption (5.9–
444
7.9 ng/kg/day),71 while was comparable to that for the Japanese population via fish
445
consumption (1.3–3.7 ng/kg/day),72 and was much higher than that for the Dutch
446
population via seafood consumption (0.06–0.17 ng/kg/day).73
447
The human health risk from dietary exposure of HBCD can be assessed using the
448
hazard quotient (HQ) approach, which is derived by comparing the EDI with a
449
reference dose (RfD) (HQ = EDI/RfD).40 A HQ below 1 indicates little or no health
450
concern. Based on a no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) of 450 mg/kg/day in
451
terms of increased liver weights and abnormal fatty accumulation in rats with an
452
uncertainty factor of 3000, the US National Research Council suggested an oral RfD
453
for ΣHBCD of 150,000 ng/kg/day.74 Following this method, a NOAEL of 35
454
μg/kg/week in terms of impaired lipid and glucose homeostasis in mice fed a high-fat
455
diet was used to derive the more sensitive RfD (1.67 ng/kg/day) used in this study.75
456
Consequently, the HQs for the local children and adults in this study were 2.44 and 0.78,
457
respectively, indicating the higher risk of ΣHBCD exposure to children through seafood
458
consumption. However, this preliminary assessment has certain limitations, and the
459
RfD could be refined when more toxicity data become available. The major
460
diastereomeric fraction of human intake from the present food web was α-HBCD 19
ACS Paragon Plus Environment
Environmental Science & Technology
461
through the consumption of crustaceans and fishes, while mollusk consumption mainly
462
contributed to the intake of γ-HBCD. However, most toxicity data were established
463
from technical mixtures, which contain much more γ-HBCD, and very few studies have
464
reported the differentiation in toxicity between individual HBCD stereoisomers.16
465
Given that α-HBCD seemed to cause the least cytotoxicity in liver cells across
466
studies,76,77 the actual human health risk posed by ΣHBCD may be overestimated.
467
The total EDIs of ΣTBECH for children and adults via seafood consumption were
468
0.78 and 0.25 ng/kg/day, respectively, where the major diastereomeric fraction of
469
human intake was α- and β-TBECH (nearly 90%). Our results of α- and β-TBECH via
470
fish consumption for the Hong Kong residents (4.78 and 4.12 ng/day, respectively,
471
where BW was excluded for comparison) were higher than those reported for the
472
Swedish mothers (3.5 and 0.60 ng/day, respectively).78 Based on a NOAEL of 20.35
473
mg/kg/day in terms of mild renal lesions and inflammation in rats with an uncertainty
474
factor of 3,000,74,79 an oral RfD for ΣTBECH of 6,800 ng/kg/day was proposed in this
475
study. The calculated HQ of ΣTBECH was