Stimulation and Inhibition of Anaerobic Digestion by Nickel and Cobalt

Subscriber access provided by UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY

Article

Stimulation and inhibition of anaerobic digestion by nickel and cobalt: a rapid assessment using the resazurin reduction assay Jian Lin Chen, Terry W.J. Steele, and David C Stuckey Environ. Sci. Technol., Just Accepted Manuscript • DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b03522 • Publication Date (Web): 22 Sep 2016 Downloaded from http://pubs.acs.org on September 23, 2016

Just Accepted “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical Society provides “Just Accepted” as a free service to the research community to expedite the dissemination of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are accessible to all readers and citable by the Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore, the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.

Environmental Science & Technology is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W., Washington, DC 20036 Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society. However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course of their duties.

Page 1 of 31

Environmental Science & Technology

1

Manuscript prepared for publication in ES&T

2 3

Stimulation and inhibition of anaerobic digestion by

4

nickel and cobalt: a rapid assessment using the resazurin

5

reduction assay

6 7

† Jian Lin Chen

8

Terry W.J. Steele*,

9

David C. Stuckey*,

‡

†, §

10 11

† Nanyang Environment & Water Research Institute, Advanced Environmental Biotechnology

12

Centre, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 637141

13

‡ School of Materials Science & Engineering, College of Engineering, Nanyang

14

Technological University, Singapore 637141

15 16

§

Department of Chemical Engineering, Imperial College London, London SW7 2AZ, UK

KEYWORDS: resazurin; trace metals; stimulation; toxicity; anaerobic digestion

ACS Paragon Plus Environment

1


Page 2 of 31

17

ABSTRACT

18

Stimulation of anaerobic digestion by essential trace metals is beneficial from a practical

19

point of view to enhance the biodegradability and degradation rate of wastes. Hence, a quick

20

method to determine which metal species, and at what concentration, can optimize anaerobic

21

digestion is of great interest to both researchers and operators. In this present study, we

22

investigated the effect of nickel (II), cobalt (II), and their mixture, on the anaerobic digestion

23

of synthetic municipal wastewater. Using a volumetric method, i.e. measuring methane

24

production over time, revealed that anaerobic digestion was stimulated by the addition of 5

25

mg L-1 nickel (II), and cobalt (II), and their mixture in day(s). However, using a novel

26

resazurin reduction assay, and based on its change in rate over time, we evaluated both

27

inhibition at 250 mg L-1 nickel (II) and cobalt (II), and also the stimulatory effect of 5 mg L-1

28

nickel (II), and cobalt (II), and their mixture, in just 6 hours. By investigating the dynamic

29

distribution of these metals in the liquid phase of the anaerobic system and kinetics of

30

resazurin reduction by nickel spiked anaerobic sludge, the concentration of nickel (II) on

31

anaerobic digestion performance was profiled. Three critical concentrations were determined;

32

stimulation starting (around 1 mg L-1), stimulation ending (around 100 mg L-1) and

33

stimulation maximizing (around 10 mg L-1). Hence, we propose that the resazurin reduction

34

assay is a novel and quick protocol for studying the stimulation of anaerobic bioprocesses by

35

bioavailable essential trace metals.


2

Page 3 of 31


36

37

TOC/Abstract art


3


Page 4 of 31

38

INTRODUCTION

39

Heavy metals are common in municipal and industrial effluents, at times causing negative

40

effects (toxicity) in biological treatment plants.1,2 However, trace amounts of selected

41

metals/elements have been reported to affect the biodegradation and degradation rate of

42

wastes beneficially,3,4 while supplementation of small amounts of trace metals has been

43

implemented to increase their bioavailability, leading to enhanced biodegradation rates of

44

both solid 5 and liquid wastes 6 over time in anaerobic digestion. Some trace metals (such as

45

Fe, Co, Ni, Mn) are considered as “essential” elements for microbial growth in anaerobic

46

digesters, functioning as protein stabilizers and osmotic balance controllers across various

47

microbial membranes, and as catalysts for biochemical reactions, etc.7 A number of studies

48

have suggested that the effect of “essential” trace metals on microorganisms can be divided

49

into three zones depending on their concentration; increasing stimulation, decreasing

50

stimulation, and toxicity.7 However, it was difficult to say exactly what concentration of the

51

essential trace metal could cause stimulation or inhibition, and which metals were toxic at

52

what concentration, because so many of the results were obtained using different methods,

53

and reported in very different ways.8 Hence, the range reported is wide in terms of threshold

54

concentrations that result in inhibition or stimulation by the various essential trace metals.7,9

55

In addition, the bioavailability of these “essential” trace metals in bioreactors depends on the

56

solution chemistry (e.g., pH, anions, cations, presence of complexing agents) which typically

57

have a strong influence on interactions between metals in the solid and liquid phases, the

58

transport of free metal ions, facilitated diffusion with the assistance of chelating complexes,

59

and metal speciation; while proton-mediated transport through the cell membrane are

60

assumed to be the main mechanism for metal uptake by microorganisms.7,10 Oleszkiewicz and

61

Sharma suggested that even full bioavailability would not necessarily mean that the required

62

metals are utilized by the bacterial population7; only when the metal ion enters the cell can it


4

Page 5 of 31


63

really be available for metabolism. However, the large number of chemical (complexation,

64

precipitation, adsorption) and biological interactions makes the system complex and difficult

65

to understand and control. In practice, it is important to understand metal bioavailability to

66

design optimal dosing strategies for anaerobic digesters, and in cases of metal limitations, the

67

exact dose and type of essential trace metals is critical to ensure suitable bioavailability,

68

leading to optimal bioreactor performance. Therefore, successful stimulation of anaerobic

69

digestion by specific essential trace metals, and determining their critical concentrations

70

beyond which stimulation becomes inhibition, is important. Given the multivariate

71

complexity of these systems, a biological assay which is quick, simple, cheap and accurate

72

would enable the field to progress more rapidly.

73

Both nickel and cobalt belong to the so-called “essential” trace metals.11 Confirmation of the

74

interrelationship between nickel and cobalt is confirmed by the fact that the microbial

75

resistance genotypes for both metals are usually present in the same plasmid of many

76

microorganisms.12,13 Also, similar biochemical transport mechanisms through microbial

77

membranes have been identified for both species.14 Identified as a key component in a

78

number of enzymes, nickel participates in important metabolic reactions, such as; hydrogen

79

metabolism, methane biogenesis, and acetogenesis.15 Cobalt is another important cofactor in

80

Vitamin B12-dependent enzymes,16 and an indispensable component in a number of

81

enzymes.17 It has been established that at relatively low concentrations (~10 mg L-1), both

82

species can stimulate both aerobic and anaerobic microbial growth, while they have toxic

83

effects at higher concentrations (>100 mg L-1).14,18 Therefore, determining these critical

84

concentrations of nickel and cobalt for stimulating/inhibiting anaerobic or aerobic

85

bioprocesses is critical when optimising these processes. A number of methods have been

86

proposed for measuring metal toxicity in activated sludge systems,19 such as the inhibition of;

87

enzymatic activity, bacterial respiration and kinetics, and the dynamics of microbial


5


Page 6 of 31

88

community evolution, and for the stimulation of anaerobic digestion by trace metals, such as

89

maximum specific methanogenic activity 6 and biochemical methane potential 4. Generally,

90

most of these methods are often too slow (days) for the optimal detection of sudden changes

91

in anaerobic digestion activity due to metals, and cumbersome in terms of the number of

92

variables that can be assessed.19

93

Resazurin, which is typically formulated into in-vitro toxicology assay kits (i.e.

94

AlamarBlue®), can be used as an oxidation-reduction indicator which results in colorimetric

95

changes, and a fluorescent signal in response to intercellular metabolic activity 20 based on the

96

reduction of resazurin to resorufin, and finally to dihydroresorufin (Scheme 1). Our previous

97

studies on assessing toxicity in anaerobic digestion has demonstrated the sensitivity and

98

efficiency of the resazurin reduction assay for detecting organic toxicants such as

99

chlorophenols,9 and a model was developed to describe resazurin reduction in anaerobic

100

digestion.21 In this present study, we further extend the applicability of this technique by

101

investigating the stimulation and inhibition of anaerobic digestion by nickel, cobalt and their

102

mixture on anaerobic digestion, and by comparing these results to the methane production test,

103

we proposed that the resazurin reduction assay is a novel and more efficient method to study

104

the stimulation of anaerobic digestion with bioavailable trace metals.

Scheme 1 105

METHODS

106

Chemicals. Resazurin (7-hydroxy-3H-phenoxazin-3-one 10-oxide), CoCl2·6H2O,

107

NiCl2·6H2O were of high purity and sourced from Sigma-Aldrich, Singapore. Other reagents

108

and chemicals used were the highest available purity, and were also obtained from Sigma-

109

Aldrich, Singapore.

110

Anaerobic Sludge. Anaerobic sludge was obtained from municipal wastewater treatment


6

Page 7 of 31


111

plant digesters and grown in a 1 L laboratory continuously mixed reactor which was operated

112

at ~30 °C as the seed for the trace metal tests. The reactor was fed weekly using fill-and-draw

113

mode with a synthetic municipal wastewater9,22 (adjusted to pH 7) without trace metals

114

consisting of peptone (0.2 g L-1), beef extract (0.14 g L-1), urea (0.01 g L-1), CaCl2·2H2O

115

(0.004 g L-1), MgSO4·7H2O (0.002 g L-1), K2HPO4 (0.011 g L-1), NaCl (0.007 g L-1), NaHCO3

116

(0.3 g L-1) and acetic acid to give a final COD (chemical oxygen demand) of around 2 g L-1.

117

Effect of Spiked Ni2+ and Co2+ on Anaerobic Digestion: Gas Production, Resazurin

118

Reduction Assay and Metals Distribution. One hour after feeding the seed reactor, 40 mL

119

of fresh anaerobic sludge was taken and mixed with 40 mL of autoclaved synthetic municipal

120

wastewater in a 100 mL serum bottle to result in a final VSS of 1.4 g L-1. After being purged

121

with N2 for 1 min and sealed with a rubber stopper, a specific amount of CoCl2 or NiCl2

122

solution in DI water was spiked into the serum bottles, yielding metal concentrations of 5 and

123

250 mg L-1, and mixtures of 2.5 mg L-1 each; a control experiment without metals was also set

124

up. Triplicate experiments for each test were carried out in an incubating shaker at 150 rpm

125

and 37°C. At 0, 3, 6, 9, 12, 24, 48 and 72 hours the gas volume was measured using calibrated

126

wetted glass syringes, and the composition of the gas analyzed using a gas-chromatograph

127

(GC- Shimadzu GC 2010) equipped with a TCD. At the same time as for the gas volume

128

reading described above, 0.35 mL of mixed anaerobic sludge was taken from the serum

129

bottles and added to a 96 well microplate with resazurin (25 mg L-1) under anaerobic

130

conditions; the microplate was sealed immediately using sterile film. Fluorescence was read

131

once every 1 min for 60 min by an Infinite M200 Pro microplate reader (TECAN, Singapore)

132

with TECAN i-control software at λex=530 nm and λem=590 nm, and a gain of 30 according to

133

our previous study 9. Meanwhile, at 0, 1, 3, 6, 9, 12 and 24 hours, 5 mL of anaerobic sludge

134

was taken and centrifuged at 12000 rpm for 10 min. After filtering through 0.45 µm filters

135

and acidifying with HNO3 to 1%, the Ni2+ and Co2+ in the supernatant were measured using


7


Page 8 of 31

136

microwave plasma atomic emission spectrometry (MP-AES; AGILENT model 4200).

137

Triplicate serum bottles were also set up with Ni2+ spiked at 0, 0.1, 0.5, 5, 15, 50, 100, 250

138

and 1000 mg L-1; after 6 hours 0.35 mL of fresh anaerobic sludge was taken for the resazurin

139

(25 mg L-1) reduction assay described above.

140

Characterizing Stimulation of Anaerobic Digestion with the Resazurin Reduction Assay.

141

Based on a pseudo-first order reaction rate, our previous study developed a model, ሾ‫ܤ‬ሿ =

142

ሾ‫ܣ‬ሿ଴

143

culture, and mixed sludge under anaerobic conditions,21 where [B] is the resorufin

144

concentration linearly proportional to the fluorescent signal, [A]0 is the initial resazurin

145

concentration reacting in the cells, k1 and k2 are the reaction rate constants for resazurin to

146

resorufin, and resorufin to dihydroresorufin, respectively, and [M] is the total concentration of

147

metabolites in the cells to reduce resazurin, which can represent the activity of the

148

microorganisms. By setting the 1st derivative of the model equal to zero, the optimum time for

149

maximizing produced B (resorufin) is ‫ݐ‬௕௘௦௧ =

150

[M]. Therefore, the change in activity of the anaerobes between two sampling points (times a

151

and b) can be described by the shift of this optimum time, i.e., ∆tbest = tbest a – tbest b. Hence in

152

this present study, the change in activity of microorganisms in anaerobic sludge because of

153

spiked trace metals can be used to predict stimulation/inhibition of anaerobic digestion by

154

∆tbest.

155

Statistical Analysis. The differences in methane production and ∆tbest between the control and

156

each metal spiked system at the same sampling time/range were determined using a two-

157

sample t-test.

௞భ ௞మ ି௞భ

(݁ ି௞భሾெሿ௧ − ݁ ି௞మ ሾெሿ௧ ), to describe the process of resazurin reduction in both pure

ೖ ୪୬ భ ೖమ

, which is inversely proportional to

ሾெሿ(௞భ ି௞మ )

158 159

RESULTS and DISCUSSION


8

Page 9 of 31


160

Spiking Ni2+ and Co2+ Results in a Significant Stimulation of Methane Production after

161

24 Hours. Methane production is a useful indicator when monitoring an anaerobic digester

162

suffering from toxicity.23,24 In this study, methane production was also employed as a

163

metabolic indicator of trace metals on anaerobic digestion. Fig. 1A shows the volume of

164

methane produced every 3 hours in the first 12 hours of the experiments, with and without the

165

addition of cobalt, nickel, or their mixture. Comparing methane production to the unspiked

166

controls, the inhibition by 250 mg L-1 of spiked Ni2+/Co2+ was obvious; in the first 12 hours

167

there was no significant increase in methane production, except in the first 3 hours of the

168

experiment with 5 mg L-1 of Ni2+ spiked (Fig. 1A-b), and the 2.5+2.5 mg L-1 Ni2+-Co2+

169

mixture (Fig. 1A-c), where there was a significant increase. However, this observation cannot

170

prove that the addition of 5 mg L-1 Ni2+, or a mixture of Ni2+ and Co2+, stimulated the

171

anaerobic process because methane production in the following 3 sampling times, e.g. 6, 9

172

and 12 hours, was not statistically significantly higher than the control. However, when we

173

measured the daily methane production rate (Fig. 1B), with the more obvious inhibiting in the

174

250 mg L-1 Ni2+ or Co2+ spiked systems, it was found that the volume of methane produced in

175

the 5 mg L-1 Ni2+ (Fig. 1B-b), or mixture of Ni2+ and Co2+ (Fig. 1B-c) spiked system was more

176

than that in the control from the first day, and for the 5 mg L-1 Co2+ spiked system (Fig. 1B-a),

177

that time occurred on the second day of the experiment, meaning that by comparing methane

178

production we can tell whether certain trace metal concentrations stimulate anaerobic

179

digestion after at least one day.

Figure 1 180

Biogas is the fundamental end-product of anaerobic digestion, and most investigations have

181

traditionally focused on biogas measurements to assess metabolic activity and inhibition.

182

Although many other methodologies are often used in parallel with gas measurements, e.g.

183

the depletion of the concentration of the test substrate, the accumulation of some


9


Page 10 of 31

184

intermediates such as short chain organic acids, the formation of hydrogen,25 biogas

185

production is by far the preferred parameter for monitoring the activity of the sludge as a

186

whole, particularly when the test material is complex and difficult to measure accurately.

187

Biochemical methane potential (BMP) is a measure of the methane that can be produced

188

biologically from a given waste, sludge, or substrate, and is used to determine the methane

189

generation potential of each waste.23 In contrast, the anaerobic toxicity assay (ATA) was

190

developed to predict the likely effect of a potential toxicant on biogas and methane

191

production, but does not show microorganism acclimation to the toxicant, or the effect of

192

toxicant build-up in the biomass.23 Using these volumetric methods, it takes day(s) to

193

determine the inhibitory/stimulatory effect of trace metals on methane production.2,4–6 The

194

present study also measured the volume of methane produced, and although the inhibitory

195

effects of Co2+ and Ni2+ spiked at 250 mg L-1 could be determined within 6 hours (Fig. 1A-a,

196

b), the stimulatory effect of Co

197

1

198

1B-b, c). In addition, in some cases the outcome of the assay was strongly dependent on the

199

rate limiting step, for example, if the test material was particulate, then the hydrolysis step

200

was generally rate limiting;26 whereas if it contained a highly proteinaceous fraction, the

201

methanogenic step can be slowed down by the accumulation of acids resulting from the

202

fermentation, and consequently is likely to be rate limiting.

203

Resazurin Reduction Assay Allows Assessment of the Stimulation by Ni2+ and Co2+ in ≤ 6

204

hours. With Co2+- The kinetics of resazurin reduction by anaerobic sludge with two Co2+

205

spiked levels, i.e. 5 and 250 mg L-1, did not show any significant difference (Fig. 2A)

206

according to the estimated tbest of around 147 min for all three systems including the unspiked

207

control. In the following sampling time periods, i.e. 3, 6, 9 and 12 hours (Fig. 2B-2E,

208

respectively), the spiked 250 mg L-1 Co2+ did not change the kinetics of resazurin reduction

2+

(5 mg L-1), Ni2+ (5 mg L-1) and their mixture (2.5+2.5 mg L-

) could only be determined by methane production after one day (Fig. 1B-a) or two days (Fig.


10

Page 11 of 31


209

significantly, suggesting that 250 mg L-1 Co2+ inhibited the activity of sludge permanently.

210

This observation was similar to the results measured by the volumetric method described

211

above. However, compared to the control, although the spiked 5 mg L-1 Co2+ slowed down the

212

resazurin reduction kinetics, i.e. tbest 3 hours= 75 min (Fig. 2B), tbest 6 hours= 38 min (Fig. 2C),

213

tbest 9 hours= 30 min (Fig. 2D) and tbest 12 hours= 30 min (Fig. 2E), with this optimum time

214

shifting left, it suggested that the experimental system was recovering from temporary

215

inhibition, and this “shift” speed could be an index of the potential bioactivity of anaerobes.

216

Fig. 2F shows a summary of the optimum time (tbest) shift every 3 hours, in which it can be

217

seen that the ∆ tbest 0-3 hours of the control was greater than that of the 5 mg L-1 Co2+ spiked

218

system, while after this time the ∆ tbest of 3-6, 6-9 and 9-12 hours were all significantly greater

219

than that of the control, suggesting a higher bioactivity with 5 mg L-1 spiked Co2+. This higher

220

potential bioactivity could lead to a faster biogas production rate, which actually has been

221

observed empirically by direct methane volume quantitation, as described above. The

222

volumetric measurement took 2 days to see the stimulatory effect on biogas production (Fig.

223

1B-a), while using the resazurin reduction assay, stimulation by 5 mg L-1 of Co2+ was detected

224

within 6 hours.

Figure 2 225

As one of the essential trace metals for microorganisms, cobalt has been reported to show

226

different effects on anaerobic processes depending on the type of substrate, and hence

227

stimulatory and inhibitory concentrations were found to be between 0.03 and 19 mg L-1, 35

228

and 950 mg L-1 (100% inhibition), respectively.5 Cobalt is the central metal ion in corrinoids

229

which are present in methylotrophic methanogens and acetogens, e.g., in methanogens;

230

corrinoids are involved in methyl transfer from methanol to methyl coenzyme M, the common

231

precursor of methane from all substrates.27 In acetogens, corrinoids participate in the

232

formation of acetyl coenzyme A, the precursor intermediate of acetate and cell synthesis.28


11


Page 12 of 31

233

However, the content of corrinoids in anaerobic bacteria varies greatly among species and

234

substrate utilized, resulting in different stimulatory and inhibitory concentrations for different

235

anaerobic processes.29 Hence, rapidly determining the optimal concentration of Co2+ for a

236

given anaerobic system would enable engineers to enhance process performance.

237

With Ni2+- Permanent inhibition with 250 mg L-1 of spiked Ni2+ was also obtained by

238

studying the resazurin reduction kinetics (Fig. 3), and resulted in the same observations as

239

with the 250 mg L-1 Ni2+ spiked system measured by methane production (Fig. 1A-b). In

240

addition, 5 mg L-1 of spiked Ni2+ slowed down the resazurin reduction kinetics compared to

241

the control, i.e. tbest 3 hours= 83 min (Fig. 3B), tbest 6 hours= 55 min (Fig. 3C), tbest 9 hours= 45 min

242

(Fig. 3D) and tbest 12 hours= 42 min (Fig. 3E). Although these tbest are still greater than the

243

control at the same sampling time, its recovery from temporary inhibition was obvious. The

244

optimum time (tbest) shift every 3 hours is summarized in Fig. 3F in which the stimulation by

245

5 mg L-1 Ni2+ was revealed after 6 hours based on the significantly greater ∆tbest of the 5 mg

246

L-1 Ni2+ spiked system compared to that of the control.

Figure 3 247

Nickel is not considered as being essential for bacterial growth, although it is found in a

248

single hydrogenase of methanogenic bacteria.30 Ni was discovered to be an essential

249

component of a low molecular weight coenzyme, F430, present in methanogenic bacteria both

250

in the free state and bound to methyl-coenzyme-M reductase, which uses the methyl thioether

251

methyl-coenzyme M and the thiol coenzyme B as substrates and converts them reversibly to

252

methane in all methanogens.31 At present, F430 has only been found in methanogenic

253

archaea.32 Cobalt and other trace metals/elements such as iron, molybdenum, selenium and

254

tungsten have also been shown to be stimulatory to methanogens;10 however, it appears that

255

nickel is essential and that no other trace metals can replace it in F430.33,34 Besides playing a


12

Page 13 of 31


256

key role in factor F430, nickel is also essential for the growth of acetoclastic organisms; both

257

methane producers and sulfate reducing bacteria.7 Depending on the type of substrate, the

258

stimulatory and inhibitory concentrations of nickel to anaerobic digestion are between 0.03

259

and 27 mg L-1, 35 and 1600 mg L-1 (50% inhibition), respectively.5

260

With a Mixture of Co2+ and Ni2+- Because a variety of trace metals are usually present as a

261

mixture in the influent of an anaerobic digester, in addition to stimulation, specific

262

antagonistic or synergistic effects between mixtures of trace metals can occur in anaerobic

263

bioprocesses, and nickel has been proved to be synergistic in the Ni–Co system, i.e.,

264

enhancing the toxic/inhibitory effect.35 In the present study of a 2.5+2.5 mg L-1 Ni2+-Co2+

265

mixture spiked into the anaerobic system using the resazurin reduction assay, both the

266

stimulatory and synergistic effects were demonstrated. In the first 3 hours, compared to the 5

267

mg L-1 Co2+ and Ni2+ spiked systems whose tbest was expected to be 75 minutes (Fig. 2B) and

268

83 minutes (Fig. 3B), respectively, the activity of the 2.5+2.5 mg L-1 Ni2+-Co2+ spiked system

269

was much lower, with a tbest around 130 minutes (Fig. 4B), which did not change significantly

270

from the start of the experiment (time 0). This observation suggested that during the first 3

271

hours in Ni2+-Co2+ mixture experiment, the addition of Ni2+ greatly enhanced the temporary

272

inhibition, which was not observed by measuring methane production in Fig. 1. However,

273

after another 3 hours (Fig. 4C), its tbest shifted to 40 minutes, resulting in a ∆tbest 3~6 hours = 90

274

minutes (Fig. 4F), which was much greater than the ∆tbest 3~6 hours of the 5 mg L-1 Co2+ and Ni2+

275

spiked systems of 37 minutes (Fig. 2F) and 28 minutes (Fig. 3F), respectively, suggesting that

276

the speed of recovery from temporary inhibition in the 2.5+2.5 mg L-1 Ni2+-Co2+ spiked

277

system was faster than in the single Co2+ (5 mg L-1) or Ni2+ (5 mg L-1) spiked systems.

Figure 4 278

Transition metals nickel and cobalt are essential components of many metalloenzymes; Ni-


13


Page 14 of 31

279

dependent enzymes are urease, [NiFe] hydrogenase, [Ni] superoxide dismutase, CO

280

dehydrogenase, and methyl-CoM reductase, while in the form of coenzyme B12, cobalt plays a

281

crucial role in many biological functions.15 The synthesis of Ni/Co enzymes, and coenzyme

282

B12, requires a high-affinity uptake of these metal ions from natural environments where they

283

are available only in trace amounts, and this uptake in bacteria is mediated by various

284

secondary transporters and by different ATP-binding cassette systems.15,36 Kida et al. 27

285

suggested that during methanogenesis, Ni2+ and Co2+ were required for the methane-

286

producing reactions via increases in coenzymes F430 and the corrinoids. In contrast, the toxic

287

effect of trace metals is attributed to the disruption of enzyme function and structure by the

288

metals binding with thiol and other groups on protein molecules, or by replacing naturally

289

occurring metals in enzyme prosthetic groups.35 Therefore, trace metals may be stimulatory or

290

inhibitory to anaerobic reactions, and the extent of these effects depends on the metal species

291

and its concentration.

292

The temporary inhibition of methane production in anaerobic digestion by Ni has been

293

reported by Muñoz et al.,37 who proposed that lower nickel concentrations provoke temporary

294

inhibition depending on the nickel concentration in the digester. In this present study, the

295

same temporary inhibition by Co, Ni, and their mixture at 5 mg L-1, was also observed. Using

296

magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), Bartacek et al. (2012) investigated the transport of Co

297

inside single methanogenic granules, and found that free Co species tend to interact with the

298

granular matrix, and a “reactive barrier” was formed resulting in slower transport (tens of

299

minutes to hours). The formation of this reactive barrier seemed to be due to the rate-limiting

300

step of transporting metals through the membrane by different transporters,15,36 resulting in

301

temporary inhibition. In view of the apparently universal occurrence of F430 in methanogens,

302

and corrinoids in methylotrophic methanogens and acetogens, the rate of uptake of free Ni/Co

303

followed by the rate of cofactor F430 and corrinoids synthesis, can significant affect the


14

Page 15 of 31


304

activity of the biomass and the amount and rate of methane production. The whole process

305

can be described as: (1) Co or Ni diffuse through the biomass and then transfer through the

306

cell membrane; (2) Co or Ni join coenzyme synthesis, e.g., cofactor F430 and corrinoids; (3)

307

the synthesized coenzymes use specific substrates and convert them to methane. In this

308

present study, the resazurin reduction assay was used to determine the bioactivity change in

309

anaerobic systems in step 2, while the methane production results measured using the

310

volumetric serum bottle method can only be obtained during/after step 3. That is why the

311

stimulation of anaerobic digestion by Co/Ni can be assessed using the resazurin reduction

312

assay quicker than by measuring methane production.

313

The rate of growth of anaerobic bacteria depends on the type of substrate used. During

314

hydrolysis, 5-72 hours were proposed for carbohydrate and lipid substrates; whereas in the

315

acetogenesis phase, the generation time for bacteria using propionic and fatty acids was

316

suggested to be 84 and 131 hours, respectively; while in the methanogenesis phase,

317

generation times range between 15 and 85 hours.39 During anaerobic digestion, it might take

318

days from a single substrate molecule, for example the peptone or beef extract in our feed, for

319

methane to be produced, while by spiking essential metals, such as Ni, at the stimulatory

320

level, the cofactor F430 will be synthesized and reserved for future use in methanogenesis. To

321

study the effect of Ni and Co on anaerobic digestion, some extracted cofactor F430 and

322

corrinoids were analyzed by atomic absorption spectrophotometer.27 In addition to the

323

drawback of the time-required, this method did not consider the possible effects of increasing

324

F430 and corrinoids on the other metabolic processes in living microbes. In contrast, as a

325

“gross” measure, the resazurin reduction assay can describe the overall activity of mixed

326

cultures, but not a single metabolite. In addition, comparing the activity measured using the

327

present assay and the traditional volumetric method (BMP/ATA), besides the advantage of an

328

earlier and more precision estimate using the resazurin assay, its other advantage is that it is


15


Page 16 of 31

329

not necessary to purchase expensive equipment such as a GC-TCD to measure methane

330

production to evaluate the activity of anaerobic sludge, while a cheaper fluorescence meter is

331

all that is required for the resazurin assay.

332

Determining the Optimal Concentration of Ni on Stimulation of Anaerobic Digestion by

333

the Resazurin Reduction Assay. By studying the shift in the optimum time of resazurin

334

reduction assay (∆tbest) between two sampling points, the stimulatory effect by metals can be

335

predicted as described above, while the optimal metal concentration at which stimulatory

336

effect is maximized, is still unknown but of practical importance. When studying the

337

mechanism of nickel sorption onto anaerobic granular sludge, Bartacek et al.40 suggested that

338

this dynamic process consisted of three distinctive phases: (1) a fast initial adsorption in the

339

first few minutes after nickel injection, (2) a slow sorption process limited by intra-particle

340

diffusion, and (3) final achievement of equilibrium. Although the second step in the bio-

341

uptake of metals such as nickel (resulting in temporary/permanent toxicity/inhibition) is rate-

342

limiting, e.g., nickel transport into Methanobacterium bryantii cells occurred maximally 4

343

hours after the nickel was spiked;41 the bio-uptake of metals takes place even prior to the start

344

of methanogenic activity, which is much slower than the nickel uptake (several days).

345

Therefore, it is possible for us to estimate methanogenic activity by investigating the

346

distribution of metals in anaerobic sludge.

Figure 5 347

In this present study, by studying the distribution of Ni and Co in anaerobic sludge (Fig. 5),

348

we found that in all the experiments with different spiked metal concentrations, the

349

distribution rate was very fast in the first 6 hours, but then slowed down to almost reach

350

equilibrium in 24 hours. Hence, in this case, we suggest using the 6th hour samples for the

351

resazurin reduction assay to study the effect of different Ni concentrations on anaerobic


16

Page 17 of 31


352

digestion. For anaerobic bioprocesses spiked with a series of Ni2+ concentrations, sludge

353

samples were collected at 6 hours, and their reduction kinetics to resazurin were studied. By

354

plotting the tbest against spiked Ni2+ concentrations (Fig. 6), two critical concentrations can be

355

determined, i.e. stimulation starting (around 1 mg L-1) and stimulation ending (around 100 mg

356

L-1), suggesting that anaerobic digestion can recover from temporary inhibition due to less

357

than 100 mg L-1 of Ni2+ being spiked. Meanwhile, by plotting the slopes of the tbest–Ni2+ curve

358

against metal concentration, the optimal Ni2+ concentration was determined to be around 10

359

mg L-1 (insert Fig. 6). These results were similar to the findings of lower nickel concentrations

360

resulting in reversible inhibition to anaerobic digestion.42

Figure 6 361

Using the present method, four zones for anaerobic digestion with essential trace metal

362

supplementation can be determined; no stimulation, stimulation increase, stimulation decrease

363

and permanent inhibition (Fig. 6). Together with the shift in the optimum time (∆tbest) method,

364

generally within 6 hours using the resazurin reduction assay, the stimulatory effect of

365

essential trace metals on anaerobic digestion can be assessed, and the dose of essential metals

366

on anaerobic process performance can be profiled. By comparing these results to the

367

traditional volumetric method, i.e. measuring methane production over time, we proposed the

368

resazurin reduction assay as a more efficient method to study the stimulation of anaerobic

369

digestion by essential trace metals, with considerable potential for studying the bioavailability

370

of trace metals. The present study developed a novel and rapid assessment method for

371

inhibition and stimulation of anaerobic digestion by essential trace metals, and quickly

372

determined the optimal trace metals dosing strategies for anaerobic digestion. Supplementing

373

exact amounts of essential trace metals to avoid anaerobic digester upset or failure is

374

important, for example, in a rapid response to mitigating temporary inhibition caused by other

375

inhibitors, such as organic toxicants. Future work involves developing a protocol to quantify


17


Page 18 of 31

376

the absolute bioavailability of trace metals in anaerobic digestion based on the resazurin assay,

377

and using this assay in a microfluidic device to fabricate a biosensor for the real-time

378

monitoring of anaerobic digestion metabolic activity.

379 380

AUTHORS INFORMATION

381

Corresponding Authors

382

*phone: +44 207 5945591, fax: +44 15 317453; e-mail: [email protected] (David C.

383

Stuckey); phone: +65-6592-7594, fax: +65-6790-9081; e-mail: [email protected] (Terry

384

W.J. Steele).

385 386

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

387

This research work was supported by the Singapore National Research Foundation under its

388

Environmental & Water Technologies Strategic Research Programme and administered by the

389

Environment & Water Industry Programme Office (EWI) of the PUB.


18

Page 19 of 31


390

References

391 392 393

(1)

Agrawal, J.; Sherameti, I.; Varma, A. Detoxification of heavy metals: State of art. In Detoxification of Heavy Metals; Sherameti, I., Varma, A., Eds.; Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2011; Vol. 30, pp 1–34.

394 395

(2)

Altaş, L. Inhibitory effect of heavy metals on methane-producing anaerobic granular sludge. J. Hazard. Mater. 2009, 162 (2–3), 1551–1556.

396 397 398

(3)

Gikas, P. Kinetic responses of activated sludge to individual and joint nickel (Ni(II)) and cobalt (Co(II)): An isobolographic approach. J. Hazard. Mater. 2007, 143 (1–2), 246–256.

399 400

(4)

Zitomer, D. H.; Johnson, C. C.; Speece, R. E. Metal stimulation and municipal digester thermophilic/mesophilic activity. J. Environ. Eng. 2008, 134 (1), 42–47.

401 402 403

(5)

Lo, H. M.; Chiang, C. F.; Tsao, H. C.; Pai, T. Y.; Liu, M. H.; Kurniawan, T. A.; Chao, K. P.; Liou, C. T.; Lin, K. C.; Chang, C. Y.; et al. Effects of spiked metals on the MSW anaerobic digestion. Waste Manag. Res. 2012, 30 (1), 32–48.

404 405 406

(6)

Fermoso, F. G.; Bartacek, J.; Lens, P. N. L. Effect of vitamin B12 pulse addition on the performance of cobalt deprived anaerobic granular sludge bioreactors. Bioresour. Technol. 2010, 101 (14), 5201–5205.

407 408

(7)

Oleszkiewicz, J. A.; Sharma, V. K. Stimulation and inhibition of anaerobic processes by heavy metals: A review. Biol. Wastes 1990, 31 (1), 45–67.

409 410

(8)

Chen, Y.; Cheng, J. J.; Creamer, K. S. Inhibition of anaerobic digestion process: A review. Bioresour. Technol. 2008, 99 (10), 4044–4064.

411 412 413

(9)

Chen, J. L.; Ortiz, R.; Xiao, Y.; Steele, T. W. J.; Stuckey, D. C. Rapid fluorescencebased measurement of toxicity in anaerobic digestion. Water Res. 2015, 75 (0), 123– 130.

414 415 416

(10)

Thanh, P. M.; Ketheesan, B.; Yan, Z.; Stuckey, D. Trace metal speciation and bioavailability in anaerobic digestion: A review. Biotechnol. Adv. 2015, 34 (2), 122– 136.

417 418

(11)

Nies, D. H. Resistance to cadmium, cobalt, zinc, and nickel in microbes. Plasmid 1992, 27 (1), 17–28.

419 420 421

(12)

Liesegang, H.; Lemke, K.; Siddiqui, R. A.; Schlegel, H. G. Characterization of the inducible nickel and cobalt resistance determinant cnr from pMOL28 of Alcaligenes eutrophus CH34. J. Bacteriol. 1993, 175 (3), 767–778.

422 423

(13)

Grass, G.; Gro e, C.; Nies, D. H. Regulation of the cnr cobalt and nickel resistance determinant from Ralstonia sp. strain CH34. J. Bacteriol. 2000, 182 (5), 1390–1398.

424 425 426

(14)

Degen, O.; Eitinger, T. Substrate specificity of nickel/cobalt permeases: Insights from mutants altered in transmembrane domains I and II. J. Bacteriol. 2002, 184 (13), 3569– 3577.

427 428

(15)

Mulrooney, S. B.; Hausinger, R. P. Nickel uptake and utilization by microorganisms. FEMS Microbiol. Rev. 2003, 27 (2-3), 239–261.

429

(16)

Battersby, A. R. Biosynthesis of vitamin B12. Acc. Chem. Res. 1993, 26 (1), 15–21.

430

(17)

Kobayashi, M.; Shimizu, S. Cobalt proteins. Eur. J. Biochem. 1999, 261 (1), 1–9.


19


Page 20 of 31

431 432

(18)

Jefferson, B.; Burgess, J. E.; Pichon, A.; Harkness, J.; Judd, S. J. Nutrient addition to enhance biological treatment of greywater. Water Res. 2001, 35 (11), 2702–2710.

433 434 435

(19)

Mudhoo, A.; Kumar, S. Effects of heavy metals as stress factors on anaerobic digestion processes and biogas production from biomass. Int. J. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 10 (6), 1383–1398.

436 437 438

(20)

Pratten, M.; Ahir, B. K.; Smith-Hurst, H.; Memon, S.; Mutch, P.; Cumberland, P. Primary cell and micromass culture in assessing developmental toxicity. Methods Mol. Biol. 2012, 889, 115–146.

439 440 441

(21)

Chen, J. L.; Steele, T. W. J.; Stuckey, D. C. Modeling and application of a rapid fluorescence-based assay for biotoxicity in anaerobic digestion. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2015, 49 (22), 13463–13471.

442 443

(22)

OECD. Test No. 303: Simulation Test - Aerobic Sewage Treatment -- A: Activated Sludge Units; B: Biofilms. OECD Publishing.

444 445

(23)

Owen, W. F.; Stuckey, D. C.; Healy Jr, J. B. Bioassay for monitoring biochemical methane potential and anaerobic toxicity. Water Res. 1979, 13 (6), 485–492.

446 447

(24)

Lin, C. Y.; Chen, C. C. Effect of heavy metals on the methanogenic UASB granule. Water Res. 1999, 33 (2), 409–416.

448 449 450

(25)

Rozzi, A.; Remigi, E. Methods of assessing microbial activity and inhibition under anaerobic conditions: A literature review. Rev. Environ. Sci. Biotechnol. 2004, 3 (2), 93–115.

451 452

(26)

Sanders, W. T.; Zeeman, G.; Lettinga, G. Hydrolysis kinetics of dissolved polymer substrates. Water Sci. Technol. 2002, 45 (10), 99–104.

453 454 455

(27)

Kida, K.; Shigematsu, T.; Kijima, J.; Numaguchi, M.; Mochinaga, Y.; Abe, N.; Morimura, S. Influence of Ni2+ and Co2+ on methanogenic activity and the amounts of coenzymes involved in methanogenesis. J. Biosci. Bioeng. 2001, 91 (6), 590–595.

456 457 458

(28)

Florencio, L.; Field, J. A.; Lettinga, G. Importance of cobalt for individual trophic groups in an anaerobic methanol-degrading consortium. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 1994, 60 (1), 227–234.

459 460

(29)

Krzycki, J.; Zeikus, J. G. Quantification of corrinoids in methanogenic bacteria. Curr. Microbiol. 1980, 3 (4), 243–245.

461 462

(30)

Jarrell, K. F.; Kalmokoff, M. L. Nutritional requirements of the methanogenic archaebacteria. Can. J. Microbiol. 1988, 34 (5), 557–576.

463 464

(31)

Friedmann, H. C.; Klein, A.; Thauer, R. K. Biosynthesis of Tetrapyrroles; New Comprehensive Biochemistry; Elsevier, 1991; Vol. 19.

465 466

(32)

Thauer, R. K. Biochemistry of methanogenesis: A tribute to Marjory Stephenson. In Microbiology; 1998; Vol. 144, pp 2377–2406.

467 468

(33)

Speece, R. E.; Parkin, G. F.; Gallagher, D. Nickel stimulation of anaerobic digestion. Water Res. 1983, 17 (6), 677–683.

469 470 471

(34)

Zhang, P.; Shen, Y.; Guo, J.-S.; Li, C.; Wang, H.; Chen, Y.-P.; Yan, P.; Yang, J.-X.; Fang, F. Extracellular protein analysis of activated sludge and their functions in wastewater treatment plant by shotgun proteomics. Sci. Rep. 2015, 5 (January), 12041.

472

(35)

Chen, J. L.; Ortiz, R.; Steele, T. W. J.; Stuckey, D. C. Toxicants inhibiting anaerobic


20

Page 21 of 31


digestion: A review. Biotechnol. Adv. 2014, 32 (8), 1523–1534.

473 474 475

(36)

Eitinger, T.; Suhr, J.; Moore, L.; Smith, J. A. C. Secondary transporters for nickel and cobalt ions: theme and variations. Biometals 2005, 18 (4), 399–405.

476 477 478

(37)

Muñoz, M. A.; Codina, J. C.; De Vicente, A.; Sanchez, J. M.; Borrego, J. J.; Moriñigo, M. A. Effects of nickel and lead and a support material on the methanogenesis from sewage sludge. Lett. Appl. Microbiol. 1996, 23 (5), 339–342.

479 480 481 482

(38)

Bartacek, J.; Fermoso, F. G.; Vergeldt, F.; Gerkema, E.; Maca, J.; van As, H.; Lens, P. N. L. The impact of metal transport processes on bioavailability of free and complex metal ions in methanogenic granular sludge. Water Sci. Technol. 2012, 65 (10), 1875– 1881.

483 484 485

(39)

Ali Shah, F.; Mahmood, Q.; Maroof Shah, M.; Pervez, A.; Ahmad Asad, S. Microbial ecology of anaerobic digesters: the key players of anaerobiosis. Sci. World J. 2014, 2014, 183752.

486 487 488

(40)

Bartacek, J.; Fermoso, F. G.; Catena, A. B.; Lens, P. N. L. Effect of sorption kinetics on nickel toxicity in methanogenic granular sludge. J. Hazard. Mater. 2010, 180 (1-3), 289–296.

489 490

(41)

Jarreli, K. F.; Sprott, G. D. Nickel transport in Methanobacterium bryantii. J. Bacteriol. 1982, 151 (3), 1195–1203.

491 492

(42)

Mueller, R. F.; Steiner, A. Inhibition of anaerobic digestion caused by heavy metals. In Water Science and Technology; 1992; Vol. 26, pp 835–846.

493


21


Page 22 of 31

494

Figure and Scheme Captions:

495

Scheme 1. Conversion of resazurin to resorufin and dihydroresorufin.21

496

At a λex of 530 nm and λem of 590 nm, resazurin is blue and weakly fluorescent; resorufin is

497

pink and strongly fluorescent; dihydroresorufin is colorless and non-fluorescent.

498

Fig. 1. Effects of spiked Ni2+, Co2+ and their mixture on methane production.

499

The volume of methane produced with Ni2+ (a), Co2+ (b) and their mixture (c) spiked was

500

measured every 3 hours in the first 12 hours (A), and daily (B). Mean and standard deviation

501

of three replicates are shown. The superscript * indicates there is a significant difference

502

between these two groups of data according to a t-test at P ≤ 0.05.

503

Fig. 2. Resazurin reduction assay to study stimulation of anaerobic process by Co.

504

Resazurin reduction by anaerobic sludge sampled at 0 (A), 3 (B), 6 (C), 9 (D) and 12 (E)

505

hours with 0, 5 and 250 mg L-1 Co2+ spiked, and the shift of optimum time for maximizing

506

produced resorufin in a fluorescent signal (tbest) every 3 hours was summarized (F), where the

507

superscript * indicates there is a significant difference between these two groups of data

508

according to a t-test at P ≤ 0.05.

509

Fig. 3. Resazurin reduction assay to study stimulation of anaerobic process by Ni.

510


511

hours with 0, 5 and 250 mg L-1 Ni2+ spiked, and the shift of optimum time for maximizing

512


513


514


515

Fig. 4. Resazurin reduction assay to study stimulation of anaerobic process by mixture

516

of Co and Ni.

517


518

hours with 0, 2.5-2.5 mg L-1 Ni2+-Co2+ spiked, and the shift of optimum time for maximizing

519


520


521



22

Page 23 of 31


522

Fig. 5. Dynamic distribution of Ni2+, Co2+ and their mixture in the liquid phase of

523

anaerobic process.

524

The initial metals concentration is: Co2+ at 5 (A) and 250 (B) mg L-1; Ni2+ at 5 (C) and 250 (D)

525

mg L-1; and mixture of Ni2+-Co2+ at 2.5-2.5 mg L-1 (E). Mean and standard deviation of three

526

replicates are shown.

527

Fig. 6. Effect of Ni2+ dose on anaerobic process performance studied by optimum time

528

for maximizing produced resorufin in resazurin Reduction assay.

529

Mean and standard deviation of three replicates are shown. By plotting the slopes of tbest–Ni2+

530

curve against metal concentration (insert Figure), the optimal Ni2+ concentration was

531

determined to maximize the methane production rate in anaerobic bioprocess.


23


Page 24 of 31

532 533

Scheme 1


24

Page 25 of 31


A

CH4 (mL)

0.3

Control Ni2+ 5 mg L-1 2+ -1 Ni 250 mg L

0.4

0.3

a

0.2

0.1

0.2

0.4

*

0.1

0.0 6

9

12

0.2

c *

0.1

0.0 3

Control Co2++Ni2+ 2.5+2.5 mg L-1

0.3

b

CH4 (mL)

Control Co2+ 5 mg L-1 Co2+ 250 mg L-1

CH4 (mL)

0.4

0.0 3

6

9

12

3

6

Time (hour)

Time (hour)

9

12

Time (hour)

B Control Co2+ 5 mg L-1 Co2+ 250 mg L-1

12

*

a 6

3

0

12

*

9

*

CH4 (mL)

CH4 (mL)

9

*

Control Ni2+ 5 mg L-1 Ni2+ 250 mg L-1

b 6

* 3

2

Time (day)

3

*

*

c 6

* 3

0 1

Control 2+ 2+ -1 Co +Ni 2.5+2.5 mg L

9

CH4 (mL)

12

0 1

2

Time (day)

3

1

2

3

Time (day)

Fig. 1

25



A

B 0 hour

200

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

200

3 hours

150

150

100

100

50

50

0

0

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

TIME (min)

C

D

30

40

50

60

6 hours

50

60

200

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

200

150

9 hours

150

100

100

50

50

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

20

30

40

TIME (min)

TIME (min)

F

200

fluorescence (RFU)

20

TIME (min)

0

12 hours

*

Control Co2+ 5 mg L-1

90

150

∆tbest (min)

E

Page 26 of 31

100

50

60

* 30

* * 0

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0~3 hours 3~6 hours 6~9 hours 9~12 hours

TIME (min)

Fig. 2

26 ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 27 of 31

B

200

0 hour

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

A


150

100

50

200

3 hours 150

100

50

0

0

0

10

20

30

40

50

0

60

10

TIME (min)

D

200

6 hours 150

100

50

50

60

50

60

9 hours 150

100

50

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

TIME (min)

20

30

40

TIME (min)

F

200

12 hours

*

Control Ni2+ 5 mg L-1

90

150

∆tbest (min)

fluorescence (RFU)

40

200

0

E

30

TIME (min)

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

C

20

100

50

60

* 30

* *

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

0

60


TIME (min)

Fig. 3 27 ACS Paragon Plus Environment


B

200

200

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

A

0 hour 150

100

50

3 hours 150

100

50

0

0

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

TIME (min)

D

200

6 hours 150

100

50

40

50

60

50

60

9 hours 150

100

50

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0

10

TIME (min)

20

30

40

TIME (min)

F

200

12 hours

*

Control

*

90

∆tbest (min)

fluorescence (RFU)

30

200

0

E

20

TIME (min)

fluorescence (RFU)

fluorescence (RFU)

C

Page 28 of 31

150

100

50

Co2+ + Ni2+ 2.5+2.5 mg L-1

60

30

* *

0

0 0

10

20

30

40

50

60


TIME (min)

Fig. 4


Page 29 of 31


B 1.5

Co2+ in liquid (mg L-1)

Co2+ in liquid (mg L-1)

A Co 5 mg L-1 spiked

1.0

0.5

0.0

240

Co 250 mg L-1 spiked

200

160

120 0

5

10

15

20

25

0

5

Time (hour)

15

20

25

Time (hour)

D

4

240 Ni 5 mg L-1 spiked

Ni2+ in liquid (mg L-1)

Ni2+ in liquid (mg L-1)

C

10

3

2

1

Ni 250 mg L-1 spiked 200

160

120

0 0

5

10

15

20

25

0

5

10

15

20

25

Time (hour)

Time (hour)

Metal in liquid (mg L-1)

E 2.0

Ni 2.5 mg L-1 spiked Co 2.5 mg L-1 spiked

1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 0

5

10

15

20

25

Time (hour)

Fig. 5



Page 30 of 31

Fig. 6


Page 31 of 31


TOC Art for Manuscript 98x84mm (300 x 300 DPI)


Stimulation and Inhibition of Anaerobic Digestion by Nickel and Cobalt

Recommend Documents