Chemical Education Today
Book & Media Reviews
edited by
Edward J. Walsh Allegheny College Meadville, PA 16335
Genomics: The Science and Technology Behind the Human Genome Project Charles R. Cantor and Cassandra L. Smith John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1999. ISBN 0-471-59908-5. $89.95. reviewed by Martin Serra
Genomics is one of the most rapidly expanding areas of science. This book is an outgrowth of a series of lectures given by one of the former heads (CRC) of the Human Genome Initiative. The book is designed to reach a wide audience, from biologists with little chemical or physical science background through engineers, computer scientists, and physicists with little current exposure to the chemical or biological principles of genetics. The text starts with a basic review of the chemical and biological properties of DNA. However, without either a biochemistry background or a supplemental biochemistry text, this chapter and much of the rest of the text would be difficult to digest. The second chapter is designed to put DNA into the context of the larger chromosomal unit. Specialized chromosomal structures and sequences (centromeres, telomeres) are introduced, leading to a section on chromosome organization and purification. The next 4 chapters cover the physical (hybridization, electrophoresis), chemical (polymerase chain reaction), and biological (genetic) techniques that provide the backbone of genomic analysis. These chapters cover in significant detail the fundamental principles underlying each technique and provide a firm background for the remainder of the text. Chapters 7–9 consider the need and methods for the development of physical maps. Chapter 7 primarily discusses chromosomal localization techniques, including in situ hybridization, FISH, and chromosome paintings. The next two chapters focus on the development of libraries and clones. In particular, Chapter 9 considers the limitations of current mapping and clone production. The current state and future of DNA sequencing is covered in the next three chapters. The first considers the current methods of DNA sequencing—especially gel-based methods of analysis, although other possible approaches (mass spectrometry) are introduced. Much of the chapter addresses
the limitations of current methods, including analysis of error in sequencing and current bottlenecks in the sequencing effort. The next chapter describes the steps necessary to scale current technologies for the sequencing of entire genomes. Chapter 12 examines alternate methods for DNA sequencing. Initially, methods of single-molecule sequencing and sequencing by microscopy are introduced; the majority of the chapter is devoted to the development of DNA sequencing methods using chip microarrays and hybridization. The remaining chapters (13–15) consider the uses and analysis of DNA sequence information. The initial focus is on the identification of genes. Several examples are given of the use of DNA sequence information for diagnosis of inherited or infectious diseases. The sequence-specific manipulation of DNA is discussed in Chapter 14. The final chapter deals with the implications of large-scale sequencing, including methods for identifying genes and finding errors in DNA sequences, to the development of computer algorithms for the interpretation of DNA sequence information. The text figures are black and white line drawings that, although clearly done, seem a bit primitive for 1999. While I appreciated the simplicity of the drawings, many students accustomed to more colorful presentations will find them wanting. The four color figures in the center of the text seem an afterthought and add little to the text’s clarity. Each chapter has a set of additional reading sources, mostly primary sources. Often, specialized topics are offset into boxes that provide clarification and amplification without cluttering the text. An appendix includes a list of the Webbased database resources. As an undergraduate instructor who has previously taught biochemistry, molecular biology, and a course on the human genome, I found many interesting tidbits and amplifications throughout the text. I would recommend this book as a text for an advanced undergraduate or beginning graduate course in genomics. Although the text works though several examples of genetic and genome analysis, additional problem/ homework sets would need to be developed to ensure student comprehension. The text steers clear of the ethical implications of the Human Genome Initiative and remains true to its subtitle The Science and Technology… . Martin Serra is in the Department of Chemistry, Allegheny College, Meadville, PA 16335
JChemEd.chem.wisc.edu • Vol. 77 No. 1 January 2000 • Journal of Chemical Education
33
